This Is Strange - Reviews

This Is Strange
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"No value?!" This line hit me like a truck and I didn't even know why at first. The Peeping Lens looked at Chao Musheng and registered absolutely zero danger points. Zero. And I keep coming back to what that means emotionally. In a world where everything is measured in danger levels and survival points, Chao Musheng is an anomaly the system itself can't categorize. But that's not even the part that got me. It's the water bottle scene. Xiaoyou, freshly traumatized, having witnessed violence in her room, following this boy she barely knows out of the guesthouse—and he notices she's distressed. Doesn't give her a speech. Doesn't ask probing questions. Just hands her a bottle of water and says 'Want some?' She drinks several gulps without hesitation. Then:[Ding. Life points: 20.]Twenty life points for accepting water. In a game where everything is transactional, where even kindness gets quantified, this tiny moment of human decency registers as a measurable gain. The absurdity of it made me laugh and cry at the same time. "How ironic—the food and water they dared not touch turned out to be the greatest kindness this game world had offered its players." This line is everything. These players are navigating death traps, cursed dungeons, betrayal and intrigue, and the thing that actually sustains them isn't some legendary artifact or holy relic. It's a retired couple's home-cooked meal. It's purified water from a convenience store. It's a boy who noticed someone was hurting and didn't make it awkward. I've read a hundred romance scenes with confessions under cherry blossoms and this single exchange about a water bottle wrecked me more. That's the mark of a writer who understands that love isn't always dramatic—it's often just someone handing you water when you didn't ask for it but needed it desperately.
... Read More
"Bit my tongue." And that's it. That's the entire line. The girlfriend cries out in pain, everyone turns around expecting drama, and she just... admits she bit her tongue. Forced smile that looks like a grimace. I laughed out loud because this is exactly how real people handle embarrassment in horror situations—you deflect with a lie so thin everyone can see through it but nobody calls you on it because the alternative is acknowledging that someone was just using a magical lens on them. The author's dialogue sense is sharp. Every character has a distinct voice: Chao Musheng: 'It's just a light drizzle—won't take long.' / 'The best-selling purified water in the country.' — casual, self-deprecating humor that disarms tension Grandma: 'No more beating people?' / 'You can get it tomorrow. It's still raining.' — no-nonsense matriarch energy Fatty: 'He must've found some crucial clue and doesn't want us to know.' — paranoid, clinical, always assuming the worst The Village Head fanning his tea and stalling: 'It's nothing major.' *hands over treasured tea leaves* — this man cannot lie to save his life but he's trying so hard And the livestream chat! ['Such slender, beautiful fingers—they look delicious! I mean the loquat!'] This is genuinely funny. The internet exists in this world and it's being used exactly as it's always been used—distracted, chaotic, wildly inappropriate, and accidentally powerful. Five thousand people showing up because one guy walked past a camera and the Village Secretary couldn't close the sale to save his life. What I love most is how the dialogue shifts register so naturally. One moment you're reading survival paranoia ('What if he gets his hands on the clearance hint?') and the next you're reading ['Host, you're so handsome, and his voice is so soothing. Fine, I'll buy the loquats!'] The tonal whiplash IS the voice of this book. It refuses to pick a lane and I respect that.
... Read More
One thing I keep coming back to is water. Not as a plot element, just as a symbol that keeps resurfacing in weird places. Chao Musheng wrenches a leaking faucet off in his sleep because 'water conservation is a virtue engraved in my bones.' Then the village performance has a water sponsorship banner on the left side of the stage. Then Xiaoyou drinks a bottled water someone handed her. Then there's the whole 'don't drink that' Fatty warning which is about the sponsor's bottle, not the tap water. So water is the medium through which the village maintains its little economy, and the players are literally being handed consumables by the system dressed up as hospitality. Uncle Ming's bus is the other big one. 'The roads between towns are all well-built now, and there are planned bus routes everywhere. Even if I don't drive my old bus, it won't affect anyone's travel.' And Chao Musheng's response is basically 'you're still useful to ME and my grandparents.' Which is sweet but also the text isn't stupid, it lets us hear that the village is being modernized, connected, and the old ways are being retired. The cultural performance itself is a symbol of that transition. Grandma doing a TV interview in her performance outfit is the village saying 'look how civilized we are, look how normal, we are NOT the place where someone died last week and we buried the body in the field.' The festival is the alibi. The banner thanking the water sponsor is the corporate layer on top of the rural layer, and both of them are there to make the players (and the reader) feel a sense of 'everything is fine, move along, nothing to see here.' And the red balloon. Lulu's red balloon. It keeps appearing at the edges of the frame. First it's tied to her wrist, bobbing in the air, 'impossible to miss.' Then Xiaoyou loses sight of the girl and all she sees is 'a bright red balloon bobbing through the crowd.' The balloon is the last thing you see before the human disappears. It's the part of the NPC that lingers. And it's red, which in this novel is always associated with danger, with the kidnapper, with blood, and here it's just a kid's party favor. That's the thematic tension I keep chewing on. The same color that marks death marks childhood. The same spectacle that hides the crime displays the innocence it's protecting. I don't know if the author is being that deliberate or if it's just the visual language working in layers, but it hits different every time I scroll back and re-read those balloon lines.
... Read More
I need to talk about the emotional whiplash of reading this. One moment you're terrified for these players trapped in some lethal game, the next you're laughing at two burly uncles doing cat-dog dances for internet clout. The tonal shifts are masterful. But what really got me was the isolation. These players are alone together on that bus — same physical space, completely separate existential fears. The description of them sitting in silence while the AC roars to life, the frayed fabric beneath seats, the suffocating heat that somehow makes them shiver... it's claustrophobic in the best way. You feel their dread viscerally. Then Chao Musheng enters and everything shifts. There's something almost tender about how he interacts with Uncle Ming — the gum, the concern about smoking, the casual familiarity. In a story about survival and execution, these small human moments hit hard. The fatty's dislocated arm and dropped watch, the quick apologies, the woman covering her mouth in fear — these are moments of genuine human vulnerability that ground the supernatural premise. The emotional crescendo comes when Chao Musheng threatens to call the principal. There's this perfect blend of authority, humor, and unexpected warmth. He's protecting these kids while also being legitimately intimidating. The CP energy between him and... well, honestly I'm not sure who the romance angle is pointing toward yet, but the chemistry is undeniable. This story knows how to make you feel.
... Read More
I'm going to get off on a tangent here and I don't care. The conflict in this chapter is not 'who wins the dungeon.' That's not what's happening. What's happening is that the village's fragile, sunny, *normal* afternoon is slowly being threaded with wrongness, and the wrongness is so small you almost miss it. The door Musheng shoved open. 'Huh?' He frowned at the doorframe. Something was there. Something that shouldn't have been. Then the bump. The feng shui master's 'I was touched by a ghost.' The retired soldier's patrol report of light footsteps. And Sister Ling, leaning against the shade tree, fanning herself: 'I dreamed the mountains behind us collapsed right before the event started.' Mountains. Collapsed. Right before the event. Not during. Before. As if the event itself is the detonation point. And the whole village is running its little Dragon Boat show on top of that. The players are there for fun, burning items, collecting achievements. The Lone Man with the S-grade invisibility is pressed against a wall swearing at 'a trash-tier dungeon.' Nobody in the village knows they're living inside someone else's game. And that's the stakes. Not 'will Musheng die.' Not 'will the dungeon clear.' It's: will the mountains actually collapse? Will the bump in the committee building be explained by something mundane, or is it the first crack in the surface? The old men's debate is comic gold but it's also the stakes stated plainly: they have no framework for what's happening. Their tools are 'ghost' and 'thief.' Neither fits. And the kunlun enterprise sponsorship, the free cultural performance, the agricultural assistance department that agreed 'the very next day' with zero pushback? In a world with S-grade items and system achievements, a corporation sponsoring a village festival 'for free' with a dedicated department and a name like Kunlun? That's not charity. That's a stake buried so deep you don't even realize you're standing on it yet. What's actually being protected by keeping the village event running? What happens to the people in it when the game layer finally shows its teeth? I'm not worried about Musheng dying. I'm worried about Sister Ling's next scheduled event getting 'canceled for safety reasons.' And that's a scarier thought than any dungeon boss.
... Read More
The stakes here are quietly suffocating. "Our phones can't connect to the internet, calls are disabled, and every possible channel for gathering information is cut off." That sentence is doing so much work. No safety net. No Googling the village history. No calling a friend who might recognize the mountains. No one coming to help. And the timer is three days, which feels both long and impossibly short. The lone male is coughing blood, which means the injury from the NPC door-opening isn't going away, and he's using it as a cudgel to shame Xiaoyou, to shift blame, to make everyone uncomfortable. "You should ask your 'good teammate' here." The quotes around good teammate are doing the venom. But then the next beat is Grandma staring at closed curtains and pulling out her phone with a fierce expression, and the tone just swings to slapstick. The author is really good at stacking dread and then puncturing it with domestic absurdity, which keeps the tension from becoming pure misery. The real conflict though, the one that's been building since the chapter started, is the fracture in the player group. The chubby guy is the de facto leader and he's already suspicious. The girlfriend is analyzing who has affinity with whom like a chess player. Xiaoyou is about to walk away from the group entirely, and the narrator flat-out says "Any player with half a brain wouldn't leave the group to stay somewhere alone. Lone players die the fastest." That's not a story beat, that's a threat dressed as a comment. And the Peeping Lens at the very end, costing ten lifepoints to use, one shot per dungeon, aimed at the man who's been carrying her bag and checking if she's comfortable. What's she looking for? Is she scared of him? Does she already know something? I don't know yet and I'm not sleeping well about it.
... Read More
Let's talk structure because this author clearly understands how to pace a narrative. The opening system messages hit fast and hard — establishment of rules, stakes, and the horror element in three lines. Then we drop into the bus scene and the pacing slows to match the oppressive summer heat. Brilliant. The reader feels the time dilation. The chapter flow is deliberate. We start with tension (the silent passengers, the threatening driver), introduce the disruptor (Chao Musheng), let the tension release slightly through his interactions, then ramp it back up with the scooter incident and the watch dropped. Each beat serves the overall arc while providing its own mini-climax. What I appreciate most is how the information drops are staggered. First we learn about the exploration instance rules, then the NPC hierarchy, then Chao Musheng's true nature (or lack thereof — is he a player? An NPC? Something else?), then the village tourism scheme. Each revelation opens new questions while answering old ones. The author trusts the reader to keep up without over-explaining. The cliffhanger elements work because they're embedded in character moments rather than generic danger signals. When Uncle Ming yells at the scooter driver, it's funny and threatening simultaneously. The pacing never lets you settle — you're always one beat away from either laughter or panic. That's skilled storytelling.
... Read More
'[Ding! Achievement unlocked: Attend a Funeral. Reward: None (No intel gained).]' I've read this line four times. Four. And every time I want to shake the author's hand. Because on the surface it's a joke. Players burned rare items, bled, fought through the crowd, and got what? A village skit about Qu Yuan. A performance. A *funeral* that isn't a funeral. No body. No grief. No intel. Just an achievement notification that reads like a bureaucratic error. But underneath it's doing something about what this whole village event actually is. Everyone is performing. The villagers are doing a cultural show for tourists and officials. The players are performing 'attendance' for the system. The grandpas are performing 'I am not going to be the one scolded for bad photos.' Grandma is performing youth. Sister Ling is performing calm while her nightmare about the mountains collapsing eats her alive. And Musheng? God, Musheng. He's performing the perfect grandson, the perfect local boy, the perfect charming audience member for the TV crew. He knows every line. He compliments the leaders, he compliments the performers, he compliments the departments. 'His compliments were so sincere' the narrator says, and I read 'sincere' and heard 'rehearsed.' The little girl wanting to grow up and be 'like Brother Musheng' is the gut-punch in all of it because she sees the performance and thinks it's *him*. She doesn't see the actor. She sees the one kid who makes everything easy. Who gets the door open. Who takes the photos. Who fans Sister Ling with two leaves. And I don't think the author is saying Musheng is fake. I think they're asking: in a world where everything is a game, a system, a dungeon with invisible rules, is there even such a thing as not performing? The ghost debate at the end is the same symbol wearing a different mask. The old men can't explain the bump. So it must be a ghost. Or a thief. Or nothing. They need a story that fits the box they have. The bump doesn't fit. So they argue. And Musheng just fills the thermos and walks away. Which is either the most peaceful character moment in this whole book or the most terrifying one, depending on what he actually saw in that doorframe.
... Read More
Chao Musheng just... exists in the most infuriatingly wholesome way. He pulls Huoxiang Zhengqi from a cardboard box and stuffs a straw in it because Little Lin looks dizzy. No one asked. He just noticed. And later he's sitting between a grandpa and a grandma, three of them laughing and chatting, and the lone male watches from the windowsill and has to yank the curtains shut because the domesticity is unbearable against the context of him spitting blood on the floor. And the grandpa says "My dear grandson, these photos are way better than what your grandpa could ever take!" and Musheng goes "Yes, yes, Musheng is your 'big treasure,' and I'm just the grass by the front ditch." And the players just stare. "Not that kind of big treasure." I was howling at my phone. But then underneath the comedy, there's this quiet thing where Chao Musheng offers to walk Xiaoyou to the women-only guesthouse, carries her bag, asks if she has a lot of luggage, glances into her room but doesn't enter. He's so gentle about it. And she freezes, stares at him, looks away fast. "That's... too much trouble for you." And the other players watch. The girlfriend especially. She's reading the room and I can tell she's already cataloguing who has affinity with whom, who's the leader, who's disposable. The chubby guy is clearly the alpha of the player group, the one who assigns intel-gathering tasks, the one who says "We agreed to gather intel together. Why did you come back early?" in that disappointed-older-brother voice. But Xiaoyou just... detaches. Accepts the solo move without a word. That's not bravery, that's something else. The Peeping Lens moment at the end—her quietly pulling out an S-grade item while everyone else is frozen in the hallway—says everything about her. She's been planning. She's been watching Chao Musheng long before this chapter. And the kid NPC on the bus who only wanted to play with her? That's not random. That's a marker. The author is tying her to the child NPCs in a way that'll probably matter later, and I'm getting anxious about it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Aunt Xiufang because her voice is so specific it's almost a character in itself. She bursts upstairs with rapid footsteps and a shrill "Who's fighting? Who's fighting?!" and then she's already inspecting damage. "You broke this!" pointing at a chipped table corner. "You'll have to pay for it." No preamble. No "oh my god what happened." She's a landlord whose kids abandoned her in this rural house and she is holding the line. The players think they're doing a convincing fake fight and she just... walks in and makes it real. The chubby man's apology—"Hey, man, really sorry about this" with the head-scratching remorse—is so perfectly average-tourist that it's almost funny. And then the couple's guy, doing this very performatively masculine thing, wrapping an arm around his girlfriend while saying "He's just heartbroken. Men like him get extra sensitive. Why bother arguing with him?" as if he's narrating his own emotions. It reads so naturally like how guys actually talk when they're slightly embarrassed and trying to save face. Chao Musheng's dialogue is the opposite. Short. Functional. "Do you want to move somewhere else?" "It's no trouble." "Do you have a lot of luggage?" Three lines, zero ornament, and somehow the kindest voice in the room. And the whole thread of the grandpa calling him big treasure followed by the collective "…" from the players is the best comedic beat in the chapter. The author writes these reactions as just an ellipsis, which is funnier than any elaborated explanation could be.
... Read More
I re-read the dinner scene four times. Not because it's plot-important. Because the dialogue is so perfectly specific it made my throat do the thing. 'How'd you get so thin after just two months at school? Is the cafeteria food that bad?' And then Chao Musheng leaning in, practically squishing his face against the camera: 'Look, my face is rounder now. Grandpa, tell her — haven't I gained weight?' And Grandpa just... NODS. Nods and agrees. Nods and fetches crispy fried pork. Nods and peels loquats. He doesn't even know if he's right. He just nods because Grandma said it and that's the law of this house. You don't see that dialogue in a lot of Chinese fiction, where the elder is a prop or a speech-giver. Here Grandpa is a physical object that moves in sync with Grandma's opinions, hauling suitcases and nodding and fetching snacks, terrified their boy will go hungry. And Grandma pinching his cheek. 'Round? You're skin and bones!' The word 'round' in quotes because she's literally quoting his words and immediately destroying them. That's not a writer showing you they're close. That's a writer who watched their own nana do it at a kitchen table and transcribed the exact rhythm. Then Chao Musheng's 'dialogue' with the lanky man at the pond is the complete opposite register. 'Kids these days have no fear,' said cheerfully. 'The pond's swarming with mosquitoes at night — you should head back early too.' The kindness is structural, not emotional. He's not being mean. He's being SO normal, SO harmless, SO grandpa-lecturing-you-about-mosquitoes, that the threat underneath it is actually scarier. The man 'discreetly exhales' and leaves. And Chao Musheng's actual warning lands in the group chat three lines later, completely different voice: 'Heads up, everyone! Keep an eye on that male tourist who just arrived today. Something feels off about him.' No smile. No mossy concern. Just flat, operational. The two voices stacked on top of each other is where this character's dialogue design earns its keep. Fatty's 'Her favorability toward me is 45. Yours must be even higher' while Xiaoyou is still holding the hairpin and feeling the ghost-heat of the kid's palm? That's the narrator letting us in on the game's logic without breaking the emotional spell. Fatty talks in numbers because that's his coping mechanism. Xiaoyou talks in fragments — 'I just…' — because she doesn't have a number for what that felt like. And I respect that the author let her not have one.
... Read More
First off: the author is a sneaky little pacing wizard in this stretch and I need to say that clearly before I break it down. The chapter opens mid-action. Door slams. Lone Man is squished. We skip thirty seconds forward to the show starting. No setup. No 'meanwhile in another location.' You're just dropped in and you have to catch up fast. That's a weirdly effective cold open for what's supposed to be a cozy village arc. Then the funeral skit hits and the achievement joke lands, and before you can even exhale we're at the TV interview. And the TV interview is where the pacing gets genuinely clever. It's not one scene. It's three. Musheng's interview (smooth, quick, done). The little girl's interview (slower, cuter, you have to watch her tiny body language shift). The grandma backstage chaos (faster again, more physical, phones being thrust into his hands). Three beats, three different rhythms, all within what should be one 'interview montage.' The author keeps changing the tempo so your brain never settles into a groove. Then BAM, we cut to the old men arguing about ghosts vs. thieves near the water dispenser, which is basically a comedy sketch set piece. And while you're laughing at the feng shui master's 'I was bumped, therefore ghost' logic, the tension thread is quietly laid down. Because that bump is real. Someone's been in the committee building. And then Sister Ling's break under the shade, fanning herself, talking about her nightmare. The pacing here is almost lullaby-soft after all that noise. You breathe out. And that's when the dread creeps in. 'Next year, no more large-scale events.' Why? What's coming? I kept my phone tilted toward me like I was texting back and forth, genuinely not able to put it down for five minutes straight. The question I keep turning over: is the author going to lean into this domestic slice-of-life for another three chapters before dropping the next plot bomb, or is the bump + nightmare combo the last warning before everything tips? Because if it's the latter, the pacing has been *very* patient. Patient to the point of making me anxious.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or