Dear Liar, With All My Heart - Reviews

Dear Liar, With All My Heart
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the birthday gift scene because my chest actually hurt. Asha goes to the beach in terrible weather, runs around looking for shells like her life depends on it, finally finds one, mails it with extra care—adds a postscript, everything—and then collapses into bed the next day. That's not just dedication, that's someone who has almost nothing to offer except their breath and whatever they can find on a beach, and they're giving it anyway. And Carol? She spent days painstakingly restoring a waterlogged letter, piece by piece, because she couldn't bear to lose a single word. That's love language, right there. Not grand gestures, but the quiet, desperate kind of devotion where you treat someone's words like they're the only thing keeping you alive. The unspoken stuff between these two is so thick you could cut it. They've never met in person. They're separated by an ocean, by different worlds, by the fact that one lives on an island with no real stores and the other is surrounded by brothers and a family dinner table. And yet they know each other better than anyone else in their respective lives. "I wish I could show you such a miracle for your birthday. It's a shame, isn't it?" —这句话我读了三遍。She can't even cross the sea on her own, and the most important thing she can send is a seashell that sounds like the ocean when you hold it to your ear. The ocean she can't leave.
... Read More
Let me just talk about the memorial ceremony scene because I genuinely cannot stop thinking about it. All the islanders gathering on the beach in their whitest clothes, piling up firewood, lighting it so the lost souls can find their way home. Every household has lost someone. That's just... that's the baseline of life there. The sea gives and the sea takes and you learn to live in between. And then Asha's grandfather crying. Not loudly, just silently, because he has a son who said he'd return and never did. Asha watching him, not knowing what to do, staring at her shoes like she's been handed an answer key to a test she didn't study for. "For me, it's a Dad with whom I have few memories." She's seventeen and still doesn't know how to perform grief the way adults expect her to. The contrast with Kasoche is brutal in the best way. Two months of people trapped inside, surviving on stored food, doors shut tight against the cold. Carol waking up to Asha's letter caught in his window, watching the sunrise for the first time of the year. These two kids are living in completely different worlds — one drowning in warmth and sea and crowds of visitors, the other buried under ice and silence — and the only bridge between them is paper and ink. I also need to mention how Asha describes looking at the sea differently after starting to write to Carol. Before, it was just there — natural, unremarkable, something she couldn't participate in anyway since she couldn't swim properly. After Carol, she starts noticing things. The texture of the waves, the fishy smell, the distant boats. The letter-writing has literally changed the way she sees her own home.
... Read More
I need to talk about Carol's relationship with her family because MY HEART. Like, her parents love her. They genuinely do. But the way they treat her is... it's so quietly cruel and I can't unsee it now. Her mother says things like "why buy when you already have clothes?" while her brothers get new everything. Her family invites someone to stay who MOCKED her silver hair as a child, who told her she'd be "an inadequate adult," and then expects Carol to just BE FRIENDLY with them. When Carol storms out mid-tea, her father doesn't ask what's wrong—he just sends a message saying don't behave rudely. RUDELY. Like her pain is a manners issue. And the crushing part? Carol keeps questioning herself. "Am I being too sensitive?" "Perhaps an inferiority complex I didn't realize has clouded my vision." She's so self-aware but still can't escape the spiral. That's the most realistic portrayal of familial emotional neglect I've ever read. But then there's Asha. Oh my god Asha. Her letter to Carol about this situation—"I'm angry that no one respects your suffering"—that's the kind of friend everyone needs. And Carol's P.P.P.P.S.: "Don't neglect me, okay?" That little plea broke me. She's so good at considering everyone else and yet she's the one who's hurting, and she still worries Asha might find someone better to talk to. The friendship between these two is the emotional anchor of the entire book. It's not romantic—well, maybe it could be, and the book leaves that door open—but it's deeply, ferociously loving in its own way.
... Read More
So the entire narrative vehicle here is letter-writing between Asha and Carol, and honestly it's kind of genius because it lets the author smuggle in plot revelations while making you feel like an accomplice. You're reading private correspondence, so every detail feels earned, not info-dumped. The big reveal—the letter-sending talent—is one of those moments where everything clicks into place. Asha breathes her intent onto the paper and it travels. Simple, almost childish in its mechanism, but the fact that she can't send anything heavier than paper immediately raises stakes. When she tries to mail a seashell as a birthday gift, the whole scene on the beach before she collapses is basically a countdown to whether it'll arrive. And then Rosette shows up at her sickbed, which means the seashell clearly landed, and now we have a three-way dynamic simmering that wasn't there before. Meanwhile Carol's storyline unfolds in parallel—she's at a party, saw someone kissing, got confused about her own feelings, and Rosette just casually dropped that she's dating Bash. The romantic entanglement isn't resolving, it's getting denser, and that's exactly how you keep people turning pages.
... Read More
There's this one metaphor that absolutely destroyed me. Carol describes her younger brother as "like a chestnut in its burr"—pointy, protected, standing out. And then she says of herself: "Just to live docilely like flowing water." Water versus the chestnut. Movement versus defensiveness. Soft versus sharp. This runs through the entire text. The snow that traps Carol in Kasoche isn't just weather—it's the physical manifestation of everything keeping her contained. Her family's protection is literally a cage. The adults say they're keeping her safe, but they're also keeping her small. "They make excuses while doing whatever they want. They could at least make plausible excuses; they're not even trying!" That line about adults being bad liars hit so hard because it's TRUE. The painting itself is probably symbolic too—a frame around reality, a doorway that's also a boundary. The mailman crosses from the painting into their world, which mirrors exactly what Carol wants: to cross from her confined village into the wider world. She traces paths on a map with her finger, dreaming of places beyond Kasoche, and the magical letter system is the closest thing she has to actually going somewhere. And then there's the whole thing about Aila's room. Empty now, prepared for a guest. What happened to Aila? Why is the room being readied but not celebrated? It's this ghost of another person's absence hanging over everything.
... Read More
Okay so Rosette is fascinating and deeply unsettling and I cannot stop thinking about her. First impression: she's the prettiest girl on the island, friends with everyone equally, adopted Aila's style—grew her hair out, learned piano, collected pearls. She mirrors people. Then she announces to Asha that she's dating Bash, which is weird because why Asha? Why not the ten other people who'd congratulate her? The letter explicitly asks this question and never really gets answered, which is either intentional mystery or a plot thread I need to watch. Then she shows up at Asha's sickbed after the beach incident, swinging her legs, asking about Bash like it's casual gossip, and watching Asha's eyelashes flutter while eating candy. The way the narration describes this—"the chair seemed too small to accommodate her stretched-out body"—tells you everything. Rosette takes up space. She invades. And she's clearly enjoying Asha's discomfort. Meanwhile Asha's family is this walking comedy of errors—brothers who sneer, parents who treat her like a secret to be managed, a grandmother comparing her timeline to a marriage market. Asha's entire existence revolves around being underestimated while being the only person who can actually communicate across impossible distances. I'm waiting for the moment Rosette's curiosity about Asha stops being friendly and starts being something else entirely.
... Read More
"On the day when the moon is fullest, Carol full of worries." I have never felt more seen by a character's signature in my entire reading life. This man signs his letters like he's presenting a mood, a weather report of his soul. And Asha does the same — on the day when leaves peek out. They're both measuring their lives in seasons and emotional states instead of dates. That is some next-level loneliness right there. Carol writing that he paced the hallway endlessly waiting for a reply, then going days without eating properly because he was too sick to open envelopes — this isn't dramatic flair, this is someone whose entire emotional ecosystem depends on a single piece of paper arriving at the right time. He lives in the coldest village in the kingdom. He hasn't left his home. His only connection to another human being is a magical painting that delivers letters to an island he's never seen. Of course he clung to Aila. Of course he was devastated. And of course he immediately latched onto Asha the second she offered him an out. But here's what kills me — Asha is just as trapped. She's confined to her house because her body betrays her constantly. She can't speak without tearing her throat. Her only family member who kept her company is gone. And yet somehow she's the one offering comfort. She understands his isolation because she knows it intimately. When she says I don't have the energy to measure truth and lies either, she's not being flippant. She's saying I'm just as tired of performing for people as you are. The scene where Carol describes crouching in the dark gallery by candlelight, writing by orange flame, surrounded by paintings nobody else looks at — that image of him alone in the dark with art and a quill broke something in my chest. Two people, thousands of miles apart, writing to each other in candlelight, building a friendship on the premise that neither of them has to be honest. That's not a romantic comedy setup. That's two wrecked people finding each other in the wreckage.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this upfront: I did NOT expect to be this invested in a letter-exchange plot. Like, epistolary novels are a tough sell when you're not in the mood, but this? This is different. The whole thing unfolds through correspondence between Asha and Carol, and on paper that sounds boring as hell. But the author somehow makes every letter a miniature drama. What strikes me is how the plot doesn't rely on big explosions or cliffhangers. Instead, tension builds through these quiet moments—like when Carol sees Rosette walking with Bash, the 'tall lover,' and literally can't walk steadily afterward. He adjusts his parasol and walks home like nothing happened, but then his shoulders tense up once he's alone. That's the plot right there. No dramatic confession, no thrown teacups. Just a boy pretending he's fine while his body betrays him. And Asha's letter where he talks about his own past betrayal—'The experience of betrayal still makes my mouth bitter, but it no longer feels like spitting ice picks down my throat'—that line hit me like a truck. It reframes everything. Asha isn't just some optimistic letter-writer; he's someone who's been through the wringer and chose to stay open anyway. That backstory doesn't get spelled out, which is exactly right. The plot trusts us to connect the dots. The Rosette subplot is also brilliant because we never actually see through her eyes. We only get Asha's theory that she's playing hard to get, and Carol's visceral reaction to seeing her with someone else. Are we supposed to trust Asha's interpretation? Or is he projecting? I keep going back and forth on this, which is exactly what a good plot should do. My only complaint— and it's a small one— is that the pacing in the middle sags a little when Asha starts giving Carol insomnia advice. Useful advice, sure, but I was ready to skim. Then Carol turns right around and makes it poetic with the fairy tale bit and I was back in. Still, if you're looking for non-stop action, this isn't it. But if you like plots that simmer instead of explode? This is the one.
... Read More
There's this moment — well, several moments, but I want to focus on one specifically — where Carol wakes up and finds Asha's letter stuck in his window. It's precariously wedged, barely hanging on, and somehow that image captures everything about their correspondence. Their connection is literal wings and fragile paper, caught in a draft, about to fly away or fall apart. He hadn't planned to celebrate the new year. He was too young for the midnight stuff, too old for the child-play assignments. He felt invisible in his own family's celebrations. And then her letter arrives with the sunrise and suddenly he's watching the first light of the new year with someone on the other side of the world. That's not romance. That's not quite friendship either. It's something that doesn't have a name yet. And Asha's side of it — the way she writes about not replying for days because she couldn't write a single character until after the memorial ceremony. Not because she didn't want to, but because the grief was too heavy and she didn't know how to set it down. She dipped her pen in ink again and again after writing just "To Carol" and then put it down. That's the most honest thing I've read about writer's block. It's not emptiness. Sometimes it's just too much fullness. The line that keeps looping in my head: "This year wasn't wasted just because I got to exchange letters with you." She's seventeen, she doesn't go to school, she watches the sea alone, she doesn't know how to grieve properly at ceremonies, and yet she looks at the past year and sees the letters as something that made it count. I'm not okay.
... Read More
I need to address the conflict in this book because on the surface there isn't much. No battles, no life-threatening dangers, no dramatic betrayals (well, one past betrayal mentioned in passing). But the stakes are enormous and that's what makes it so tense. Carol's internal conflict is the main engine here. He's dealing with insomnia that he won't name, pain he won't process, and a growing attachment to someone he's never met. The stakes? His emotional survival. 'I really… I'm afraid I might end up hating everyone.' That line isn't hyperbole. That's a boy describing the edge of his capacity to cope, and he's standing right on it. The external conflict is subtler but no less real. Rosette is apparently involved with someone else (Bash, the 'tall lover'), and Carol watches this happen helplessly. He can't confront her—he can barely confront his own feelings. So he does what he does best: he observes, he records, he writes letters. The tension comes from the gap between what he feels and what he's allowed to express. Asha's conflict is different but equally compelling. He's been betrayed before ('the experience of betrayal still makes my mouth bitter') and yet he keeps choosing to be open. Every letter he writes to Carol is a risk. He's exposing himself to someone who could disappear, could reject him, could prove him right about how painful this all ends. The stakes here are vulnerability itself—his willingness to care despite knowing how it might end. What makes this work so well is that the author never lets the tension drop. Even the insomnia advice section—seemingly the calmest part of the book—is charged with unspoken longing. Asha suggesting they write to each other across the painted world? That's not just practical advice, that's him saying I want to be closer to you in any way possible. The suspense isn't 'what will happen next?' It's 'how long can these boys sustain this before something breaks?' And the answer, presumably, is not very long. That's what makes every letter feel like it could be the last one before everything changes. The quiet desperation of two sixteen-year-olds who don't yet know how to ask for what they want is the highest-stakes drama I've read in a while.
... Read More
What are we actually betting on here? The external conflict seems to be Asha vs. her own crumbling health and isolation. But the REAL stakes are internal and relational. Asha is betting her life on silence. She believes that not writing, not responding, is a way to protect something—or someone. The stakes Carol raises are terrifyingly simple: 'Falling isn't always bad... When falling is better than holding on, for those times, there's a way to fall as safely as possible.' This is Carol directly addressing Asha's perceived stagnation. She's not asking Asha to be well; she's asking her to risk the fall. The tension is maintained because we don't know what Asha is falling from. Is it her writing? Her friendship with Carol? Her sanity? The 'suffocation' she describes when her grandfather visits, and the even greater suffocation she feels with Rosette's ambiguous attentions, shows her external world is a series of pressing threats. The suspense isn't about whether she'll recover; it's about what will FORCE her to choose between the safe fall and the impossible hold. Carol's final P.S. about the dried flower petals—'they say it's good to drink when you lack energy'—is a tiny, tangible stake. It's an offering of strength, a ritual of care. If Asha doesn't engage with that, she's not just losing a friend; she's rejecting the very mechanisms of survival Carol is trying to hand her. The next letter from Asha is going to change everything.
... Read More
The voices here are so distinct I could tell them apart blindfolded, and that's largely because they're communicating through writing, which means every word is chosen, revised, left out, or added back in. Asha's voice is measured, self-deprecating, and quietly devastating. She wraps her deepest vulnerabilities in parentheses and hedging language: "I'm not sure if it was truly 'enjoyable,' but…" "This is just my guess too." "I don't need to explain this in detail, right?" She never lets herself say what she actually means directly. Even her magical ability—breathing life into letters—is described as something that was "completely useless until" Carol appeared. She frames herself as insignificant even while doing extraordinary things. Carol's voice is warmer, more direct, slightly more performative. Her surprise at the soaking letter, her dramatic wait-and-read tension, the birthday wish that arrives late with genuine warmth—she doesn't hedge the same way. When she says "I thought I would go crazy with curiosity" she means it. There's no armor. The dialogue between them feels authentic because it captures how real pen-pal friendships work: you reveal yourself in layers, you test the waters, you leave things unsaid and hope the other person fills in the gaps. The fact that they've never met and yet understand each other this well is the whole magic of the book. Not the breath-on-paper thing. That.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or