[Crime Investigation] 13th Case - Reviews

[Crime Investigation] 13th Case
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I'm still thinking about Zuo Shuyang. Just thinking about him. The police officer who was kind to the narrator and she didn't know how to handle it. That line—“He was very kind to me, so kind that I didn't know how to handle it”—and then she tries to treat him well in return. Like kindness is something you pay back, not something you receive. That broke me a little. Every time he shows up, it's gentle. Patting her head. Not daring to ask directly when something's wrong. Trying to bring it up indirectly. He's this genuinely good person trapped in a story that doesn't deserve him. And she knows it. She hugs him before he leaves and whispers “Stay safe.” That's not foreplay. That's a goodbye she'll never say out loud. And then there's Yin Zhuo. “I can finally let go. I can finally see Jing Jing again.” He's been carrying this since the beginning—since that afternoon when Jing Jing went to find Hao Yiming. The narrator said his expression wasn't resignation, it was “the calm before the storm.” God, that phrase. That's love. That's grief wearing a face so steady nobody can tell it's cracking. But the most painful emotional beat—the one I can't shake—is Jing Jing pushing the narrator away in the white void. Ten years and she's still the same. Blue hair clip still in her hair. Smiling. But she won't let her friend follow. Maybe because she loves her. Maybe because the narrator has already done too much. Or maybe because some people aren't meant to be rescued, even from death. “Zuo Shuyang, I hope in your next life, you don't meet someone as bad as me.” That's the last line. Not romantic. Not hopeful. It's a curse dressed as a wish. And I'm not okay with that.
... Read More
Every conflict in these chapters is layered, and I love that the stakes keep expanding instead of narrowing. Surface level: Cheng Hao is dead, someone jumped or was pushed from that building, and an old man claims he saw a visitor delivering a bag full of cash. That's a motive. That's a trail. Zou Shuyang follows it dutifully. Deeper level: Jian Mengyan knew the victim. She identified him as her high school teacher's killer. But her statement doesn't exist in the case file. Why? Is it because she was hospitalized and couldn't give one? Or is it because someone—or something—prevented her from being heard? The stakes here aren't just about solving a murder; they're about whether she can trust the system she's supposed to work within. Personal level: Zou Shuyang is caught between two loyalties that are tearing him apart. His job demands he pursue every lead, including the gap in her record. His heart demands he protect her. And the text makes it clear he's not a cold bureaucrat—he's someone who literally cannot separate work from personal matters, despite trying. That's a character flaw that the plot is going to exploit, and I'm here for it. The old man's inconsistency is the sharpest conflict trigger in this batch. Zou Shuyang doesn't call him out aggressively; he does it with what the text calls "tact." He asks sympathetically if there's something he's not telling. And the old man cracks. But here's what bothers me: does Zou Shuyang fully believe the corrected version? Or is he just accepting the path of least resistance? The reader is being asked to question everyone, and that's excellent suspense design.
... Read More
This book is obsessed with unfinished things. The building is unfinished. The case is unsolved. The victim's identity is incomplete. Even the witness—he's partially revealed, like a draft of a person. There's symbolism in that incompleteness. We live in a world of half-finished lives, half-told stories, half-known truths. The ghost motif isn't just plot device; it's theme. The old man says “there's no such thing as ghosts” but then sees one anyway. That's the human condition right there—we deny what we fear until it stands in front of us in bright red clothes. The ghost isn't supernatural; it's the unknown wearing a costume we recognize. And red! Why red? In Chinese culture, red can mean luck, celebration, blood, danger. Here it's all of those. The victim isn't dressed for a wedding or a funeral—they're dressed for something we don't understand yet. The color choice is symbolic overload, and I'm living for it. Winter is another symbol. The scavenger disappears in winter. Why? Hiding? Shelter? Death? The season itself becomes a metaphor for abandonment—people don't see him because he's not worth seeing, or he's not worth finding. Social invisibility as seasonal cycle. The unfinished building on Xiyi Road is literally and figuratively incomplete. Rumors killed its purpose. Ghosts repelled its buyers. Now it's a corpse graveyard. That's not coincidence; that's authorial intent. Buildings remember what people forget. Even the title—or what we'll eventually have—probably won't be about resolution. It'll be about the spaces between: between life and death, truth and lies, witness and suspect. That's where the real story lives.
... Read More
OK so the pacing in this batch is WHAT. You start with Hao Yiming's full confession - that's chapter 134 material, right? Big reveal, big drama, we think the arc is wrapping up. Then BOOM - dashcam footage appears, new suspect enters, and suddenly we're not done at all. The author just yanks the rug out from under us and I love it. But then - and this is where it gets brilliant - after the Yin Zhuo reveal, instead of going straight to action or resolution, we get a phone call. “The phone rang twice before Jian Mengyan picked up.” Simple. Quiet. And then the rain. And then the car ride where Zou Shuyang is “trembling so badly that after a few too many graceful S-shaped turns, he had to stop the car.” The shift from interrogations and confessions to a desperate drive through a storm - that's masterful pacing. The author knows exactly when to slow down and when to speed up. And the interrogation room scene at the end? Yin Zhuo walking in casually, greeting Hao Yiming, confessing to murder like he's reporting the weather - and then the final line where he's asked about motive and he says “Revenge, of course” but Captain He doesn't buy it? CLIFFHANGER. The author leaves us hanging right when we think we have answers, which means we're immediately turning the page.
... Read More
I need to talk about Xiao Tang because honestly he is carrying half the dialogue in this batch and he deserves credit. The man absolutely loves a dramatic reveal. His pacing when he's doling out information about Lin Shaohuai's true nature is theatrical in the best way — he takes a sip of water before continuing, he gauges Zou Shuyang's unreadable expression before press-着 on, he relishes the suspense. And then there's Zou Shuyang, who couldn't care less and delivers one-line intercepts like 'It's related to the case. Ding Jing.' Absolute machine. The banter between Xiao Wang and Xiao Tang feels genuinely natural, like two cops who've worked together long enough to have a rhythm. Xiao Wang's 'What do you mean by off?' followed by his impatience, Xiao Tang's deliberate delay — this is real workplace friendship, not written friendship. And Jian Mengyan's voice is distinct too: cheerful, slightly defensive about her class reunion info, ending with 'Alright, talk to you later.' She feels like someone I've actually met. The boss in the opening scene doesn't speak much but every line is sharp and loaded. 'Forget it, just to be safe, make sure the job is thorough.' That's a person who has given up on nuance and moved straight to efficiency. The dialogue across these chapters does heavy lifting without ever feeling exposition-dumped.
... Read More
I need to be honest—the moment I read about that red dress, my stomach dropped. Not because it's gruesome (though it is), but because of how the author frames it. “Dressed in bright red clothes, motionless.” That's not horror; that's tragedy wearing a costume. This book gets me emotionally because it doesn't tell us how to feel. It shows us the old man trembling, swallows hard, and stammers “Ghost… there really is a ghost!” And suddenly we're feeling his fear because we've never seen him afraid before. That shift from calm rummaging to terror is masterful. But the emotional core here isn't the body—it's the isolation. The old man lives alone in a half-finished building with ghost rumors. No family mentioned. No friends. Just him and the garbage. When he says “I've lived here for years and haven't seen even half a ghost,” it's not bravado; it's loneliness masking itself as skepticism. Then Zou Shuyang arrives, and suddenly there's connection. He doesn't dismiss the old man. He takes the documents seriously. He goes back to question him. That care—the professional care—is what makes me invest emotionally. This isn't just a case; it's someone trying to give voice to someone who can't speak. The scene in the interrogation room gave me chills too. The old man staring at his hands “as if there were some rare flowers growing on them.” That's not madness; that's dissociation. Something happened to him, and I want to know what. Not because I'm a detective, but because I'm a human who sees another human suffering. I also loved the small moments—the “Click” of the door closing, the young officers bolting, Zou Shuyang's dry observation about Captain He. These tiny emotional beats keep the story from feeling like a cold procedural. There's warmth here, buried under the dread, and I'll be chasing it all series long.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter is absolutely RIVETING and I need to process this. First off, the way the plot just SLIPS into Jian Mengyan's memory problem — you're driving along, having a cute moment with your boyfriend, and then BAM, a name triggers a migraine. That's not just good writing, that's malicious cruelty to the reader because we ARE NOT READY for what she's about to uncover. Ding Jing. That's the name. A classmate who disappeared ten years ago. Jian Mengyan and this girl were supposedly BEST FRIENDS and she doesn't even REMEMBER HER?? That hits so hard. But then — and this is where I got CHILLS — she remembers. Not all at once, but in fragments. The rainy night. The phone call where Ding Jing says goodbye. The plastic board that fell from upstairs and gave her that scar. And then Shen Tinglan walking them home, checking her homework like some weird but caring teacher dad figure. "He was dead. And so was she." That line. That single sentence. It just appeared in my head and I had to stop reading for a second. Because which one died first? Is it Shen Tinglan? Is it Ding Jing? Or is it... wait. "And so was she." DOES THAT MEAN JIAN MENG YAN IS ALSO DEAD?? OR IS SHE SAYING THAT Ding Jing died and now Jian Mengyan feels like a ghost of herself?? I keep going back and forth. The structure here is deliberately confusing, feeding us memories like broken puzzle pieces. And the parallel with Zou Shuyang investigating the same case is just *chef's kiss* — he's digging into the past while she's literally drowning in it. Also side note: the principal's evasion. Classic guilty conscience move. He's sweating, making excuses, saying Ding Jing wasn't notable. But why would a dean of students NOT remember a missing student?? Something is OFF here and I need to know WHAT. And then the phone call to Doctor Y at the end. She lies and says she's busy tomorrow. Why lie?! She's clearly deteriorating and she doesn't want him to know how bad it really is. That's either protective or manipulative or BOTH and I'm OBSESSED.
... Read More
I have to say the hallway-to-office sequence gave me actual chills. Let me walk through this: They arrive at the 4th floor and the noise just DROPS. The text says it perfectly — "The sounds of patients and activity from behind them seemed distant, almost like they were separated by countless years." That's not just atmosphere, that's the author pressing a pause button on the entire world so you focus on ONE door. Then the door opens and sunlight floods in. White tiles, bright, blinding. After all that dim hallway tension, the brightness is almost violent. It's like the author is saying: everything you think you know about this case just got exposed. And then Zhong is in the corner screaming. The transition from blinding light to a broken man huddled behind his own desk — that's a pivot so sharp it made me actually stop scrolling for a second. The recording scene afterwards slows things right back down. Yin Zhuo unfolds his phone like a card dealer revealing a winning hand. It's methodical, almost boring on the surface, which makes it more terrifying. The pacing here is a masterclass in alternating between rapid sensory hits (the hallway, the scream) and slow-burn psychological pressure (the conversation on the recording). Each beat serves the next.
... Read More
There's this one image in this chapter that has been haunting me since I finished reading. Jian Mengyan standing on her balcony, watching Zou Shuyang's car disappear. The smile she's been holding up — for him, for the public, for whatever mask she wears in daylight — just CRUMBLES the second he's out of sight. She stumbles back to bed. Gasping breaths. Cold sweat. That scar she touches absentmindedly. It's such a visceral transition. One moment she's this bright, playful girlfriend skipping up the stairs, and the next she's collapsing like her body can barely support her. The physicality of it — the heavy chest, the throbbing head, the damp hair clinging to her temples — it makes her condition feel REAL in a way that most supernatural stories don't achieve. And then the flashback to June 3rd, 2012. The rain. The text literally says "the rain hurt as it pelted her skin, and the wind was so strong that she could barely stand." I need to emphasize this — the weather isn't just atmosphere here. It's physically PAINFUL for her. Ten years later and the memory of that storm is still written on her body. The contrast between scenes is also striking. The present-day car ride — warm, 30+ degrees, Zou Shuyang breaking out in cold sweat from nervousness — versus the memory of that violent storm. Heat versus cold, stillness versus chaos, safety versus danger. The author is using temperature as a motif and I am NOT OKAY. Then there's the principal's office — top floor, overlooking the schoolyard, students bustling below. Zou Shuyang thinking about seeing 'Mengmeng' while looking at the kids, completely unaware of how strange that thought must sound to anyone who knows the full picture. The banality of a school office, the bald principal sipping tea like nothing's wrong, the sweaty palms and forced smiles. It feels so mundane compared to the storm imagery, and that's what makes it unsettling. Shen Tinglan's home in the memory is painted with warmth — dinner, fussing over them, Lin Xi serving food and smiling quietly. It's domestic and safe, which makes the fact that "he was dead" hit even harder. That normalcy was stolen from them. The visual storytelling here is cinema-quality. Every scene has a clear color palette, temperature, and emotional weight.
... Read More
There's a lot sitting beneath the surface of this passage that only reveals itself on reread. The most obvious symbol is the blood — red everywhere in Lin Shaohuai's villa, on the floor, from his wrist. But blood in this story has always been the currency of the old crimes. Ten years ago, someone's memory was taken. Now someone's blood is staining a living room floor. The continuity is the point. The word "Will" on that paper is doing multiple jobs simultaneously. It's a legal document, yes — but in the context of a man who tried to kill himself and failed, it becomes a philosophical statement too. What does he will? Not just his possessions, but his story? His guilt? The weight of whatever he knows about these two factions? Then there's the architecture of the settings themselves. Zhong Langming coming up from the basement detention area — literally rising from underground, from where secrets are kept. Jiangyuan Group's glass-fronted corporate building, where a receptionist whispers to a man who is secretly pulling strings. And finally the villa, that domestic space turned crime scene, where a successful man's home becomes a cage of his own making. The two groups motif is also symbolic — duality as a structural principle. Past and present. Crime and revenge. The visible world of police procedure and the hidden world of bosses and phone calls. The story keeps asking: which world is real, and which one is just the performance?
... Read More
I have to address Dr. Zhang because this man walked in, dropped two lines of perfectly casual dialogue, and I genuinely miss him already. "If you don't want to get married, at least date one of them for a while." — That's such a specific, human thing to say. It grounds the whole hospital setting in something normal before the nightmare stuff starts. We need these breathing moments or the tension would suffocate the reader. Then Yin Zhuo's voice throughout the recording is another level of writing. Listen to this exchange: "I just think Director Zhong should set things right and let the truth come to light." vs. "Coming clean yourself is always better than being exposed in the end. That way, you won't lose both your dignity and your reputation." Two sentences. One is poetic abstraction, the other is practical calculation. Yin Zhuo is saying: I can protect you, or I can destroy you, and the choice is yours (but it's not really yours). That's not dialogue, that's a power move disguised as conversation. And Zhong's voice cracks from composure to panic in three lines: denial, deflection, then full psychological collapse. You can hear his voice deteriorating across just a few sentences. That's craft.
... Read More
I need to talk about the dialogue in this section because the author really knows how to make different characters sound different, and the old woman's scene alone is worth the price of admission. Zou Shuyang's voice is so distinctive—short, practical, barely any filler. 'I need to look up some information. You can go back to sleep.' He doesn't waste words. Captain He, on the other hand, is all cautious probing: 'Do you really think Shen Tinglan's death is connected to his students?'—the slight hesitation, the tentative phrasing, it tells you everything about their professional relationship without any narration explaining it. But then the old woman at Cheng Hao's building—her dialogue is in a completely different register. 'Young men, there are some things you shouldn't dig too deeply into, or you might end up like that nosy neighbor next door, getting burned.' This is folklore-level dialogue. Oral tradition energy. She sounds like she's speaking from a different story entirely, and the fact that she disappears immediately after (literally 'as if the old woman had been a figment of their imagination') makes the whole scene feel like the narrative itself is warning us. The station banter between Xiao Wang and Xiao Tang also has great rhythm—you can hear the younger officer's nervous enthusiasm ('No, I'm not busy. Captain Zou, what do you need to look up?') versus the sleepy veteran energy. Every character has a voice here.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or