Before the Predetermined Future Arrives - Reviews

Before the Predetermined Future Arrives
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Terion Iligen's dialogue because THIS MAN is weaponizing warmth. He says things that should be embarrassing — 'Shall I say it often?' 'Trust only me.' 'I had something lovely to look forward to, so my heart was a little too stirred to sleep' — but he says them with such an open, guileless face that you can't even be annoyed. The narrative itself keeps saying 'he said the strangest things' and 'he was the sort who only ever reached for words that made one's skin tingle' The dialogue between them has this electric quality where NOTHING is being said directly but EVERYTHING is being communicated. When he asks 'Do all people from Ilion have hair and eyes like yours?' that's not small talk. That's him trying to understand what makes her different from him. When she deflects with 'Is it common?' and he replies 'Hmm... This color is not common. It is a bit excessively pretty, this one' — HE IS FLIRTING AND HE DOES NOT KNOW IT OR HE DOES AND HE DOES NOT CARE. And then the Ian Dnie conversation. She brings him up almost as an afterthought — 'There are people in Masion with a reddish tint to their eyes, I noticed.' Casual! Totally casual! And Terion goes 'Yes, at the banquet' like he remembered this information from a brief encounter. Then SHE says 'People seem to like Sir Dnie' and he just stops walking and asks 'But I am prettier, right?' And when she stalls he pushes 'Surely not. Him over me?' The confidence is absurd. The vulnerability underneath it is... also there? 'Please answer fairly.' He actually wants a fair answer. This man is a walking contradiction wrapped in blue hair and a devastating smile.
... Read More
Let's be real: this chapter hurts because the stakes are invisible to everyone except Pamona. On the surface, nothing dramatic happens. Two people talk at sunset. But underneath? Pamona is fighting a war against her own desperation. She wants to believe Heil will be fine. She wants to believe Terion's reassurances. She wants to go to Ilion. She wants to be seen. She wants none of this to matter. The internal conflict is brutal: if she admits how much she wanted to go, she's admitting how much she hates being trapped. If she lets Terion see her vulnerability, he might pity her—or worse, laugh. And yet, she keeps opening up. She tells him about the lake. About the forest. About her sister. Each admission is a risk. Each silence from Terion is a relief that somehow feels like hope. External stakes? Ilion remains mysterious. We know almost nothing about it except that outsiders can't enter, that Princess Heil went there at eighteen, that four siblings rule, and that Terion's brother is also eighteen. That's it. The author is deliberately withholding, which makes Pamona's longing sharper. She's grieving a place she's never seen. And Terion? His stake is subtler but equally real. He's a ghost-hunter, apparently. He asked about a woman Pamona claims she didn't see. He knows she's lying but doesn't press. Instead, he offers her something more valuable than answers: the belief that she could leave if she wanted to. “I will take you.” Those words change everything—not because they're promises, but because they're the first time anyone has treated her confinement as negotiable rather than absolute.
... Read More
The geography of this place is doing SO much heavy lifting and I'm here for it. Payen Castle on the east side is described almost like a circus tent that never stops spinning—noisy, crowded, full of princes huffing and puffing and establishing dominance. Reynard's tantrum echoes off walls that seem designed to carry sound everywhere. It's claustrophobically loud even when the prose isn't shouting. But then Pamona walks. And walks. Past every path she knows, past the eastern territory, all the way to the WESTERN side of the palace grounds. And suddenly—the grass. The wind. 'Standing still, she could hear the sound of the wind moving through the grass.' That line. That's the whole novel in one sentence. After two chapters of noise, silence becomes its own kind of revelation. And the contrast isn't just atmospheric, it's political. The east castles belong to the powerful—the queen's children, the concubines' favored sons. Heil's Heryen Castle sits far out in the west because she's the daughter of someone the king didn't care about, born a girl in a system where both of those facts make you invisible. The physical distance between east and west IS the social hierarchy. I also love how the author describes the garden: 'Soil turned up every which way, weeds growing in wild tangles, pulled out every day only to spring up fresh again.' That's not just scenery. That's the entire royal family in metaphor form.
... Read More
This scene with Pamona and Terion absolutely wrecked me. You know that feeling when someone finally asks the question you've been carrying around alone? That's exactly what happens when Terion asks “Why?” about the castle rules. Pamona's internal reaction is everything: “A question she had asked countless times had finally been asked by someone other than herself.” The way she teases him afterward is so carefully constructed. She makes him put it on his tab, says “put two on the tab,” but really she's just relieved someone finally saw her as a person instead of just a princess behind walls. And Terion? He doesn't push. He just sits with her in it. But then—God. When Heil comes up, Pamona completely falls apart. She's worried, yes, but underneath that is jealousy and grief. She wanted to go. She should have refused. She stayed behind while her sister left. Terion senses this immediately. His gentle “Shall we go together someday?” and that tap on her hand—he doesn't try to fix it, he just offers presence. That blue-eyed softness is lethal. I love how Pamona fears he'll see through her and laugh like her half-siblings do. She's so desperate to maintain this playful mask. And Terion sees right through it anyway. Not with cruelty, but with that quiet intensity that makes her heart race. The scent detail—she imagined cool fragrance from afar, but up close it's warm and ticklish. How perfect. Distance had romanticized him; proximity has made him real.
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about how the author paints this scene? Pamona sitting by the lake, watching a body float there, and feeling... peaceful? That contrast is everything. The insects in the grass, the ripple like a fish playing, the stale smell of water that hasn't moved in years—it's like the whole world has gone silent except for those tiny natural sounds, and then you're jolted back into the reality of the castle nearby, all noise and duty and people in white dresses doing their thing. "Strangely, Pamona felt that this moment, sitting here with a body floating on the lake, was peaceful." I need to sit with that sentence for a second. A dead woman in the water and her immediate reaction is that it's peaceful? That's not some edgy writing choice either—it makes complete sense given who Pamona is. She's trapped in this castle, surrounded by banquets and expectations and people trying to dress her up like a doll, and the one moment of quiet she finds is at the edge of death itself. The imagery of the dark hair drifting on the water, the woman in white almost invisible in the night—it reads like a painting, and the narrator even says so. "Which was somehow like a painting." And then the next morning, the contrast is brutal. Sionel's invitation, the servants bustling around her, the whole ridiculous process of being dressed and powdered and ornamented like she's some kind of display piece. The castle itself feels like a character—massive, carved with symbols of the kingdom, towers piercing the sun, banners fluttering everywhere. It's beautiful and suffocating at the same time, and I think that's exactly the point. The royal castle is this place where nothing seems to matter, where a dead woman can float and no one notices, while simultaneously being this gilded cage that swallows people alive.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about Terion's laugh for a second because this is genuinely one of the most important moments in the entire book?? Pamona literally has this inner monologue where she compares Terion's laugh to everyone else's—Sionel gives hollow chuckles, Reynard laughs to mock people—and then Terion laughs this way that's clear and sincere and she can't stop listening. I literally screamed when I read that. Not because it's romantic (though it is) but because it's devastating in the best way. Pamona has apparently never heard someone laugh like that before, and the fact that she finds herself wanting to keep saying things to him that sound like jokes? That's the entire romance arc in one sentence. She's not falling for him because he's handsome or strong—she's falling for him because he makes her feel something she's never felt. And the way he teases her, pulling her into these ridiculous interactions where he makes her flustered and then apologizes while still laughing? That's not just charm, that's genuine warmth. He could be cruel given who he is, but he chooses to be light. Choose to make her laugh with him instead of at her. Even when she bursts into his bathroom by mistake, instead of being annoyed he plays along. This man is dangerous in the best possible way.
... Read More
What I love most about this narration is that it doesn't feel written—it feels overheard. Pamona's inner monologue is so restless, so stream-of-consciousness, with all these fragments and half-finished thoughts that somehow capture exactly what it's like to be someone who thinks too much and says too little. "Had she really had nothing to do all this time? She had forgotten, having spent so much of the past four years with Heil. How long and tedious each day had been." Four years. Four years of tedium, and the way that sentence lands—so matter-of-fact, so quiet, but underneath it there's this ache that the narrator never quite names. She doesn't say "I was lonely" or "I was sad." She says four years and how tedious each day was, and somehow that's infinitely more painful. The dialogue itself is sparse but razor-sharp. Reynard's line—"Hey, are you smitten?"—is perfectly Reynard. No elaboration, no malice on the surface, just that blunt delivery that cuts right through whatever pretense Pamona might be putting on. And Sionel using the word "invitation" deliberately, making it an event, making her an obligation—those small details in how people speak to and about her tell you everything about her position in this world. "Your Highness, the Princess has arrived." The formal announcement followed by a bell ringing once—that single ring feels so loaded. It's ceremonial, cold, like she's being presented rather than welcomed. The servants' dialogue throughout these chapters is equally revealing. They ask permission to open curtains, to prepare baths, to dress her—always asking, always performing service, and she always swallows her protests. The narration itself has this rhythmic quality, these questions that stack up: "What had brought her here?" "Had someone disturbed her?" "Whether it was she herself who had left herself like this, or not." These aren't rhetorical questions—they're the sound of a mind that can't stop turning, that's trying to solve a mystery even when the stakes feel abstract. And that's what makes reading Pamona's POV so immersive. You're not watching her think about things—you're inside the thinking itself, bouncing from observation to speculation to dread to numbness and back again, all in the span of a few paragraphs. The voice is unmistakable. No other narrator in fiction feels quite like this.
... Read More
Let me just say this scene is doing SO MUCH work and I am here for it. Pamona is watching Terion walk away, completely captivated by his back, and he STOPs. Turns around. Holds out his palm like she's some kind of bloodhound. "Does anything smell strange?" And what does she do? She presses her face into his hand and sniffs. Like a dog. Like an animal. And then HE does the same to HER—buries his nose in her shoulder, sniffs her hair, declares she smells good despite being pulled from dirty water. This is intimate without being romantic, and that's what makes it so electric. They're learning each other through sensory details that have nothing to do with formal introductions. Meanwhile Pamona is spiraling internally about his forearms being the size of her legs and Terion is over here just being effortlessly charming in a wet shirt. The power dynamic is wild too—he's a guest in her home but he's completely in control of every interaction, and she's the one losing her composure. And yet she's the one who says the boldest thing: "You must be a bit of an odd person, Terion." She calls him out on his strangeness while being equally strange herself. That's not submission, that's recognition.
... Read More
I need to talk about Heil because WOW. This girl shows up for like ten pages and completely steals the emotional weight of the entire chapter. Remember how Pamona spends the first half of this chapter being absolutely invisible to everyone who matters? Reynard uses her as furniture. The princes don't even bother learning her name properly because why would they? She's just there, a girl among boys, tolerated at best. And then she walks into the west and bumps into Heil—her only sister—and everything shifts. Heil introduces herself. Like, full formal self-introduction. 'I present my greetings, Your Highness. My name is Heil. I am your younger sister.' Not because she has to, but because she actually WANTS Pamona to know who she is. That moment hit me like a truck. And then the way she looks at Pamona—'her eyes were shining.' She's genuinely excited to see her. After all this time, across the entire castle grounds, these two girls who are the ONLY daughters have been orbiting each other like strangers. The fact that Heil says 'I always heard news that you were well. I never expected to see you here' made my chest tighten. Pamona's own thought—'It is a little inconvenient... But for some reason she couldn't name, it felt like an inconvenience she was willing to accept'—that's the quietest, most devastating line about human connection I've read in a while. She's so starved for genuine warmth that even an intrusion feels like oxygen.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this section makes you feel physically while reading it, because WOW. The opening starts almost dreamily—Pamona and Heil talking about sea views and dream husbands. Light, airy, almost comedic. Then it rains. Just suddenly. "Pit-a-pat. Drop." Two words and the mood drops like a stone. From sisterly chatter to heavy dramatic reveal in three sentences. Then Sionel appears with Ian Dnie and the pacing shifts into something claustrophobic. Every line of dialogue is measured, controlled, polite. Teacups being set down. Slow sips. The word "calm down" repeated like a mantra that only makes things worse. The author is using the opposite of chaos to build tension—and it's brilliant. The slower everyone moves, the more panicked Pamona gets, and the more panicked Pamona gets, the more panicked YOU get. When Pamona says "I'll go" the pace accelerates wildly. Quick back-and-forth. Questions without answers. Sionel pressing his fingers to his temple—that's the author letting us hear the internal clock ticking. And then Ian Dnie speaks, flat and final, and everything stops again. The chapter ends on that note of collapse, not resolution. No dramatic exit, no breakthrough. Just Pamona dropping her head and realizing she's been looking at her sister wrong this whole time. The pacing doesn't give you relief—it gives you revelation. And honestly? That's so much more devastating.
... Read More
Everything about color in this chapter is loaded. Terion has blue hair and blue eyes—colors that seem “not of this world” according to Pamona's own thoughts. Blue represents the foreign, the untamed, the answer to questions she's too afraid to ask. Then the sunset pours red light over everything. Red is passion, danger, the visible heat of suppressed emotion. The blending—“the red had seeped into the blue and drawn out a deeper shade”—that's the entire relationship in one image. Water imagery dominates: the lake Pamona compares herself to, the “deep and quiet current stirred” beneath Terion's closed lashes, the damp air settling between them. Water is transformation. Water moves. Pamona explicitly says she is stagnant water, but the scene itself is flowing. She's beginning to move toward something, even if she won't admit it. The forest is another crucial symbol. “The forest grew on love.” Heil created it not through gardening technique but through devotion. It's wild because love is wild. Meanwhile, Pamona remains in the castle—manicured, contained, beautiful but artificial. She can't tend a forest. She can only lie down and stare at the ceiling. That's tragedy, but it's also resistance. Her refusal to leave isn't weakness; it's a different kind of love—for Heil, for home, for the sister she couldn't stop from going. And that gaze—Terion's blue eyes watching Pamona instead of the sunset—that's the real transformation. He sees her. Not the princess. Pamona.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second. Pamona's younger sister has been TAKEN. Her own bedroom has been OCCUPIED by a man she barely knows. She cannot sleep in her own castle. She is surrounded by political marriages she didn't choose — Ian Dnie, House Dnie, all of it. And what is she doing on this particular evening? Discussing whether Terion is prettier than her fiancé. The stakes are TERRIBLE and the surface-level conversation is about a GARDEN. She wanted to keep it exactly as Heil left it. Even if it cannot be improved upon, she wants it preserved. This is about something so much bigger than flowers — it's about holding onto the last intact piece of something before everything changed. And now Terion wants to tend it. She says no repeatedly. She says 'The garden cannot be ruined by the time she comes back' — implying her sister WILL come back. There is hope there, or maybe just stubborn refusal to accept anything else. But the real tension isn't the plot tension — it's the quiet, suffocating tension of a woman who hasn't slept properly in who knows how long, who flinches when servants enter rooms, who finds herself letting a complete stranger sit on her stone and pull her to her feet. The domestic moments are where the real danger lives. Every 'Good night, Terion' she says while fleeing is a brick in a wall she's building between herself and whatever this is becoming. And Terion — he stays up all night thinking about seeing her in the morning. 'I had something lovely to look forward to.' This is a man who is fully aware of what he's doing to her and he is NOT stopping. The rain came. She stayed. He watched her sleep in HER bed. And in the morning he appears 'from somewhere without warning' like he owns the place. What happens when she finally catches up to how deep she's in?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or