I need to talk about Jian Mengyan because she's the most fascinating character in this entire story, and she's barely even alive in this batch.
On the surface, she's described as ordinary. "So ordinary that if I were thrown into a crowd, I would disappear without a trace." But that's the first lie we're told. She comes from wealth—parents who run big businesses, plenty of money, nobody paying attention. She skips class to an internet cafe, not because she wants to game, but because she wants to feel something, to be seen. She sends fake messages pretending to be her teacher, hoping her parents will notice. All these small acts of rebellion that fail because nobody is watching.
Fast forward, and she's orchestrating murders through Yin Zhuo's hands. She's a surgeon's associate with access to PHR769 and spores. She wrote a thesis that apparently explains everything. And when it all comes crashing down, she kills herself rather than face consequences. "Meng Meng committed suicide." Zou Shuyang says it like he's still trying to process it.
But the relationship between her and Zou Shuyang is what haunts me. They're clearly close—romantically involved, presumably. And when he realizes she might be the real killer, he can't bring himself to arrest her. He grabs Yin Zhuo by the collar instead, desperate for some kind of confession, some proof that his girlfriend isn't a monster. When Yin Zhuo won't give it to him, Zou Shuyang just leans against the table, closes his eyes, and breathes.
Yin Zhuo's relationship with Ding Jing is tragic in its simplicity. He loved her, she felt tainted, she wanted to die, and he gave her that gift. But did he? Or was he manipulated into it? The text leaves this ambiguous, and I think that's intentional. Maybe Yin Zhuo really did throw her in the river. Maybe Jian Mengyan told him to. The truth might be lost forever.
And then there's Shen Tinglan—dead, mentioned only in passing, but apparently the one person who treated Ding Jing well after her family went bankrupt. "He was a good person who met a tragic end." Yin Zhuo says this almost casually, but it reveals everything: he didn't know Shen Tinglan, didn't care about him, but he avenged him because it served a larger purpose. That purpose, of course, was Jian Mengyan's design.
The tragic symmetry is that nobody wins. Yin Zhuo thinks he's found peace in confession, but he's just another pawn. Zou Shuyang is about to lose the woman he loves to a investigation she created. Jian Mengyan gets her revenge but not her life. Ding Jing dies anyway. And the readers? We're left wondering who we're supposed to sympathize with.