The Top-Tier Star is Both Powerful and Hilarious - Reviews

The Top-Tier Star is Both Powerful and Hilarious
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
You know what I kept picturing? The pile of phones in that transparent box. One, two, ten, thirty, different brands, all just stacked up like little black bricks of anxiety. And then the wailing. Young women in tears because someone found a phone in their SHOE. 'You, take off your shoe.' And then another one in waist-high stockings. I just... the sheer audacity of those hiding spots. 'So many ways to hide a phone. Useless knowledge increased.' Xia Xi's commentary here is so deadpan and it sells the scene. But what I keep coming back to is the contrast of spaces. We go from the grubby practice room where Xia Xi is doing leg stretches to 'Love Fight Will Win' while everyone else looks at her like she's lost her mind, to this blinding white top-floor office where Lu Chen sits with a fountain pen and a rented view of the whole city. 'In the most prosperous center of the city, office towers soared into the clouds. On the top floor, the room with the best view was the exclusive office of Lu Chen, President of the Lu Corporation. Rented.' That last word. RENTED. Just dropped there like a punchline. The man owns the building, probably, and the office is rented, and it's the 'exclusive' one, and he's sitting there recalling cat emojis to a girl who's currently in a camp where they confiscate your phone. The spatial separation between these two is the whole point. She's in a villa with 101 other people, no electronics, doing camp entry checks. He's 40 floors up in a glass box, one-sided chat history filling up his phone. And the camera language shifts with each location: practice room is grounded, physical, legs on bars, sweat. The office is cold, still, a deep voice asking for updates. The camp entry is chaotic, loud, a staff member shouting through a loudspeaker, 101 people in a row, the wails, the shoe-removal. Three completely different textures of space in like two pages, and none of them overlap yet, but I can feel the author holding all three rooms open at once, waiting for the characters to walk into each other's scenes. I also love that the warm-up song choice is this ancient motivational track and every trainee is staring at her. 'Three parts destined, seven parts rely on fighting spirit.' She picked that. Of course she did. She's a martial artist who chose the most aggressively un-idol song she could think of, and she's practicing 'with great energy, fully focused' while everyone else is watching her like she broke the song.
... Read More
I keep looking for a soft moment in this section and there isn't one. Not yet. She walks into a practice room full of girls who already resent her existence, and the first thing that happens is Rui Ziyue does a front flip off a stool while looking down her nose at her. The other trainees think 'competitor with better looks' and I could feel the social temperature drop ten degrees. Xia Xi is standing there feeling 'slightly uneasy' — Slightly. The woman can bench-press a van and she's getting flustered by a nineteen-year-old doing gymnastics. What gets me is how alone she is in that room. No friend to stand next to her, no rival-turned-ally, no one who says 'hey welcome, I'm sitting next to you, ignore the weirdo.' She's introduced to a group of people whose internal monologue is 'what qualified her?' and that's it. Brother Chao left to find the manager. She's just... there. Blowing patiently. I want a scene where one of those fawning girls ('Teacher Rui that big move is awesome!') actually turns and says something kind to Xia Xi instead. Give me one. Please. The closest thing to emotional warmth is the 'three meals a day plus room and board' promise. It's transactional. It's the company feeding its assets. But for a girl whose entire original host personality was about 'keeping fish' and marrying rich, being told 'we'll feed you' as a benefit of exploitation hits different. There's something quietly sad about her accepting that because the alternative is a breach-of-contract fee she can't pay. She's eating free meals in a corporate cafeteria and calling it home for now. I'm not saying the romance track is active here. It isn't. But the friendship track is clearly going to be 'hostile environment, slow thaw,' and I want to know which trainee breaks first.
... Read More
Yao Xingzhe is doing the most unhinged emotional gaslighting in my current reading list and I cannot get over it. So he texts her this little performance: 're working, just take leave. Hand it off to someone else. Didn't you say you'd take good care of me... Or is your job more important than I am?' And then 'If I don't get to eat it, I won't eat anything at all.' That second line is a child's ultimatum wrapped in an adult's syntax. He KNEW it would work. He knew she'd drop everything and come make a sandwich. And the worst part, the part that made me put my phone down and stare at the ceiling for ten seconds - he describes it as 'feeling a mix of disgust and amusement at his own game.' HE KNOWS. He's not confused. He's not hurt. He's entertained by himself manipulating her while feeling vaguely ashamed, and the shame doesn't stop the behavior. It just adds flavor. And then in front of the livestream, when teammates ask who he's texting, he says 'It's the cook.' Not his girlfriend. Not someone he cares about. THE COOK. A household employee. He reduces her to the most disposable role available and his teammate just goes with it because of course he does, because Yao Xingzhe is famous and rich and has 'a temper' and nobody pushes back. Dating? As if she was worthy. That one quiet internal line did more to characterize him than any of his threats. It's not jealousy. It's not insecurity about a girl he finds unattractive. It's a genuine belief that she is below the category of 'person who gets to be his girlfriend publicly.' And that's terrifying because he probably means it with a straight face. What I'm not sure about is where Xia Xi fits in all this. In this batch she's mostly seen from the outside - her application form, her audition, her 'how about I just demonstrate' moment. She's solid but I haven't seen her REACT to his mess yet. And I need that. I need to see the girl who wants to open a martial arts school and run a seafood buffet look at this dramatics machine and say 'whatever, pass me the punch bag.' Am I projecting? Probably. But the tension of those two personalities orbiting each other without acknowledging the orbit is giving me genuine anxiety.
... Read More
I was genuinely not expecting this chapter's opening to hit me where it did. Rui Ziyue is on the floor crying, makeup all smeared, and then Xia Xi walks in and the first thing she says is 'Stop crying.' And then after Rui Ziyue goes 'I will cry! None of your business!' the response is 'Your crying is giving me a headache.' And I just... I cannot stop thinking about this. These two are clearly close, like, 'first person you want to hide from when you fall apart' close, and that's a really specific kind of intimacy. The vulnerability of being caught crying in front of YOUR person, not a stranger, not a parent, not a manager, but the one friend who's supposed to get you. And Xia Xi's response isn't comforting, it's slightly hostile, and that's actually more honest than a soft 'it's okay, everything will be fine' would have been. They both know why she's crying. The part about the solo. They don't need to say it. 'Both of them knew perfectly well why Rui Ziyue was hiding and crying at noon.' That single sentence carries so much unspoken stuff. And then the Lu Chen side. He changes his profile picture to his own face and thinks that's obvious enough. 'Girl, the profile picture is me. Not satisfied?' He's a man of few words, apparently, and he assumes she'll decode a selfie as 'I'm thinking of you, I apologize for ignoring you.' And she just... doesn't see it. Or doesn't care. Or maybe she's at the camp and literally can't check her phone. The emotional distance here is funny and a little sad. He's in this cold corporate tower doing this very small, very human thing, and she's on the other side of the city doing push-ups to 'Love Fight Will Win' and not even thinking about him. I keep going back to the cat emoji he recalls. Just one cat peeking. That's the most pathetic and also most tender 'hey you' I've read in a while. I'm not gonna say it's a heavy emotional line, it's more of a low-grade ache. A 'huh, these two are gonna be annoying at each other for a while' kind of ache. But the Rui Ziyue thing, the 'startled bird' description, the way she keeps glancing at Xia Xi during warm-up but never goes to ask, that's the real gut-punch of the batch.
... Read More
There is a specific tone to this novel that I cannot stop appreciating. It's got this sharp, dry wit that feels like the narrator is standing right beside you reading the book and occasionally making snide comments under their breath. When Xia Xi sees her reflection and thinks "So pretty" about the seventy-to-eighty-percent-identical-but-better-dressed version of herself in the mirror — that's not just description, that's the narrative voice having a moment. It's playful, self-aware, and completely unbothered. The system's dialogue is another highlight. It's mechanical and polite but clearly struggling to process Xia Xi's reactions. The line where it "comforts" her by implying her miserable fate was the original owner's problem, not hers — and then immediately notices she's still silent and gets confused — this is comedy gold. The system is essentially a customer service bot that can't handle a dissatisfied customer, and I want to see more of its limited emotional range. Xia Xi's internal monologue is where the real voice shines though. Her thoughts about the five-star fish being "hundreds of millions in assets" and her immediate practical concern about whether she owes them money — this is the kind of humor that comes from a character who is fully themselves. She's not trying to be witty. She's just being brutally honest with herself and the reader happens to be along for the ride. The contrast between Xia Xi's straightforward, almost childlike excitement (wanting to open a martial arts school!) and the manipulative undercurrents of the world she's been dropped into creates this wonderful tonal friction. The novel never takes itself seriously, but it also never lets the stakes disappear. That balance is harder to pull off than it looks.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely masterful. Let me break down why: we go from tension (don't eat during recording) to rebellion (eating anyway) to connection (sharing the secret) to transformation (Xia Xi becoming the unofficial mentor). All of this happens in roughly five minutes of story time. The author doesn't rush any of it, though. Each beat gets exactly the attention it needs. The gummy bear moment lingers—we watch Xia Xi's face change from shock to acceptance to enjoyment, savoring each micro-expression. Then there's this breathing room where she watches the performances, completely absorbed, before the next plot point arrives. The structure mirrors reality: life doesn't have dramatic climaxes every three pages, it has these small, cumulative moments that build character. What's clever is how the author uses the show's timeline as a natural pacing mechanism. As performances continue and time passes, so does Xia Xi's transformation. The pacing feels organic because it's tied to something real—the structure of a talent show recording. We experience it alongside her, minute by minute.
... Read More
Okay I'll just throw out the bits I noticed because this scene's pacing is basically a snappy little drum hit. First beat: Wan Jun does his generous-mentor routine. Quick, breezy, 'lively' is the word the author picks, not 'eloquent' or 'inspiring,' so we know it's not going to get verbose. Second beat: Xia Xi glances around, finds the director, gets a nod. That's maybe eight seconds of real-time action compressed into two lines. Third beat: she speaks. The whole scene is under four lines of dialogue and I did not want a paragraph of internal monologue before she opened her mouth. The author respected the rhythm. No 'Xia Xi took a deep breath, gathered her courage, and considered how to phrase her objection while the studio lights hummed above her.' No. She just talks. And the punchline 'Then I'll need extra pay' lands almost immediately after the setup, which is what a good comedic beat needs. If it had sat for two more sentences of reaction from the audience, it would've gone stale. The pacing here is basically the shape of a stand-up joke: setup, beat, payoff, walk off. I also liked that the 'audience perspective' interjection sits in the middle, slightly slowing the tempo, giving us a half-second of external commentary before snapping back inside Xia Xi's head for the button. It's a tiny breathing room. Not enough to let the momentum die, just enough to register that the audience got it before she delivers the next line. I was reading this at like 11pm and I didn't even blink. It was that kind of clean, no-fat scene. My only small gripe is I wanted just a little more of Wan Jun's delivery, one extra line of him being specifically charming so his 'sacrifice' felt more performative and I could feel the wink harder. But that might've ruined the snap. So maybe it's fine as is.
... Read More
Here's what kept looping in my head: 'People felt both amused and a bit sorry for this poor kid being toyed with by this bunch of pranksters.' The narrator calls her poor. The audience pities her. And in the same breath, she walks up with the mic and says she wants a pay bump. There's this tiny, almost invisible emotional beat where the story tries to make you feel protective of her, to set up a 'hahahaha look at the sweet contestant getting pranked' vibe, and then she just... sidesteps the pity entirely. It's not a big emotional climax, it's more like a small recalibration. The reader was about to land in 'oh Xia Xi is the underdog being bullied by the mentors' and instead the author gently redirects to 'Xia Xi is capable, observant, and not your typical pushover contestant.' And that redirect matters emotionally because it repositions how we care about her. We stop feeling like we need to shield her and start feeling like we want to see what she'll pull next. The 'extra pay' line isn't just funny, it's a quiet declaration of self-worth. She's not going to be the girl who blushes and stammers when the power structure wiggles. She's going to negotiate. I don't know if that's a big deal in the grand scheme of the novel's emotional arcs, but in this moment it made me feel like 'yeah, I get why you'd root for this one.' Not because she's vulnerable. Because she's not. There's something almost refreshingly un-needy about her affect here, no trembling lip, no 'I'm so scared of the mentor panel,' just a quick look around, a micro-expression of 'oh, I see,' and a counter-offer. The emotional temperature of the scene is warm, not hot. Comfortable. And I think that's intentional, this is the scene where the reader settles into the rhythm of the show and gets comfortable with these characters before the actual plot teeth come out.
... Read More
The setting of this entire passage is fascinating because it's so deliberately constructed. Every space is controlled by cameras—live broadcasts, crew members, producers watching from behind the scenes. Even the simple act of sitting and watching a performance happens under surveillance. But what strikes me most is how the author paints these visual contrasts: Xia Xi in blue and white traditional costume, Zhao Tianqi in red and black modern attire. They're literally dressed as opposites—one ancient and restrained, the other contemporary and bold—yet they end up doing the same secret thing together. The imagery of Xia Xi's neck "resembling a white swan" while she chews nervously creates this beautiful juxtaposition of grace and humanity. And then there's the stage itself, described through Xia Xi's overwhelmed perspective as she takes in street dance, ballet, tap, cha-cha. The author builds this world of competitive performance culture where everything is captured, edited, broadcast. It's a fishbowl existence, and Xia Xi navigating it with her accidental wisdom creates this wonderful tension between visibility and authenticity.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is deceptively simple. Let me break down why it works so well. When Chu Sisi approaches Xia Xi, her lines are full of hesitant energy — 'So… can I ask you to open bottle caps for me again?' with that apple-shaped face turning pink. You can hear her nervousness in the ellipsis and the tentativeness. Then Zhao Tianqi's dialogue is the complete opposite: short, direct, almost clinical. 'Zhao Tianqi.' (points to name tag) 'Xia Xi.' (tugs at her own clothes) 'Is this seat taken? Can I sit here?' It's like two kids introducing themselves but with this underlying coolness that makes it feel so in-character. And the gummy bear offer — that's peak Zhao Tianqi. She doesn't say 'would you like something?' she just rummages in her pocket and presents the option. The live chat dialogue is also surprisingly well-done. Lines like 'If you say Xia Xi has bad connections, I don't believe it. If she really had bad connections, does that make me invisible?' feel like actual internet comments — snarky, reactive, slightly unhinged. The author captures different voices so distinctly.
... Read More
The stakes in this opening are surprisingly layered for a story that starts with a girl picking up a skill book. On the surface, Xia Xi's conflict is simple: survive in a compensation world where the original body's owner was a gold-digger who got played by wealthy men. But the moment we see Yao Xingzhe demanding sandwiches at midnight, the external threat becomes visceral. These aren't just background characters — they're active, powerful, and they already have opinions about Xia Xi's predecessor. The internal conflict is equally interesting. Xia Xi has this skill book that promised her a life of seafood abundance and martial arts mastery, and now she's trapped in a body that belongs to someone whose choices will determine whether she lives or dies in this world. She didn't choose this setup. She chose the skill book. The system chose the rest. And yet she's already planning — filling out that audition form, checking her debts, mentally preparing to navigate a social minefield. What's brilliant about the stakes is that nobody in this story is innocent. The original sea queen manipulated these men. The men knew and participated anyway, treating her as entertainment. Yao Xingzhe is a manipulator himself. And Xia Xi — well, she's a reincarnated person who got dropped into someone else's life with incomplete information. That's a lot of moral ambiguity compressed into four chapters, and it makes every interaction feel charged. When Xia Xi walks into that audition venue surrounded by beautiful girls and wealthy men who all have secrets, I want to see who blinks first.
... Read More
'Is that considered a big move?' I'm going to circle back to that line later. First I need to talk about the dance/martial arts miscommunication because it's doing so much thematic work and I don't think anyone else will notice. Brother Chao hears 'martial arts school' and translates it to 'dance studio' in his head. Xia Xi confirms it. He nods. They're two people speaking the same words about completely different things and neither registers the gap. She's talking about passing on her master's lineage, the physical transmission of knowledge, the weight of a tradition handed from one person to the next. He's talking about choreography for a TV show, performance, packaging a body for cameras. The word 'dance' is doing the bridging but it's a flimsy bridge and I think the author knows it. This whole section is about translation failure. The system translates the original host's plot into Xia Xi's reality and gets the audition wrong. Brother Chao translates Xia Xi's ambition into industry-speak and gets the sport wrong. The trainees translate Xia Xi's presence into competitive threat and get the motivation wrong — she's not here to win, she's here to survive contractually while building something else entirely. Every interaction in these chapters is a mistranslation, and the comedy of it is genuine, but underneath there's something quieter: nobody sees what she actually is. The assistant director sees 'hobby' where there's a specialty. The male staff member sees 'slender limbs' where there's a woman who could put him on the floor. Rui Ziyue sees a beauty threat where there's a completely different threat category entirely. And that last question — 'Is that considered a big move?' — is the thematic thesis of the whole book in five words. The world is measuring her on their scale. Front flips. Choreography ratings. Survival show rankings. And she's looking at them with the calm, slightly confused expression of someone who learned to move through water and fire and stone and is genuinely trying to figure out why a front flip deserves applause. I think the recurring image is going to be her patience. Blinked, waited, blinked again. The water doesn't fight the stone. It just... goes around it. Or through it. I'll know when I see the next confrontation. Oh and the Little Mermaid book she brought. The only possession. A fairy tale about a creature trading her voice for legs, walking into a world where everyone's a little bit wrong about what she is. That's not an accident, I don't think. That's the spine of the whole thing.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or