A Midsummer Night’s Letter - Reviews

A Midsummer Night’s Letter
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the staircase moment because WOW. Xu Jing thinks he's done something terrible—he withdrew his support, Shen Yan falls, their faces are about to collide, and Xu Jing's entire mind just short-circuits. 'This is really over.' 'Xu Jing, with no way to retreat, had many collapsing thoughts flashing through his mind.' And then—nothing. Just Shen Yan catching himself against the wall, close enough to feel his breath, and asking 'Did that vent your anger?' I cannot. The tension in that narrow stairwell is UNREAL. Xu Jing is panicking internally, heart going a mile a minute, and Shen Yan is completely calm, pursing his lips, watching him with this expression that's equal parts guilty and... something else. Something softer underneath the mischief. Then Shen Yan pushes up Xu Jing's sleeve and sees the bruise—that purple mark from when Shen Yan pinched him hard before—and says 'I'm sorry.' Right there, in that cramped corner, with his face still close to Xu Jing's. And Xu Jing's response? 'Isn't this coming a little too late?' Which is basically code for 'I've been holding onto this for so long and you just now decided to say it?' But here's what really got me: the piggyback apology. Shen Yan doesn't just say sorry once, he says it three times, lower and softer each time, like ripples on a lake. And Xu Jing—who has been cold and sharp and frustrated this entire chapter—just lifts him up and keeps walking. No words for a long while. Just the sound of footsteps on fallen leaves. And that final 'Got it' feels like the first real crack in Xu Jing's armor. I was not prepared for this emotional damage.
... Read More
"Although the sun in August was bright, it was also very scorching." This line keeps echoing in my head. The heat isn't just weather—it's the uncomfortable exposure between these two characters. Xu Jing can't even open his eyes from the sun, but he can SEE the shadow. He can FEEL the presence. He doesn't want to acknowledge it but it's right there. The umbrella is such a loaded object. Shen Yan has one. Xu Jing doesn't. One is prepared, protected, hiding from the elements. The other is exposed, suffering, trying to escape. And Shen Yan offers... nothing. Just follows him with his umbrella like it's a game. 'Did you get a delusion after the fall?' As if the fall never happened. As if Xu Jing is crazy for remembering it. Then there's Zhou Ji's notebook. A small notebook carried to the bathroom. This kid is armor-plating himself with studying, burying his face in books, turning red at any attention. It's like he's trying to make himself invisible through diligence. Meanwhile Xu Jing makes himself invisible by indifference. Both are forms of self-protection, just different flavors. The English textbooks appearing on Xu Jing's desk—that's such a potent symbol. His mother's profession, his weakness, her inability to help him despite being an expert. The books sit on his clean desk like an accusation he refuses to open. He stuffs them into the bookcase without looking. That's not defiance—that's shame wearing a mask of nonchalance. And 602 being empty while 601 has Xu Jing living there alone... two adjacent spaces, both occupied by boys who seem to want no one around them. The walls between apartments must feel SO thin.
... Read More
I need to address how absolutely hilarious Cha Fei'ang is because this guy is carrying half the comedy in these chapters and I'm not even mad about it. His energy is unhinged in the best way—throwing the math book at Xu Jing, immediately pivoting to 'brother you're about to be single no more,' and then later trying to be a middle finger gesture with full commitment. But then Lin Jiayu just slides in and the energy shifts completely. This kid says things like 'it cost me a thousand yuan' and 'are you stupid from studying too much?' with the most deadpan delivery. And Xu Jing's lines? So minimal. 'Just me.' 'Come at me together. Don't waste my time.' The man speaks in bullet points and it somehow works perfectly for his character. The contrast between Cha Fei'ang's chaotic energy, Lin Jiayu's calm professionalism, and Xu Jing's one-word answers creates this really natural rhythm. Even the gossip between the guys about Zhang Dong's dad being in real estate feels like something actual high schoolers would say—not expository, just ambient worldbuilding disguised as chatter.
... Read More
There's a lot happening beneath the surface in this chapter and I need to unpack it. The bruise on Xu Jing's arm—that purple patch Shen Yan sees in the stairwell—is such a loaded symbol. It's physical evidence of their past collision, a mark that hasn't faded, and Shen Yan touching it to apologize feels like he's acknowledging every unresolved thing between them. The injury is visible, undeniable, impossible to ignore. Just like whatever happened that night. Then there's the piggyback itself. Shen Yan literally placing his full weight on Xu Jing—trust, vulnerability, surrender—all wrapped up in what started as a joke. But it becomes something tender, something real. The repeated line 'This was the second time Shen Yan had apologized to him. His heart trembled twice.' That repetition isn't just structural—it's thematic. Each apology lands differently. The first was theoretical, on the stairs. The second was physical, weighted, unavoidable. And the empty apartment versus the full one. Xu Jing's room has gifts from people who love him—potted plants, hand-knitted shoes, a piano, mecha models. Shen Yan's has nothing. He could leave with one bag and vanish. This speaks to a deeper theme about belonging and being anchored to people versus being untethered. Xu Jing is surrounded by evidence that people want him to stay. Shen Yan... doesn't seem to have that. Teacher Liang's osmanthus line—'someone I like, likes them'—is the chapter's quiet thesis statement. Love doesn't need grand declarations. It lives in the small things: a flower, a bruise, a back carried down a leaf-strewn path.
... Read More
There's a lot happening beneath the surface of these chapters and I can't unsee it. Doors. Everything is about doors. Xu Jing gets locked OUT of his apartment. The neighbor slams his door shut. The city's main entrance is under renovation, blocking the way in. The police say "if you see them, contact us"—a door they want us to walk through but we don't know which one. Even the radio program is a door into information Xu Jing didn't ask for but can't look away from. Then there's the rain. It dissipated the heat but also made everything slick, noisy, hiding. The neighbor came out in the rain—was he going somewhere? Coming from somewhere? The wet bangs covering his eyes, the bloodstains on his fingers he scrubs raw in the bathroom. Cleaning but never clean. Xu Jing's OCD is interesting here too—it's not just a character quirk, it's about control. His fingers are sore from... something (we don't know yet). His hair has to be perfect. He can't tolerate smoke and alcohol. In a city where a body has been found and a suspect is roaming free, his need for order becomes almost tragic. The world is becoming ungovernable and he can't even get into his own apartment. The title "A Midsummer Night's Letter"—midsummer is already hot and restless, and night is when things happen that daylight won't touch. Letters suggest communication that hasn't happened yet, or messages that arrive too late.
... Read More
What I love about this section is how the author layers multiple conflict threads simultaneously and none of them feel forced. On the surface, there's the immediate external conflict: someone is stalking Xu Jing. A person from apartment 602 who walks slowly, changes outfits, disappears into stairwells. The headless corpse case adds a darker backdrop—a university teacher arrested for murder after an attempted sexual assault. These stakes feel genuinely threatening. But the internal conflict is where it gets interesting. Xu Jing's reaction to the person in 602 is unusual: "He had never had such great malice towards anyone before." This isn't just fear—it's personal irritation, almost hatred. And then in class, he finds out that Shen Yan (the 602 person) is going to be his DESKMATE. His face must have been priceless. The comedic conflict between Xu Jing and Yan Zhe provides relief, but even that has weight. When Yan Zhe worries about delaying Xu Jing's high school entrance exam, the stakes become real—"he wouldn't be able to forgive himself even if he worked as a slave for the rest of his life." That's not just comic relief; it shows how much Yan Zhe values Xu Jing's future. And the suspense around Shen Yan—who is he, why does he keep appearing, what does he want—keeps pulling me forward. The line "A bridge in his mind had collapsed" suggests this encounter has deeper significance than either character fully understands yet. I need to know what happens next.
... Read More
I need to talk about the atmosphere of this book because the author has a real talent for making ordinary spaces feel charged with meaning. Let me start with the stairwell stalking scene. You've got these two boys following someone up to the sixth floor because apparently the elevator isn't being used, and the narrative voice just casually notes "what turtle speed" while the tension is absolutely thick. The night setting, the sportswear-clad figure moving between buildings, the sense that something is *off* about this person who disappears and reappears—that's pure atmospheric writing. The author doesn't overdescribe; they let the situation itself create the unease. Then there's the classroom scene when Xu Jing walks into 104 and locks eyes with Shen Yan across the room. The description is minimal but devastating: "No matter how noisy the sounds around them were, they were all extinguished in this instant. Xu Jing only felt that there was a bridge in his mind that had collapsed." That's it. That one sentence does so much work. The ordinary high school classroom—with boys playing games, a teacher announcing substitute arrangements, kids complaining about exams—becomes something completely different the moment their eyes meet. And the hospital scene! The smell of disinfectant, Xu Jing's bandaged head, Yan Zhe's ridiculous flattery attempt. It's clinical and cold but also deeply intimate, which I think is exactly the tone the author is going for throughout the book. Ordinary places, extraordinary tension.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this chapter moves because the pacing is actually really clever. It opens with the book distribution scene—slow, awkward, establishing the new classroom dynamics. Then we cut to the afternoon walk with Shen Yan following Xu Jing. Tension builds. You're like okay this is going somewhere serious. And then—BAM—we're at home having dinner with Mom. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it WORKS. It gives you breathing room. Then the English books appear and we get exposition about his grades, which could've been boring but is saved by the personal angle (his mom being an English teacher who CAN'T teach him). Perfect. Keeps it relevant. The gaming scene with Yan Zhe is where the pacing really shines. You've got the music box comedy bit, the call ending mysteriously ('I have something to do' with a lowered voice—we KNOW what that means), and then the game itself. Over an hour of gameplay described in just a few lines with chat messages as the highlight reel. The climax is SY stealing the base, and then the immediate deflation when Xu Jing realizes WHO invited him. The relief turns to dread in one paragraph. That's skilled writing. The exam scene that follows is almost peaceful in comparison—just kids taking a test, Xu Jing sleeping, Cha Fei'ang chatting. A calm before whatever storm is coming with Shen Yan sitting right next to him. And then Chapter 5 opens with Zhou Yan entering like a force of nature—old teacher, bent back, teacup, immediately handing out test papers and setting rules. The energy shift is immediate. The chapter structure keeps you on your toes.
... Read More
Let's talk about structure because the author absolutely knows what they're doing with chapter placement. Here's the sequence: Chapter 5 gives us the food stall encounter, the walk home, the "bronze player" tease. It's light, atmospheric, building this slow-burn tension. Chapter 7 continues that walk-home energy with the rain and Xu Jing finally asking Shen Yan a personal question. But sandwiched between them is Chapter 6—the Shen Yan and his brother confrontation, pure emotional devastation. This is BRILLIANT pacing. If Chapter 6 came first, we'd meet Shen Yan as this broken kid and lose the mystery. If it came last, the emotional release would come too late. Placing it in the middle means we experience Shen Yan in three layers: the cold exterior (Ch5), the raw wound (Ch6), and the careful reassembly (Ch7). By the time Xu Jing asks "Do you live alone?" and Shen Yan deflects with "Are you so interested in me?"—we carry the knowledge of his grief into every interaction. The lightness of their banter is undercut by everything we now know. Within chapters, the pacing is equally sharp. Chapter 5 opens with school-life mundanity (Zhou Ji offering notes, the late dismissal complaint from the stall owner) before pivoting to Shen Yan's entrance. The transition from Zhou Ji's politeness to Shen Yan's blunt "None of your business" energy creates immediate contrast. Chapter 6 goes from Shen Yan entering his house casually to violent confrontation in three paragraphs. No warning. Just: door pushed open, photo snatched, blood on the hand, tears on the pillow. And the classroom scene in Chapter 6? Exam results posted, kids surrounding the board, Xu Jing retreating to the corner, Shen Yan casually solving problems without scratch paper—it moves at the exact speed of a high school afternoon. You feel the noise, the distraction, the sudden focus when the two of them end up at the blackboard together. The author trusts the reader. Doesn't over-explain. Lets silence do the work.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Yan Zhe for a minute because this dude is genuinely one of the funniest characters I've read in a long time. The way he just casually faked an asthma attack on a random locksmith and then immediately broke into laughter right after the door opened? Iconic behavior. And their history together hit so much harder than I expected. The backstory of how they met—Yan Zhe begging for homework answers, Xu Jing silently handing it over because he ran out of patience—is such a perfect origin story for their friendship. It shows exactly who Xu Jing is: not cruel, not warm, just... efficient. And then the whole scene where Yan Zhe gets surrounded by a dozen guys and Xu Jing appears like some kind of silent guardian angel. I literally gasped at "the leading burly man on the opposite side flew several meters away." Xu Jing looked delicate—"slender white arms"—but he completely demolished those guys. That contrast is everything. And then the running gag of Yan Zhe declaring he's straight when Xu Jing says he looks at him with "intense adoration and infatuation" had me roaring. Their dynamic is so comfortable and real. Years of friendship, falling together while blindfolded with a baseball cap, hospital scenes where Xu Jing threatens him and Yan Zhe immediately backpedals with a ridiculous list of illnesses. "I actually have a heart condition and can't handle shocks. I also have osteoporosis." I was wheezing. But underneath all the comedy, there's something genuine here. Yan Zhe knows not to tell Xu Jing's mom about the hospital visit. He knows what matters to Xu Jing. That's the kind of friendship that feels earned, not written.
... Read More
Let's talk about structure for a second, because this batch is masterfully paced. It opens with a physical emergency—Shen Yan on the floor, heart hammering, glass shattered—and immediately pulls back to show Xu Jing's reaction: the hesitation, the ear to the door, the retreat. That's chapter 47, and it's a perfect hook. You're invested before you even know why. Then it cuts to the text exchange, which is almost comically understated. “Nothing.” “I accidentally broke a glass.” “Oh.” Three messages that contain an ocean of unspoken emotion. The restraint here is remarkable; the author could have had Xu Jing bang on the door, call 911, show up with first aid—but he doesn't. He listens at the door and then sends one word. That choice defines their entire relationship. Chapter 48 pivots sharply into domestic routine—the tutoring book, the English homework, the forced proximity of sitting together for two hours. This is where the pacing slows down, deliberately, to build tension through intimacy rather than action. The alcohol reveal, the physical closeness, the chair being pulled back—it's all escalating on a microscopic level. And then WHAM, the model race car question detonates everything. The transition from romantic tension to hostile confusion happens in three lines, and it's brutal. Chapter 49 accelerates again with the morning-after encounter, the school walk, the near-lateness, and then settles into the classroom scene where Xu Jing finally gets to shine. The English vocabulary recitation is the structural payoff—it's the moment where all the quiet buildup pays off, where Xu Jing proves he's not the passive recipient of Shen Yan's projections. He has his own competence, his own voice, his own way of surviving. And the ending, with Jiang Pei panicking and rushing to Shen Yan's side, loops back to the grief thread and sets up the next conflict. The pacing across these chapters feels like a heartbeat—fast, slow, fast, pause—and I couldn't put it down.
... Read More
There's this one moment where Xu Jing is walking and the text says: 'Although the sun in August was bright, it was also very scorching. Xu Jing was so blinded by the sun that he couldn't open his eyes, so he could only walk towards the shade of the trees. He looked down and saw a long shadow beside him. There was an umbrella above the shadow's head.' I can FEEL this scene. The heat, the blinding light, the sudden relief of shade—and then realizing someone's following you with an umbrella. It's so cinematic. I saw this like a movie shot. Close up on the shadow, pan up to reveal Shen Yan being annoyingly prepared while Xu Jing is suffering. The school setting also feels really lived-in. The classroom with Liang Yin trying to maintain order, the crowded hallway, Cha Fei'ang grabbing snacks from the supermarket, Zhou Ji literally carrying a small notebook to the bathroom. These tiny details make the world feel real. It's not just 'a school'—it's THIS school with THESE people doing THESE things. Xu Jing's home is another favorite—braised prawns waiting, iced plum juice, the clean desk with English tutoring books mysteriously appearing. The apartment feels small but warm, especially compared to how isolated he seems to walk through the world. 601 vs 602—that's such a nice detail. Two apartments, one occupant each apparently, and yet they're worlds apart. The night market reference with Yan Zhe shopping also adds this layer of everyday teen life that grounds everything. It's not all drama and tension—sometimes your friend just needs to complain about overpriced music boxes.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or