Before the Predetermined Future Arrives - Reviews

Before the Predetermined Future Arrives
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Pamona and Heil because their dynamic is doing so much heavy lifting here. On the surface, it reads like typical older-sister teasing—Pamona calling Heil a baby, Heil getting mad, the whole routine. But when you actually look at what's happening, it flips. Heil is the one who's actually composed now. She's the one tending the garden with precision, knowing every plant name, treating everyone with careful courtesy. Pamona is the one in the nightgown, rolling around in the dirt until her clothes are ruined. The moment where Heil gets called a baby and literally falls over laughing—it's so specific. It shows that despite being two years older and apparently more 'adult,' Heil still melts around Pamona. And Pamona? She's holding onto this idea of Heil as a child because if Heil is a baby, then maybe their world hasn't changed that much. But then Pamona jokes, 'Have you ever seen a baby who's engaged?' and you can see the guilt underneath the humor. She knows. She knows Heil is growing up too, even if she wants to pretend time stopped at the Twin Castle. The tragedy is in those small gestures—Pamona picking up the gloves Heil threw and slapping them on the ground, mimicking her. It's sibling synchronization. They're drifting toward different futures (Ian, the dukedom, marriage) but right now, in the garden, they're just two girls who figured out how to be sisters over four years.
... Read More
"Ian Dnie would not give it a second thought. If he were the sort of man who placed any meaning in this kind of thing, he would have sent word weeks ago to arrange it in advance. He knew she would refuse, so he sent someone on the day itself just to keep up appearances." This right here. This is the kind of sentence that makes you understand an entire relationship in three lines. Ian Dnie isn't cruel, exactly. He's just... empty. He goes through the motions because that's what you do when you're engaged to a princess, and Pamona knows it too. She doesn't hate him for it. She just recognizes the performance for what it is, and honestly, that's kind of sadder than if he were genuinely mean. Then there's Reynard. Oh, Reynard. "Hey, are you smitten?" He says this about the blue-haired entity, and it's so casually brutal, but also—I don't know, does he ever say anything serious to his sister? The text says he torments Pamona and she just takes it, and that dynamic feels so specific and painful. He's the younger brother who knows exactly which buttons to push, and the worst part is she lets him because what else is she supposed to do? And Sionel—his brother, the Crown Prince—uses the word "invitation" deliberately, makes a show of it, wants to see her face. There's something controlling about that, even if it's wrapped in familial warmth. These are all the men in her life who either want something from her or treat her like glass, and she's just sitting there thinking about going back to the lake to check on a dead woman instead of any of them. "Please... stop." The words rise to her tongue as the servants handle her like a doll, but she swallows them. That's Pamona in a nutshell, isn't it? Not rebellious, not dramatic, just... internally screaming while outwardly compliant. What kind of person does that make her? What kind of person does that make her world?
... Read More
Ian Dnie's dialogue is terrifying because it's so controlled. "Childish talk." That's it. Two words to dismiss the most emotionally raw moment in the entire chapter and he says it like he's commenting on the weather. He doesn't even look at Pamona when he says it. He's speaking to her but not seeing her, and that's somehow worse than if he'd yelled. Sionel's voice is completely different—he performs warmth. "Your Highness" used almost teasingly at one point, that gesture with his fingers at his temple that screams *you're giving me a headache*, and then the pivot to gentle brother mode when she actually matters. "Because you're my sister" lands because he said it while looking directly at her, unhurried, with affection in his eyes. Whether it's real or calculated, the delivery is perfect. But Pamona's internal monologue? That's where the real voice lives. The way her thoughts spiral—"She must have been startled? He was a brother she cherished dearly under ordinary circumstances, but not now."—that's not polished. That's raw stream of consciousness. She's angry at Sionel for existing while calm, furious at the situation, guilty for being furious, and then suddenly compassionate toward Heil all in the span of three paragraphs. Heil's dialogue is almost entirely absent because she's not even in the room—she exists only through Pamona's memories of her. But those memories paint a vivid picture: the sobbing the night before, then waking up already adjusted. "What would change even if we saw the Crown Prince?" That line is devastating in its simplicity. Heil doesn't perform grief. She doesn't have the luxury. The narrative voice itself is third-person limited, locked tight to Pamona, and it never lets go. Every observation is filtered through her exhaustion, her resentment, her dawning guilt. The author doesn't narrate feelings—they narrate physical sensations. Shoulders trembling. Throat parched. Hands shaking. You feel the anxiety in your own body before you understand what it's about.
... Read More
Okay so the king has basically declared Heil a political hostage disguised as a diplomatic envoy and NO ONE is stopping him except Pamona—and she can barely stand up. The plot is building this slow, crushing tension where everyone involved knows something is wrong but nobody has the power or will to fight it. Let me break down why this scene works so well structurally. First, we get the info dump through Pamona's panicked retelling: Heil got the decree two weeks before departure, to a country literally nobody has ever visited. That's not diplomacy—that's throwing someone into the dark. Then Ian Dnie chimes in, cool as a cucumber, revealing he was part of the negotiations. The person most affected knew last. The betrothed knew first. That hierarchy of information is deliberate cruelty. Pamona's offer to substitute herself is the emotional peak, and Sionel's refusal—"Because you're my sister"—is the thematic gut punch. It confirms she's right to be furious but also confirms she's trapped. The plot isn't just moving forward; it's tightening like a noose. And that ending? "She wondered whether she had ever truly looked at Heil's life"—that's the pivot point. Everything shifts from external conflict to internal realization. The real story here isn't Ilion. It's Pamona finally seeing the world through someone else's eyes instead of her own.
... Read More
I need to process what happens when the royal decree arrives. Because this is where the abstract becomes unbearable. Pamona has spent years knowing she'd marry into House Dnie. She's accepted it. She's told herself she has no dreams left to lose, no heart left to hurt. So when the official unrolls that paper and announces the betrothal to Ian Dnie, you'd think she'd be prepared. But the text says: 'Pamona felt for a moment as though something inside her had broken down.' That's the conflict right there—not between her and the marriage, but between what she thought she felt and what she actually feels. She thought she'd processed it. She thought she'd moved past wanting things she can't have. But hearing it spoken aloud, in a formal decree, in front of an official—it makes it real. And reality hits differently than speculation. The stakes aren't just political or romantic; they're existential. This is about who she is versus who she's supposed to become. The war ending removes the excuse to delay. Her brother Sionel's marriage triggers hers. Time, which she thought had paused in the garden, is now accelerating. And Heil's reaction—that forced optimism, 'It's Sir Dnie. If it has to happen, there's no one better suited than him'—adds another layer of tension. Heil is performing support while probably feeling the same dread. The external conflict (the decree, the marriage) forces both sisters to confront their internal conflicts (loss of agency, fear of the future). The rain at the end isn't just weather. It's the release of all that pressure. The storm breaks, and they're standing in it together.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about the sea. Seriously, the sea. Because Pamona's entire monologue about Ilion and the ocean is doing so much symbolic work. She's asking these innocent questions—what color is it, does it smell fishy, are the waves fierce like horses or soft like butterflies—but she's really asking about freedom. About a world beyond the palace walls. The sea represents everything she's been denied: boundlessness, mystery, the possibility of something unknown. And Ilion, the closed island nation, mirrors her own confinement. Just as no outsiders go to Ilion, no one really knows what's on the other side of her world. There's this haunting line: 'Would it carry a fishy smell like a lake? If not, what smell would it have?' She's trying to imagine something entirely foreign using only the sensory tools she has. That's exactly what she's doing with her life—trying to picture a future she's never experienced, using only the framework of duty and expectation. And the foam—'Would it be clear and blue like the many paintings she had seen? Would the endless spread of blue feel beautiful, or would the boundlessness feel frightening?' Here's the theme laid bare: the unknown is both allure and terror. The sea could be everything she wants, or it could swallow her whole. Just like marriage, just like adulthood, just like whatever comes next. The fact that Lady Rine only saw the sea once in her life adds another layer. Even those who escape confinement still carry the weight of what they missed. Pamona's questions aren't just curiosity; they're grief for experiences she may never have.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the tension in these chapters is absolutely chef's kiss. Pamona finds a dead woman in the lake, doesn't report it, goes back the next night to check, and what does she find? Not the body. She finds THE THING. The tall, blue-headed entity that sends her running back to the castle in pure terror. And then—plot twist of the century—the same entity is introduced at lunch the next day like nothing happened. Like Pamona didn't spend the night sprinting through darkness because something non-human was walking toward her. The stakes shift so smoothly from internal to external here. On one level, Pamona is drowning in existential dread—what's the point of her life, why is she trapped in this castle, who is she even—for God's sake, she literally wonders if she should take up gardening just to have something to do. But then you drop in a supernatural entity with blue hair and suddenly her problems have a face. A very handsome, divine face, apparently, because even Pamona notices. "She was flustered because her body had locked up on her, contrary to every thought telling her to run." That moment of paralysis—fear and fascination colliding—is everything. And the suspense! The author doesn't tell us what this thing is. We only get Pamona's POV: the blue light where hair should be, the cold wind, the way it moves slowly and deliberately toward her. Then it's standing at a formal dinner like it belongs there. What is it? Why is it here? Is it connected to the dead woman? Is it connected to Heil? Is it connected to anything human? The external conflict just exploded while her internal conflict was barely being tended to, and I am HERE for it. She went from questioning whether her life has meaning to encountering something that actively defies the natural world, and the book doesn't even pause to let her process it before lunch. That's how you pace a reveal.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or