Dear Liar, With All My Heart - Reviews

Dear Liar, With All My Heart
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this whole arrangement between Carol and Asha is brilliantly deconstructed. Carol gets burned by Aila's elaborate lie, and instead of just moving on to a normal friendship, Asha proposes this wild arrangement where they don't even have to tell the truth to each other. Think about that for a second — the central premise of their entire relationship is built on mutual permission to fabricate. Carol's response is absolutely my favorite moment in this entire batch: "Does unchangeable truth even exist in the first place?" He basically flips the entire script on romance conventions. Most stories would have him demand honesty, get angry, write her off. Instead he says just believe whatever I say because truth is subjective anyway. It's almost philosophically reckless but also so human — he's just tired of being hurt. And Asha? She accepts it immediately. Like, within one letter she's fully onboard. That speed is either terrifying or incredibly intimate, depending on how you read it. The Aila subplot technically resolves here but the real plot engine is this new contract they're forging. What I love is that the stakes aren't about whether they'll fall in love — they're already past that question. The tension now is about whether this truth-less foundation can actually hold two lonely people up. And then Rosette shows up at the very end with tea leaves and a casualness that completely disrupts Asha's world. Who is she? Why is she so comfortable in Asha's space? This is the kind of subplot drop that makes you immediately flip to the next chapter.
... Read More
The stakes in this story are deceptively simple on the surface — two people writing letters — but they're actually enormous when you think about what's really on the line. Carol has already been burned once. Aila used him, lied to him, made him believe in a friendship that was fundamentally constructed on falsehood. The text makes it clear this wasn't a minor disappointment — it shattered his ability to trust. "Thank you for staining even my only memory with truth." That's not a line you recover from in a week. So when Asha proposes this arrangement, Carol isn't just making a new friend. He's walking back into the exact same vulnerability with his eyes open and his defenses down. That's either courage or self-sabotage and I genuinely can't tell which. Asha's stakes are different but equally high. She's physically fragile — her body fails her constantly, her throat tears from shouting, she spends days bedridden. She can't leave her house. She can't meet people. Her only connection to the world has been through this letter system, and now Aila is gone. Carol represents her only tether to someone outside her isolation. If this correspondence fails, she's back to being completely alone in a house with a deafening grandfather and no sister. The external conflict — Aila's betrayal, the letter-delivery mystery — gets resolved pretty quickly. But the internal conflict is where the real tension lives. Can these two actually sustain something real on a foundation of voluntary dishonesty? Carol says truth doesn't exist. Asha agrees. But they both clearly WANT truth — they just can't afford to need it. That gap between what they say and what they feel is where every scene generates its electricity. And then Rosette shows up. A third party. Someone who moves freely in Asha's world. Someone who knows her. The stakes just tripled.
... Read More
The voice distinction between Carol and Asha is so sharply drawn that I could identify who's writing even without seeing the names. Carol is emotional, rambling, full of P.S.s that spiral into even MORE postscripts. She writes: "I.I.I hate that person." Three I's. That's not a stylistic choice—that's a breakdown on paper. And then she immediately softens it with "I really love my family, but..." Classic Carol. Can't express anger without immediately apologizing for it. Asha's voice is different. More controlled but not by any means cold. She's the one who says things like "Having to be in the same space as a terrible person! It's an unimaginable pain" and then goes on a whole tangent about a sculptor who stabbed his spouse. That's Asha—analytical, reference-heavy, but with warmth bubbling underneath every intellectual observation. What I love most is how natural their dialogue feels even though it's all one-on-one (letter-writing). Carol's internal monologue IS the dialogue here, and it reads exactly like how a smart but emotionally turbulent teenager would actually think. The stream-of-consciousness moments—the sudden tangents about clothes, the random questions about snow texture, the birthday wishes—are so authentically young-person. And Asha's line: "You worry that you might be too sensitive. Maybe you are. Some might think you're having these worries because you're more privileged than other children. That's probably true. But so what?" THAT right there is the kind of dialogue that sticks with you. It's direct, compassionate, and completely devoid of the usual novelistic polish. It sounds like a real person talking.
... Read More
"The flower petals I gave you help your recovery even a little? If so, I could pick flowers wedged between rocks many times over. It's not that difficult, you see." I need to talk about this moment because it changed everything for me. Asha giving Carol flower petals—that's not just a nice gesture, that's him laying his heart on the table without saying a single word about his heart. And Carol receiving them, noticing the small details (the third step creaks, the blue waves on the teacup, Rosette showing her upper teeth when she smiles)—this is a boy who has learned to find meaning in tiny things because the big things hurt too much. Their relationship is the absolute center of this story and it's gorgeous. They've never met in person. They don't even know each other's eye color. And yet Asha has constructed such a vivid image of Carol—'a shape with blurry lines, full of water'—that I literally felt jealous of Carol for being imagined so tenderly by someone far away. But here's what gets me: Asha is also painfully self-aware about his own feelings. When he says 'my opinion about Rosette stems purely from my heart that cherishes, values, treasures you,' he's not being manipulative. He's being honest in a way that almost hurts to read. He knows he's biased. He knows he's worried. And he owns it. Carol's side is equally compelling. The way he describes encountering Rosette and Bash on the street—adjusting his parasol, walking steadily, only realizing his tension after he gets home—this is someone who is deeply affected by people but has built walls around himself. He doesn't want to bother Asha with his drama, so he filters everything through observation instead. The fact that they're both十六岁 (sixteen years old) makes all of this even more intense. Neither of them has the vocabulary or the emotional maturity to process what they're feeling, so they do what teens do: they write letters. They overthink. They imagine. They pretend everything is fine while their shoulders stay knotted. I'm genuinely obsessed with how these two complement each other. Asha is warm, impulsive, slightly reckless with his emotions. Carol is measured, observant, careful with his words. Together they make something neither could be alone. And the fact that we, the readers, are basically flying blind about whether they'll ever meet in person? That's torture. Beautiful, necessary torture.
... Read More
The pacing here is unhurried in the most deliberate way possible, and I respect it. We open mid-conversation, basically—in media res of a friendship that's been building for what feels like months or years. There's no exposition dump about how they met or why they're writing. You just fall into the rhythm of their exchange, and by the time you realize you've absorbed all the backstory, it's too late—you're already invested. The structure alternates between Asha's letters (longer, more introspective, emotionally dense) and Carol's (slightly more brisk, reactive, moving the external plot forward with the party and the Rosette/Bash development). This creates a natural push-pull that keeps you reading. Asha pulls you inward; Carol pushes the story outward. The real pacing spike comes at the end with Asha's beach scene. Everything slows down—the weather, her breathing, the deliberate search for shells—then accelerates abruptly when she collapses. The narrative doesn't warn you. One moment she's running, the next she's bedridden and Rosette is already at her door. That leap is jarring in the best way. It's the narrative equivalent of someone appearing in your doorway unannounced. No preparation, just presence. If there's a critique, it's that the middle section of Asha's letter about her family and the drinking age debate could've been tightened. But honestly, that digression is also character, so I'll let it slide.
... Read More
Okay so the thing about epistolary fiction that most people get wrong is that they make all the characters sound the same. You open a letter and you have no idea who wrote it because everyone's just doing the same earnest teenage voice. Not this book. Not even close. Asha's voice is immediate. It's like he's talking to you while gesturing wildly with his pen. 'Craving the attention of someone you dislike—ugh! I can't even imagine it. It would make me vomit today's soup.' That's not just a sentence, that's a personality. He's dramatic, he's opinionated, he inserts himself into situations before understanding them, and he's unapologetically emotional. His letters read like he's sitting across from you at a café, leaning in, eyes wide, telling you everything at once. Carol's voice is the complete opposite and that's what makes their correspondence work. His sentences are measured, observant, layered with things he's not quite saying. 'Words become impoverished after a sentence or two, and you'll run out of things to say. Like that. My days are so monotonous that I don't have much to tell you.' This is a boy who is hyper-aware of the gap between experience and expression, and that awareness shapes every word he writes. Where Asha floods the page, Carol carefully places each word like it costs something. The dialogue between them—even though it's all letters and not actual conversation—has this incredible rhythm. Asha asks a question, Carol circles around the answer for three paragraphs and then gives him something true anyway. Asha shares something vulnerable, Carol matches it with something equally vulnerable but dressed up as practical advice. Their voices bounce off each other like ping pong balls. And the minor characters! Rosette and Bash barely appear but they have distinct voices. Rosette waving her hand a few times as she passes. Bash being the one who actually greets Carol. These tiny interactions tell us everything about their dynamics without any exposition. Even the narrative voice—the unnamed narrator who frames these letters—has a personality. That opening section where they're speculating about Rosette's feelings toward Carol? That's someone with opinions, biases, and a very strong reaction to the idea of unrequited love. 'Unless she's mentally destitute enough to need that.' Oof. That's a hot take delivered with zero chill. The author clearly understands that voice is everything in correspondence-based storytelling, and every character sounds distinct. I could identify who wrote any given letter just from the first paragraph. That's craft.
... Read More
I need to talk about Carol because this boy is doing the emotional equivalent of running on fumes and I'm obsessed. The man received devastating news about his letter partner — found out his friend was essentially a fraud — and instead of shutting down completely, he immediately pivots to proposing a correspondence with the sister. That's not weakness, that's desperate hope masquerading as practicality. His line about not needing to know the truth is simultaneously the healthiest and most unhealthy thing I've ever read. He's saying I don't care if you're lying because being alone is worse. That is a heartbreaking calculation. And Asha! Oh my god, Asha. She's got this whole situation going on — isolated on her island, sister is gone, grandfather is going deaf, she's physically frail and can barely shout — and yet she's the one proposing the terms of this new relationship. She takes the lead. She sets the boundaries. She says I'll believe whatever you say and that's somehow both generous and deeply self-protective. The dynamic between them feels dangerously close to something real but they're both guarding themselves with this whole truth-is-subjective philosophy. Carol wants freedom from disappointment. Asha wants connection without the risk of another betrayal. They're both using intellectual frameworks to avoid admitting they just really want someone to write to. The best part is how quickly they fall into rhythm — the pacing of their correspondence feels like two people who've known each other forever, even though they've barely exchanged ten letters. That's the magic of it. They're not pretending to be strangers anymore.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this epistolary format is actually GENIUS and I need everyone to appreciate it. The whole story is told through letters between Asha and Carol, and somehow that makes every tiny detail feel so much more intimate. Like, you're literally reading someone's private thoughts as they write them in real time. No omniscient narrator hand-holding you. But the plot device that absolutely got me? The painting. The one where a little mailman crosses into their world and delivers letters. Asha discovers it casually, almost matter-of-factly: "when I go to the study to either wake myself up or kill time, I discover a letter placed neatly." Just... there it is, this magical occurrence, treated like a mundane daily event. And yet it's the entire backbone of the narrative. Without that painting, there's no friendship between Carol and Asha. The whole story hangs on this one whimsical detail. What's fascinating is how the letters themselves drive the plot forward in real time. Carol's birthday is approaching. Grandfather's acquaintance is coming with a son. New clothes are being made. The tension builds through these small chronological markers rather than dramatic chapter events. It's slow-burn storytelling at its finest. And the fact that we never see the "other side"—we only get Asha's voice through Carol's replies—creates this wonderful asymmetry where we're always slightly hungry for more. The subplots are woven in so naturally too. The C who came to stay, the brother dynamics, Rosette tutoring Asha, the snow storm—all of it feels organic to the letter format rather than forced in.
... Read More
Carol's P.S. section. Let me just sit with this for a second. He starts with one line: "No, I won't ask. Don't answer." Then immediately contradicts himself: "No, I'll listen after all. Will you tell me honestly?" Then pulls back again: "But don't be too honest." Then: "It's better if I don't hear it." This boy is doing the emotional equivalent of walking up to a door, raising his hand to knock, then pulling back, then raising his hand again. It's so achingly real. I've done this. I've sent messages and deleted them and sent them again with different words. The fact that Carol voices this uncertainty out loud — that he lets Asha see him being fickle and contradictory — that's when I knew he was someone worth writing back to. And Asha's response? "How fickle! Reading your four lines of postscripts, I pondered considerably what to do. Then I decided to do as I please!" She calls him out immediately but then gives him exactly what he's asking for — permission to be honest, permission to share everything, permission to take up space in her letters however he needs to. The narrative voices are so distinct too. Asha's letters have this restless quality — she goes from describing a memorial ceremony to complaining about not knowing how to act sad to mentioning she's seventeen and can't throw tantrums forever. Her thoughts spiral. Carol's are more controlled, more structured, but that control keeps cracking. "My seriousness is easily dismissed as a momentary whim or impulse." That line from Carol just... it's the sound of a kid who's been told his feelings don't matter so many times that he's started believing it. Also the lullaby. Asha remembering her father's song — "My child, may you have good dreams today. My child, even typhoons cannot trouble you." I need a moment.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or