With My Profound Love, I Offer to the Years - Reviews

With My Profound Love, I Offer to the Years
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'To him, Shen Nian was an addictive kind of poison, one he would be unable to shake off for the rest of his life.' I read that line twice and then closed the book and stared at my ceiling for ten minutes. Because here's the thing—this isn't a romance. I need to say that up front. This is two people in a grief chamber, and one of them has decided the other's face is the trigger for his mourning. Every time he looks at Shen Nian, he sees Lingrui. Not Shen Nian. HER. And the cold lifelessness of a body in a morgue. Do you feel how that reframes everything? The kiss isn't desire. It's an exorcism that goes wrong. He's trying to push the dead girl out of his skull by crushing the living one's mouth. And she doesn't fight. 'Like a soulless puppet she mutely allowed him to vent all his emotions.' I want to scream at the page. I want to shake her. But I also get it, don't I, because if you've been in that room for so long, if your sleep is 'increasingly restless' and your life feels 'worthless,' if the dawn is just 'the continuation of her own worthless life for one more day'—you don't have the bandwidth to fight back. You just endure. And the worst part? After the whole thing, after the biting and the hovering and the 'Do you know how much I hate you?'—he just turns his back. Lays down. Silent. As if nothing happened. And she brushes her teeth in the morning and notices the tiny lesion on her lower lip. 'Thankfully it wasn't obvious unless scrutinized closely.' THANKFULLY. As if being bitten by the man who lost his sibling and now channels that rage through your skin is a minor cosmetic inconvenience. I'm not even okay. I'm not okay at all. And then Jiang Lingling walks in and goes 'you have a boyfriend' and Shen Nian just... deflates. Because the idea of a boyfriend, a ring, a normal life, is so alien to her now that it registers as a wrong frequency. 'A ring... she would never wear one in her life again.' That's the actual emotional gut-punch hiding under all the kissing and biting. It's not the violence. It's the fact that she's already decided she doesn't deserve the symbol of permanence.
... Read More
I want to talk about how little these characters say and how much that means. The break room scene is basically two people taking turns being quiet. "What did you want to talk about?" "Why did you come into work today?" "Why wouldn't I be able to come into work?" And then "..." Lu Lingchen doesn't reply. Just watches. And her smile "stiffened slightly before slowly disappearing altogether." Three sentences and I understand the whole power dynamic shifted. She came in smiling, professional, in control. He just... looked at her. And the mask cracked. That's all it takes. No monologue. No internal narration explaining why. Then the hot water thing. He goes and gets a cup of hot water and sets it in front of her. No words. "Thanks." Two syllables. And suddenly he's not the angry younger brother anymore, he's the guy who remembered the thermos flask by the table because he noticed she was pale, because he cares in a way that doesn't announce itself. The dialogue is doing the caring. "Thanks" is the only thing she can say to a gesture she can't reciprocate because he's the brother of the girl she killed. And Shen Nian's voice in the phone call with Jiang Lingling is completely different. She's patient. She explains A University credits. She says "there's nothing much I can teach you, just learn and do more. You're smarter than me." She deflects the compliment about boys being heartbroken with a smile. She tells Jiang Lingling to "go do your work, be careful or they'll dock your pay for slacking." She's performing normalcy so hard I can hear the creak in the hinges. Every line is slightly too smooth, slightly too considerate. The Jiang Lingling voice is the opposite: "Hehe," "Sister Nian isn't like what they said..." She's bouncy, a little rude in a sweet way, the voice of someone who hasn't lost anyone yet. The contrast is doing all the thematic work the narration refuses to do explicitly. One line I've been chewing on: "You're insane." Lu Lingchen says it after she refuses to leave. And she says "Perhaps." One word. Not defensive. Not explanatory. Just... accepts the label. And then moves on. "Anything else? If not I'll get going first." Like he just called her crazy and she's asking if the meeting's over so she can go back to her desk. The flatness of that is either the most terrifying line in the book or the most human one. I can't tell which and I think the author wants me to not be able to tell. The narration voice is doing a weird thing too. It's close-third but keeps slipping into this observational mode. "Other employees would take breaks and relax when no one was looking, but Shen Nian was an exception." Almost clinical. Like a HR report. "She had the heart of a forty-year-old." And then immediately after: "Her composure and calmness were certainly not what a twenty-two year old should have." The "should have" is doing so much work. Should have what? Be crying in the bathroom? Screaming? The narrator is encoding expectation without stating it and I love that about this book. It trusts the reader to fill in the "should" and it makes the gap between who Shen Nian is and who she's supposed to be feel physically painful.
... Read More
The thing that gets me is that the STAKES here aren't "will they or won't they." Everyone already knows Shen Nian is involved with Lu Lingchuan. The conflict isn't the relationship itself. The conflict is what it COSTS her to maintain this position. She's 22. She's working harder than people her age and older. She's handling contracts and project management at a level that makes her colleagues genuflect. She just survived a medical event severe enough to soak through a mattress pad. And the NEXT morning she's in the office, reviewing contract templates, giving four-step instructions to a woman twice her experience, and making a tiny smile when the girls tease her about the "hardest-working spinster in the company." And that boy shows up at the end, looking twenty, tall, with Lu's features but different eyes, and says "I wanted to talk to you" and she starts a whole new thread of tension. The stakes escalate in layers. Layer one: will Lu come back? What's his "something to deal with"? Layer two: what does this boy represent, another person who wants access to Shen Nian? Layer three: can Shen Nian sustain this performance of competence while internally she's the girl who told her brother to stop contacting her because she's "unworthy"? The suspense isn't "will she get hurt." We know she will. The suspense is HOW and whether anyone catches her before she falls. I think I'll be up at 2am wondering if that boy is Lu's brother or some new antagonist and whether Shen Nian can handle one more person entering her orbit while she's running on sleep debt and emotional shrapnel. This chapter ends on a question that's so small in the text but so huge in implication. "Did you need me to confirm something?" "No. I wanted to talk to you." And that's where we cut. Not even a full scene break. Just... off.
... Read More
I keep wanting to skip ahead but the author keeps making me read the nurse gossip. And I hate that I don't hate it. Like, structurally, you've just had Shen Nian swallow pills, go to sleep, wake up, discover the guy's been holding her hand, Dean Li barges in with his whole prostrate apology routine. The scene's already got LOTS of information density. Then—cut to the nurses' station. 'I noticed something strange about the patient in bed 23.' Full stop. We lose our POV. We're watching two women whisper about a nightmare, a crying girl, repeated calls to a dead number. And the pacing choice is: slow it DOWN. Make us sit in that hallway while she's asleep and probably hallucinating. It's annoying on a first read, you want to get back to Xiao Mubai's face, you want the next beat of the main plot. But then I reread it and realized the author is using the nurses as a RABBIT-HOLE mechanism. They're feeding us breadcrumbs about what we didn't see. What was she doing at 3 AM that the main scene skipped over? The nightmares. The 'I'm sorry.' The disconnected number. And the transition back—'a young nurse rushed over, anxiety written all over her face'—is a HARD cut. Like, zero easing. One paragraph they're vibing about it being 'creepy,' next paragraph someone's sprinting down the hall yelling about an accident. That jolt works because we've been lulled into the gossip register and then WHAM, the stakes are back up. I was literally refreshing my chapter page thinking 'oh god, what's the accident, did she try to check herself out again' before I remembered she's stable now. What also caught me: the Dean Li scene is SO compressed. In like six paragraphs he bows, offers to fire people, waives fees, covers nutrition costs, demands private settlement, glares at Dr. Kong, scolds her, and they're both leaving. That's a LOT of procedural detail that in a slower book might take three chapters of back-and-forth. Here it's just... done. And honestly that compression mirrors the actual emotional state—she's too depleted for the legal machinery. She can't be lawyering up. She just says 'I won't pursue this' and the whole corporate apparatus deflates. The pacing serves the character. I'll give the author credit for that. Though I DID want one more sentence of internal reaction from Shen Nian while he's rambling. Just... something. A thought. Even 'this feels weird' would do. Does anyone else have a theory on why we get the nurse scene BEFORE the morning scene instead of after? It's placement that's doing all the work here.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lu Lingrui because even though she's dead, she's literally the most present character in these chapters. Shen Nian has this graduation photo she hides under the sofa cushion like it's contraband, and the fact that it's the ONLY photo left standing means everything. Lu Lingchuan burned all the others in a 'fit of madness' after her death - madness, my ass. That's rage directed at something else, something he can't say out loud. And then there's this line that wrecked me: 'They were clearly once so in love, yet didn't even have a single photo together.' Wait, WHAT? Shen Nian and Lu Lingchuan were married and never took a single photo? Meanwhile Shen Nian and Lu Lingrui had an album? The hierarchy of intimacy in this story is absolutely brutal and I am here for it. Jiang Lingling is also fascinating - she invites 'us three' to a DIY shop completely unaware that one of the threes is a ghost. She says Shen Nian 'resembled her a lot' when she smiles, which means Jiang Lingling is somehow continuing Lu Lingrui's existence through her friendship with Shen Nian. That's either deeply touching or deeply pathological, and I haven't decided which.
... Read More
This section. This whole hospital scene where she opens the phone and there's one photo and one message. I read Lu Lingrui's text message like... four times. Maybe five. I kept stopping at 'I don't regret letting you run away first' because that line just... it cuts different every time you read it. First read: oh no she's dying. Second read: wait, she's NOT even blaming her. In her LAST message, the one she sends right before she jumps, she's absolving Shen Nian. She's saying 'I made that choice, I'm not angry at you for surviving.' And THEN she writes 'But I also can't accept myself now.' And that 'but' is the most devastating two-syllable word I've ever read in a novel. The forgiveness isn't clean. She forgave you AND she still can't forgive herself. She's letting you off the hook while she's already halfway off the ledge. And the fact that Shen Nian has read this message so many times that 'every word, every punctuation mark had been etched into her bones' - that's not hyperbole, that's a 22-year-old girl who has replayed her dead best friend's last words until they're literally physical texture in her skull. And then the dream sequence where Lu Lingrui is still reaching out, still screaming 'Nian Nian hurry and run!' and Shen Nian wakes up calling her name and the nurse is just... there, tucking her hand back under the quilt, completely normal, and the contrast is so violent I actually felt my chest tighten. The whole friendship was supposed to be this bright thing - two girls taking a shortcut through an alley, finding a small road together - and now it exists only as a text message on a phone three generations old, next to a blue ID photo where Lu Lingrui looks 'a little mischievous' with 'curly bangs.' A photo from before. From when she was alive and a little funny and still around. And Shen Nian staring at it in a blood-soaked hospital gown, hands cold, not looking 'at all like a 22-year old girl' while some doctor lectures her about self-care and she just says 'Thank you.' One word. In this entire chapter she gets exactly one word of dialogue that isn't the name 'Little Rui' in a nightmare. I think that's the real emotional gut-punch. The girl who can't stop replaying four-year-old memories, who dials a dead number over and over until 'the number you dialed is unavailable' becomes the only voice that answers her, who tears off the medical tape the second the bleeding stops on her hand because she NEEDS to walk to the doctor's office and ask for sleeping pills because she hasn't slept in two days - this girl gets 'Thank you.' That's it. That's her entire emotional bandwidth left. And I couldn't stop thinking about who she's gonna call next if not him. Who's even on that phone anymore. The answer is nobody. Just the dead.
... Read More
Okay so I just realized something that made me flip my phone face-down on the desk: the earrings. Shen Nian walks into a luxury store, randomly picks a pair, and the salesperson casually drops 'many brides-to-be would choose this.' And that single word—brides-to-be—rewires her entire brain. Because Lu Lingchuan had told her earlier he was going on a blind date. So she assumes these earrings are a gift FOR that girl. She buys them. Lightly. 'I'll take this one then.' Like she's ordering takeout. And the whole time she's running on fumes emotionally, barely holding it together, but she performs this transaction with zero hesitation because what else is there? Then she points at the sunflower necklace and just... adds it to the order. No explanation. No context. The salesperson just says 'Sure.' And that 'sure' broke me a little, honestly. No one questions her. No one asks why a woman in her state is buying a sunflower necklace and a pair of 'wedding earrings' with no face changing. The plot is doing this thing where it hands you the key to the lock but pretends the door isn't there. The blind date subplot is clearly not what it seems—Lu Lingchuan isn't actually going to meet some random girl. But the narration doesn't confirm it. It just lets Shen Nian assume the worst and act on that assumption. And the sunflower? That's not random. That's the whole Lingrui flashback. That little kid voice saying 'Sunflowers count as flowers too!' I kept waiting for a reveal that Lingrui was more than a sibling, more than a memory, something with teeth in it. The structure here is all deferred gratification. Every scene is a room with the lights off, and you keep tripping over furniture you can't see.
... Read More
Okay I'm genuinely furious at how this whole setup is constructed and I can't stop thinking about it. You know what I mean? Shen Nian is literally dating the older brother of the friend who died BECAUSE SHE RAN AWAY. Not because she caused the attack directly - Lu Lingrui made her own choice to block those drunkards - but the guilt architecture is so specific, so *personal*, that the entire relationship with Lu Lingchuan is built on a corpse. And the worst part, the part that made me actually put the book down and stare at the ceiling, is that Lu Lingrui's final message basically says 'you and my brother be happy together.' She GAVE PERMISSION. She went 'Nian Nian, you must be happy' right before she jumped off that building. And now four years later Shen Nian is carrying a baby that isn't even from a loving context, she's in this whole 'evil result of an ill-fated relationship' situation, and Lu Lingchuan just... walks out of the room and slams the front door. Just slams it. After saying 'thank you President Lu' in some hollow corporate register. And she lays there on the bed bleeding out, thinking 'if I died like this it didn't seem so bad.' I keep going back to the fact that he's the only other person who existed in that room. He's the brother. He's the one she's supposed to be with. He's the one who left the room so she could curl up and die quietly in private. Is that abandonment? Is that mercy? Does he even KNOW how much she's carrying? I don't think he does. I think the whole 'unpayable debt and unavengeable' thing is a wall they both built and neither of them will demolish. And honestly I need to know - is Lu Lingchuan actually a bad guy or is he just... trapped by his sister's death too? Because he lost her AND he's stuck with the girl she wanted him to be happy with. That's not a clean hate setup. That's two people drowning in the same ocean and neither can reach the other's hand. I genuinely cannot tell if I should be protective of him or want to throw something at his face, and I think that's... I think that's actually the point the author is making? Am I overthinking this or is it just the most complicated character web I've encountered in a while and I NEED more chapters before I can decide where my loyalties are.
... Read More
Okay so I just finished reading the scene where Lu Lingchuan has been standing on that pebbled path ALL NIGHT watching Xiao Mubai comfort his sister and he just... walks away. No confrontation. No grabbing her arm. Nothing. He's still in the same suit from yesterday, tie crooked, creases everywhere, looking like a man who hasn't slept or eaten in fifteen hours, and he just turns around and struts off with big steps. And I literally slapped my couch cushion because the plot tension here is INSANE. Think about it. He was presumably the one who caused whatever made Shen Nian bleed out on her bedsheet last night (the dried blood is still there, they don't even explain HOW it happened yet). She goes to the hospital. Her brother brings her back. And the man who's supposed to be her... whatever he is to her... just stands in the courtyard like a ghost and watches someone else hold her when she cries. Then he leaves. No dialogue. No interaction. The narrative just... cuts. "After some unknown amount of time, he moved and instead of walking over, he turned and strode away." That's it. That's the payoff for all the buildup. And I'm NOT upset, I'm actually kind of relieved because if he'd stormed over and grabbed her, it would've been generic. This silence is way scarier. The plot is building toward something with Lu's absence at work the next day too. His secretary says he had "something to deal with" and to refer matters to Manager Lu. What thing? The thing that made him skip work AND stand outside his girlfriend's apartment in the cold for a full night? I think the author is really good at withholding. They let us see the aftermath but not the cause. It's like they know we'll stay up figuring it out.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the abortion reveal because honestly I was NOT ready. Like, we spend all this time watching these two fight and kiss and basically destroy each other in the most romanticized way possible, and then BOOM — ultrasound report, termination form, blood on the sheets. My jaw literally hit the floor. The way the author layers this is so smart too. You think it's just angsty enemies-to-lovers nonsense, but then you're like wait, she was pregnant, she lost it, he has no idea... and now he's holding the evidence of something she did because he told her he didn't want any ties. That line where she says "Since he didn't want it, she would listen to him" — I had to put the book down for a second. It's one of those plot twists that completely reframes everything that came before. Every angry look, every bitter word, it all takes on this devastating new meaning. Also the way the chapter ends with her asking him to call an ambulance while he's standing there absolutely shattered? Chef's kiss. I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is so sparse but every word hits. Let me just highlight the exchanges that stuck with me. First, the door confrontation: "I hate you!" / "What a coincidence. I hate you too." That's it. Two lines and you get the entire history of their relationship. No exposition needed. Then later, when she explains why she got the abortion: "Don't worry, I remember what you said, you don't want any ties with me." This is the most Shen Nian thing ever — she turns his own cruelty into justification for her suffering and says it calmly, almost gently. And his response, "A cold-blooded creature like you only deserves to stay in hell!" — he's so mad he can't even be poetic about it. It's raw and ugly and completely characteristic. The author doesn't give us long speeches or internal monologues, just these sharp verbal jabs that reveal everything. Sometimes the best writing is the stuff left unsaid.
... Read More
First off—Lu Lingchuan speaks in syllables. 'Mm.' 'Put them on the table.' 'Shen Nian.' Two, three words max. He's a man who communicates through silence and the ambient creak of a bathrobe. And it works. It absolutely works, because the less he says, the more weight each word carries. 'Do you know how much I hate you?' hits different when you've been waiting forty pages for him to use more than two words. His voice is basically negative space. Now contrast that with the Lingrui flashback: 'Nian, you're no fun... But I really like one kind of flower!' The ellipsis, the switch, the kid-energy. It's the only place in the whole passage where someone is ALLOWED to be warm and unburdened, and that makes it so much sadder. Because you know that voice is gone. Literally. The morgue line is right there, two paragraphs later. And then Jiang Lingling. 'Pff—' and 'Sister Nian, you're lying.' She's the release valve. She's the person who walks into a room that's been sealed since Chapter 1 and cracks the window open without realizing it's supposed to be airtight. Her whole register is 'hee hee' and 'today is Singles' Day anyway, so all the couples are out there torturing us singles.' She doesn't understand what she's walking into. She thinks it's a lip bite from a cute boyfriend. And that ignorance is almost crueler than knowing, because she looks at Shen Nian's face and sees a love story where there's only an open wound. The narrative voice itself is interesting too—it's close to Shen Nian but slightly detached, like she's narrating her own life from a distance. 'An expanse of black greeted her vision, a reflection of her own pitch dark existence.' That's not her inner monologue. That's the author's hand, but wearing her skin. I haven't figured out if I like that distance or if it's just another way the text keeps me from fully landing in her pain.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or