This Is Strange - Reviews

This Is Strange
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how the plot keeps gaslighting me. Like, we go from Chao Musheng grumbling about a leaking faucet at 3am to suddenly we're in the middle of a village-wide cultural performance with TV crews and official vehicles parked outside, and my brain just goes WAIT. How did we get here. And then the players are standing in the crowd looking miserable while everyone around them is buying grilled sausages and handing out peanuts, and the tone shift is so jarring it actually makes the stakes feel more real. The thing that got me is Lone Man's logic. He says the best time to snoop through the village committee office for death records is when there are this many people around. 'That's exactly why it's the best time to act.' And I'm like, yeah, okay, hiding in plain sight, classic. But it also means the author is telling us that the funeral got postponed specifically for this performance, which is a genuinely creepy detail. A village kills a person, then throws a festival to cover it up. The juxtaposition of Grandma doing her little dance segment on camera while somewhere in that committee office a body might still be lying in a cold storage room. That's the plot architecture here, and it's mean. Also the peanut thing. Xiaoyou cracks one open, pops it in her mouth, and gets +5 HP. A special item disguised as a snack a child gave you. I was not ready for that. It means the NPC economy is actively feeding the players, or maybe the kid just randomly handed her something from her pocket and it happened to be a game item. Either way it's a plot device that makes the whole village feel like it's running on two parallel rule-sets at once, and I want to know if the NPCs even know what they're doing or if the system just... dropped a consumable into a toddler's pocket for balance. What a wild choice. I don't know if I love it or if it's a cop-out but it definitely made me pause and re-read that paragraph twice.
... Read More
I need to talk about how Chao Musheng reads people because this character just keeps ratcheting my respect gear up and I can't stop. The scene where the senior officer asks him to explain why the thin man was suspicious, and he goes: 'When he got off the bus, he claimed to be a programmer, but his hairline was fuller than any computer science major's.' I literally choked on my water reading that. He also noted the guy asked what the 'Descendants of Lu Ban' shop sold, which would mean the person doesn't know Chinese cultural history despite claiming to be a domestic tourist. And then, the kicker, 'he said he was here as a tourist but didn't even carry a backpack. Nothing about him adds up.' It's this incredibly dry, methodical observation of the mundane that somehow out-solves the entire police force in the room. He's not some action hero kicking the guy in the jaw (well, he does kick the wrist, but that's tactical, not dramatic). He's just... paying attention. And being a top student at Jinghua University while doing it makes me want to genuflect. But what actually gets me is how he interacts with Little Lin. The kid draws his stun baton, jabs the suspect, announces 'Suspect is assaulting an officer!' before fully understanding what's happening, and Musheng just... lets him do it. Doesn't correct him publicly, doesn't roll his eyes. Later, when they're walking back and Little Lin asks about the mountains, Musheng steadies him when he's about to step in a ditch and answers patient, 'Since the reforestation policy, they've become wildlife territory.' He treats the cop kid like an equal even though he's clearly the smarter one in the room. And Little Lin's response is just 'Bro, you're sharp' with wide eyes, which is so endearing it almost undoes me. What irks me more is the thin man's internal monologue seething at 'that meddling pretty boy.' The resentment is SO disproportionate to what Musheng actually did. He kicked a wrist. One kick. And the guy is mentally filing a permanent grudge. I want to know what happens when they cross paths again, if ever. Also, the village cadre getting excited about the two-hundred-thousand bounty for his own work record while two parents are still clutching his hand going 'arrest him' makes me feel like we're watching three completely different people in the same room. Nobody's in sync here, and I think that's intentional.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second. 'With 38 HP left, Chao Musheng and the other NPCs would leave soon. He could hold out!' Thirty-eight health points. In a dungeon where the fog eats two HP per hour, that's nineteen hours before this person is dead. Nineteen hours crouched in a corner, invisible, searching bookshelves for answers, while rain falls and shadows twist around him. And the most terrifying thing? We don't even know who he is. He's been operating in the background this whole time—scouting, surviving, gathering intel—and now he's down to his last gasp. The stakes aren't just personal; they're narrative. Whatever he finds in those books matters. The author has built enough mystery around this character that I'm genuinely anxious for him, which is remarkable for someone we've only seen as a silhouette in the rain. But the stakes operate on multiple levels simultaneously. There's Fatty's faction closing in, suspicious and armed. There's the Peeping Lens losing power, which could mean Xiaoyou loses her only edge. There's the dungeon itself, with its 'seriously cursed' reputation and children's laughter echoing through foggy streets like a cruel joke. And woven through ALL of it is this almost mundane layer—the loquats ripening on trees, the livestream viewers climbing, the Village Secretary sweating over sales data. The author is doing something really sophisticated here: the stakes are life-and-death, but they're happening alongside ordinary village life that refuses to stop. People are dying in the fog while other people are trying to hit their daily sales targets. Both things matter. Both things are happening at once. 'They're gone.' The Village Party Secretary's whispered line at the end—gone where? Gone from the camera? Gone from the village? The ambiguity is perfect. Every resolution breeds new questions and I cannot stop turning pages.
... Read More
The little girl hands Xiaoyou the hairpin. 'It was warm.' That's the sentence I can't shake. Not 'her hand was small' or 'her ponytail swayed like a butterfly' — though those are pretty. It's the WARMTH. In a system that measures every NPC by a favorability number, where you check stats before approaching, where the whole village is quantified and gamified — this kid just... touches you. No number attached. No favorability popup. Just skin-to-skin warmth and then she's skipping away and you're standing there with a hairpin in your pocket and a tight chest and NO IDEA if that was a clue or a manipulation or just a kid being a kid. And the golden fish. The lanky man plants it: 'I saw a golden fish here.' The kid takes it literally. Sits by the pond at moonlight trying to catch something that isn't there. Is that just his con? Or is it a metaphor the author is layering in — you can't catch what doesn't exist in this place, and anyone who looks for it will be pulled underwater? Because the pond 'swarms with mosquitoes' at night, Chao Musheng says, like a warning. The golden fish as false hope. The reeds as the part of the village that swallows you. I don't know. Maybe I'm over-reading a side gag. But then there's the whole favorability system itself as theme. Every villager is 40+. The driver is 35. You're welcome, you're safe, you're loved. And the quest is: attend a FUNERAL. The village that rates its visitors with open-arms warmth is the same village about to kill someone and bury them. The 'Protect the environment, respect the crops' slogan on the brochure back becomes almost grotesque once you know what's coming. Respect the crops. Attend the funeral. The bureaucracy of normalcy masking the machinery of death. I keep thinking about 'No matter the mountain's height, if gods dwell there, it's divine.' Chao Musheng spouts it mid-sales-pitch, waving his arms at a rock. And I think that's the thesis of the whole dungeon. You're in a place where the mundane is a mask. The mountain doesn't matter. What's dwelling inside it does. And right now, something with a funeral and a treasure is dwelling inside Chaojiawan. I just wish the author would stop wrapping the horror in so much cumin-spiced barbecue smoke.
... Read More
I am not prepared for how much a fictional seven-year-old NPC is ruining my sleep schedule. Chao Musheng pinching Lulu's hair bun and saying 'Princess Lulu graces us today' while she clings to his leg going 'I missed you so much' — I screamed. Like, full volume, at my phone. Then he pretends to be hurt that she ignored him two nights ago, and she does this vigorous head-shake going 'Lulu doesn't know,' and I physically lost in my chair. The dynamic is so specific. He's not being a gentle big-brother type, he's being a slightly smug older kid who's going to get away with it because she's four and will do anything if you call her a princess. And then his braiding skills are objectively bad, the ponytail is lopsided, and she refuses to let her mother fix it because SHENG-gege made it. That's character work for like three lines of dialogue and it tells me everything about how this village treats outsiders who are kind. They latch on. They make the bond official by making the gift irreplaceable. Xiaoyou crouching down to the kid is different energy. She knows the girl is an NPC. She knows this whole village loops forever. And she still asks 'Why are you alone?' and still says 'Remember, never talk to strangers' like she's talking to a real child who'll actually retain the instruction. And then the girl offers peanuts and it's a special item and Xiaoyou's body goes stiff and she SNATCHES UP to see where the girl went but all she sees is a red balloon. The detachment she's trying to maintain, the 'I'm playing a game and these people aren't real,' completely collapses in one interaction with a toddler. That's the character arc in miniature. She can't help it. The village gets in under your skin no matter how many times you've done this before. Uncle Ming is my quiet favorite too though. The wistful smile when he says the roads are built now and his bus doesn't matter. 'He was getting older, and so was his bus.' One sentence. No drama, no speech. Just a guy watching his whole identity dissolve because infrastructure improved. And then Chao Musheng flatters him about needing the bus for school, and Uncle Ming chides him for rascally behavior, and it's the most normal grandpa-nephew interaction I've seen in this entire novel, which makes the contrast with the players doing tactical split-up operations in the same scene almost violent.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely masterful. It starts with a livestream sales dashboard—almost comedic, almost mundane—and then pivots so hard into assassination attempt that I genuinely gasped. One minute Chao Musheng is sipping cooled tea while people spam the chat, the next a prison-dungeon serial killer is crouching outside like a vengeful ghost. What I love is how the author controls the tension rhythm. We get these breathing moments—Chao Musheng yawning, wanting to go home, the Village Secretary stuffing tea and a jacket into his arms—right before cutting to Lone Man's escalating impatience. Three hours. Three. Hours. The repetition drives home the mounting frustration, and then the pay-off is instant failure. Then the structure does something really smart: it pulls back to show Poison Man's death through the system notification, which resets the entire threat level for everyone reading. Even the worst player in this dungeon died. What chance do the others have? And Fatty's encounter at the end—starting casual, getting creeped out, noticing the rain boots, the lack of an affinity indicator, the unnervingly dark pupils—this is a perfect cliffhanger sequence. It doesn't end with an explosion; it ends with a question that haunts you. 'How does that pretty boyfriend not have an affinity value?' That line alone justifies every chapter that came before it.
... Read More
The tension in this section isn't the big dramatic kind. It's the 'you've got fifty minutes and if you look even slightly off, an NPC notices and the whole instance collapses' kind. And honestly that's scarier than any knife fight because the threat is social. Lone Man says 'Looking miserable is just asking for NPCs to notice something's off.' That line rewired my understanding of the whole game. The enemy isn't a monster. The enemy is a village of people who've been told to be cheerful, and if you break the script, the system might flag you. So the players are in a room full of people and they cannot have a bad thought visible on their face. That's a genuinely tight constraint and I respect it. But then the little girl tells Xiaoyou the village caught a kidnapper yesterday. Just, casual, tiptoe whisper, 'Jiejie, I'll tell you a secret.' And that's the conflict spike. Not the kidnapping itself, we already know that's happening. The spike is that the child KNOWS and is TELLING and Xiaoyou has to process 'the NPCs have awareness of the crime but they're not reporting it to the players in a structured way, they're just... leaking it through a kid's whisper at a festival.' The information asymmetry is the real danger here. The players think they're sneaking around to find records. The village is openly, cheerfully, handing out clues in peanuts and hairpins. And that makes the stakes feel less like a heist and more like a horror where the door is open and the lights are on and everything is normal except it isn't. What's at risk isn't just the players' lives, it's their composure. Fatty says 'Forget about the double rewards. Focus on surviving five days.' Five days. They've been here at least two already. The clock is visible. And the performance is the midpoint, the half-way marker where the village will shift back to its daily rhythm and the players will have to figure out round two. I'm not sure what round two looks like yet, and that uncertainty is keeping me reading. The real question is whether Lulu telling her mom 'Mama!' and running off is the last we see of her, or if that kid becomes the key to the next plot turn. Because I keep thinking about that peanut. The +5 HP. If the system is giving them items through a child, what else is the child carrying that hasn't popped yet?
... Read More
"Musheng is your 'big treasure,' and I'm just the grass by the front ditch." I read this line four times. FOUR times. Not for any romantic reason, I swear. It's just that the image of this old couple treating Chao Musheng like a real grandson, photographing him, laughing, calling him by name, while outside the window a player is actively dying of coughing blood. The contrast is so jarring it makes my chest hurt in a weird way. It's like the NPC world has this warm, grounded, stupidly normal texture that the players are desperately trying to exploit, and the author keeps reminding us that for these villagers, it IS normal. Their lives aren't a dungeon. The grandma grabbing the wooden stick and storming upstairs while Musheng chases her shouting "Grandma!" made me physically groan with affection. She's going to assault a random young man for peeping at the windowsill and she's not even mad at him, she's mad that the rules of the house are being violated. It's so petty and so human. And then there's the quiet beat where Xiaoyou picks up two water bottles in the hallway and hands them to him. Two bottles. No eye contact. Just a small physical exchange that says more than any dialogue could. I keep thinking about what it would feel like to be the one on the other side of that curtain, watching someone so normal and warm from behind glass, knowing that everything is a simulation, a test, a dungeon. The emotional weight of "is this real or is this the trap" hangs over every tender moment here and I can't shake it.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how this chapter structure is doing the thing where it makes you forget you're in a dungeon and then slaps you back into it. Like, the whole village tour scene with Chao Musheng hyping up fruits and chickens and 'free-roaming' ducks — you're like, oh, cute little village lore, very grounded, very warm. And then BAM: 'Please successfully attend the funeral in two days to uncover crucial clues about the village's treasure.' And I'm sitting there going, WAIT, we just got residency rights and already there's a corpse being prepared for us?? The pacing here is so smart because it buries the quest under two pages of Grandma pinching Chao Musheng's cheeks and Grandpa nodding along to everything. You stop bracing for the plot and then the tension sneaks in sideways. What really got me is the layered misdirection with the lanky man at the pond. He's clearly 'off' — the system flagged him early, he was rude to the couple, he's the one pushing the golden fish line onto a kid. But Chao Musheng handles it so casually, just yanks the child out, calls the parents, and the whole thing dissolves. No confrontation. No dramatic showdown. Just 'Kids these days have no fear' said cheerfully while the guy's sweating through his shirt. And THEN, the group chat erupts. Hundreds of people arguing whether this is a human trafficker or a spy or an ALIEN. The narrative uses that chaos to tell us something subtle: the players in this dungeon are so used to threat that a kid swimming in a pond triggers full-blown paranoid discourse. That's a plot device disguised as comedy but it's actually worldbuilding the social dynamics of the player base. And the hairpin moment at the very end — Xiaoyou getting her hairpin back by that little girl, feeling the warmth of her palm, chest going tight — I don't even know what that's 'for' plot-wise yet. It doesn't resolve anything. It just sits there like a pebble in your shoe. Is that a memory? A future reference? A clue about the funeral? I genuinely don't know and the fact that I don't know is what's making me flip back through earlier chapters looking for payoffs. The two-day funeral timer is ticking and every 'warm' scene now has this undercurrent of, when is the mask going to slip? I keep wondering if Sister Ling's perfect tourism smile is actually the villain's cover or just... a woman doing her job. Can't tell yet and I'm mad about it.
... Read More
I'm going to be honest, I read the Lulu scene and then I just put my phone face-down on the desk for ten minutes. Not in a good way. In a 'I need to pretend I'm a person who reads things without feeling things' way. What gets me is that Chao Musheng promised her a hair accessory during Spring Festival. Like, weeks ago, or months ago, in some other beat of the story. And he KEEPS the promise. Carries the little rubber band in his pocket. The text says 'Auntie, you shouldn't spend money on...' and he deflects with 'Can't have the princess thinking I break my word.' It's not a grand gesture. It's a hair tie. But in a village where an NPC child's entire emotional world is a loop, the fact that he remembers, that he carried it, that he tied the lopsided ponytail and she wore it proudly to her friends — that's the whole relationship. He's investing in a character who will never invest back. She'll forget tomorrow. Or maybe she won't. Maybe the loop keeps the memory pinned in place like a butterfly in a jar. And that uncertainty is what makes it ache. Xiaoyou's temple fair memory is the other half of this. Her grandmother took her to temple fairs 'just as lively as this.' And now she's standing in a crowd that looks identical to her childhood, except her grandmother is probably dead, or maybe the grandmother from the game is an NPC who will never age, and the real one is gone, and the parallel is so sharp it made me actually stop reading for a sec. The text just says 'Her expression grew distant' which is the most understated way to say 'I'm mourning something I'm not supposed to mourn because this is a game.' I don't think this book is doing romance or any of that. The emotional lines are all lateral, all sideways, all 'this kid gave you a peanut and now your HP went up and you feel guilty.' Which is a very specific flavor of grief and I am not recovering from it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Chao Musheng because this guy is doing something dangerous with his character. On the surface he's just sweet—he brings water to a traumatized girl, he plays with a dog named Da Huang, he says things like 'making visitors feel at home is the service philosophy of Chaojiawan Village' with a straight face. But here's the thing: every single one of these gentle moments is ALSO a calculated move. He knew the peeping lens had failed. He saw that two guys were fighting in a girl's room. And instead of calling it out or confronting them, he just... relocated Xiaoyou. 'It's only right to relocate her for her own protection,' Grandma says, but we all know Chao Musheng was the one who made it happen. He protected her without her even knowing she needed protecting. Then he goes out into the rain at night under the cover of 'Grandpa left his water bottle'—which is probably true but ALSO gives him free movement while his enemies are watching. The man is playing three-dimensional chess while everyone else is playing checkers. The most chilling part? He actually seems to care. When Xiaoyou says 'If I had to die, maybe this lively, mundane dungeon wouldn't be the worst place for it' and he just hands her water and says 'the best-selling purified water in the country' like it's no big deal—he's acknowledging her despair without making it a thing. That's not manipulation. That's genuine warmth wrapped in survival instinct. And the old couple! Grandpa hiding the carrying pole like a mischievous kid, Grandma immediately scolding him, the whole family unit operating with such natural rhythm. They feel REAL. Not NPC flavor text—they feel like people who will remember your name when you leave this dungeon.
... Read More
Okay so this section? I had to put the book down twice just to process what I just read. The whole set-up with Lone Man waiting three hours in the rain for a strike that literally cannot connect is chef's kiss. Classic dungeon logic where the system itself seems to protect this guy, and it shows in the most satisfying way possible. But here's what really got me—Poison Man died so casually in the same dungeon and the other players are now genuinely terrified. That name drop about a serial killer who murders other players for mission rewards? And he got wiped so easily? That raises the stakes immediately. The rules of this world just got scarier, not clearer. Then there's the chicken, Da Huang, who appears out of nowhere and scratches up Lone Man's face before vanishing back into the grass. Is it just a dog? Or is it some kind of NPC guardian, or maybe even tied to Chao Musheng's secret status? The text drops hints like 'Precious... precious...' from that elderly couple and then suddenly everyone's speculating whether Chao Musheng is the real boss of this scenario. And Fatty, the tourist who noticed the rain boots and got the creeps? His ending realization—'how does that pretty boyfriend not have an affinity value? Isn't he an NPC?'—chills me every time. It's the perfect closing beat that leaves you questioning everything about this world. The plot doesn't give answers; it gives better questions.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or