Reincarnated as Cthulhu - Reviews

Reincarnated as Cthulhu
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I keep coming back to this line: "We have only just set foot on the Earth's Shadow Side." What does that even mean? The Frank family has built something enormous beneath their mansion—a calculating engine, powered by steam, spewing heat and noise into the foundations of the house, running for decades in complete secrecy. Arthur calls it the Oracle. A device that predicts the future. But Philo identifies it as something else entirely: a mechanical computer, an ancestor of ENIAC, a product of human intellect rather than divine intervention. And then Arthur flips the whole thing: "Since it predicts a future that even God doesn't know, it's humanity that should truly be called God." This is the thematic core of the scene, maybe of the whole story so far. The tension between faith and technology, between the old world's understanding of divinity and this new age where human invention replaces revelation. The machine itself is dripping with symbolism. It's described as a "crouching monster," its joints moving silently, cogwheels engaging with the sound of combat boots. It's both organic and mechanical—a god made of steel. The steam engine connected to it resembles a train, endlessly consuming coal, forever calculating. And beneath it all, the word "Oracle" hangs like an ironic label over what is actually just a calculator. "God of the Machine..." Philo whispers, and Arthur immediately corrects him. This back-and-forth isn't just banter—it's the central philosophical question. Who or what controls fate? Is it a deity, or is it the accumulated knowledge and calculation of humanity itself? The Frank family has clearly answered this question with their actions, building this temple to human reason in secret for generations. Whatever comes next will have to reckon with what they've created.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the reveal of that notebook is genuinely one of the craziest plot devices I've read in a long time. Our narrator wakes up from a two-week fever and Mari casually drops that while he was out of it, he got up during a storm, stood naked at an open window screaming incomprehensible words, and wrote something. Something titled "The Gospel of Blackriver." And then the horror unfolds page by page: eleven pages of sacrificial ritual describing dismembering a live sheep, fifteen pages of obscene prose written as if it were his own experience, blood spatter getting worse toward the back, and self-inflicted pen wounds on his hands. The last page written in blood continues the story from where his memory cuts off, with endless prayers in the monster language. He just KNOWS what they are. The way the author builds this — starting with the vague title, then peeling back layer after layer of increasing dread — is masterful. And then the lockbox scene where he chains it up and plans to have it incinerated with his body? That line "The blessing of ignorance" hit me like a truck. He's protecting Mari specifically. It reframes everything about his motivation. Also the Richmond Co. tag appearing out of nowhere after he collapses? Chef's kiss. This plot is threading multiple secrets together like a nightmare.
... Read More
Okay, so let me just say this plot is absolutely unhinged in the best way possible. You've got Earl Morris Essex showing up at the protagonist's door looking all dignified about a meteorite, then two months later Madame fucking Curie is at his doorstep too? Like what is this, a crossover fanfic and I'm here for it. The Earl's whole pitch had me gripped. Here's this nobleman whose family has ruled Jacob's Island for two hundred years, and some merchant from Richmond waltzes in with a forged document claiming the meteorite. The Earl's desperation is palpable—even calm Earl Essex shows anger, which tells you everything. "The only thing that matters is the fact that the family's honor has been tarnished." Not the money, not the science, the HONOR. That's very aristocratic. But then Curie drops this bomb: the Frank Academic Society is paralyzed because Arthur went full hermit mode. The Chairman who used to run everything has shut himself away, and the eccentric members are all scattered. And the reason Curie came to the protagonist? Because she can't reach anyone else. It's like watching a chain of dominoes fall—you realize the protagonist is somehow at the center of all of this without even trying. The line about Becquerel's rays being announced a year early, the meteorite potentially containing something that could rewrite scientific history—it all points to something bigger lurking beneath the surface. This isn't just a land dispute anymore. Something is manipulating the timeline itself, and the protagonist is the only one who seems to notice.
... Read More
I'm not okay. I just finished the first two chapters and I have so many feelings and I don't even know where to start. First, the protagonist's relationship with his brothers. His eldest is a wastrel and he 'couldn't care less about that bastard.' His second eldest he 'could never bow his head enough' to. His parents — same dynamic from his previous life carried over. This is a man who has built his entire identity on outworking the people around him, and the emotional cost of that is just... there. Underneath everything. He succeeded. He survived. But he also had to do it alone, and everyone who mattered to him is either disappointed in him or irrelevant to him. Then there's Mari. The housekeeper. Three sentences of dialogue and I am invested. 'Will you be back late?' 'It's not a nearby place, so probably. I might even stay the night.' 'That's good.' What does 'that's good' mean? It means she's relieved he's going somewhere familiar instead of doing something reckless. It means she's been worried before. It means she knows him well enough to read his moods without him saying a word. And the saury pie. The PICKY EATER. The man who has defeated poverty, survived combat, conquered the African continent, and written bestselling books — is defeated by a fish pie his housekeeper keeps trying to make him eat. I laughed so hard. It's the most human thing I've read in months. But then the ending. 'My life began to change drastically. And in a very wrong direction.' And I just... I need to know what happens. I need to know if Arthur is the friend who helps him or the friend who breaks him. I need to know if Mari's 'that's good' was genuine relief or anxious hope. I need to know if the photograph is going to change everything. This book has me by the throat and I'm not even mad about it.
... Read More
The structural choices in these chapters are relentless. We open mid-crisis — our narrator has just witnessed something unspeakable, is shivering by the Thames with a low body temperature, muttering alien syllables. Two weeks of fever, bedridden, barely alive. Then he wakes up and within hours we're at Silver-Wolf's office with a rifle pointed at an earl's head. The transition is so sharp it makes your stomach drop. And yet it works because the author gives us exactly enough breathing room — the Mari caretaking scene, the discovery of the notebook, the locked box, the calendar check revealing it's May 31st (THE trial date) — before launching into the confrontation. The pacing mirrors the narrator's own mental state: fragmented, urgent, circling back to traumatic details. The lightning strike that cuts the power right when Silver-Wolf starts revealing his father's murder is such a deliberate dramatic beat. Darkness. Just eyes visible. A rifle aimed. This author understands that tension isn't about how much happens — it's about WHEN things happen. Every scene ends on a note that forces you to keep reading. The chapter structure here is basically a series of rising terrrors that never quite resolve.
... Read More
I need to talk about this chapter's atmosphere because it's genuinely one of the most visceral pieces of worldbuilding I've read in a while, and I'm not even being dramatic. The way the author uses SMELL as the primary indicator that reality is shifting? Brilliant. You go from the filth of Jacob's Island to this distinctly different odor — the Thames loses its characteristic stench and becomes something almost oceanic, fishy and vast. That transition is so subtle yet so effective. You don't need big explosions or supernatural reveals; the author just changes the weather and the smells and suddenly you're standing in a place that shouldn't exist. And the visual details — the buildings with no doors, the shoe sole prints on windowsills like someone treated every window like an entrance, the ash-covered roads with handprints instead of footprints. These are the kind of details that lodge in your brain and won't leave. The description of the pursuers is equally unhinged in the best way: 'less like people and more like beasts dressed in clothes to imitate people,' eyeballs that don't blink, tongues lolling because they can't breathe without noses. I literally got chills reading that. But the real masterstroke is the crater. The entire island collapsed into a giant bowl, the green meteorite glowing at the center, the mutated water laps at its edges like some kind of unholy altar. By the time the fish-thing crawls out of the Thames, you already know you're not in London anymore. This isn't a city under threat — it's a city that has been completely remade, and the humans here are just the latest inhabitants of a new ecosystem.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author wrote Curie because honestly it wrecked me a little. You know how in every history book she's this iron-willed, unstoppable force of nature? The one who just kept going no matter what? Well, this Curie? She's retching by the Thames because the smell is so bad, and she admits she was afraid her life's work could be rendered meaningless by a rock from space. "Or, it might make it completely meaningless." That line hit me hard. Here's a woman on the verge of the greatest discovery in radioactivity, and the meteorite could steal her thunder before she's even found it. The vulnerability is so human. It's like the author is saying: no great person starts perfect. Even legends were once scared young researchers. And the banter! When she jokes about Becquerel being forty-one and throwing a fit about being called old? That's not the Curie from textbooks. That's a person. The two patriots laughing together over disparaging France and Russia—that moment where the weight of history fell away and she was just... a colleague? Chef's kiss. But what really gets me is the protagonist's relationship with Arthur. "A being I shouldn't remember was recalled along with him." What does that even mean?? And the fact that Curie came to the protagonist specifically instead of any other academic in London—who IS this guy, really? The power dynamics here are fascinating. He turns down the Earl's recommendation letter offer calmly but then gets threatened by policemen in a slum he's never dared enter before. He's navigating worlds he didn't ask for.
... Read More
There's something deeply significant about how the narrator frames his prosthetic leg throughout this passage. He calls it a 'truly foolish thing' by modern standards — volunteering, coming back maimed — yet he's also suddenly proud of it. This contradiction is the key to understanding the entire thematic architecture of the book. The leg isn't just a physical injury; it's a symbol of the cost of existing between worlds. He's a man from the future trapped in the past, carrying the weight of knowledge he can't share, wearing a body that bears the visible scars of his wars. The Military Medal pinned back onto his suit is equally loaded. It's a token of recognition from a society that gave him nothing but a stump, and yet he wears it like armor. When he tells Curie 'you don't need to mind it,' he's not being modest — he's revealing that he's made peace with his body in a way most people never do. And then there's the ending choice. The high priest demands a sacrifice — one must stay. The narrator immediately volunteers because he believes his life is expendable compared to Curie's potential contribution to humanity. But Curie chooses to stay too, not out of sacrifice, but out of scientific hunger. Both characters are offering themselves up, but for completely different reasons. One for duty, one for discovery. That tension between altruism and obsession is where the deeper meaning of the story lives.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this descent into the Frank family basement because WOW. This entire sequence is basically the biggest reveal of the story so far and I was NOT ready for it. Let me rewind a bit. We start with this whole setup about the prank at the entrance—the locked doors, the false invitations—and Philo pieces together that it was all a FILTER. A test to separate the real curious thinkers from the pretentious fools. That was already clever, right? But then Arthur pulls down a candlestick and suddenly there's a SECRET STAIRCASE going underground? The pacing here is masterful. First, the narrow passage, the heat, the noise that sounds like a train. Then the dead-end stairs, Philo stepping on a pressure plate, the automatic door creaking open. Each beat builds tension until we finally see THE ORACLE. And what is it, by the way? A half-century-ahead mechanical computer that looks suspiciously like ENIAC. Built sometime in the 1800s, running for decades in secret beneath a mansion. The fact that Philo immediately recognizes it from a 21st-century photograph—that is such a devastating reveal for a time-traveler protagonist. He thought he understood this era's technology. He was wrong. "This is just the tip of the iceberg. We have only just set foot on the Earth's Shadow Side." That line gave me chills. Whatever is further inside the mansion, whatever the real purpose of this "academic conference" is—it's going to blow my mind even more. Also, Marie Curie? Young Marie Curie, working down here? The historical crossover is getting interesting. The plot just keeps escalating and I'm here for it.
... Read More
Richmond. I need a minute. The man walks into a room where a seventy-year-old earl has just confessed to decades of corruption and murder, and his first concern is whether the protagonist came to help him win a lawsuit. His reaction to finding out nobody went to court? He's almost disappointed, like a manager whose underperforming employee didn't show up. "You're annoyingly competent." "Of course not. Since you said you were acquainted with the Earl, I thought if I made a snobbish offer mixed with a few lies, you'd do whatever it took to make him win." The guy is SO CHILL about being exposed as a fraud. He admitted to stealing a meteorite from non-human beings, to using it to make all his creditors vanish in 'unfortunate maritime accidents,' and he says it with the casual tone of someone describing how they got a good deal on a country village. "Once my business was well on the way, I bought a country village called Moreton. It was a quiet village, far from the sea. I built a factory there and saved the people by giving them work. Isn't that a wonderful, heartwarming story?" SIR. YOU STEAL COSMIC ARTIFACTS AND PEOPLE DIE. But then he immediately screams about the Fish-men stealing HIS meteorite back, and you realize this guy is not a calm mastermind—he's a chaotic, greedy, dangerously impulsive person who got lucky and has been riding that luck for twenty-five years. And the protagonist's relationship with him? There's this weird mutual respect underneath all the hostility. Richmond called the protagonist 'annoyingly competent,' and the protagonist loathes him 'and yet, at the same time, felt a certain comfort' at finding him there. That's not nothing. These two are connected in ways neither of them fully understands yet. Also, the new character Wilson—just introduced, already saying 'I can't let you go alone, sir!'—I have a feeling he's going to be important. The protagonist literally sent him to find a woman named Curie while he went to face Richmond. That's trust.
... Read More
"London is the filthiest city in the world." I love when an author just commits to the bit, and this novel absolutely commits. The Thames passage alone gave me actual nausea. Buildings that can't even open their windows. The Princess Alice sinking incident—130 people died drinking the river water, and it was only 17 years ago. Seventeen years! That's not worldbuilding, that's documentary horror. And Jacob's Island—"where all the pests of the Thames River gather to live." You can literally smell it through the prose. The police officers sitting in the shade because even they won't go further, the carelessly scattered filth and rat corpses, the way just a few meters changes everything. This is a city divided not just by class but by atmosphere itself. The wealthy draw room with the Earl versus the waterfront with rotting herring and choking stench. The Cthulhu bronze statue with the cephalopod head—"terribly profane" after seeing That Thing. That's such a specific, unsettling image. It sits in this academic mansion alongside real scholarship, and now it feels cursed. The juxtaposition of intellectual pursuit and cosmic dread is delicious. The meteorite falling like "a worm drawn to filth" is one of the most thematically perfect descriptions I've read all year. Of course it lands in the worst part of London. Of course it becomes a legal battleground. The setting isn't backdrop—it's active participation in the story.
... Read More
I am not okay. I am genuinely not okay after reading this chapter and I need to process because the emotional trajectory here went from dread to something I can only describe as heartbreaking hope. Let's start with the chase. You know that feeling when you're being herded somewhere you don't want to go and you can't fight it? The author nails it completely with lines like 'They realized we noticed their pursuit and are now leading us somewhere.' You feel the narrator's military instincts kicking in — analyzing, assessing, trying to find the tactical advantage — and you feel the utter futility of it. These aren't normal enemies. You can't outthink them. The helplessness is palpable. But then comes the pivot. When Curie walks toward the high priest, when she looks back at the narrator and says 'Then I will stay,' something in my chest just... tightened. Because this woman, who moments ago was vomiting at the sight of burnt corpses, who was clinging to the narrator for protection, just made the most radical choice imaginable. And the narrator's response — grabbing the vagrants, elbowing faces, shouting 'Get out of the way!' — that's not action-movie bravado. That's pure, unfiltered terror of losing the one person who matters. The moment that wrecked me though was when the narrator thinks about telling her the truth — 'That I came from the future?' — and then can't. He hesitates. He doesn't have the words. And in that silence, in that gap between what he feels and what he can say, there's more love than any romance novel could ever write.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or