Before the Predetermined Future Arrives - Reviews

Before the Predetermined Future Arrives
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"When a Blue Root tree grows large, its once-solid trunk becomes soft and supple. After that, some of the branches begin to droop down toward the ground. You take a few of those branches, which are tougher than rope, and weave them together to make a swing like that one." I keep coming back to this description because it's the perfect metaphor for everything. Pamona sits on that swing all the time—kicks her feet, enjoys the shade—but she never actually looked at what it was made of. She just enjoyed the result. Heil, though, she knows the tree's history, knows how the branches were woven. That's their whole relationship in miniature: Pamona enjoying the comfort, Heil maintaining the structure. The garden itself feels like a character. It's enclosed, curated, alive with Heil's devotion. The Blue Root trees ring the entire space like a border. And then there's the rain at the end—heavy clouds gathering, the first drop falling tap onto Pamona's face. The author does this brilliant thing where the garden feels safe and contained, but the sky above it is opening up. That transition from the ordered plants to the unpredictable weather mirrors what's happening to Pamona. She's been contained in the palace, in her duties, in her anticipated marriage. Now the rain is coming, and she can't stay dry forever. The imagery of the red berries too—too small to be proper fruit, not looking edible, but Heil knows their name. Even the details Pamona ignores have their own existence. The world feels lived-in because everyone sees it differently.
... Read More
Heil is different from her. She lay staring at the ceiling every night wondering why and how she could be so different. This line hit me like a truck. Pamona spent the entire chapter obsessing over how radiant and adaptable Heil is, but then at the very end she finally lets herself see it—the reason Heil is so good at surviving is that she had no choice. There was no one there to protect her. No Sionel. No mother really. Just darkness and adaptation. And Pamona? She's been worn down by waiting for light that never comes. Iron skewer through her core. That's not strength, that's just... rust. She can't bend, but she can't move either. The sister dynamic is so layered. Pamona genuinely envies Heil—not because of what Heil has, but because of what Heil hasn't lost yet. And when she offers to go to Ilion instead, it's not heroism. It's guilt. She's protecting the one part of herself that's still alive through her sister. Sionel says "Because you're my sister" when Pamona asks why she can't go. But what about Heil? Heil is his sister too. Half-sister, sure, but still. The protectiveness has a hierarchy and Heil falls outside it. That fact alone explains everything about who Heil became.
... Read More
There is a moment in these chapters where heavy rain starts falling and Terion just says 'Stay the night' and the way it lands — it's so casually devastating. The prose describes 'patter patter' and then 'heavy rain poured down over the garden at once.' The rain is basically the universe itself telling Pamona she cannot leave. She literally cannot go back to Payen Castle tonight. Fate is intervening with weather. And the images! Pamona visualizing Terion from behind, blue hair against the red sky — 'a lovely shadow.' The color palette alone is cinematic. Red sky. Blue hair. Blue eyes. The dried steam rising from his hair. Sunlight pouring through curtains that shouldn't exist in this bedroom. Every frame is deliberate. What I keep coming back to is how the setting mirrors Pamona's internal state. The Twin Castle is the place she dreamed of as a child, and yet here she is — displaced, unable to sleep in her own home, sleeping in someone else's bed, surrounded by people who have taken things from her. The garden she wanted to keep exactly as Heil left it... it's the only thing she controls, and now Terion is going to tend it. Symbolism much? The morning scene where she wakes up to sunlight she can't escape because there are no curtains — she's been exposed overnight, vulnerable, and the first person she sees is the man who stole her bedroom. 'The bedroom plunderer appeared from somewhere without warning.' The word 'plunderer' is doing SO much work here. He plundered her space, her sleep, her composure. And yet she sits on his outer robe without protest. She sits on it LIKE IT'S ALLOWED TO BE THERE.
... Read More
What gets me about this whole setup isn't some big dramatic threat—it's the suffocating sense that Pamona is always one bad decision away from disaster, and she has zero control over it. Think about it: fourteen princes, all raised on swordsmanship and tactics, all bigger and stronger than her, and not a single one of them has ever bothered to genuinely know her. She admits it herself—that if they all turned on her at once, her handful of guards wouldn't save her. That's not paranoia, that's a structural reality. She's living in a den of lions and pretending the cage door is locked. And what's brutal is how normal this sounds to her. She just walks around with this background radiation of fear and calls it 'peaceful and quiet.' The fact that she can't even identify the threat by name—she forgets seventeen of her own siblings' names!—makes it worse. She doesn't even know who might want to hurt her. Meanwhile Reynard, the literal child version of chaos, waltzes through the same castle throwing temper tantrums like a emperor in miniature, and nobody even blinks. He gets to be dangerous and get away with it. She gets to be fragile and have to live with it forever. I keep waiting for the other shoe to drop. Like, how long can this tension simmer before something actually snaps? Because the author is clearly laying groundwork—Heil appearing out of nowhere in the west, the political landscape, the war happening beyond the borders—all of it feels like setup for something big.
... Read More
I have to praise the dialogue here because it's deceptively simple. These two sound like real sisters, not some stiff royal upbringing would produce. The rhythm is perfect—quick, overlapping, full of shorthand. 'I'm not a baby anymore, sister.' 'Babies never like being called babies. They have no idea how good it is to be one.' That line from Pamona? That's wisdom wrapped in teasing. She's saying something true while also getting under Heil's skin. And Heil's response—'Sister, you keep subtly looking down on me now that you've come of age'—it's sharp but affectionate. You can hear the eye roll through the text. The humor lands because it's grounded in physicality. Heil falling into the dirt. The gloves flying. Pamona mocking her by slapping her own gloves against the ground. The dialogue isn't just words; it's movement. It's two people who know each other's tells. But what's interesting is how the tone shifts when they talk about the future. 'It's going to be all right. It's Sir Dnie.' Heil's reassurance feels practiced, like she's saying it to convince herself as much as Pamona. The dialogue carries that double meaning—surface-level comfort, underneath anxiety. That's craft. The author lets you hear what they're not saying.
... Read More
Okay so Pamona literally NEVER had anyone call her shadow lovely. In ALL her life. And Terion just... drops that line like it's nothing. Like he's not completely dismantling every single wall she's built up. And then when she says 'Please do not,' what does he do? He laughs. He LAUGHS and says 'Shall I say it often?' This is not a man who respects personal boundaries in the traditional sense, and honestly I am HERE FOR IT. But the thing that really gets me is HOW he operates. Watch this — he wants to tend the garden. She says no. So he doesn't push. He just... slowly erodes her resistance over like three paragraphs of increasingly pathetic pleading. 'Would you pass that along to the caretaker?' 'What if I did it?' 'I am quite good at it.' 'If they had eyes, do you not think they would like me?' — this is not manipulation, this is something else entirely. He knows exactly what he's doing. Every line is calibrated to make her feel simultaneously exasperated and... I don't know, seen? And then the bedroom scene. She's furious that he's occupying her room, that her sister was taken, and yet she lets him stay because apparently the rain is worse than her discomfort. The fact that she falls into such a deep, unbroken sleep in a stranger's bed in a stranger's house tells you everything about how exhausted she is underneath all that composure. 'I slept wonderfully' — said the woman who cannot sleep at home. The contrast is devastating. That hand pull at the end where he yanks her up and they're suddenly too close and she wants to disappear — she thinks he's joking but he's not. He says 'I know, I heard' about Ian Dnie like he's filing it away for later. This man is playing a LONG game and Pamona is too tired to notice.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk structure for a second because this chapter is a masterclass in controlled pacing. The entire scene takes place during one sunset. That's not accidental. The sky goes from gray heaviness to bright flame to red, and Pamona's emotional state mirrors that exact arc. She starts guarded and curious, moves through vulnerability, dips into darkness when Heil comes up, and ends somewhere warm but unresolved. The author doesn't rush any of it. Every beat earns its place. Notice how the lake gets introduced early—Pamona says she is “still water in a lake,” stagnant, born there, forced to remain stagnant. Then later the forest: “The forest grew on love.” These aren't just decorative images. They're structural anchors. The lake represents her trapped self; the forest represents Heil's wildness; the garden is somewhere in between—tended but overgrown, maintained by one person's love. And that ending? “The breeze blowing in was cool, yet it felt warm.” Cut to black (or rather, cut to an unfinished sentence). Perfect. The scene doesn't need to resolve. It needs to leave us feeling exactly what Pamona feels in that moment: caught between warmth and chill, embarrassment and hope, confinement and the fantasy of freedom. The author also does something brilliant with silence. Terion doesn't fill every gap. He watches. He taps her hand. He looks at her instead of the sunset. These pauses create space for Pamona's internal monologue to breathe. Without those beats, the pacing would feel rushed. With them, it breathes.
... Read More
Okay first of all—Reynard's dialogue is MASTERCLASS level writing. The kid is fourteen, the son of the queen, heir to the throne potentially, and he sounds EXACTLY like what you'd expect: loud, impulsive, completely lacking in filter, and somehow absolutely charming despite being a menace. "Can't you hear me! Huh?" "I'm going to die of frustration, seriously!" "Hurry up and get over here!" This kid doesn't speak in sentences, he speaks in projectiles. And the fact that he yells "Rafaello? Rafaello? Then who's this person? Huh? Is this one also Rafaello?" after Pamona embarrasses herself? That's not cruelty, that's just a kid who has no concept of social consequence and finds everything mildly amusing. But here's what's genius: the narration NEVER judges him for it. The narrator just... observes. "Because no one expected anything from him in the first place, there was nothing to fight about. He was nothing more than a foolish young colt." This is narrative empathy at its finest. Reynard is written with the same warmth you'd give a golden retriever that just knocked over a vase and is now looking at you with earnest eyes. Compare that to Pamona's internal monologue, which is all ellipses and hesitation and self-doubt. Their voices couldn't be more different, and that contrast is how the author builds their relationship without ever stating it outright.
... Read More
The opening of this sequence is CINEMATIC. Pamona drowning in a lake, everything blurry, and then this blue light cutting through the current like something out of a fantasy film. She surfaces gasping, disoriented, and there he is—Terion emerging from the water with sunlight catching his blue hair, looking absurdly composed while she's a drowned rat. The contrast between them is almost comedic. But what I love about this scene is how the environment mirrors their emotional states. The lake is stagnant, dirty, cold—everything Pamona has been feeling trapped in. Terion pulls her out into open air, into sunlight, into warmth. And then there's the Twin Castle itself, this mirrored replica where she keeps walking the wrong way, disoriented, frustrated. It's a physical manifestation of her entire existence—familiar but reversed, comfortable but wrong. The Western Bridge becomes this liminal space where they finally talk, where the sun is setting and the air is cool, and for once she's not running from anything. She's standing still with someone who could destroy her but chooses to lean against a pillar and comment on the weather instead.
... Read More
This exchange about princesses not being allowed to leave the castle hit me like a truck. Terion asks "when?" like it's the most absurd question he's ever heard, and Pamona's answer is just... yes. She's never left. Not once. And he's genuinely confused by this, like it's some foreign concept. What's interesting is that Terion himself is described as having a "blue soul"—he radiates the same color as the light that saved her from drowning. He's everything freedom represents, and he's standing right there offering to help her understand a world she's never known. Meanwhile she keeps running into his bathroom trying to escape her own situation, tripping over her own instincts. The mirrored castle is symbolic too—everything is the same but backwards, just like how she's supposed to be identical to other princesses but she's fundamentally different. She doesn't just want to leave the castle; she wants to leave the version of herself that's been built for her. And Terion, in his complete innocence about how the world works, might be the only person who could help her do that without judging her for wanting to.
... Read More
The sea keeps appearing in this text like a ghost. Heil imagines Pamona getting a villa by the sea. Pamona thinks about it for exactly two seconds before dismantling the fantasy. The sea represents everything Pamona can't have—freedom, beauty, openness, a world beyond these walls. And Heil offers it so naturally, because she genuinely believes in the possibility of good things. That's the tragedy: Heil's hope is real, and it's also useless. Then there's the darkness motif, which is absolutely central. Pamona describes herself as having "worn herself out grumbling about why the light wouldn't come in and collapsed from it." She wanted light. She waited for it. And it never came. Meanwhile, Heil "learned to see clearly inside a pitch-dark cave. She knew how not to fall." This isn't praise—it's mourning. Heil survived by becoming someone who doesn't need light. Pamona died inside by needing it anyway. The rain that starts falling during their conversation isn't just atmosphere. It's the external world finally matching the internal one. "She could see the sky darkening to match her world." The weather doesn't change anything—it just confirms what's already true. And the castle itself, repeatedly described as a pretty cage, borders the sea but Pamona can never reach it. That's the symbolic core of everything: proximity without access. Being close to freedom but imprisoned by it. But the deepest symbol is probably Heil herself. She's not just a character—she's what Pamona lost. The ability to adapt without breaking. The ability to find something good in mud. By the end of the chapter, Pamona realizes she's been projecting her own trapped state onto Heil, when really Heil learned to survive differently because she was never given the same protections. The book is asking: who gets to remain soft in a hard world, and who gets hardened by necessity?
... Read More
I keep coming back to the water imagery in these chapters, and I think it's not accidental at all. The lake is described as stagnant—"so long it gave off a stale smell"—and it's holding a dead woman. Stagnant water, dead water, hidden water. And Pamona is drawn to it repeatedly, like she understands what that water represents without being able to name it. "Is it quiet now? Is she at peace at last?" That question about the dead woman echoes Pamona's own question about herself. Who is this woman who chose (or was forced) to end up in this dark, stagnant lake? And more importantly—does Pamona see her own reflection in that floating body? She's alive but not really living, surrounded by people but utterly alone, trapped in a castle she can't leave, performing royalty like it's a role she was born into but never chose. The white dress is another detail that won't leave me. "If she had not been wearing white, would anyone have noticed her in this dark night?" White makes the woman visible—makes her death visible—yet no one sees her anyway. The body is gone by morning and the castle acts like nothing happened. That's the real horror, isn't it? Not the supernatural entity, not the dead woman, but the erasure. The way people who die quietly just... disappear from everyone's awareness. And then the blue hair. That unnatural, luminous blue against the darkness—could it be a symbol of something outside this world's moral system? Something that doesn't care about the games of courts and castles and marriages? Pamona runs from it in terror, but she's also drawn back to it, just like she's drawn back to the lake. Both the dead woman and the blue-haired entity represent an escape from the suffocating normalcy of her life, even if that escape looks like death or madness to everyone else. The recurring motif of light and dark is doing a lot of heavy lifting too. The banquet is full of light and noise and people, and it exhausts her. The lake at night is dark and silent, and it calms her. Is the author suggesting that truth lives in darkness and performance lives in light? Or is Pamona just deeply, profoundly tired of pretending?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or