A Midsummer Night’s Letter - Reviews

A Midsummer Night’s Letter
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I'm not sure if I've ever laughed harder at dialogue in my life than during the entire English tutoring sequence. Xu Jing's responses are absolutely devastating in the best way possible. Shen Yan: "Can we communicate normally?" Xu Jing: "Nonsense." NONSENSE. You just asked a serious question and your answer is 'nonsense.' That is a man who has entered a new level of not caring. And then the whole thing with option B — "Didn't you say 'be verb plus adjective of property plus to do' means passive?" And Shen Yan's reaction? He actually laughs out loud. From extreme anger. The man walks out of the room, closes the door, stands at the corridor window for five full minutes, and still can't bring himself to finish the explanation properly. He just leaves "That's a verb." And the silence after that line? Perfect. But here's what really got me — Xu Jing's dialogue style actually shifts between the two arcs. In the tutoring scene, he's all sharp edges and defensive sarcasm. Every response is a weapon. "What are you kidding?" "I can't." "Fuck your mom." But after the fight, when he's lying half-naked on Shen Yan's bed with iodine on his back, his dialogue becomes something else entirely. Muffled. Hesitant. "Mm." "Help me." "Today, thank you." That transformation in how he speaks is so subtle but so powerful. The boy who couldn't stop swearing suddenly can't form a complete sentence when he's vulnerable. And Shen Yan — oh god, Shen Yan's voice changes too. He goes from cold commands and sneering questions to just... softer things. "Does it hurt a lot?" "This medicine can only take care of the surface." Even that final "You're welcome" carries a completely different weight than anything he said two chapters ago. Wen Yi's introduction in chapter 10 was also a highlight — "Dream on." Two words, perfect comedic timing, and immediately establishes her dynamic with Cha Fei'ang. The author knows exactly how to let characters breathe through their dialogue.
... Read More
I keep coming back to how lonely all of these characters are and it's so understated it almost hurts. Yu Qianfang giving Xu Jing watermelon because "it still helped pass the difficult times." She's alone in her store, repeating days, and this teenager is her connection to something living. She doesn't say that. She just... gives him fruit and tells him to go home. Xu Jing calling his mom and getting a busy signal, then a long message about how school is crazy and she'll be home soon, followed by "emotional words" at the end. She's trying. But the distance between them is visible—you can see it in the fact that he doesn't even know where his keys are, and she's working late again. Yan Zhe drunk and heartbroken at 11pm, calling his friend who clearly doesn't want to talk. "Can't you say something nice to comfort me?" And Xu Jing says "Condolences." It's funny but it's also... Yan Zhe is drowning and his only救生圈 is a guy who'd rather sleep. And the neighbor—alone in his apartment at midnight, scrubbing blood from his hands, slamming his door because some idiot is standing in the hallway. We don't know what he's done or what he's running from, but the isolation reads clearly. Every character in this story is reaching for someone and missing. That's the emotional core, and it's built without a single melodramatic line.
... Read More
The pacing of this chapter is a masterclass in gradual escalation. It starts almost lazily—classroom scenes, desk bumping, Cha Fei'ang excited about a competition that sounds ridiculous. The tone is light, almost comedic. Even the interaction between Xu Jing and Shen Yan in the classroom has this dry, low-key energy. Annoyed glances, leg-crossing incidents, the occasional unfriendly tone. It's comfortable. It's safe. Then the competition happens. The lights go out. The pacing tightens. Every moment in the dark becomes charged—Shen Yan's voice beside him, the mint scent, the hand that won't move away, the whisper in the ear that says "I'm not telling you" with that unclear smile. The reader is pulled forward because something is happening, something intimate, something that can't be undone. The dinner scene slows back down but the undercurrent never stops. Conversation about food, about tutoring, about whether they're friends now. It feels like respite but it's actually preparation. The author is letting you relax before pulling the rug out. And then— Bam. Chest pain. Shattering glass. Red pills. Heavy breathing. The final lines cut off mid-sentence: "Heavy breathing echoed throughout the b..." We don't even get to finish the word. This cliffhanger structure is merciless and perfect. The pacing went from campus comedy to medical emergency in the span of one chapter, and I am not okay with this.
... Read More
"Your mom's half-baked cooking skills are like opening a blind box. You never know what level of food you'll get in your mouth with one chopstick. It all depends on luck, and the saltiness depends on her mood." I need to talk about this line because it perfectly captures their relationship. Xu Jing could've just refused to eat. He could've made some excuse. Instead he braces himself, takes a bite of what is CLEARLY burnt eggplant, and says 'It's pretty good, you can add more soy sauce next time.' That is such a specific kind of love—where you're exhausted by dinner but you still play along because your mom is beaming at you. And then the neighbor situation! Qin Xin wants him to invite the boy from 602 over for dinner and Xu Jing's immediate 'No' followed by the weak excuse 'He's already eaten'? He's clearly been avoiding this person. When his mom presses, he won't even say they're in the same class. The avoidance is SO loud. Also Zhou Ji's interaction with Cha Fei'ang—this kid is trembling through every conversation, face red, burying his head. And Xu Jing bails him out just by saying 'Let's go.' Zhou Ji's response? Panting after them and saying 'Thank you.' These two are already forming this weird dynamic where Xu Jing doesn't even realize he's being kind. And Shen Yan calling Xu Jing by his full name like 'Xu Jing' with that cold tone? The tension is unreal.
... Read More
Okay so plot-wise, this section is doing something really interesting and I want to unpack it. We have two parallel tracks running: the school-track (exam results, Cha Fei'ang's comic relief, Zhou Ji's scholarly desperation, the blackboard showdown) and the personal-track (Shen Yan's family trauma, the walk-home encounters, the growing proximity between him and Xu Jing). The genius move is how they intersect at the blackboard scene. Zhou Yan deliberately pairs them—both called up simultaneously, both solving the same impossible problems, both finishing at roughly the same time. The chalk sounds competing against each other. Xu Jing noticing the dark circles under Shen Yan's eyes. Shen Yan catching Xu Jing staring at his answers. This is where the plot stops being about separate individuals and becomes about a relationship in formation. The exam results amplify this: Shen Yan outperforms the second-highest scorer by nearly twenty points while apparently failing English (59?), and Xu Jing—supposedly the straight-A student—is surprised by his own score. The roles are already shifting. But the plot twist that genuinely surprised me wasn't academic. It was the food stall scene. A middle-aged stall owner, ten years of experience, commenting on how kids study harder these days. Then Shen Yan walks in, orders extra-spicy cold noodles (which Xu Jing wouldn't eat because he can't handle spice), and leaves a hundred-yuan bill without taking change. The owner's reaction—"Being rich is just capricious"—is the funniest line in these chapters and it serves a purpose: it establishes Shen Yan as someone outside the normal ecosystem, someone whose money and behavior mark him as different even from the other high-achievers. Then in Chapter 7, Xu Jing asks the question neither of them expected: "Do you live alone?" And Shen Yan deflects with "Are you so interested in me?"—which is literally his own line from Chapter 5 turned back on him. The plot isn't just moving forward; it's circling, returning, deepening. And I am HERE for it.
... Read More
Oh my god, Chapter 6 absolutely destroyed me. I need a moment. Let me compose myself first. Okay, so we spend Chapters 5 and 7 building this whole cat-and-dog energy between Xu Jing and Shen Yan—awkward walks home, snarky one-liners, the "Do you like my answers?" / "Can't I?" exchange that has me shrieking internally—and then WHAM, Chapter 6 drops this absolute devastation about Shen Yan's family. His mother left. His own brother, Shen Linzhi, casually asked about her like nothing happened. And Shen Yan just—snapped. Grabbing his collar, voice shaking, saying each word clearly like he was trying to prove he still had some control over something. Then alone in his room, crying into his pillow like the world had finally caught up to how much he's been holding in. What wrecked me most wasn't even the dramatic confrontation. It was the aftermath. "Tears silently streamed down, soaking the pillow." That image hit me like a truck. Here's this guy who presents himself as cold, untouchable, someone who says "bronze player" to people he barely tolerates—and he's sitting on his bed at 2 AM completely shattered. And the beautiful, painful irony? Xu Jing, who also seems to be missing a mother figure, ends up walking home beside him in Chapter 7. The rain, the humidity, the way they maintain this enormous physical distance despite having the same stride length—it's like the universe is saying: these two damaged boys are orbiting each other and neither knows how to close the gap. Is it wrong that I immediately wanted to wrap both of them in blankets and feed them shrimp balls?
... Read More
I wasn't expecting to feel this attached to these characters after just a few chapters, but here we are. The moment that got me wasn't dramatic or explosive. It was small, almost throwaway: Xu Jing asking Yan Zhe not to tell his mom about the hospital visit, and Yan Zhe immediately understanding why. "As his only friend, Yan Zhe knew better than anyone that if something happened to Xu Jing, Qin Xin would definitely be the last person to know." That single paragraph contains so much emotional intelligence. Their friendship has boundaries and understandings that don't need to be spoken aloud. And then there's the Shen Yan / Xu Jing thread, which is developing with such delicious tension. The first encounter—the stairwell, the mockery, the hospital—establishes clear antagonism. But then in class, when their eyes meet and Xu Jing literally grabs his bag and leaves like the person is contagious, and Shen Yan just... chuckles and goes back to sleep? That's not hatred. That's something else. The disdain in Shen Yan's eyes, the amusement, the recognition—it all suggests this isn't their first real encounter either. The mother-son moments with Qin Xin are tender without being sappy. She warms his milk. She walks him to the door. She's concerned but not smothering. It gives the story a grounding warmth that makes the darker threads—the stalking, the murder case—feel even more dangerous by contrast. I'm invested. I'm fully invested.
... Read More
I keep coming back to this one image of the blue cabinet in the corner of Xu Jing's room. All these meticulously arranged racing car models, polished to perfection, organized by model and color—this is a guy who clearly takes pride in order and control. But then there's this EMPTY space in the middle grid. Just this one gap where a model should be. And Shen Yan freezes when he sees it. Obviously we're supposed to know what that missing piece represents without being told, and it kills me a little because it's such a quiet way to convey backstory. A yellowed photo and a blue racing car model in his own locked box at home, and now he's standing in Xu Jing's room seeing the same model missing from the display. The physical world of this story feels so grounded too—the specific details about the school uniforms, the different styles across schools, even the commentary on No.2 High School's burgundy uniforms being tacky. It makes everything real. The supermarket scene with the condensation forming on the cold drink bottles, the steam from the food Qin Xin prepared—it's all so vividly sensory. This isn't a story that needs fantasy elements to feel immersive.
... Read More
"Sorry, I didn't think." Five words. That's it. That's all Shen Yan says and somehow it lands so much heavier than some grand dramatic confession would have. Because think about it—from the alleyway to the next day at school, he's been acting all aloof and mysterious, and then he just walks into Xu Jing's apartment and drops that apology like it's nothing. But it's NOT nothing. You can feel it in the way the text describes his eyes, those "peach blossom" eyes with something obscure hiding underneath. Xu Jing immediately looks away though, can't handle sincerity apparently, and brushes it off with some half-technique about his fever being gone. The unspoken stuff between these two is INSANE. And then later at dinner when Xu Jing deliberately puts the spiciest fish in Shen Yan's bowl and calls him "Teacher Shen" with all this malicious glee—that's not just petty revenge, that's him finally finding a way to equalize something. He's annoyed that Shen Yan sees through him, that Shen Yan was right about the pretending. But also—he invited him over. He could've just turned him away at the door.
... Read More
There's this recurring image that struck me—Xu Jing and Shen Yan literally routing around each other every single day. Shen Yan leaves through the back door, Xu Jing goes out the front. Shen Yan eats, Xu Jing leaves. They can't be within a hundred meters of each other unless it's the classroom. This isn't just awkwardness; it's choreographed avoidance that says everything without words. And then the basketball court becomes this space where that carefully maintained distance collides with physical reality. The floor is hard, the ball is round, and bodies don't negotiate treaties. I also keep coming back to the breakfast scene—the mysterious offering that someone left for Xu Jing. Who sent it and why doesn't matter as much as the fact that it's an act of care that arrives without a face, without acknowledgment. It mirrors the entire dynamic between Xu Jing and Shen Yan: gestures that happen in the margins, attention that refuses to be named. Even the broken sensor light on the sixth floor feels symbolic—literally the thing that makes visibility impossible, forcing these two to navigate their relationship in darkness.
... Read More
I have to talk about the sensory writing in this novel because it is NOT even fair. The food stall scene in Chapter 5 is one of those moments where the author just lets the world breathe around the characters. Summer night, cicadas chirping, butter sizzling on the grill—that's three of your five senses hit immediately. And then Shen Yan is just... staring at ants. At night. With this intense, serious expression that makes Xu Jing genuinely curious, and then it turns out he was watching INSECTS. I laughed out loud. That is such a perfect character beat for Shen Yan—he's too intense for his own good, and the world gets to be quietly funny about it. The walking-home scene is equally crafted: "flowering crabapple tree planted every ten meters, but you can't see the crabapple flowers at night, and you can't smell their fragrance. Only hearing occupied most of the five senses. So the footsteps behind him were very clear in the dark." This is SO atmospheric. The city becomes a character itself—dark, fragrant but invisible, defined by sound. And the fact that Xu Jing notices Shen Yan smells like "aquatic fragrance after the rain" and allows someone this close to him for the first time? The worldbuilding here does double duty: setting the mood AND revealing character psychology. Even the classroom scenes have texture. Zhou Yan teaching for exactly fifteen minutes. The chalk sound "crackled, as if they were competing." Liang Yin's smile "leaving a pure smile for the students below" before dropping the bomb about exam results. These details make Linhe No.1 High School feel like a real place with real rules, real rhythms, real sweat and pressure. And that final scene in Chapter 7 with the rain and the awkward distance between the two leads? I can SEE it. I could film it. The author clearly understands that atmosphere isn't decoration—it's emotional architecture.
... Read More
I have not stopped thinking about that line: 'Ten o'clock, school gate.' Three words. That's all it takes to escalate from playground gossip to a full-blown confrontation. What I love about how this plays out is that Xu Jing doesn't just react—he plans. He finds the blind spot without cameras, he brings backup, and when Lin Jiayu shows up, the whole power dynamic flips in seconds. Zhang Dong thought he was the predator but he's suddenly surrounded by people who operate in a different world entirely. And the stakes? They're deceptively simple on the surface—protect your friend's honor—but underneath it's Xu Jing making a choice he didn't have to make. He could've walked away. He didn't. That bruise on his arm afterward? Proof that he chose the risk. The fight scene itself is almost secondary to what happens after—Xu Jing picking up his backpack like nothing happened, walking away while Cha Fei'ang is internally screaming. The calm after violence is always more unsettling than the violence itself.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or