Dear Liar, With All My Heart - Reviews

Dear Liar, With All My Heart
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing of this entire section is unlike anything I've read before, and I need to unpack why it works so well. First, the author makes a bold structural choice — almost everything happens through letters. Not dialogue scenes, not third-person narration of events, but written correspondence. And somehow this feels MORE immediate than any traditional scene could. When Carol writes about waiting days for a reply, my heart rate actually increased. When Asha describes her illness, I found myself holding my breath. The epistolary format creates intimacy that standard prose just can't match because we're reading thoughts, not observations of thoughts. But here's what's clever — the pacing within the letters themselves mirrors the emotional pacing of the relationship. The early letters are tentative, formal, circling around the Aila situation like elephants. Then Carol's big philosophy letter about truth being subjective — that's the turning point, the moment the relationship shifts from polite to real. And Asha's response comes almost too fast, which is exactly right. When two lonely people connect, the urgency feels sudden even if it shouldn't. The section break where we finally leave letters behind and enter a scene with Rosette is jarring in the best way. Up until that point, we've been so deeply inside these two minds that the physical world has been invisible. Rosette's entrance forces us out of the epistolary bubble and into a room with actual bodies and presence. It's a structural whiplash that mimics how real life interrupts our inner worlds. There's also this brilliant use of time skipping. We jump from May to June to mid-June, and the gaps between letters do so much work. We're not told what happens during those weeks — we infer it from the tone shifts. Carol goes from devastated to cautiously hopeful to comfortable. Asha goes from guarded to affectionate to physically unwell to recovering. The ellipses between letters are where the real story lives.
... Read More
I need to talk about the settings in this book because they're not just backdrop—they're basically characters themselves. Kasoche is described in these snippets of winter preparation that paint this incredibly vivid picture: merchants leaving, people returning from other cities, storage full of pickled food and alcohol. It's a place that braces for cold the way some people brace for heartbreak—methodically, dreadfully, knowing it's coming but hoping it'll be gentle this time. The weather itself becomes a metaphor for emotional states, which is a bit on the nose but executed so well that it doesn't feel forced. Then there's Iota—the island where Carol lives. 'The endless sea as their playground,' Asha calls it. But Carol's relationship with the sea is complicated. He has poor eyesight, avoids the blazing sun, and yet he's drawn to it. He plans to visit 'the sea that you're so curious about.' This is someone who defines himself in opposition to his environment and also feels most alive when confronting it. The domestic scenes are where the worldbuilding really shines. Carol's study with the armchair that belongs to his grandfather, not him. The staircase with its third step that creaks. The teacup with blue waves painted on the side he grips most often. These aren't decorative details—they're the entire emotional landscape of the story. A boy who finds comfort in the worn edges of his world because nothing else feels reliable. And the insomnia scenes! The ambiguous time 'too vague to fall asleep or to fully wake,' the mansion going quiet, sunlight brightening at dawn. These passages have this dreamlike quality where the boundary between reality and imagination blurs. Asha even suggests they could 'reach into the oil painting on the wall and enter inside the picture' if only the passages in paintings were connected. This is worldbuilding as wish-fulfillment—two boys wanting to escape into a space where distance doesn't matter. The visual imagery throughout is striking. Rosette's dark water marks behind her steps. Her loosened hair with hair tie marks. Her insteps darkly tanned from going barefoot. Carol adjusting his parasol to hide the fact that his shoulders are tense. The moon like 'a misshapen hole' behind the tallest tree. Every scene has this cinematic quality that makes me want to frame individual passages. What I love most is how the physical world reflects the emotional world. Cold weather = emotional coldness approaching. Insomnia = inability to process feelings. The sea = vast unknown emotions. Even the glasses Carol wears, pressing into the bridge of his nose, leave a permanent mark—a physical manifestation of how his circumstances shape him.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this section is absolutely drenched—literally and emotionally. Let me just say: the rain on Iota is not a weather event, it's a mood. "It's raining. A rain that won't stop for a while. So violently that it soaks the entire island thoroughly and makes me wonder if it might sink completely." This is one of those lines where the setting becomes a character. The island isn't just wet, it's drowning, and Asha's writing it on paper that's about to turn to pulp. She uses waterproof ink but admits the paper itself is doomed. There's something profoundly honest about writing something you know might become unreadable. And then Carol's response—bright, sunny, snow melted, roads open for merchants. The contrast between their climates mirrors the contrast between their lives. Asha's world is damp and enclosed; Carol's is expanding, opening up, full of people and movement and parties where she witnessed something that shook her. The island itself feels like a prison with warm weather. Superstitions about crossing the sea before adulthood, limited stores, no one your age to study letters with—this is a place where possibilities feel thin. The magic system (breathing life into paper) is beautifully constrained. She can send words but not herself. She can bridge the distance between them but never close it physically. That limitation IS the worldbuilding.
... Read More
I keep coming back to this one line: "Asha imagined a boy whose appearance she didn't know, though she knew so much about him." Isn't that just the most devastating way to describe a friendship? They've built this entire world inside their correspondence — she knows he's tall, has silver hair, keeps his nails rounded. He knows she can't swim deep, that she's the weakest kid on the island, that her mom died giving birth to her. But they've never even seen each other face to face. And then there's Rosette. Oh god, Rosette. She's everything Asha isn't — wet hair, sun-kissed skin, naturally charming, the kind of girl who can walk up to someone and press a damp hand on their shoulder and make it feel like a gift. The scene on the beach where Rosette finds Asha staring at the sea, asking "What brings you here?" in that voice that could be sarcasm or concern — I couldn't tell which either. And then Rosette says "When you get better, let's swim together" like it's nothing, like she hasn't just reopened a wound Asha is still picking at. But what really got me is Aila. Her story is told in this offhand way, almost like gossip, but there's something unsettling underneath it. She caught a rich husband by reading people like a spider reads a web. Three minutes, that's all it took. "Destiny is created more deliberately and diligently than one might think." That sentence stayed with me for hours. Is Aila a romantic lead or a cautionary tale? I still don't know.
... Read More
Let's talk voices, because they are SO distinct. Rosette's dialogue is like picking at a scab—quick, sharp, and leaving you wondering why you let her touch you. 'I see him every day anyway.' Dry. Dismissive. But then she's tapping her lips, pointing at the letters, her violet eyes narrowing. The action tags do so much of the work here. Her words are often minimal, but her physicality is loud and invasive. She's all 'What's this?' and 'Why are they piled up like this?' It's not curiosity; it's interrogation dressed as friendship. And Asha's response is pure deflection: 'No! ... No, really, it's fine.' The power dynamic in that scene is everything. Rosette holds all the cards because she's healthy, mobile, and probing, while Asha is trapped in bed and defensively weak. Now contrast that with Carol's voice. Carol doesn't just speak; she paints with words. Her letters have a flowing, almost breathless quality. She explains the poet Marso Cella in vivid detail, walks us through her family's aesthetics ('black wallpaper with red lighting and blue furniture'), and asks for opinions like 'What do you think, Asha?' Her voice is expansive, intellectual, and yearning. It's the voice of someone who uses language as a tool for connection and discovery, which makes Asha's silence so much more painful. The author uses these contrasting voices to brilliantly highlight the central conflict: Rosette speaks in probes and pressures, while Carol speaks in invitations and offerings. And Asha? Asha's voice is disappearing.
... Read More
Okay so the structure of this section is basically just letters back and forth, right? On paper that sounds like it could drag — two kids writing to each other for twenty thousand characters. But the author is playing a longer game here and it's brilliant. What works incredibly well is how the pacing mirrors the actual experience of correspondence. There's the waiting. The not knowing if the other person got your letter. The days where you write and rewrite and can't send anything. Asha's silence around the memorial ceremony isn't a plot hole — it's the point. The story includes the gaps, the voids, the not-replying, and that's what makes it feel real. Most stories skip over the boring parts of communication. This one leans into them. The Rosette scene in the middle acts as a pressure valve. You've been in Asha's head for a while, submerged in her letters, and then suddenly there's this warm, vibrant, complicated human showing up on the beach asking her to swim. It breaks the epistolary rhythm without breaking the emotional one. If the author had kept it as just letters the whole time, I think I would have started feeling the isolation too much — not in a bad way, but in a way that exhausts the reader. What doesn't work as well for me — and I say this gently — is some of the exposition around Aila's backstory. The rich husband, the three-minute reading, the spider-web gaze. It's well-written but it arrives as a block of explanation when the rest of the section has been so intimate and immediate. I got the sense the author wanted to plant this seed about Aila being different from Asha, about what kind of woman Asha might become, but it felt slightly detached from the emotional temperature of the surrounding letters. The ending lands perfectly though. Asha asking "What do you do? Haven't you ever felt so bored it was painful?" and then pivoting to how writing to Carol has made her look more closely at her own world. That's the thematic button — the correspondence isn't an escape from her life, it's the thing that's teaching her to see it.
... Read More
Okay, so these three unopened letters are NOT just a throwaway detail. The way Asha practically throws them aside when Rosette asks about them? That's a massive red flag. Who writes letters without addresses, without seals, and hides them? And why does Rosette's question about them cause such a visceral, panicked reaction? It's not just embarrassment; it's fear. This feels like the author is dropping a breadcrumb trail for a major subplot about Asha's silenced voice or a past connection she's desperately trying to bury. The letters feel like a ticking bomb in the room. Every time Rosette lingers near them or asks about her writing, the plot tension tightens. I'm dying to know what's inside those envelopes. Are they from Carol? From someone else? The author is masterfully using this physical object to represent Asha's internal block, and I can't look away. The parallel between Carol's beautifully opened, vulnerable letters and Asha's sealed, untouched ones is the core structural beat here. It's asking the question: who gets to be heard, and who chooses silence? And what happens when those silences start to crack?
... Read More
This is the kind of story that makes you put the book down and just stare at the ceiling for twenty minutes. "The moon was really big today. By the time you receive this letter, the date will have already passed, but I still wanted to tell you. It was big enough to make your eyes widen." I have never related to a line about the moon more in my entire life. This is the emotional core of the whole book right here—two boys who are too far apart to touch, too young to fully understand what they feel, connected only by the same sky. Asha sees the moon and his first instinct is to share it with Carol. Not because it's profound, but because it's beautiful and beauty means nothing if you can't share it. And Carol's reply: "P.S. The moon was pretty today too. It had a reddish tint like crushed cherries." He didn't just acknowledge the moon—he gave it a color, a texture, a taste. Crushed cherries. That's not an observation, that's an emotion wearing the disguise of description. What kills me is how understated all of this is. There's no grand confession. No dramatic declaration. Just two boys writing to each other at dawn, one of them unable to sleep because of insomnia and the other writing from a room full of memories he hasn't processed yet. The emotional stakes are sky-high but the delivery is whisper-quiet, and that contrast is what makes it so devastating. The Rosette situation adds another layer of ache. Carol sees her with Bash—the 'tall lover'—and feels his head spin. Not from jealousy necessarily, but from the sheer weight of all the things he can't say. Rosette is someone he cares about, someone who's close to him, and she's happy with someone else while he's stuck writing letters to a boy he's never met. The contrast between their visible happiness and his hidden longing is unbearable. And yet—the letters keep coming. Every night, almost. Through insomnia and self-doubt and the fear that he might end up hating everyone. Carol writes anyway. Asha writes back anyway. That persistence, that stubborn refusal to let distance win, that's where the real romance lives. Not in kisses or confessions, but in the daily decision to keep reaching out. I cried. Not dramatically. Just those quiet tears where you pretend you're not crying and your nose gets stuffy and you blame it on dust. This book understood something about loneliness that I didn't have words for.
... Read More
Let me just start by saying the worldbuilding in this book is so quietly masterful that I didn't even realize I was taking notes until I'd already memorized every detail. We have two completely different worlds colliding through correspondence, and the contrast is gorgeous. Carol's world is Kasoche — a village at the northern edge of the kingdom where winter lasts half the year, where the mountains are so tangled that even locals get lost, where the only tree he can see from his window is one his father says was blessed by a fairy. Everything about his environment screams isolation and cold and permanence. The mountains pile upon each other like barriers. The roads are rough even now. His family's gallery is full of paintings that nobody visits except him. There is something profoundly moving about a boy surrounded by art he treasures in a house full of people who couldn't care less, writing letters by candlelight because it's the only place that feels cozy. Asha's world is the opposite — an island, sea air, salt on her hair, a painting that literally moves and walks to deliver letters. Magic exists here but it's domestic, mundane. Mother calls it fairy mischief. Carol calls it wondrous. The same phenomenon, refracted through two different emotional lenses. And then there's this one detail — Rosette appears at the very end, smelling of fish and sea, whistling a sailor's tune, bringing tea leaves from Delling. In three paragraphs, the author opens a entirely new world we barely had time to process. A woman who walks into Asha's house uninvited and sits down like she owns the place. The contrast between Carol's frozen stillness and Rosette's oceanic movement is staggering. I couldn't tell you what island Asha lives on or what the political situation is or anything beyond these few rooms and halls, and honestly? I don't need to. The world feels complete because it's filtered through two people who will never leave their own corners of it. The setting isn't described — it's felt.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this book is EVERYTHING. I'm still thinking about that opening image—Carol's letter stuck to the window during a snowstorm, and she opens it just a nail's width to pull it out, terrified of tearing it. The snow on the envelope melts the moment it enters the room, and she has to shake it off fast or her 'love' becomes 'candy' or 'death.' That's not just description. That's POETRY. Kasoche feels so vividly real. Mountains piled upon mountains. Snow that never seems to end. A village so enclosed that adults keep people inside 'for their own good' while making up excuses. The contrast with Iota—this sweltering island where Asha lives—is delicious. Asha has never seen snow except in books, and she describes it with such hunger: "Is it soft like cotton? Rough like sand? What about the sound, the smell, the feel?" There's also this underlying world where fairies and werewolves exist but are treated as textbook curiosities rather than everyday reality. Grandfather warns Asha that fairies can lead "weak-minded humans down the wrong path," which immediately makes me want to know MORE about this world. The fact that Asha has never seen a fairy in all her long-lived grandfather's years but still believes they might exist despite his warnings—that tension between skepticism and wonder is so beautifully rendered. The domestic spaces are equally evocative. The spacious mansion where uncomfortable relatives stay for months. The study where Asha goes to 'wake herself up or kill time.' The room being prepared for guests that used to belong to Aila—just a few belongings in a box now, but clearly still felt.
... Read More
What makes this book so tense is that nothing dramatic happens—and that's exactly why it's so gripping. There's no battle, no murder, no grand betrayal. Just a girl sitting in a snowy village, feeling increasingly trapped, waiting for a visitor she's anxious about meeting, while her family keeps making decisions that dismiss her feelings. The stakes are deeply personal and that's what makes them matter. When Carol's family invites C (that vaguely described relative who mocked her as a child) to stay for months, the conflict isn't just 'I don't like this person.' It's 'my family is choosing comfort over my wellbeing and calling it kindness.' The stakes here are about identity, autonomy, and whether her pain matters to the people who claim to love her most. Then there's the impending visit from Grandfather's acquaintance and his son. Asha is simultaneously nervous and curious—"Honestly, it would be a lie to say I'm not looking forward to it." But she also knows her discomfort will be dismissed. "If I show a little discomfort, Grandfather will immediately send the guests away." So she has to perform willingness. That's the real tension: the constant calculation of how much truth you can speak before being silenced. The suspense about the painting's magic is subtle but present. Asha wonders if she should bring it into her room. Should she try to meet the mailman? "I'm not that curious" she says, but we know she is. Every unanswered question about the magic system adds a low hum of anticipation beneath the domestic surface.
... Read More
I am absolutely losing my mind over Carol's letters. The emotional whiplash from the first one to the last is incredible. She starts with joy over the seashell gift, dives into sweet childhood memories of Marso Cella's painting, and then—bam—her tone shifts entirely. That line, 'I put my ear to that seashell and gazed at Marso Cella's sea for a long time. When I sit leaning against the wall, the sea looks much bigger. It feels like the foam created dot by dot by the deceased might wet my ankles.' That's not just pretty writing; that's heartbreak. She's trying to connect with Asha through a shared memory, using the gift as a bridge, but the bridge feels like it's collapsing. And then the fourth letter... 'Your determination and stubbornness are stronger than the tall trees.' She's not just worried anymore; she's fascinated and terrified by Asha's silence. Meanwhile, Asha's emotional state is a disaster zone. She's sick, isolated, and actively pushing away the one person who sees her. 'I don't understand her feelings... She says mean things but then rubs her forehead against my shoulder.' Asha is completely overwhelmed by Rosette's ambiguity, which mirrors her own inability to process Carol's steady, profound care. The tragedy here isn't a fight; it's the quiet, aching distance between two people who clearly love each other deeply but can't find the language to meet in the middle. I'm so sad for both of them.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or