Reincarnated as Cthulhu - Reviews

Reincarnated as Cthulhu
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Silver-Wolf because this guy completely flipped my understanding of the story. You meet him in this perfectly ordered, frugal office, emptying a glass of wine without touching his mustache, acting like some cold earl business figure. But then he starts talking about his father — Earl William — who fell into the Thames forty years ago on a stormy night, just like today. And it hits you: this man has been carrying this grief and rage for FOURTY YEARS. He investigated, found out his father was murdered by dock workers who were then blackmailed by a factory owner, and he spent decades plotting ruin against them. When the lights go out from the lightning strike and he's sitting there in the dark with those ghastly eyes, he basically confesses everything. "I wasn't in my right mind" — no, OUR narrator says that right before pointing a rifle at him, but honestly? Both of these men are operating from places of profound damage. And Mari, don't get me started on Mari. She's the only person who stayed through the fever, who tried to force-feed him soup, who cried when she thought he was dying. The narrator's realization that he fought to protect people like her — that's the core of who he is. Their dynamic is everything.
... Read More
Let me tell you about the most uncomfortable friendship in recent fiction. Herbert and Arthur Frank have known each other since university — twenty years, and the entire dynamic reads like a slow-motion car crash you can't look away from. Arthur is the kind of person who 'stood out everywhere and committed all sorts of unimaginable eccentric behavior.' That's the novel being understated there. He's rich, powerful, connected enough to pull in Darwin and Amundsen if he wanted — but he chose Herbert. Why? That's the question eating at the reader. And Herbert — God, Herbert. He left the military, he lost his leg, and somehow Arthur's attention went from something he 'enjoyed as a wealthy friend' to 'gradually became a burden.' That word choice is surgical. It wasn't rejection. It was erosion. What kills me is the ending beat. Arthur's reaction when Herbert mentions his housekeeper Mari. Complete displeasure. Disgust even. And then the line: "Yes, someone a little more submissive, less intelligent, and who doesn't assert herself would be good." He says this about a woman who works for his friend. Like it's nothing. Like he hasn't just revealed something truly rotten. This isn't just social commentary — this is character exposure in real time. Arthur doesn't see people. He sees props in his own theater. And Herbert knows it. He's been knowing it for years. But he still shows up. That's the tragedy — or maybe that's the horror. Because somewhere between 'my foolish youth' and this moment, Herbert lost the ability to walk away. Whatever Arthur has on him, whatever invisible leash is around his neck, it's real. And the fact that Herbert walked into that thorn garden anyway, knowing exactly what it might be... that's not friendship. That's something far more complicated.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is absolutely suffocating and I mean that in the best way possible. From the very first image — wave-like ripples hitting the bank at the steel mill, the Thames showing movements it hasn't shown in forty years — you know something is WRONG. Our narrator literally cannot escape the shadows and sounds of Jacob's Island. "All the shadows of London were their origin, and all the waves of the Thames River were their splashing." That line stays with me. Every scene reinforces this drowning, rotting city: the pouring rain on the trial date, the lightning striking the wooden utility pole outside Silver-Wolf's office, the red glow of the world through the window, the rain beating against the glass like his father's last moments. The storm is a constant character. Even the rifle in the golf bag feels symbolically perfect — a man carrying death disguised as sport, hiding violence in plain sight through the popular new game of golf. And Jacob's Island itself, described only through fragments and blood-written memories, becomes this pulsing nightmare space. The author doesn't need to describe it fully — the absence IS the horror.
... Read More
"Like a worm drawn to filth, that man sprang up like a rat at the site where the meteorite fell." This image is doing SO much work thematically. The meteorite is simultaneously a scientific miracle and a curse that attracts predators. It falls on Jacob's Island—the worst place in London—because that's where corruption already lives. The rich merchant with forged papers, the Earl defending ancestral honor, Curie worried about her discovery being stolen... it's all hunger, all parasitism. And the Oracle. That steam-eating steel monster. The protagonist thinks it might be a computer operating 100 years early, manipulating events. But what if it's something else? What if the meteorite IS the Oracle, or connected to it, and everything—Becquerel's rays appearing early, Curie's accelerated timeline, the protagonist's transmigrated consciousness—is part of some grander design? The theme of stolen time runs through everything. Science advancing too fast. History being rewritten. A man who shouldn't remember remembering. The meteorite isn't just a rock; it's a disruption in the natural order, a hole in reality where something foreign has crashed in. And London—filthy, decaying London—is the perfect place for an alien intrusion because it's already a liminal space, half-dead, half-alive, where the Thames has literally claimed hundreds of victims. "No great person is perfect from the start." That line about Curie isn't just character development—it's the novel's thesis. Greatness emerges from vulnerability, from fear, from the willingness to face the unknown. The meteorite tests everyone differently, but it reveals everyone truthfully.
... Read More
Let me just lay out all the stakes here because they're stacking up like a house of cards about to catch fire. First layer: the Earl's family honor. A merchant forged his way into claiming a meteorite that fell on Essex land. The London court accepted the claim. This is a legal nightmare that threatens two centuries of noble authority. The Earl is offering a professorship recommendation as payment—real stakes for the protagonist's career. Second layer: Curie's entire scientific legacy. If the meteorite contains radium, her life's work becomes irrelevant. She's not just competing with other scientists—she's competing with DESTINY ITSELF. A rock from the sky stealing her greatest achievement before she's even found it. That's existential dread dressed as a science problem. Third layer: the timeline. Becquerel's rays announced early. The Oracle moving pieces on a chessboard. Someone or something is accelerating history, and the protagonist is the only one who notices because he remembers how things SHOULD go. But knowing the future doesn't help when you're standing in front of policemen who won't let you enter a slum, and the slum is becoming stranger by the day. And the physical stakes—entering Jacob's Island after the meteorite fell. The officers won't even guarantee your safety past a certain point. Whatever's down there, it's worse than poverty and disease. It's something else. The question isn't whether the protagonist will go in. It's whether he comes out the same person.
... Read More
I need to talk about water in this chapter because it is EVERYWHERE and it means everything. The Thames is surging. The rain is pouring. The island is literally sinking. And then the protagonist has this full-blown visionary sequence where London gets submerged, Big Ben and Buckingham Palace go underwater, and the Fish-men return to claim their ancient territory. Mars is their evil god. The Queen's residence becomes an altar. Parliament becomes a farm where humans are bred as livestock. And the author drops this line like it's casual: "I, from the 21st century, know that prophecy to be true. The sea level has been rising without pause for the last several thousand years." So on one level, this is cosmic horror—the Fish-men returning, the apocalypse of London. But on another level, it's literally about climate change and rising seas. The author is wrapping a Lovecraftian nightmare in contemporary environmental anxiety, which is such a smart move because it makes the horror feel possible instead of purely fantastical. And the maps! The whole premise of the earl's revenge hinges on maps—how he bribed officials to omit the first floor on every official survey, making the geography of Jacob's Island deliberately inaccurate. Maps as instruments of power and concealment. The government controls what people see, and the earl exploited that control for decades of hidden revenge. Meanwhile, the flood washes away all the bloodstains at the island's entrance within hours: "There was no need to erase the traces. In another hour or two, all the bloodstains would be washed away by the rain." The water doesn't distinguish between justice and evidence. It just swallows everything. That's the real theme here, isn't it? Nature—floods, rising seas, the ancient sea creatures—is indifferent to human schemes. The earl thought he was executing divine revenge. Richmond thought he was playing a clever game. But the sea was always going to win.
... Read More
Okay so the first thing that happens is a coachman warning the narrator. Not a mysterious stranger in a dark alley — a working-class Londoner with a newspaper. That's such a smart structural choice. The ordinary world interrupts the extraordinary before we even enter it. The Daily Telegraph's 'jokes section' contains a victim list. Of course it does. This isn't hidden danger — it's public knowledge that everyone ignores. That's so much creepier than any secret conspiracy. Then the carriage ride. This is where the pacing does something I really admire. Most authors would rush us to the mansion. Instead we get twenty minutes of Herbert thinking. 'Why was Arthur looking for me?' He runs through everyone Arthur could have summoned — Darwin, Amundsen, royal guards — and each one is 'better than me, not worse.' This is character development through pacing. The slowness IS the point. We're meant to sit with his dread. And the sleep. He tries to rest, falls into it 'in an instant' — but wakes 'before his hand could touch me.' The military habit. The body remembers trauma even when the mind wants to rest. Three dots. Two dots. One dot. The punctuation itself becomes a countdown. Then the arrival. Gate opens by itself. Butler speaks in a way that makes Herbert's blood run cold. The knock at the door — three thumps — and then the ridiculous, devastating name: Floccinaucinihilipilification. If this were any other genre, it would be a joke. Here, it's a trigger. Herbert's knees give out. The entire chapter compresses two decades of friendship into one syllable-heavy moment of surrender.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage are established almost entirely through absence. Nothing explicitly threatens Herbert — no guns drawn, no monsters revealed, no overt danger. And yet I was gripped from the first paragraph. The coachman's warning is the first stake: 'If you don't want to suffer disgrace, Elder, you'd best turn back.' Disgrace. Not death. Something worse for a man of Herbert's social position — public humiliation. The newspaper has already published his name on a victim list. The game is being played in daylight, and everyone knows it. But the real conflict is internal. Herbert wants to leave. He knows he should leave. The narrator's own thoughts confirm it: 'I tried my best to shake off the anxious thoughts.' And yet — he goes in. He rings the bell. He introduces himself. Every step deeper into the mansion is a choice, and that's what makes it terrifying. No one is forcing him. The stakes escalate invisibly. The butler offers to take his cane — Herbert's leg — and Herbert nearly strikes him. This is the moment where physical violence almost occurs, and then doesn't. The tension doesn't resolve; it compacts. And Arthur's final lines about Mari? Those aren't just creepy. They're the thesis statement of the entire conflict. Arthur doesn't want Herbert to have autonomy — not over his household, not over his friendships, not over his own life. The photograph, the invitation, the old joke — none of it is generosity. It's recruitment. Herbert isn't a guest. He's a conscript. The chapter ends on 'Fire her as soon as you get back. I'll arrange for a housekeeper for you.' A command disguised as hospitality. The conflict has nowhere left to hide — it's in the open, polite, and absolute.
... Read More
I am not okay. "Silver-Wolf looked far older than before he had started speaking. The sharp aura that had enveloped his entire body was completely worn away, and he had become a wrinkled and frail old man befitting his seventy years. He had aged almost 20 years in 10 minutes, but his expression looked more peaceful than before." This man spent his entire adult life building a revenge so elaborate that it required bribing government surveyors, manipulating property maps, and waiting decades for the perfect moment. And in those ten minutes of confession, every single year of that tension just collapsed out of him. He couldn't carry it anymore. Not because he was caught—because he FINALLY said it out loud. And then the devastating part: he confesses, expecting judgment, expecting the protagonist to expose him. Instead, the protagonist KNEELS. The words that follow are gentle: "Rejoice, Count. Your revenge was a success." The kid is showing mercy to the man who killed his parents. That is a moment of such extraordinary emotional complexity that I had to stop reading and just sit with it. "In the end, you had nothing to do with the meteorite." — and the earl swears on the name of the protagonist's dead father. He's not hiding anything anymore. The weight is gone. But then the scene CUTS to the flooding Thames, the protagonist having visions of London's destruction, stumbling through rain-soaked streets, seeing dozens of尸体 lined up in execution formations. The peace of that confession room is shattered by the chaos outside—and that contrast is everything. Inside, a man finds absolution. Outside, an island is literally being consumed by the sea, and the protagonist has to run into it anyway. "To escape the terrible nightmare of London sinking, I was prepared to sacrifice anything." That line hit me like a truck. This person has been through hell, they've seen things no one should see, and they're still moving forward. I don't know what happens next but I need to know now.
... Read More
Okay so the thing that hit me about this opening is how efficiently the plot establishes everything in one go. The protagonist is a reincarnator, third son of a fallen baron, in 19th century Britain. That's the setup. Then he survived childhood, got a degree, joined the navy, lost a leg in combat, became an explorer, wrote books, got an honorary doctorate, and somehow ended up respectable and pensioned by age forty. All of that — four decades of backstory — is compressed into what amounts to a very dense first chapter. What I really appreciated is that none of it felt wasted. Every single detail pays off immediately. The military connections? They're why he can board a ship to Africa. The academic reputation? It's what earns him the honorary doctorate. The fall from noble status? That's his entire motivation for surviving at all. The author doesn't bury any of these threads — they're all visible and functional from page one. Then Arthur's letter arrives and everything tilts. The shift from "I've survived and settled down" to "my life begins to change drastically, and in a very wrong direction" — that's a masterclass in narrative pivot. One moment you're reading a comfortable autobiography of a man who made it, and the next you realize he's been setting the trap for himself this whole time. The photograph mystery is a great hook too. A blurry image that neither the protagonist nor his housekeeper can properly interpret, because they see it through completely different cognitive frameworks — one trained on modern visual media, the other on period-appropriate realism. That's not just a gimmick, it's a metaphor for his entire situation: he sees things differently than everyone around him, and that difference is both his advantage and his curse. I'm hooked. The plot doesn't waste a single beat.
... Read More
I need to talk about this garden scene because the author absolutely cooked here. Every detail is weaponized. The ivy spilling unrestrained over the wall. The moss. A mushroom. These aren't decorative — they're the novel telling you: this place is sick, and it's been sick for a while. The magnificent garden Herbert remembers from his youth is gone, replaced by thornbushes and red roses 'waging a war to see who had the sharper thorns.' Two plants fighting for dominance in a space that should be harmonious. That image stayed with me for days. And the door. The door that opens by itself. The narrator's reaction is perfect — instead of fear, he gets absurdity: "Is this British technology? Even the 21st Century is no match. We could probably catch up in 200 years." This is genius writing. A sane man would be terrified. Instead, his mind retreats into deadpan observation. The narration itself is doing what the character can't — it's letting you feel the wrongness while he deflects with humor. Then the hallway. The creaking floorboards. The sense that they're passing 'I don't know how many room doors' in something that feels 'more like walking down a hotel hallway than a residence.' A home shouldn't feel like a transit space. The architecture itself is rejecting its purpose. And the butler. Oh god, the butler. His face is 'far beyond the limit of a human' — half-melted, ageless — but his body is that of a robust young man. Two different people, joined at the neck. An 'incarnation of disharmony.' This isn't just weird Victorian Gothic atmosphere. This is visual storytelling at its most precise. Every image reinforces the central unease: nothing in this house belongs together, and everyone knows it except the people living inside it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say it right now — the dynamic between the narrator and Curie is absolute fire, and this chapter is where it really detonates. At first, you get this instinctive read that the narrator is protecting her. He's the soldier, she's the foreign woman, he's got a cane and a prosthetic but he's clearly operating on some kind of guardian mandate. Classic setup, right? But then BOOM, she walks toward the high priest and says 'Then I will stay.' And that single line completely flips the entire axis of their relationship. He's the one who wanted to sacrifice himself all along — not because he's being noble, but because 'Her brain is a treasure of humanity.' That's his logic, and it's beautiful and frustrating and so deeply him. But Curie? She had her own calculation happening. When she says 'this was an opportunity, just as you said, Professor,' you realize she wasn't being selfless at all — she was being a scientist seeing the experiment of a lifetime. Neither of them was playing the role the other expected. And that gap between what they thought the other was doing and what was actually happening? That's where the real chemistry lives. Not in swooning or hand-holding, but in two people who genuinely didn't anticipate how the other would show up.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or