But Deliver Us From Death - Reviews

But Deliver Us From Death
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What I love about these chapters is how the author uses escalation like a drumbeat. We start with Valentine's private breakdown—intimate, quiet devastation. Then Astaire arrives and immediately pivots to executing the Empress and her entire family. BOOM. The stakes just jumped from personal tragedy to political genocide in three paragraphs. Then we cut to the noble banquet where Astaire is building a forest of meat and a pond of alcohol while Valentine stares blankly. The extravagance here is doing so much heavy lifting—it shows how far Sehera has fallen, how the tyranny has metastasized, and how Valentine is already emotionally checking out. The silence between them at that party is louder than any explosion. And then—eight pages later—we land on the assassination. The poison scene is almost deceptively calm. No dramatic music, no last-minute reversals. Just a woman offering a cup to the man who ruined her life and saying 'You did.' The pacing choice to let Astaire almost stand up, to let him grab his throat, to let him ring the bell—that micro-suspense before the guards don't come? Chef's kiss. The author trusts the reader to sit in that terrible moment of realization. No rush. Just the slow, dawning horror on Astaire's face as he understands everything too late.
... Read More
I need to just breathe for a moment. The scene with Bastian in the garden. That's it. That's all I have to say. Valentine, who just woke up rotting from her grave, who just made a deal with Satan, who has been plotting revenge against everyone who wronged her—she sees a child laughing near a fountain and her entire world stops. Her line says everything: "Would my child have been alive?" The author doesn't even elaborate. Doesn't describe her face, her tears, anything. Just that one devastating question hanging in the dark air. And then Lucifer asks her—indifferently, almost clinically—"Are you curious?" And she says no. Because curiosity implies hope. And hope is something she can't afford. I re-read that passage five times. FIVE TIMES. The image of that child with golden curls and blue eyes—it's deliberately mirroring what Valentine LOST. Amaryllis didn't just kill her baby; she made sure Valentine would never know what that baby would have become. And now here's another child, living, breathing, laughing, and Valentine can only watch from the shadows. The emotional brutality of that scene is unmatched in this entire novel. Nothing else comes close. She wanted to love her country. She wanted to be sincere. And now the only thing she has is hatred—and even that's tainted by grief. This is peak emotional writing and I am not okay.
... Read More
I can't get over how far Valentine has fallen. We're talking about a woman who once lived purely and blindly for a man—someone who would have faced the entire world as her enemy just to be with him. And now? Now she's literally sold her soul to Lucifer. The scene where she stands in the dark, pointing at where Liam disappeared, is one of the most devastating character moments I've read in a long time. "How can that person treat me like this… How can he be so nonchalant?" This line hit me like a physical blow. It's not just anger—it's disbelief. She expected to face him, she even prepared for it. But his calmness, the way he didn't even flinch when he accidentally said her name beside Amaryllis? That's what broke something in her. His indifference is more painful than any physical wound. And then there's Lucifer. That demon doesn't comfort her, doesn't offer absolution—he just coldly validates her desire for revenge. "Those whom Master hates will eventually perish." Valentine laughs through tears after saying she wants Liam to experience the same brutal betrayal she endured. That image of her laughing while crying is something I can't shake. The most chilling part though? The text explicitly states: "Forgiveness. It is the ultimate arrogance recited by people who have never lost anything." Valentine chose revenge over forgiveness because she can't become a merciful angel. She's no longer that pure woman. Her purity "sank deep into the sea, battered by the storms." What she becomes from here… I'm terrified. Also—Gwenael licking his lips while talking about making a move on the lookalike? The fact that Count Glastia thinks his worthless son might actually be useful for manipulating this new Madame Marguerite? The father-son relationship is so toxic and fascinating. Gwenael is genuinely unhinged.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are INSANE. Let me break down why this works so well. On the surface, Valentine wants revenge against five specific people. That's a clear, achievable goal—but the author complicates it immediately by showing us that Valentine's methods will be psychological torture, not simple murder. She says it outright: "Death was the most generous mercy." She wants them to STRUGGLE. She wants them to lose what they value most. And the author's genius is in how she sets up Count Glastia as the first target—not because he's the weakest, but because Valentine understands his psychology. She knows his obsession with blood ties and honor. She knows Bastian is his weakness. The external conflict is clear: vengeance vs. the powerful people who destroyed her. But the INTERNAL conflict is where this becomes genuinely tense. Valentine wants to die eventually—she asks Lucifer to kill her after her wishes are granted. She's not fighting to LIVE; she's fighting to make certain people UNDOABLE. That's a fundamentally different motivation, and it raises the stakes because Valentine herself is expendable. Every step she takes toward revenge is also a step away from her own soul. Meanwhile, the political stakes are escalating: Liam is panicking at court, Cassian remains chillingly calm, and the rumor of "Belle Laure" is spreading through the empire. Everyone is connected to this web, and Valentine is the spider. The suspense is suffocating in the best way—because we know what's coming, but we have no idea HOW it will unfold, and that uncertainty is exactly what keeps you turning pages at 2 AM.
... Read More
I need to talk about Liam and Valentine because my chest actually hurts. They share no blood but he was literally her father figure, her brother, her everything. And she—she sits there in the sunset, glowing, thinking she's finally being rescued. She asks about Cassian like it's the most natural thing in the world. Like she's already planning their future together. And Liam has to be the one to destroy that. The text says he struck her 'as if killing himself' and one tear soaked into her back. One tear. That's it. That's all he could give her. But here's what absolutely destroys me—she doesn't even understand why. Her last thought isn't anger, it's confusion. 'For what reason?' She spent her entire life surviving Astaire, enduring things no one should endure, just hoping to be with the person she loved. And her brother figures out the 'truth' that the people's hatred was directed at HER, not at Astaire. He internalized the mob's violence and redirected it at the one person who never hurt anyone. And then there's Cassian and Valentine's ghost dynamic, which is simultaneously the sweetest and most agonizing thing. He's sitting alone at night, wine glass to the moon, whispering 'Belle.' She's RIGHT THERE as a spirit, reaching for him, but her touch passes through. He never knows. He carries this unbearable loneliness for the rest of his life while she can only watch. And when he names Amaryllis Empress? That line—'Who else but you could be my Empress?'—I felt like I couldn't breathe. Because of course he says that to someone else. He swore love to Valentine but gave his throne to Amaryllis. The relationship triangle here is so beautifully, cruelly constructed.
... Read More
This whole arc is built on one devastating ironic loop and I am STILL thinking about it. Astaire vows 'I won't let those who hurt and troubled you go unpunished' after Valentine loses her child. He means it. He actually means it. So he executes the Empress, butchers her family, makes wine from her corpse—this is the man who follows through on his promises. And then Valentine uses THAT promise against him. 'Didn't you say you wouldn't let anyone who hurt and troubled me go unpunished?' YES ASTAIRE. YOU DID. The trap wasn't set by Cassian or any rebel. The trap was set by Astaire's own words. His vow became the weapon that killed him. What makes the stakes so personal though is that this isn't just political revenge—Valentine's internal conflict is what carries the weight. She spent months smiling at the man who destroyed her, laughing at his jokes, letting him touch her, all while cultivating the trust that would let her poison him. The scene where she accidentally pulls the bell cord and laughs at the guards scrambling in—that's not madness, that's someone holding onto sanity by the thinnest possible thread. Every fake laugh, every performed smile was survival. And the final line, 'Goodbye, Astaire' followed by his shattering wine glass—the stakes were never about the kingdom or the rebellion. They were always about one woman getting her life back.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this banquet scene because honestly it's the kind of moment that changes everything. Everything before it was this slow build of tension—you know, Astaire being Astaire, Valentine playing the perfect consort, the pregnancy announcement—and then BAM. The Empress corners Valentine and it all goes to hell in about three paragraphs. What really got me though is the setup. The author spends all this time establishing that Valentine is pregnant with Cassian's child, that Astaire doesn't know but is genuinely happy about it, and that the Holy Father is cursing the whole arrangement. You can feel the trap closing. When the Empress calls Valentine "filthy" and talks about her being a concubine who conceived an illegitimate child—like, yes, but also? Astaire is celebrating anyway. This is a tyrant throwing a party for his mistress carrying another man's baby. The absurdity of it makes the violence hit even harder. And then the push. Just one shove and Valentine hits the ground. The blood spreading on her dress—man. I actually had to put the book down for a second. It's not just physical violence; it's the destruction of something precious. That child was going to be Astaire's first. Even if it wasn't his biologically, it would have been his. And now it's gone. The aftermath is where it gets really interesting though. Astaire threatening the Empress, Valentine waking up to the worst news possible, and then the physician delivering the final blow—she'll never be able to have children again. That's not just a miscarriage; that's a permanent sentence. The author stacked every tragedy on top of each other like: you lost the baby, now you're losing the possibility of ever having one. That's cruel storytelling and I respect it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just… is anyone else obsessed with the dynamic between Valentine and Cassian? Like, on paper it should be pure villain energy. He's literally manipulating her into helping overthrow his own nephew-uncle situation, and she's playing the role of the treacherous concubine. But here's the thing that genuinely messed with me—the author made me care about them anyway. Cassian first appears to Valentine in this sun-drenched garden scene, all pale gold hair and those ridiculous blue eyes, and he says 'Please, call me Cassian' like he's some rom-nov prince instead of a political predator. And Valentine? She melts. We see it happen in real time. Her heart literally 'sank to the floor.' She's not stupid—she knows what he's asking of her. She knows Astaire is cruel, yes, but she also knows Astaire loved her in his own way. And yet. What gets me is the power imbalance. Cassian tells her, 'You must unconditionally say that he is right. That's how you can survive.' She becomes 'Cassian's faithful dog,' as the narration itself puts it. That's not a romance—That's dependency wrapped in silk. And yet when they're together in that garden, it reads as genuinely tender. The author forces you to feel both things at once, and I kept second-guessing whether I should be rooting for them or feeling deeply uncomfortable about it. Which, honestly, is great character writing.
... Read More
I want to focus on how each character's voice reveals who they are, because the dialogue in these chapters does so much heavy lifting. Start with Astaire. His dialogue is all commands and declarations. 'Bend over.' 'There must be a reason for everything you do, Astaire.' No—wait, that's Valentine. Astaire says: 'How dare you defend Count Glastia in front of me!' and 'Only you... understand me.' He doesn't ask questions often. When he does, it's accusations. His language is possessive, absolute, binary. People are right or wrong, alive or dead, and Valentine is his. The way he whispers 'My Tina' while violently marking her body—that contrast between tender words and brutal actions defines his entire character. Then Valentine. Her voice is always accommodating, always mediating. 'There must be a reason for everything you do, Astaire.' 'You have reason to be angry, Astaire.' She never pushes back. Even when she's trembling, even when she's disgusted (the text literally says she 'barely swallowed her nausea'), she smooths things over. Her dialogue is the language of survival. She's playing a role—perfect consort, understanding lover, loyal subject. The tragedy is that no one asks what SHE wants. Cassian's dialogue is the coldest. 'Astaire will be pleased.' 'Of course I'm happy.' His answers are flat, measured, empty. The text tells us 'It was a calm answer. It was a dry whisper that felt neither joy nor sorrow nor anything.' He's performing happiness while his veins pop and his face contorts in darkness. The gap between his words and his body is where his real emotion lives. The Empress is pure venom. 'How filthy.' 'What good is inheriting noble blood?' Her dialogue is aristocratic cruelty—insults about lineage, legitimacy, purity. She doesn't just hate Valentine; she hates what Valentine represents: an unmarried virgin who became a concubine and got pregnant first. In her world, that's worse than death. And then Amaryllis—her voice is raw, fractured. 'Because I wanted it. Because I desired it. Because it's mine!' Three repetitions, escalating desperation. She's not composing herself for anyone. Her dialogue is emotional vomiting, and then later: 'Even though I'm this broken... You, at least, should understand me.' She wants empathy without taking responsibility. The most honest voice in the entire chapter, and the most morally compromised. What strikes me is how the author uses dialogue to show power dynamics. Astaire commands. Valentine placates. Cassian deflects. The Empress attacks. Amaryllis confesses. Each character speaks from their position of strength or weakness, and you can map the entire court hierarchy through who gets to say what and how.
... Read More
The scene transitions in these chapters are masterful. Let me walk through why they work so well. We open with Valentine in the dark—pure emotional devastation, internal monologue, tears, demons. It's intimate and claustrophobic. Then BAM—"Bang!" Count Glastia slams the door and we're instantly in a completely different room with a completely different energy. The son playing with a sword. The father furious. Political rumors swirling. The tone shifts from tragic to almost darkly comedic, then back to menace when Gwenael starts drooling over the Marguerite lookalike. Then another hard cut: midnight, Emperor's office, candlelight, silence. The pacing slows down dramatically. Every sentence about Cassian's appearance—"not a single wrinkle," "crisp, tightly-tied white cravat"—deliberately stretches the moment. We feel the weight of each word. The dialogue here is sparse but devastating. Unlike the fast exchange between Glastia and Gwenael, this conversation moves like molasses. And that's the point. You're supposed to feel Count Glastia's mounting dread. The chapter ends with Count Glastia telling his son to "play with her for a while and then dispose of her somewhere out of sight." The transition from emotional climax (Valentine's vow) to political maneuvering (Cassian's interrogation) to predatory threat (Gwenael being sent after the new Marguerite) creates a three-act structure within two chapters. Each segment raises the stakes differently—one internally, one politically, one physically. By the time you finish, you're simultaneously worried about Valentine's soul, the Empire's stability, AND the lookalike's safety. That's tight pacing.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this about Astaire because honestly it made me physically angry rereading these chapters—this man is the walking definition of toxic. He watches Valentine fall apart after losing her child and his response is to embrace her and whisper something like 'I drown in your tears.' Like bro, YOU are the reason she's drowning. He had her child killed. He executed an entire family. And he still thinks he's the victim here somehow? The moment he says 'Tina, who else could I love but you?' while kneeling—that's not romance, that's a hostage situation with extra steps. Meanwhile Cassian walks in two seconds later, calls her 'Belle,' and suddenly Valentine's breathing again. Not because Cassian is good, let's be real, he orchestrated all of this. But because at least his cruelty is honest. Astaire's cruelty is wrapped in performative devotion and that's what makes it so suffocating. The line that haunted me: 'Valentine, whom he had always thought was small, felt like a giant.' She didn't become powerful. She just finally stopped performing love for a man who never deserved it.
... Read More
'Your wish to be saved, to live, called me.' I just— what. That line hit me so hard I had to put the book down for a second. The prologue sets up this devastating image: Valentine, having just killed the man she's supposed to hate (or maybe the man she was trapped loving), lying in wait for rebels who then execute her anyway. She dies thinking she succeeded, thinking she bought Astaire's destruction, and her body is tossed in an unmarked grave. Dust. Dirt. Forgotten. But then—years pass—and there she is, clawing her way out of that mound like some nightmare flower blooming from rot. Maggots and all. And this figure, this cold-eyed entity, appears and offers her something she didn't even know she was still desperate for: a chance at justice. At revenge. The emotional core here is so messy and human. Valentine loved someone who loved her in a twisted, possessive way (Astaire). She loved someone who used her as a weapon (Cassian). And through all of it, she was alone. Even in death, the grave was empty. No brother came. No lover mourned. Just silence and dirt. So when she rises and says 'I will kill that person,' it's not just vengeance talking—it's a person who has nothing left to lose declaring that she will exist again on her own terms. And I'm not even sure who 'that person' is yet, and that uncertainty is making me obsess.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or