I have to talk about the Young Butler. This character is absolutely stealing the show and I don't think people are giving them enough credit.
On the surface, they're just the grumpy attendant following around a young, inexperienced lord. But every interaction reveals someone who is fiercely loyal, brutally honest, and quietly devastatingly perceptive. When Lovell forgives Chard for the illegally hunted crows, the Butler doesn't just accept it—they call out the lie immediately. "He probably caught at least five." This isn't pettiness. This is someone who understands that the people in this territory are not naive, and that blind trust is a luxury Rodrick can't afford.
The scene where they brandish a ladle and shout at Captain Pulp is pure comedy gold, but it also shows something deeper. The Butler will physically posture themselves between Lovell and conflict, even when they're clearly outmatched in combat. Remember—Dutch challenged Lovell once and couldn't walk for five days. The Butler has seen this. They know their lord can handle herself, but they worry anyway. That's not weakness. That's the kind of devotion that makes you want to read about this character forever.
What I find most interesting is the power dynamic. The Butler is technically a servant, but in every scene they're the one offering advice, questioning decisions, and essentially parenting the young lord. Lovell listens to them. She doesn't always agree, but she respects the input. That's a relationship built on genuine trust, not just feudal obligation.
And then there's the crow meat scene—sharing the tiniest pieces of protein with the mercenaries like it's a grand feast. Is she being generous or petty? The text says it's hard to tell. Maybe that's the point. She's a ruler learning to navigate scarcity while maintaining the image of abundance.
I keep coming back to this: the Butler sees everything. The way they watch Lovell share that bread, the way they gauge when to speak up and when to stay quiet. They're the emotional anchor of this entire operation, and I for one am here for it.
Who else is obsessed with this character??