Reincarnated as Cthulhu - Reviews

Reincarnated as Cthulhu
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say this first: if you told me the author could make a letter-reading scene feel like a character introduction, I wouldn't have believed you. But Arthur Frank is somehow fully realized before he even appears in person. The letter does more work than most novel's worth of dialogue. 'I've been screaming every single day. Very happy screams, I might add.' That's not just quirky — that's a man who has found something that consumes him completely, and he's so excited about it that proper etiquette simply doesn't occur to him. Twenty years of friendship, and the protagonist still can't stop suspecting his old college roommate might be a character from a dream. But the real character work here is in how the protagonist talks ABOUT Arthur. There's this line — 'a dreamer with a child's selfishness, a cat's curiosity, and an endless dream. And even if you add all that up, it wouldn't amount to the immense property he inherited.' That's such a specific, sharp observation. It tells us everything about Arthur (generous, distractible, absurdly wealthy) AND everything about the narrator (he notices these things, he's observant, and he's clearly not envious despite having none of Arthur's advantages). And then there's Mari. The housekeeper scene is tiny — three or four exchanges — but it reveals so much. The saury pie joke. The routine of doors and chimneys and windows. The way she immediately reads his mood and starts reciting her checks back to him like a script she knows he wants to hear. There's this deep, quiet history between them. She's not just staff; she's someone who knows exactly how to handle him. The narrator's little disclaimer — 'I am a person who is very kind and approaches my servants with an open mind' — said three times in as many paragraphs, each time slightly more defensive — that's comedy gold. It also tells us he's acutely aware that people perceive him differently than he perceives himself. That gap between self-image and external perception? That's where the real character lives.
... Read More
There's this one passage that stuck with me like glue. The narrator describes the Thames as 'a rotten body of water where no living creature could survive, thanks to decades of sewage flowing from factories' and then says — and I'm not making this up — 'I loved this foul smell of oil.' He knows it would trigger his eczema. He knows it's poisonous. He loves it anyway because it's the smell of his hometown. That single image — the poisoned river that feels like home — is basically the entire thesis of this novel written in one sentence. Everything about this story is about the gap between what something is and what it means to the person experiencing it. The same logic applies to his own body. A fallen noble family with no money, in an era where noble literally means land ownership. A third son — the kind of son you send away or forget about. A missing leg. Yet he's comfortable. He has a pension. An honorary doctorate. A housekeeper who knows his routines. He's built something stable out of something that should have been worthless. And then there's the photograph. That blurry, indecipherable image becomes a perfect symbol for his entire existence: he's looking at something that other people can't quite parse, and their confusion about what they're seeing is directly tied to the fact that he sees it differently. His modern 21st-century visual literacy — shaped by photographs, cartoons, media from an era of visual overload — makes him see a 'person' where someone from the 1800s would see an abstract shape. His difference is his superpower and his alienation, simultaneously. The novel keeps circling back to this tension: being genuinely from another time, in another world, yet finding that the foreignness is also what allows you to survive. The Thames is rotten and it's home. He's an outsider and he's a gentleman. A reincarnator and he's been here longer than anywhere else.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say—Silver-Wolf's confession scene is one of the best plot pivots I've read in a long time. You spend the whole chapter thinking the meteorite is the key, right? That it's some cosmic force controlling everything. And then BAM. It turns out the weird street layout, the missing first floor, all of it was just a corrupt old man who bribed surveyors to redraw maps. The meteorite was a COMPLETE COINCIDENCE. "Only then did I understand the truth of that strange street. The buildings without a first floor and the streets that differed from the map had nothing to do with the meteorite. It was all a revenge plot written by the earl." Think about how brilliantly layered this is. Silver-Wolf built an elaborate, decades-long scheme of revenge, and he thought he was orchestrating divine punishment. But then Richmond's plan—Richmond! the fraud, the guy who claimed he had development rights he couldn't possibly have—accidentally made his revenge succeed. The earl's last line to the protagonist nails it: "Your revenge was a success. They met a fate more terrible than death. By the mistake of someone other than you." And THEN, just when you think the plot resolution is complete, the ground literally sinks beneath their feet. Jacob's Island is collapsing into the Thames, and the Fish-men are waking up. So the personal revenge plot merges into something apocalyptic. I love that structure—it makes the whole story feel like it's building toward a convergence the author clearly planned. Also, who else is obsessed with the timing? The earl confesses, and the protagonist checks their watch at the exact same moment: "The hour hand was pointing directly at noon." This is the precise moment Richmond makes his move. The author is weaving together three timelines—past (the original sin), present (the confession), and future (Richmond grabbing the meteorite)—and they all collide at noon. That's not lazy writing. That's craft.
... Read More
I keep coming back to one image: the butler's face and body. An ancient, half-melted face on a young man's frame. Two different people, joined at the neck. This isn't accidental — it's the novel's central thesis wearing literal flesh. Herbert himself is divided. Military man / invalid. Young man / old man. The body that served him and the body that failed him. His prosthetic leg is both a literal object and a symbol of everything Arthur Frank represents: something artificial replacing something natural, held together by will and good manners. And Arthur himself — the man who 'had not changed' in twenty years. Not aged. Not diminished. This is where the symbolism gets dangerous. Is Arthur supernatural? Is he a vampire? Or is the novel saying something about wealth and power — that some men simply consume time the way other men consume food? The thorn garden is another layer. Two plants — thornbush and red rose — 'waging a war to see who had the sharper thorns.' Both are beautiful. Both are dangerous. Both are destroying the space they share. Herbert and Arthur's friendship is exactly this: a relationship where both parties are armed, neither backs down, and the garden — whatever was once cultivated here — is being consumed from within. Even the name Floccinaucinihilipilification works as symbolism. It means 'the action of estimating something as worthless.' It was a joke between them — a private language of friendship. But it's also Arthur's assessment of Herbert. The oldest joke in their friendship has become the most accurate description. Everything the coachman warned about, everything the garden predicts — the mansion, the butler, Arthur himself — they're all exercises in evaluating the worthless. Herbert is the fool. And he's been the fool since university.
... Read More
Can we talk about the narrative voice here because it is absolutely chef's kiss? The narrator has this incredible range — he can go from dry, self-deprecating humor ('thanks to my nose going numb') to full-blown philosophical meditation ('It was a truly strange thing to be reliving that sensation in a mere London slum') in the space of a paragraph, and it never feels jarring. His internal voice is sharp and observant but never pretentious. When he describes the pursuers, he doesn't just say 'they looked scary.' He gives you the specific, almost clinical detail: 'their eyeballs shone clearly, watching us, and none of them blinked as if they had no eyelids. Some panted with their tongues out, as if they had trouble breathing without a nose.' That's not horror writing for shock value — that's someone who has seen terrible things and is reporting them back with the precision of a soldier who's learned that details matter. The dialogue is equally distinctive. The narrator speaks in short, economical sentences when under pressure — 'I don't know.' 'Yes.' 'That's not it.' — which contrasts beautifully with Curie's more measured, intellectual responses. And the high priest's alien language ('Bbugura! Szhu-tuthnn'uun Anghuha!') is such a bold choice. The author could have just described it as 'unintelligible' and moved on, but instead they gave it phonetic weight, rhythm, specificity. You can almost hear it. The prose doesn't waste a single word. Every sentence is doing double or triple duty — advancing plot, building atmosphere, developing character. This is writing that trusts the reader.
... Read More
I need to talk about the structure of the opening because honestly it's one of the most efficient piece of storytelling I've read in a while. Chapter 1 starts with the protagonist addressing his readers directly — 'Dear readers in my head' — which immediately establishes an intimate, almost confessional tone. He lays out his entire life story in what reads like a memoir excerpt: birth, childhood, education, military service, exploration, recovery from malaria, writing career, retirement. It's a lot of information. A lot of historical ground to cover. By any normal standard, this would be a boring information dump. But it's not. It reads like he's briefing you before the real story starts. He's giving you context so that when the actual disruption hits, you understand exactly what's being disrupted. The pacing works because every sentence earns its place — there's no fluff, no filler, no 'and then I also did this other thing that turned out to be important later.' Each paragraph is either building his competence or establishing his vulnerability. Then the transition. 'Until just a few days ago, that is.' Two sentences. That's it. Four decades of careful biographical construction, dismantled by a semi-colon and a pause. The letter from Arthur arrives, the pacing slows down into dialogue and description, the photograph becomes a small mystery, and then — 'my life began to change drastically. And in a very wrong direction.' The final two lines hit like a punchline to a joke you didn't know was a joke. The second chapter opens with atmospheric street scene and immediately pivots to worldbuilding through the Red Flag Act debate. Again, zero fat. The automobile vs. carriage detail isn't just color — it's a signal that this world is in motion, transitioning, and the protagonist is someone who remembers when neither existed. I haven't even finished Chapter 2 and I've already read through once because the momentum won't let me stop. This author understands that good pacing isn't about speed — it's about making every single line feel like it's pulling you forward.
... Read More
Let's talk about what this protagonist has already survived before we even get to the main plot. Born to a fallen noble family with literally no money. Third son — the son who gets sent away, conscripted, or married off to some distant relative's estate. In 19th century Britain, that's not a romantic position. That's a death sentence by obscurity. He figured this out at age three when he could barely form words. His survival strategy was academic credentials. Not charming personality. Not political maneuvering. Just: get the degree, because 'an academic background is just like insurance.' He went from starving noble bastard to navy officer to explorer to published author to respected gentleman. But notice what the cost was. He lost his leg. He caught malaria in the Dark Continent and spent months convinced he was going to die. The medal he earned replacing his limb is literally the reason he has a pension. So when Arthur summons him, the stakes are layered. On the surface, it's just a friend asking for help with a research discovery. But beneath that: this man has already bet everything on survival and barely survived. His body is failing him (eczema, lost leg). His past adventures nearly killed him twice. He's finally reached a point of comfort at forty — the age when most people his era are either dead or settling into decline — and now someone is dragging him back into uncertainty. And the phrasing — 'my life began to change drastically. And in a very wrong direction.' That's not foreshadowing as literary device. That's a man who has experienced the difference between stability and catastrophe firsthand, and he knows exactly which way the wind is blowing. The conflict here isn't 'will he survive?' The conflict is 'he survived everything only to walk into something worse, and he's going anyway.' That's infinitely more interesting.
... Read More
"Philo, our family wasn't always wealthy." Classic Arthur. Building up this grave, dramatic moment about his deceased father and his family's hidden fortune—only to immediately undercut it with the most pretentious title imaginable. "Madame, this is the renowned Baron Floccinaucinihilipilification." I literally fell out of my chair. This man cannot take anything seriously for more than thirty seconds, can he? The scene cuts from Philo feeling pure terror in front of a mechanical god to Arthur deliberately humiliating him in front of a young Marie Curie, and the tonal whiplash is absolutely delicious. Philo's response though—"Just Herbert. Please ignore that idiot"—perfect. The exasperated warmth, the twenty-year friendship compressed into three words. And Arthur's follow-up: "That's not a very gentlemanly way to speak," followed by Philo's flat "Shut up." This is their love language. I swear to god. But the dialogue also does heavier lifting in other moments. When Arthur explains the Oracle's origin—"born from the daydream of a mathematician named Charles Babbage. My late father declared himself his patron"—his voice drops. The humor recedes. He's genuinely explaining something profound to Philo, testing to see if his reincarnated friend will recognize what this machine represents. And Philo's realization that he slipped up by saying "boiler"—"A slip of the tongue only a reincarnator could make"—that moment of panic is so well-written. The author uses dialogue as both entertainment and as a vehicle for tension. Every line carries weight, even the jokes. The way Arthur repeats Philo's words back to him—"An automatic door, you say"—that little quirk of his, the way it makes Philo tense up, it's a small character detail that paints a whole personality.
... Read More
There's something deeply unsettling about watching Philo and Arthur's dynamic shift in this chapter. Up until now, Arthur has been this playful, teasing, almost boyish figure—always cracking jokes, dragging Philo into schemes, treating everything like a game. But here? Down in that basement, something changes. When Arthur talks about his late father—"He was called a businessman with foresight, but I knew he didn't deserve to be called by that name"—he's speaking in a completely different register. Stiff, rehearsed, as if reading from a script. The narrative literally notes this shift: "It wasn't his usual spontaneous eloquence." And then he reveals the Oracle and says, "Since it predicts a future that even God doesn't know, it's humanity that should truly be called God." And Philo sees something in him—"an aberrant being." Not quite human anymore. That moment hit me hard. This guy who's been Arthur's friend for twenty years is suddenly standing in front of a machine that shouldn't exist, talking about human divinity, and Philo can't reconcile the two versions. Meanwhile, their banter never fully disappears. Even after all that weight, Arthur winks at Philo before introducing him to Marie Curie using an absurdly long title, and Philo's internal scream—"I was a terrible fool for having trusted him even for a moment"—that's still the same dynamic. But underneath it, there's this growing distance. Arthur is keeping secrets, even from Philo. How much longer can they pretend this is just a friendship when Philo clearly has no idea what's going on?
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is deceptively light. On the surface, it's banter. Underneath, it's violence. Let me start with the butler, because his voice is a masterclass in wrongness. When Herbert asks who's at the door after the lock has already been undone, the butler says "Who is it?" — as if the sequence hasn't already broken. Then: "No such person is invited." The politeness is absolute. The cruelty is absolute. And Herbert's response? "That can't be right. Check the list properly!" A man pleading with a doorman about a guest list. This is someone trying to maintain normal protocol in an abnormal situation. The dialogue writes his panic without ever showing it. Then Arthur. Oh, Arthur. He hasn't even been properly introduced and already he owns the entire conversation: "Good heavens, Philo, what happened to you all this time? Where did the pure young man burning with a studious mind go, and a narrow-minded old man arrived instead?" This isn't a greeting. It's a diagnosis. He's rewrites their entire history in one sentence, and Herbert can't even argue with it because... part of him knows Arthur's right. And then the worst exchange, the one that plays like comedy until it doesn't: "Did you say Mari?" "Hm? Ah, yes. She helps with the housework for me, since my leg is bad." "You've got a very bad woman attached to you. Fire her as soon as you get back." The topic shift is so casual, so unstaggered. One moment they're discussing a mysterious photograph, the next Arthur is reorganizing Herbert's household staff like he's rearranging furniture. The dialogue never raises its voice. It never needs to.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is wild because it refuses to settle into one mood. You start with the Earl coming to visit—formal, tense, aristocratic drama. Then the protagonist is just lying in bed exhausted next to his cold fried herring, and suddenly Madame Curie is at the door. The transition from high-stakes nobility to a scientist double-crossing radiation fears to slum exploration happens faster than I can process it. But here's what's brilliant about it: the cold fried herring. That detail. After two months of no visitors, the protagonist is so done with life that reheating his dinner feels like too much effort. The mundanity grounds everything. Before we dive into meteorite disputes and secret societies, we get a guy who just wants to eat his fish in peace. That's the kind of detail that makes the wild stuff feel real. The chapter ends with the police warning them about Jacob's Island becoming strange since the meteorite fell, and then cuts off right as the officer whispers something. Classic cliffhanger energy, but it works because we've earned the tension through the pacing. We've had the calm, the absurdity, the dread, and now the threat. The reader is hooked without feeling manipulated.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or