To You, Who Burned Me - Reviews

To You, Who Burned Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I have SO many thoughts about Kailos. First of all — he literally came ALL THE WAY to the edge of the hall just to ask Selonia to dance? Like, he's the Grand Duke of Laharden, leader of the North, he should be standing at the CENTER of this banquet surrounded by important people, and he somehow found her hiding against a wall? That is NOT casual behavior. That's someone who has been watching her. And then when they dance, the way the author writes it — 'his grip on her had grown firmer ever since she had almost stumbled' — read that again. He was being careful with her. Genuinely careful. But here's where it gets MEAN. Because then Selonia immediately goes, 'Was he jealous? Did he harbor feelings for me?' and then slaps herself mentally saying 'He insisted she be burned at the stake.' UGH. The author is playing with us SO hard here. We're meant to be confused too — did Kailos love her in the previous life or was he complicit in her death? Or both? That tension between the gentle way he catches her when she stumbles and the fact that he once sent her to die is absolutely delicious. And then there's Vanessa. Remember how Selonia used to flee from Vanessa's gaze like it was fire? This time she LOOKS BACK. Just a quiet nod. And Vanessa actually... pauses? Confused? Nods back? That tiny exchange says SO much about how far Selonia has come. She's not running anymore. She doesn't need to. The power dynamic between them has shifted fundamentally, even though nothing outwardly changed.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the garden scene because honestly it wrecked me. Not in a bad way — in a 'I forgot to breathe for three pages' way. Alix is doing that thing where he's being all charming and easygoing, talking about the music being too fast and which foods he likes, and he thinks he's being this warm, approachable guy. But Selonia? She's standing there thinking about grinding her heel into his foot until stars burst before his eyes. That is COLD. And also so relatable?? Like, the internal monologue is everything. She's performing this whole naive courtesan bit — fidgeting, lowering her eyes, playing the blushing girl — while internally she's doing calculations on how much damage she could do. The moment that got me though? When he says "When I'm with you, I find my mind strangely at ease" and she literally thinks: it felt as though she had heard those words before. At the time, she had been happy. Now, hearing them again, they sounded like nothing more — and nothing less — than a carefully rehearsed line. That is such a devastating line. It captures the entire tragedy of their relationship in one sentence. He's not being sincere — he's been scripted into this behavior, or worse, he's using the same playbook on everyone. And she knows it now. She USED to know it when she was the naive girl who believed every word. And then the hand-kissing! She can't tell if he's interpreting her trembling as emotion or if he even cares — it doesn't matter to him. It's all about HIS desire. The way the text describes his golden eyes having "something unmistakable: desire" and how it was "the gaze of a man consumed by his desire to possess her" — oof. She even explicitly notes that once she mistook that look for love. ONCE. The growth between the Selonia who believed in sweet whispers and the Selonia who now sees clearly is absolutely heartbreaking. I love her so much and I hate that she has to play this exhausting game.
... Read More
There's a pillow that catches fire in chapter one and I don't think anyone talking about this book is going to stop mentioning it because the symbolism is so aggressively on the nose that it's almost impressive. Selonia's magic manifests while she's preparing for bed—just a simple pillow, reduced to ashes in seconds. She manages to extinguish it with water, but the implication hangs in the air: if she hadn't been quick enough, if she hadn't had her training, she could have burned the entire castle down. And sooner or later, that's exactly what will happen. Not to a pillow. To her. The witch trial is literally about proving whether she will burn, and the entire narrative structure is built around the tension between accidental destruction and deliberate sacrifice. But the deeper symbolic thread is about her body as a site of danger and power. Her magic leaks from her hands when she loses control. Her body produces pleasure so intensely that it interacts with her magic in ways she can't fully regulate. She is, in the most literal sense, a walking catastrophe—a woman whose very existence threatens to consume everything around her. And yet the accusation against her is that she used magic to seduce the Emperor. The implication is that her sexuality itself is the heresy, that her body is a weapon she wields deliberately when in truth she can barely control it. The title of this section—"Was her birth itself a sin?"—is probably the most important question in the entire text, and it's not just about her mother. It's about the idea that some people are fundamentally wrong to exist, that their very nature is a transgression against the natural order. Selonia was born an illegitimate daughter, abandoned by her mother before she could even be weaned. She grew up believing her existence was a burden. And now the state, the church, and history itself are confirming her worst fears. The regression is itself a kind of symbolic act—a rejection of the narrative that her birth was a sin. By going back, by choosing to entangle herself with Kailos despite knowing how it ended, she's making a radical statement: my existence is not a mistake, and I will not accept the story they're writing about me. Even if it leads to the same outcome, the fact that she's choosing it this time instead of having it chosen for her is the entire theme of the book compressed into a single narrative gesture.
... Read More
The opening scene of this book is one of those moments where the setting does so much heavy lifting that you barely notice it happening until you're already fully immersed. We open with night falling over Serdin Castle, and the first image is of a moat connecting to the Lake of Eternity, beyond which stretches a dense, seemingly endless forest. Even though it's the beginning of summer, the wind through the slightly open window is bitterly cold. This isn't subtle—the author is establishing from the first paragraph that this is the North, a place of literal and metaphorical distance from warmth and safety. And then there's the detail about the unlit gardens, an old custom to keep monsters at bay. Monsters. Not wild animals. Monsters. The world immediately feels more dangerous than a standard medieval fantasy setting would suggest. But here's what's interesting about how the setting mirrors Selonia's psychology: the interior of the castle is brightly lit, contrary to the custom. The author has Selonia question this directly, and it's such a small observation but it signals that this place operates by different rules than the surrounding world. She's trapped in a space that defies its own logic, just like she's trapped in a life that defies her expectations. Then we cut to Velua Palace, and the atmosphere shifts dramatically. The embroidered hangings, the gleaming marble floor, the enormous bed in the center of the room—everything screams opulent luxury. But the narration immediately undercuts it: "Yet to her, it was now nothing more than a golden-barred prison." That phrase is everything. It's not just that she's confined; it's that the confinement is gilded, beautiful, and therefore inescapable. No one can blame her for wanting to leave because she has everything material she could want. The prison is designed to make her gratitude a cage. The mirror itself is a piece of set design that functions as a character. It shows her image with "merciless clarity," reflecting not just her physical deterioration but the death of her former self—the bright, resolute expression that's been replaced by hollow cheeks and trembling hands. The moonlight that creeps into the bedroom is described as almost predatory, illuminating without warmth. And the contrast between these two spaces—Serdin Castle, where she has some agency even in vulnerability, and Velua Palace, where she's surrounded by luxury but imprisoned—is a structural choice that tells you everything about where she actually belongs. One place is cold but honest. The other is warm but suffocating. Both are prisons. She just happens to be physically in the cold one while emotionally trapped in the memory of the golden one.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Kailos because MY HEART JUST WENT THROUGH A WASHER CYCLE WITH THAT SCENE. Throughout everything we've seen, Kailos has been this unreadable wall of a man—icy violet eyes, no expression, all business. We're told he was THE ONE pushing hardest for her execution, that he wanted her burned alive. And yet when Selonia looks up through the smoke and sees him... she's wearing a half-unbuttoned shirt in freezing cold, forcing his way through the crowd, gripping a spear blade with his bare hands like he doesn't feel the pain, and those terrible violet eyes are FLOODED. Rage. Shock. Sorrow. Despair. ALL OF IT. And Selonia's internal monologue just SHATTERS when she sees it: 'You were the one who tried hardest to crush me—so why do you look at me that way?' This is not the face of a man who wanted her dead. This is the face of a man watching something irrevocably wrong happen in real-time and being utterly powerless to stop it. Or... can he stop it? I'm already losing my mind over the timing. He appears at the exact moment the flames touch her. What happens next? What was he doing there? Why is he dressed like he literally ran from somewhere else? And more importantly—did he try to save her already and fail? That spear blade in his bare hand suggests violence, desperation. Is he fighting the holy knights? Is he trying to get to her? Meanwhile Alix on the terrace—bored, dismissive, glancing at Selonia only when their eyes meet and then going back to whispering with Vanessa. The contrast between these two men's reactions to Selonia's suffering is just brutal. One couldn't care less while the other looks like his world is ending. And what about Selonia herself? She's at her absolute lowest point—trapped, betrayed by Alix, abandoned by everyone—and yet her first instinct isn't to beg or scream. It's to read Kailos's face like she's trying to solve an impossible equation. Even on the verge of death, her mind is still working, still searching for answers. This scene alone made me need air.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this chapter builds tension and then—bam—just stops at the exact moment your heart is in your throat. The pacing is really carefully calibrated. It starts slow, almost dreamily, with Selonia waking up and checking her body. There's a quiet, almost meditative quality to those opening scenes. Then Mariam shows up and the tempo picks up—a little awkwardness, a little urgency. Selonia finds the notebook and the timeline clicks into place. By the time she's dressing and heading out, the reader is already leaning forward. But the real pacing masterstroke is the encounter with the knight. The author doesn't rush it. We get the full, uncomfortable beat-by-beat escalation: the comments, the stepping closer, the hand reaching for her hair, the arm blocking her path. Each of his lines adds pressure, and each of her responses shows she's changed even though nothing's resolved yet. She's steadier this time, sure, but the danger feels just as real because he doesn't care about her growth. And then just as she's about to do something definitive—about to scream, about to force the issue—the cold voice cuts in. “Remove your hand.” Wrist twisted, a scream, “If you make another sound, I'll break your neck as well”—and then the chapter just stops mid-sentence. No resolution, no reveal of who saved her, no moment to breathe. I literally gasped. The cliffhanger isn't cheap either; it feels earned because the entire chapter has been slowly tightening the screw. Absolute perfection.
... Read More
I have been WAITING for this moment. For forty-plus chapters Selonia has been reactive — running, surviving, playing defense against a man who holds all the power. And then Camella drops a bundle of budget documents on her desk and suddenly everything changes. "This might be a chance that would never come again." That sentence gave me actual chills. Not because it's dramatic — but because it's understated. Selonia doesn't have a hero moment here. She just notices an opportunity and SEIZES it. The tension in that office scene is incredible. Camella's "piercing intensity" — those sharp eyes that can see straight through people — and she just... nods? Lets Selonia take the papers? I keep re-reading that beat because I'm not sure if Camella is genuinely oblivious or if she's letting it happen on purpose. "For a brief moment, she studied Selonia with a look that held quiet significance." Quiet significance. What does that MEAN? Is Camella playing a longer game? Because if Selonia thinks SHE'S the one making a bold move, but Camella has been three steps ahead this whole time — that would be such a brilliant subversion. The stakes here are enormous but carefully calibrated. She's not storming into the Emperor's office to confront him. She's walking into a space she's never accessed before, hoping he won't be there, hoping to find information that could change everything. The risk-reward calculation is so tense because we KNOW what happens if she's caught. We KNOW what Alix does when someone crosses him. And the ending — she's hurrying through the eastern wing, thinking about the papal procession, the tour of territories, the grand spectacle masking something darker. The author is widening the scope from personal survival to political maneuvering. Selonia is no longer just trying to avoid her fate — she's actively trying to read the board and find her move. The stakes just went from "will she survive" to "what can she actually change?"
... Read More
The fire imagery in this section is absolutely brutal. Alix's red hair gleaming 'like fire beneath the crystal chandeliers' — and Selonia's immediate flashback to the pyre, to being unable to scream. The author doesn't even need to show us the burning. One visual trigger and we're there. His charisma, his glory, his golden eyes — all of it is now inextricably linked to the flames that killed her. That's not just symbolism, that's psychological horror disguised as romance novel aesthetics. Then there's the garden itself. Crystal orb lanterns strung through trees like scattered starlight. Fountain water gleaming. It's beautiful — almost too beautiful. But it's also a maze. She walks deeper and deeper into it, past lovers and secret trysts, until she's completely alone and lost. The garden is both seductive and treacherous, exactly like the Empire, exactly like Alix. Pretty on the surface, swallowing you whole if you wander too far in. The coldness is another recurring motif. Her fingertips tremble then go 'cold as ice.' The spring air 'eased the tension' but she's still overheated. There's this constant push-pull between heat and cold — fire and ice — that mirrors her internal state. She's trying to be cold and calculated like a proper regressed person, but her body betrays her every step of the way. Lips warm, cheeks hot, heartbeat thundering. She can control her mind but she can't control her body, and that's where the real tragedy lives.
... Read More
"Grace. Salvation. Purification. Cloaked in sacred language, cruelty was softened — made righteous." This line right here is the thesis statement for the entire passage, and honestly for the whole novel. The Grand Cathedral doesn't just kill witches—it packages murder as divine mercy. The word 'purification' is doing SO much heavy lifting. These people burning Selonia alive aren't calling it execution. They're calling it SALVATION. As if burning a woman is an act of love. The Pope calls Selonia a 'descendant of the evil god' while the real evil is standing on a terrace watching, bored, with a smile on his face. The inquisitor holds up a flaming brand and says 'In the name of Ardian, purify the witch!'—as if the god of this story would care about any of this. The Church has built an entire apparatus of control on the foundation that cruelty equals holiness. But here's what really gets me: Selonia's internal reaction to this. 'If she had truly been a witch who wielded sorcery, she would never have been subjected to such grotesque injustice.' This is such a razor-sharp observation. The irony isn't lost on her—if her magic were real, the Cathedral would have used it as proof of guilt instead of fabricating charges. Her innocence is precisely what makes her vulnerable. The system doesn't care about truth; it cares about producing a witch to destroy, and she fits the part perfectly because of who she is, not what she did. Then there's the freedom motif woven throughout. She's chained from the beginning—ankles cut raw, wrists bound in coarse rope. But even bound, she refuses to kneel. 'Her body swayed, teetering on the brink of collapse, but she refused to kneel.' That refusal is everything. Physical captivity, spiritual defiance. And the rebirth at the end? It's not just a plot device—it's the ultimate subversion of the 'purification' theme. They tried to burn her into nothing, to make her suffering serve their narrative, and instead she came back. The flames didn't purify her. They RESET her. Every lie the Cathedral told about her death was wrong. She didn't find salvation in their fire. She found something else entirely. The message is clear: systems of power dress oppression in sacred language, but the human spirit refuses to stay burned.
... Read More
This whole chapter is a masterclass in building tension through a single event. The banquet starts, Alix gives his speech about the grain alliance — which sounds benevolent on the surface but Selonia KNOWS it's a trap for Tellua — and then Kailos appears like a ghost from her past, pulls her onto the dance floor, and she can barely think straight. Every beat is deliberately placed. What I love is how the author uses the dance as a pressure point. They don't say a word to each other the entire time. No exposition dumps, no confessions — just Kailos leading her through steps, her internal monologue spiraling, that moment when she nearly trips and he catches her like it's choreographed. The orchestra reaching its climax while her heart basically explodes? Chef's kiss. Then — BAM — she escapes to the garden. And get this: she gets LOST. I laughed out loud. After all that calculated regression and preparation, she wanders into the imperial garden and has no idea where she is. Which is honestly perfect pacing because it forces the narrative toward the inevitable encounter with Alix. She wanted to find him? Fine. But she can't even navigate a garden. The author is trolling us gently here, and I'm here for it. The chapter ends with Alix's voice behind her — 'I didn't expect to find anyone in a place like this' — and it's the EXACT line from her memory. Which means either fate is truly stacking the deck, or he's been waiting for her this whole time. Either way, I NEED the next chapter.
... Read More
This is the kind of passage that makes you genuinely anxious for a character, and I want to understand why. On the surface, the stakes seem straightforward: Selonia was burned alive after a devastating betrayal, and now she's been given a second chance. The external conflict is obvious—navigate the palace, avoid Alix, survive the political maneuvers waiting for her. But what really grips me is the internal conflict, and honestly, it's far more complicated than “she doesn't trust anyone anymore.” She says it herself: “Because Alix's betrayal had cut so deeply, it was unease that came first — an instinctive fear and a certainty that she must never trust or accept anything lightly again, no matter what happened.” That line sits heavy. She's not just afraid of dying again. She's afraid of feeling that betrayal all over. And the tragedy is, she can't afford to let her guard down even a little—if she's going to change her fate, she needs to play the game. But playing the game means getting close to people, and getting close means risking everything again. The knight scene amplifies this perfectly. In her first life, her fear of losing her position paralyzed her. Now she's ready to scream, but she's still trembling. The stakes haven't changed—she's still vulnerable, still in a system where one wrong move could cost her everything. The difference is internal, and that's where the real tension lives. She's fighting two battles at once: against the people around her, and against the part of herself that still flinches at kindness. And that's what makes every encounter feel dangerous, even the ones where she technically “wins.”
... Read More
I need a moment. Camella laughing out loud. Just that one image of her — this cold, distant, untouchable Crown Princess — actually LAUGHING at Selonia's embarrassment. It's such a small moment but it carries SO much emotional weight. Camella had been the most guarded character since the beginning, always watching, always calculating. But when she explains WHY she chose Selonia, something shifts. She says she saw herself in Selonia's struggle. That unbroken will despite having nothing. The way she describes it — pulling up those flailing arms — it's not pity. It's recognition. And Selonia's breakdown before that, crying alone in her room about her past life... god. She thought she had made the right choice serving the Crown Princess, that the palace was her sanctuary. Instead it became her grave. The guilt she carries isn't just about Alix — it's about every choice she made thinking it would lead somewhere safe. Her realization that she needs to abandon everything she fought for is devastating and beautiful at the same time. There's also this quiet, powerful moment with Camella's past — losing Justin just fifteen days before he was supposed to get his ducal title. That detail just DESTROYED me. Fifteen days. She stayed in this hostile palace because she suspected something was wrong. She stayed out of love and grief and loyalty to a man who couldn't even die safely. The line about northern women never abandoning the person they gave their heart to hit me like a truck. The emotional dynamics in this batch are layered in a way I didn't expect. Every relationship feels different — the predatory tension with Alix, the protective murmur between Camella and Selonia, the ghost of Justin hovering over everything.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or