To You, Who Burned Me - Reviews

To You, Who Burned Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so this chapter just wrecked me in the best way. Selonia literally just realized she regressed — she was burned at the stake by Alix, and now she's back in time — and the FIRST person she runs into is Kailos, the Grand Duke of Laharden. And here's the thing that absolutely gutted me: it was Kailos who saved her from that guy harassing her in the corridor, not Alix. Remember? "Thank you. You helped me avoid serious trouble." And then she looks up and sees HIS face. The scene where he reaches out to steady her and she INSTANTLY jerks away? That hit like a truck. Of course she jerks away. In her previous life, THIS was the man who stood beside her at the pyre. She literally imagines his face looking down at her through flames. And now here he is, alive and concerned and saying "Are you all right?" in this gentle voice, and she can't even respond properly. She stammers and sways and he catches her and she recoils like she's been electrocuted. The fact that he seems genuinely hurt by her rejection — his gaze wavers, he takes a measured step back — that tells me so much about him already. He's powerful, commanding, violet eyes glowing with authority, but there's something soft underneath that only she's ever seen. Then there's Dora. Oh my god, Dora made me tear up. This maid who used to help Selonia dress for banquets, who honestly just enjoys doing it because "it's like working on a piece of art," and who was visibly reluctant to see her go in the previous timeline. When Selonia thanks her directly and Dora gets all flustered and then asks if she can continue helping — that is the most wholesome moment in this entire novel and I needed it. Selonia realizes SHE had zero allies in her past life. Zero. And the people who condemned her were literally just maids. "After all, the first person to accuse her of witchcraft and the person who gave false testimony at her trial had both been 'mere' maids." So she secures Dora. One ally. Maybe that's enough to change everything.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are layered like an onion and I am NOT okay. On the surface level, Selonia's goal seems simple: determine whether Alix approached her from the beginning with hidden motives. But the deeper you dig, the more dangerous it gets. Alix just announced a grain alliance that will apparently enslave Tellua economically. Selonia knows this but can't do anything about it at the banquet — she's a nobody compared to the Emperor. Meanwhile, she's supposed to be investigating Alix while simultaneously avoiding Kailos, who apparently orchestrated her death in the previous life but is now looking at her with something that MIGHT be regret or longing or both? The most suspenseful moment for me wasn't even dramatic — it was when Alix's gaze landed on her during his speech. 'She must have truly been a fool,' she thinks, realizing he probably noticed her way back then. The stakes just shifted overnight. If he was always watching her, then everything she thought she understood about their relationship was a lie. And if he's watching her NOW, in this life — with all her regressor knowledge — what does that mean for her plan to survive? Also, the Kailos question is eating me alive. Did he love her? Did he hate her? Was he coerced into supporting the witch trial? Every time I think I've figured him out, the author gives me another contradictory signal. That uncertainty IS the tension. We're not sure who to trust, and neither is Selonia. And honestly? That's exactly how it should be.
... Read More
I need to talk about Kailos because this character is somehow both the most dangerous man in the story and the only one Selonia might actually be able to trust, and I don't even know which one is true yet and it's driving me insane. Let's start with what we know about him from this text. He's composed, articulate, physically imposing, and—this is the part that keeps looping in my head—he is genuinely considering himself being "used." When Selonia storms into his bedroom in a panic because her mana is escaping and threatening to burn things, she expects him to be difficult about it. Instead, he just... agrees. He ties her up, helps her calm her magic, and frames it entirely as a transactional arrangement. But then he smiles. This rare, almost predatory smile that transforms his usually cold expression, and suddenly you realize he's not nearly as detached as he's making himself sound. He's enjoying this. He's enjoying HER. "You decided to use me for this. And I agreed to be used like this. So what's the problem?" He says this while literally binding her wrists above her head and spreading her legs open. The contradiction is almost comical if it weren't so psychologically rich. He's performing compliance while actively dominating the situation, and Selonia knows it. That tension—the gap between what he says and what he does—is the exact space where their whole relationship lives. Now contrast that with Alix. Oh god, Alix. The Emperor. Her former lover. In the past life, he was the one who ultimately condemned her, who let her burn. And yet in this scene, he still comes to see her daily, still calls her "Selie," still touches her with that practiced gentleness. But Selonia is perceptive enough to notice the difference now. His touch is rougher. His patience thinner. When she tries to stop him to ask about the trial, his irritation isn't hidden—it leaks out as a sigh, a deeper breath from above her head, like her hesitation is a personal rejection. "What's wrong, Selonia?" he asks, and the fact that he frames it as if SHE is the problem is chilling. Six years of believing his love was genuine, of thinking she'd found something real in a world that despised her, and now she's looking at this man and realizing he may have been performing the entire time. The triangle between these three characters feels incredibly volatile. Kailos is honest about his desires even while lying about his motivations. Alix is dishonest about his affection even while performing tenderness. And Selonia is caught between them, trying to figure out which version of each man is real. The regression has given her the advantage of hindsight, but hindsight doesn't mean she's immune to manipulation—especially when she herself initiated the relationship with Kailos in this new life. Is she choosing him, or is she replaying the same patterns?
... Read More
I'm going to be honest with you—I read this passage and I actually had to set the book down for a full five minutes afterward. Not because it was confusing, but because the pacing was so precisely calibrated that it hit me in waves. The passage opens with EXPOSITION—background on witch executions, crowd behavior, the rarity of the event. This feels almost documentary, calm and distant. And that's intentional. The author is letting us settle in, preparing us for what's coming. Then—the chains clank. 'The witch is coming!' The pace immediately sharpens. We move from general context to specific moment, from abstract cruelty to one woman walking to her death. From there, the pacing becomes almost unbearable in its deliberation. Every detail slows us down: the thin chains on her ankles, the blood from her wrists, the cold cutting to her bones. The author is making us EXPERIENCE time the way Selonia experiences it—slowly, agonizingly, moment by frozen moment. There are no shortcuts. We walk every step to the stake with her. Then comes the Pope's speech—another deliberate slowdown, a ceremonial pause that lets the dread build. 'Do you acknowledge these sins?' ... '......' The silence stretches. The crowd gets restless. 'CONFESS YOUR SINS!' The rhythm is building, crescendoing, and we're all waiting for something to break. And then—Kailos appears. This is where the pacing becomes GENIUS. Just as the execution sequence reaches its peak tension, the author SLAMS the brakes with a single name: '…Kailos?' The crowd noise drops away. The flames don't matter. The Pope doesn't matter. Everything narrows to one pair of violet eyes locked on Selonia. This is the pivot point of the entire passage—a moment so charged that the prose itself seems to hold its breath. The fire returns, violent and sudden, and the pacing accelerates again—'With a violent rush of fire,' 'The flames surged,' 'Ash drifted down'—faster now, desperate, drowning us in sensation. And then—darkness. Full stop. And the next paragraph opens with FREESIAS. Warmth. Sunlight. A chandelier. The most dramatic pacing reversal I've read in a long time. From absolute extremity to complete calm, from death to waking, from chaos to stillness. The structural whiplash IS the point—the reader, like Selonia, has no idea what just happened. This is how you control a reader's heart. Not through action alone, but through the rhythm of attention—when to slow down, when to speed up, when to stop everything for one impossible moment.
... Read More
There's this one moment early on where Selonia runs her hands over her body, and the text says her hands were “smooth and healthy, as though they had never experienced starvation or decay.” I keep coming back to that image. The burns that should have scarred her flesh are gone. But her memories aren't. The whole chapter seems built around this tension between the external self and the internal self. Her body is young, unscarred, capable of running without pain. But her mind is carrying six years of trauma—betrayal, imprisonment, public execution. The mirror scene reinforces this: “a face both familiar and unfamiliar staring back at her.” She looks like the girl who entered the palace innocent and hopeful, but she's not that girl anymore. That girl died on the pyre, even if her body was somehow brought back to life. And then there's the notebook—her own handwriting, the factual record of dates and events. It's almost like an anchor, something solid she can hold onto when everything else feels unstable. The author keeps circling back to these small objects and details (the chemise, the mirror, the leather notebook) as touchstones between who Selonia was and who she's become. Camella is another layer I can't shake. She chose Selonia—an unwanted, illegitimate daughter—to be her maid. Selonia is grateful, but she also wonders why. Was it kindness? Or was it part of some larger design that led her straight to Alix? The palace itself feels like a character, vast and cold and indifferent to the women trapped inside it. Time travel might have reset the clock, but it didn't reset the system.
... Read More
Let me talk about structure for a second because the author here is doing something really deliberate with pacing that I can't stop thinking about. The chapter opens with a needle. Just that image—blood being drawn while she sleeps—and immediately we're thrust into confusion rather than revelation. Selonia wakes up disoriented, and the reader wakes up alongside her. We don't know why Alix is doing this any more than she does. Then he lies to her. The dinner tray, the excuse about physicians. And she—god help her—considers believing him. That's the pacing masterstroke: making us feel her hope flicker before it gets crushed. Vanessa's question about the engagement acts as the first crack in the dam. But here's what's brilliant—the author doesn't rush the collapse. Selonia asks again. "Is it true?" And Alix doesn't answer. The silence between those two lines is where the real horror lives. The author lets the reader sit in that unbearable gap, building dread through absence rather than exposition. Then comes the execution scene, and the shift in perspective is jarring in the best way. We go from a claustrophobic bedroom to an open square, from intimate betrayal to public spectacle. The crowd's dialogue does double duty—we learn about the world's magic system and its misogyny while also feeling the mounting dread of what's about to happen. "Was the execution by fire about to begin?" The chapter ends on this question mark, and I was absolutely desperate to turn the page. The pacing is unhurried but never boring. Every scene serves the suffocation. By the time Selonia loses consciousness, you feel physically drained alongside her.
... Read More
"Do you truly believe His Majesty ever loved you? In the end, I am the one he chose as Empress. You were nothing more than a pretty toy — something Alix amused himself with for a time before discarding without a second thought. Know your place, you miserable witch." That is Vanessa at her most vicious, and honestly? It's perfect dialogue because it does triple duty. First, it establishes Vanessa as a genuine antagonist — not cartoonishly evil, but cutting with surgical precision. Second, it reveals something devastating about Selonia's psyche: she WANTED to believe it wasn't true. "She had wanted to believe it wasn't true, but ultimately, Vanessa's words had been painfully accurate." Third, it reframes everything we know about Selonia's past life. She wasn't just discarded — she was USED until her purpose was fulfilled and then consumed in flames. A toy doesn't get discarded after a moment of amusement. A toy gets played with until it breaks. But what I love most about the dialogue throughout this chapter is how differently people speak to and about Selonia. Kailos speaks to her with genuine concern — "Are you hurt?" — and when she rejects him, he doesn't push. He gives her space. "The assessing look he had fixed on her disappeared, and he took a measured step back, as if deliberately giving her space." That's a man who is used to commanding but knows when to retreat. Alix, on the other hand, speaks in declarations and justifications. His dialogue is all about framing his own narrative — "If that isn't love, then what is?" He's writing the story where he's the romantic hero even as he's murdering her slowly. And Selonia's own internal monologue? It's sharp and fractured in exactly the right way. She's regressed, she's traumatized, and her thoughts don't flow smoothly — they spiral. "Her body was unharmed, yet whenever she recalled his betrayal, the pain flared up as vividly as if she were still trapped in the flames." The author nails the voice of someone whose mind is caught between two timelines, constantly second-guessing what was real and what was manipulation.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage are as high as they possibly can be—death by burning in front of a mob—and yet the author finds a way to make them feel EVEN MORE personal, more intimate, more devastating. On the external level, the conflict is straightforward: Selonia versus the Grand Cathedral and the Empire. The Pope publicly accuses her of colluding with demons, bewitching men, disrupting the sacred order. The crowd throws stones. The inquisitor raises a flaming brand. This is the kind of conflict where the system IS the antagonist—every institution present exists to ensure her destruction. But the REAL conflict is internal, and it's where the passage truly destroys us. Selonia has spent her entire arc believing that love—any love—was worth sacrificing for. Alix gave her attention, affection, and then used it as a weapon. When she realizes this at the end, she says: 'She would never again have foolishly loved someone who had drawn near only to use her.' This isn't just regret. This is the death of her fundamental worldview. The moment with Kailos introduces a THIRD layer of conflict that completely shatters any neat narrative. If Kailos truly wanted her dead (as she was told), why is he tearing through the crowd like a man possessed? The contradiction between what she was told and what she witnesses creates an epistemic crisis—in the face of death, the one person she thought was her enemy is the only one who looks like he's losing his mind. What does this mean? What was the truth all along? And then there's the meta-conflict: the reader versus the narrative itself. We've been trained to expect either a rescue or a tragic death. The author delivers NEITHER. She dies (we think), and then the story resets. This is a conflict between what the story promises and what it delivers—and it's ruthless. What makes the stakes work so well is that Selonia has NOTHING left to赌. No allies, no defenses, no voice (she's gagged), no hope. She's been reduced to pure endurance. And yet—even in that state—she refuses to give them the satisfaction of a scream. The smallest act of defiance becomes the biggest statement: I will not perform my own destruction for your entertainment. That's when the flames rise. And the stakes don't just stay high—they become permanent.
... Read More
I'm not okay. I am genuinely not okay after the mirror scene. Like, I need a minute. Here's what happened: Selonia is standing alone in her confinement, looking at herself in the mirror, and the author just—just—destroys her with three paragraphs of physical description that also happen to be the most emotionally devastating thing I've read in a fantasy novel in forever. Her skin is "pale and translucent, that it seemed unreal." Her hair is soft and pink like "scattered flower petals." Her eyes are the color of an icy lake rather than the sea. And then: "During her confinement, her once thick, lustrous hair had become dry and brittle, and the color had long since drained from her hollow cheeks and lips." She's literally dying in front of her own reflection and she can do nothing about it. But the emotional gut-punch isn't even just the physical description—it's what surrounds it. She reflects on how she fought desperately to become a palace maid, abandoning favorable marriage prospects, enduring whispers and comparisons to a kept woman, all for the sheer sweetness of Alix whispering her name with smiling eyes. And now? Now even that memory feels like it was built on a lie. She says to herself, almost inaudibly: "Can I be certain?"—referring to Alix's claims of belief in her innocence. That single question, hanging there, contains six years of her entire emotional life collapsing into dust. The scene with Kailos, by contrast, is full of physical urgency but weirdly, emotionally Safer. She thinks about how whenever she shares her body with him, she always feels cared for. He puts her pleasure first. He withdraws when she seems overwhelmed. Even in the most intimate, vulnerable moment of her life—bound, exposed, magic threatening to erupt—she feels safe with him. And that's the tragedy, isn't it? The man who loved her (or pretended to) hurt her the most. The man she's supposed to distrust (because he condemned her in the past life) is the one making her feel secure. Her regression hasn't just changed her circumstances; it's inverted her entire emotional compass. What felt like betrayal in the past life might be protection now. What felt like love might have been possession. And the most heartbreaking moment comes at the very end when she repeats to herself, almost mechanically: "It will be fine. His Majesty said he would take care of everything." She's soothe herself the same way she's soothe herself every day. But the text makes it clear—these words are "nowhere near enough to erase the fear pooling in her icy eyes." She's performing hope at this point. She's gone through six years of hope and it led to the stake, and now she's running on habit and terror and the desperate, irrational possibility that this time might be different.
... Read More
I need to sit down for a minute. Alix is probably one of the most horrifying villains I've ever encountered in fiction, and that's because he's written so casually into a romance framework. He drew her blood while she slept, medicated her food for SIX YEARS, and when confronted, genuinely believed he was being romantic about it. Can you even— "I did this because I love you, Selie." And he meant it. He truly believed that keeping her alive long enough to extract what he needed was an act of devotion. The fact that he could look at her shaking, sobbing body and think his own pride was wounded because she told him not to come closer? That's not manipulation for manipulation's sake. That's something else entirely. What really gets me though is how the narrative slowly peeled back the layers of their relationship. We're talking about six years of supposed love, and every single moment—his gentle smiles, his whispered confessions in the night garden, the jewels he placed around her neck—all of it was calculated performance. The banquet where they first met? A setup. The moment she tried to leave him and he begged with tears? Also a tactic. "You were extremely valuable. I failed to reach my goal in the end, but you helped me a great deal. How could I not love you?" The way he reduced an entire relationship to utility and transaction. She wasn't a person to him—she was a resource. The Aetheria bloodline, the magic she carried through her mother's lineage, the child she couldn't give him. Every layer of their intimacy was just another extraction. And the most chilling part? He still calls it love. He doesn't even recognize what he is. Selonia's arc in this section is devastating because it's not really about her becoming stronger—it's about her becoming awake. Six years of blindness, and the moment she sees clearly, she's facing a pyre. I don't know whether I'm angrier at Alix or sadder for her.
... Read More
There's this one moment — and I need you to understand how devastatingly tender it is — where Selonia is getting dressed for the banquet and she touches the diamond necklace and earrings that Camella lent her. And she thinks about how, in her previous life, she NEVER wore them again after becoming Alix's lover. "Compared to the rare jewels gifted by the man who had once tried to exploit her, these were modest. Yet the fact that they had been given freely to a maid in distress made them far more precious." I literally had to put the book down. Because that's not just description — that's Selonia's entire emotional arc in one paragraph. Those diamonds represent genuine kindness from someone who asked for nothing in return. Camella didn't exploit her. Camella saw a maid in distress and gave her jewelry because she could. And Selonia stopped wearing them the moment she let Alix into her life, the man who would drain her blood for six years and then burn her alive. Every time she touched that necklace now, she's reminded of what pure kindness looks like versus what predatory manipulation wears. And then there's Alix. I need to talk about Alix because I am FURIOUS and heartbroken simultaneously. His confession is haunting me: "If that isn't love, then what is?" He kept her by his side, mixed medicine into her food, secretly took her blood, gave her the best of everything — all to build a lineage of powerful magicians to overthrow the Grand Temple. But here's the thing that makes me actually unsettled rather than just angry: is ANY of it a lie? Does he truly believe this WAS love? Because his expression when he said it — "as though he were the one who had been betrayed" — that suggests he genuinely thought he was entitled to her blood AND her affection. That's so much more terrifying than a mustache-twirling villain. Selonia sits there torn between anger and this fragile sliver of hope. "If his words had been born of irritation and resentment towards her, then at least he had once loved her. But if he had approached her from the beginning with the sole purpose of using her…" Oof. She'd rather believe he loved her and betrayed her than that it was all calculated from day one. That is the most painful thing I have ever read and I mean that as the highest compliment.
... Read More
I'm not even going to pretend this wasn't the most satisfying detail in the entire chapter. Three little words buried in the middle of an otherwise tense scene: "She thought that dancing in silence with Kailos had been far less tedious." LESS TEDIOUS. Than walking with the EMPEROR. That's it. That's the tea. While she's over here doing mental gymnastics to not lose her composure around Alix, the memory of just standing quietly with Kailos is apparently the bar she's measuring everything against. I am OBSESSED with this character. You don't even need a big dramatic confession — you just drop one honest comparison and we ALL know what's up. It also tells us so much about Selonia's current state. She's forced into proximity with Alix constantly now — he's making excuses to visit the Crown Princess's palace, suggesting they go to the main palace together, asking her to give him tours. Every interaction is an endurance test. And the fact that the baseline for "pleasant company" is literally Kailos? Yeah, no further evidence needed. What I love is that this isn't written for drama — it's just an offhand observation, a mental note Selonia makes while trying to survive a conversation with the man who's about to ruin her life. The author trusts the reader to understand the weight of it. No big romantic declaration, no "she realized she loved Kailos" monologue. Just: Kailos was better. Alix is exhausting. Move on. I'm also wondering what the author is building toward here. If Selonia is this acutely aware of the difference between Alix's hollow attention and genuine connection with Kailos, where is this heading? And more importantly — has Kailos noticed? Does he even know she's different now? Because that would be THE scene when he does.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or