A Midsummer Night’s Letter - Reviews

A Midsummer Night’s Letter
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There are two scenes in this batch that I keep coming back to, and they're not the big dramatic ones—they're the quiet, almost mundane moments that somehow carry more weight. The first is Xu Jing pressing his ear against the apartment door. Think about the sensory details here: the silence on the other side, the hesitation, the way he immediately feels “perverted” for doing it. It's such a specific, intimate image—this kid from apartment 601, who barely speaks to his neighbor, standing at a threshold between spaces, listening for a sound that never comes again. The door becomes this liminal object, a barrier that's also a connection point, and Xu Jing's inability to cross it says everything about his character. The second scene is the empty cabinet. Shen Yan describes it with this reverent certainty—the blue cabinet, the models arranged by number, the one missing piece in the middle. It's such a vivid visual, and it represents something larger: memory as curation, the way we arrange our past into neat little rows and then leave one space intentionally blank. That empty grid isn't just missing a race car; it's a hole where someone important used to be. And Shen Yan's devastation when Xu Jing says “I never gave that to anyone” hits because it's not just about the object—it's about the person it represented being erased from Xu Jing's story. The school scenes are also worth noting for how they build the world. The strict Zhou Yan at the gate, the two-hundred-page student handbook, the rumor about upperclassmen getting lectured for an entire morning—these details paint a picture of a place that's rigid, almost dystopian in its rules, but where the teachers occasionally show mercy. Li Qin's joke about her eyesight (“can you help me see if this is really Xu Jing”) is such a perfect slice-of-life moment that grounds the whole story in something relatable. The classroom becomes this pressure cooker where Xu Jing's hidden competence finally explodes, and the silence that follows is delicious. These scenes work because they balance the emotional intensity with everyday texture—they make the world feel lived-in, not just a backdrop for drama.
... Read More
I need to just appreciate how cinematic some of these scenes are because the author really knows how to paint a picture. The horror story competition venue—small, crowded, lights suddenly going black. Xu Jing's immediate reaction is pure suffering. Having him sit in the dark for two hours would be more painful than killing him directly. I felt that. As someone who cannot tolerate darkness, this was visceral. But then the lighting comes back up and Shen Yan is there, leaning over with that faint mint scent. Clean and pleasant. The contrast between the oppressive dark and that sudden freshness is Chef's kiss. And then the scene where Xu Jing is watching Yan Zhe with that red-haired girl—"If it weren't for the occasion, they would have been stuck together. Xu Jing couldn't bear to watch and didn't want to admit in his heart that this guy was his friend." This is such a specific, aching detail. He's watching someone else's obvious romantic situation and feeling... something, and he won't even name it. The dinner scene has this gorgeous stillness to it. Shen Yan leads Xu Jing to the most secluded corner. The braised fish with its rich sauce and green onions. Xu Jing picking up a piece and narrowing his eyes unconsciously at the taste. These small sensory details make the world feel lived-in. And then the ending—Shen Yan stumbling into his apartment, glass shattering, swallowing red pills, heavy breathing echoing. The shift from warm restaurant light to that cold, painful darkness in his bedroom... it's like the entire chapter exhales and then gets punched in the chest. Visually, emotionally, it's devastating.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author uses structure because it's genuinely masterful. Chapter 1 ends with Xu Jing photographing the suspect and telling Yan Zhe "the murderer" while Yan Zhe goes silent. That's a chapter ENDING. Not a cliffhanger where someone gets attacked or a door opens—but just the weight of what was said hanging in the air. The silence of "…" is the actual climax. Then Chapter 2 opens with Yan Zhe's reaction, and immediately we're in action—Xu Jing following the guy. The transition from "I photographed a murder suspect" to "I am actively pursuing him on foot" is seamless because the chapter break gave us exactly the right amount of breathing room. The pacing inside scenes is equally controlled. Watch how Xu Jing's internal monologue works—he thinks through his options (call police? follow him? go home?) and each thought is a beat. The author doesn't rush his decisions. We feel the weight of each choice. And then the lockout situation creates a natural slowdown in Chapter 2. After the intensity of the pursuit, we get Yan Zhe playing mobile games and making bad jokes. It's a breather—but it's also building the mundane reality that makes the strange parts feel MORE real. The bus passing and the suspect vanishing—that moment of impossibility. One second he's there, two seconds he's gone. The pacing of that disappearance is almost choreographed. Fast enough to be shocking, slow enough to be witnessed.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about the scene where Shen Yan takes Xu Jing back to his own apartment and literally tends his wounds. This is HUGE for their relationship and I am still processing it. Think about it — these two were literally wrestling on a bed five chapters ago. Shen Yan was being all smug and condescending, and Xu Jing was ready to murder him. And then suddenly, Xu Jing shows up at his door with a beaten-up back after some fight I still don't fully understand, and Shen Yan just... takes him in. No questions asked at first. Just "This is my house" like he owns the place and Xu Jing somehow belongs there now. And the wound-tending scene?? The author writes "The place where his fingertips touched felt like an electric current was running through him, making him instinctively want to tremble." BRO. That's not medicine. That's not even about the pain. That's a completely different kind of electricity and both of them feel it. Xu Jing says "It's itchy" and pretends he's just hot in an air-conditioned room while his face is basically nuclear. Shen Yan doesn't call him out on it — he just... looks at him and says softly, "Did you fight with someone?" Not "who did you fight" or "why were you fighting." He just asks if he fought. Like he already knows this is what Xu Jing does. Like he's starting to understand the boy behind the attitude. And the absolute peak? Xu Jing, who literally cannot bring himself to say thank you directly, ends up fiddling with the quilt edge and whispering "Today, thank you." And Shen Yan just laughs — actually laughs — and says "You're welcome." That laugh. That's not mockery. That's something else entirely. Also Shen Yan walking out of his OWN house to check on Xu Jing at the door and seeing him doubled over in pain? The fact that he immediately came to get him? Something shifted here. I'm not okay.
... Read More
Okay so this entire chapter basically runs on the single most important dynamic in the book: Xu Jing and Shen Yan. Like, everything else is background noise. I need to talk about the hand thing first because I literally cannot get over it. They're sitting in the dark, Xu Jing is half-asleep, his hand lands on Shen Yan's side, and instead of pulling away, Shen Yan... moves his hand slightly toward Xu Jing. Toward HIM. Like, "go ahead, touch me." That is NOT normal friendship behavior. That is someone who is completely aware of what they're doing and is deliberately pushing boundaries. And then later, the voting scene? Shen Yan literally covers Xu Jing's hand with his own and guides it to press a button. Yan Zhe witnesses this and is visibly shaken. Yan Zhe, who knows Xu Jing desperately avoids all living things, is like "are you guys...?" and Xu Jing's response is basically a panicked retreat. But here's the thing that got me—Xu Jing doesn't actually break free immediately. He freezes. His mind goes to that memory of applying medicine. He FORGETS to pull away. That's not someone who's repulsed. That's someone who's confused by their own reaction. Then at dinner, Shen Yan says "so we're friends?" and Xu Jing's internal monologue is "if this person wasn't so annoying. Then, barely, yes." Barely. YES. The most reluctant agreement in literary history and I love it. They clearly don't like each other at first but now they can sit at the same table and eat. That's growth, baby. That's the whole arc compressed into a paragraph.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about the fact that Shen Yan showed up at Xu Jing's door? Like, in the dark, holding his bag, just... waiting? And Xu Jing's first instinct is basically 'what are you doing at MY door' which is such a Xu Jing move honestly. But then he notices the bruise and dismisses the thought that maybe Shen Yan was being KIND. That guy is so stubborn I love it. Their whole dynamic is just two boys who can't communicate their feelings at all and I am HERE FOR IT. And then the basketball scene where Xu Jing accidentally elbows Shen Yan? That's not even an accident of the body—it's an accident of the heart, right? He avoids touching him so deliberately but gravity and momentum don't care about your feelings. The ball rolls away, Shen Yan falls, and suddenly EVERYONE is worried except Xu Jing is just standing there stunned. Because of course no one else matters in that moment. I'm not even being dramatic about this.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—the way these two interact is absolutely delicious and I am obsessed. Shen Yan is a menace. A total, unrepentant menace. He fakes a sprained ankle (which, by the way, we KNOW because he basically admits it was intentional when he says 'it's easy to injure muscles and bones' like he calculated the risk), and then he literally throws his entire body weight onto Xu Jing on the stairs. Like bro, you could have broken your neck. But of course he doesn't, because this is all a scheme, and the scheme is: get Xu Jing to feel bad enough to actually talk to him. And Xu Jing—oh, Xu Jing. He's so done. He's so visibly done. 'I don't care if it breaks.' But he cares. He always cares. He's been carrying this guy (literally and figuratively) for a week, getting water, food, submitting homework, and he complains every single time but never actually refuses. The moment Shen Yan asks him to give a piggyback ride? Xu Jing's entire demeanor shifts. He's furious, he's threatening to throw him down, but he does it. He always does it. The back-carry scene is where it all clicks though. Shen Yan whispers those three apologies—'That night, it was my fault. I'm sorry. Don't be mad at me anymore.'—and Xu Jing just walks. Doesn't say anything for a long time. And then finally: 'Got it.' Not 'I forgive you.' Not 'It's okay.' Just 'Got it.' Like he's acknowledging that he heard it, that he's letting it land. And somehow that's so much more meaningful than any grand apology acceptance scene I've ever read.
... Read More
The racing car models aren't just set dressing—they're the whole point. That empty space in Xu Jing's cabinet where one model should be mirrors the gap in Shen Yan's life, represented by the yellowed photo and the matching model he keeps locked away. Both of them are missing something irreplaceable and neither knows how to talk about it. The darkness phobia is huge symbolically too. Xu Jing can't handle the dark, and Shen Yan is basically the personified darkness in his life—mysterious, unsettling, showing up unannounced at night, operating in shadows. But here's the thing: Shen Yan is also the one who apologizes. He's both the source of fear and the comfort. The locked box on his bedside table, the secrecy around his past, the way he lets people like Mao Chengyu call him "God Yan" while clearly preferring solitude—all of this points to a boy who built walls and doesn't know how to take them down. And Xu Jing? He pretends to read English. He puts the spiciest food on Shen Yan's plate as revenge for seeing through him. Everyone in this story is performing, wearing masks, and the racing car models are the only honest thing about them because they're either perfectly arranged or achingly empty.
... Read More
I'm going to be honest—I picked this book up for the plot but I'm staying for the dialogue. The banter between Xu Jing and Yan Zhe is absolutely immaculate. Some highlights that made me scream: Yan Zhe after his asthma performance: "Hahahahaha, am I awesome? Was my acting realistic?" Xu Jing: "Realistic. Like an idiot." That exchange is the kind of thing I read and immediately reread. Yan Zhe's hospital flattery speech: "Jing-ge, you're so wise, brave, handsome, kind-hearted, and suave, please be generous and don't hold it against me." And Xu Jing just says "Get out." And then Yan Zhe says "Okay" and leaves and then comes right back five seconds later. The commitment to the bit! The absurdity! The line that broke me though was Yan Zhe trying to rationalize their failed stalking mission: "Like handsome people are mostly good people, there's nothing good about not going home at night, like you should check the auspicious days before going out..." This man genuinely believes every single one of those lessons. He's writing himself a moral for tripping over his own feet while wearing a baseball cap over his eyes. And Shen Yan's voice is completely different—minimal, cold, almost bored. "Following in a group, is that so fun?" delivered from above them while they're sprawled on the ground after their spectacular fall. The contrast between these two characters' ways of speaking immediately tells you everything you need to know about their personalities without any exposition.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this moment where Shen Yan totally breaks and realizes he's been projecting this whole thing onto the wrong person. Like, he was so convinced that Xu Jing was someone else—some kid he gave a model race car to—that he completely misread everything. And then Xu Jing just looks at him like “what are you even talking about” and Shen Yan has to leave in this awkward, almost pathetic retreat. It's not the angry exit you'd expect; it's more like a wounded animal backing away. What's interesting is how this shifts their dynamic entirely. Before this, there was this weird tension where Shen Yan was always pushing, testing, maybe even punishing Xu Jing for something he didn't do. Now? Shen Yan is reeling. He's the one who looks vulnerable, stumbling out the door, while Xu Jing is just sitting there confused and slightly offended that his friend acted like a maniac over a toy car. And then the next morning, Xu Jing walks out and sees Shen Yan with this girl—Jiang Pei—and suddenly all that confusion gets layered with jealousy. Not that he'd admit it, obviously. But the way the text describes it, “his behavior of waiting all night for an apology was incredibly stupid,” that's not just pride talking. That's someone who cared enough to wait up, who wanted closure, who got denied it because Shen Yan's brain short-circuited. I keep thinking about what drove Shen Yan to call Jiang Pei at that hour and say “I got the wrong person, it's not him.” There's grief in there, heavy grief, and it's tied to Zhong Yiqiu's death anniversary. So he wasn't just confused—he was triggered, overwhelmed, and lashing out at the wrong emotional target. Xu Jing just happened to be there. Their relationship after this is going to be messy, and I'm here for it. There's guilt on Shen Yan's side, confusion on Xu Jing's, and this unspoken thing that neither of them is ready to name yet. The model race car detail is haunting me—the middle cabinet is empty, but Shen Yan remembered it as if it were sacred ground. Something about giving that car away must mean everything to him, and he projected it onto Xu Jing without realizing he was erasing the real person in front of him.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this chapter had me doing all the things. The opening exam scene? Chef's kiss. Everyone's scrambling through English except Xu Jing, who just... puts his head down and sleeps. While literally everyone else is stressed and he's out cold. I love that. It tells you everything about his character without any exposition. But here's what really got me—the Shen Yan encounter on the road. "Why are you following me?" / "Did you get a delusion after the fall?" This guy is UNHINGED and I am HERE for it. The fact that he DARES to bring up the fall incident like it's nothing? Xu Jing's anger is so justified and also so fun to read. He walks into the SUN because he's that mad. Classic. Then there's the Yan Zhe subplot with the music box—two hundred and fifty for a BROKEN one? And it's for his cousin's birthday? My guy has terrible taste AND he's being scammed. But also sweet? I don't know what to feel. Also the fact that SY (Shen Yan's game alias!) carried Xu Jing to victory and then Xu Jing spent the next second NOT laughing because he realized it was the nearby people feature? The layers. And Zhou Ji reading in the BATHROOM? With a small notebook? That man is committed and I respect it so much.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: Cha Fei'ang's horror story competition is the plot device that makes everything else happen, and I am here for it. The whole setup is almost comically convenient—Cha Fei'ang wants to win a Dream Girl 3D model (of course he does), he drags the boys along, and then Fate itself intervenes when the lights go out and Shen Yan manipulates the brightness so Xu Jing can't escape. But what's really clever about the plot structure here is how the competition becomes this pressure cooker for character revelation. Xu Jing goes in wanting to leave, dozes off, accidentally touches Shen Yan, gets his hand guided to vote for his own friend's story (number fourteen: "Thriller Campus: No One Survives"—meta, honestly), and ends up having a entire dinner conversation where they basically become friends. All while sitting through twenty-five three-minute horror story performances that nobody actually listened to. The subplot threads are also weaving nicely. Zhou Ji's awkward interaction with Yan Zhe and the dropped vocabulary book—that's building something. The red-haired girl sitting next to Yan Zhe at the event. And then the ending twist: Shen Yan's health crisis, the chest pain, the red pills. This shifts the entire genre tone from campus slice-of-life to something with real stakes. The plot isn't just about a weird competition anymore. It's about what happens when the person you're slowly getting close to is hiding something serious. And Xu Jing doesn't even know yet. Neither do I. What is he taking those pills for?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or