The Top-Tier Star is Both Powerful and Hilarious - Reviews

The Top-Tier Star is Both Powerful and Hilarious
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's something deeply symbolic about Xia Xi being compared to a Taoist priest throughout this passage. Taoism values simplicity, naturalness, following the Dao—but Xia Xi's version of this has been performative, a mask she's wearing for the cameras. The gummy bear becomes this fascinating symbol of genuine desire breaking through artificial restraint. It's small, almost trivial, but it represents something enormous: the moment when someone stops performing and starts being. The blue and white costume reinforces this—colors associated with purity, tradition, restraint. Meanwhile the red and black Zhao Tianqi wears suggests passion, danger, rebellion. Yet the pure one is the one who caves first. That's the irony the author is playing with. And Xia Xi's commentary creates another layer of symbolism—her words are pure expression, untainted by strategy or calculation. When she describes Chu Sisi's song as walking through a village with family calling you home, that's not performer-speak; that's soul-speak. The deeper theme here is about authenticity in a world designed to commodify every gesture. Xia Xi accidentally embodies what the show claims to search for: someone genuine.
... Read More
I need to talk about Rui Ziyue because this girl is EVERYTHING and I am already obsessed. From literally three paragraphs in, she labels Xia Xi as 'a beast.' That is such a specific, loaded word. It's not 'hardworking' or 'disciplined.' It's BEAST. And then she watches Xia Xi close another trainee's eyes gently and drift back to sleep, and her reaction is pure chaotic disbelief: 'This is just absurd! This is just absurd!' She says it twice. Twice! Like her brain physically cannot compute the girl who is simultaneously a sleep-avoiding morning machine and someone tender enough to physically close a roommate's eyelids. Xia Xi herself? The text says: 'As a qualified player, multiple phones were the original owner's tribute to the game. For Xia Xi, six phones were a burden.' This single line tells us everything about her internal logic. She's not playing by the same social rules everyone else is. Her priorities are shifted. She runs because her body needs training. She helps open a bottle for a round-faced girl. She wants braised pork after exercise. Her motivations are practical, almost alien compared to the other contestants who are performing for cameras and fans. And then there's Morning Runner No. 2, who stays shadowed behind a mask and hat while Xia Xi offers her a faint smile and gets a nod back. Their entire relationship exists in silence and synchronized footsteps. What does that say about both of them? I need to know.
... Read More
Let me just say this — I did not expect to be hooked in the first three pages and yet here we are. The chapter starts with Xia Xi examining a skill book titled "The Little Mermaid" and building an entire fantasy life around becoming a fisherwoman who sells grilled squid. This is the funniest setup I have ever encountered. She goes from "I might be a fisherwoman" to "I could open a martial arts school" in what feels like three seconds, and I was laughing out loud the entire time. Then — wham — the system dumps her into a compensation world where she's now a film school student and upcoming contestant on a girl group survival show called "Pick 101." The transition is so fast it's almost dizzying, but somehow it works because the humor carries you through. The chapter doesn't waste a single moment on exposition. We learn about her death, the system, the skill book, the world rules, and her new identity all while she's simultaneously filling out an audition form and checking her phone. Multi-tasking narrative, if you will. The structure also does something clever with perspective shifts. We're deep inside Xia Xi's head for most of the chapter, and then at the very end, we cut to Yao Xingzhe's POV in his dimly lit room. This is the classic "meanwhile" move, but it lands perfectly because it reframes everything we just read. Suddenly the "sea queen" isn't just a backstory character — she's a living, breathing threat who is already plotting against Xia Xi. And Xia Xi has no idea yet. That dramatic irony is going to be delicious to watch unfold. The only thing I'd note is that the chapter ends on an almost abrupt cutoff — Yao Xingzhe is mid-text and then we're done. It's a cliffhanger, yes, but it feels more like the author just lost interest in finishing the sentence than a deliberate pacing choice. Either way, it made me immediately want to turn the page.
... Read More
Okay so this whole scene where Xia Xi shares gummy bears with Zhao Tianqi feels like such a crucial turning point in her character arc. She starts off completely by-the-book—wearing that Taoist priest energy, actually warning someone about eating on camera—and then five minutes later she's a full-blown accomplice. The plot twist isn't even dramatic, it's this quiet, almost subversive little moment where her "good girl" persona just... cracks. And I love that the author uses something as small as a gummy bear to show this transformation. It's not a huge revelation or confrontation, just two girls secretly eating candy while cameras roll. But somehow it says everything about who Xia Xi really is versus who she's pretending to be. The show itself operates on these hidden layers too—everyone's performing for the cameras, everyone's trying to craft their image. Xia Xi's commentary later becomes another layer of performance, except this time she's actually good at it, which creates this fun tension between authenticity and strategy. Did she plan those compliments? Probably not. But the fact that she accidentally destroyed her own "pure" persona through genuine talent shows how the plot keeps undermining the expectations both characters and viewers have built up.
... Read More
Okay so the hospital-fainting-during-livestream thing really rewired my brain on how this author builds structure. On the surface it's 'oops esports guy didn't eat and passed out,' but I keep going back to it because it's doing THREE jobs at once. First, it's the consequence of his little sandwich standoff - he threatened her, she didn't show up (or isn't shown yet in this batch), and now his body literally fails. Second, it drags him out of his controlled environment (the studio, the mic, the camera, the audience) and drops him in a hospital bed where he's just 'the third fish' - nameless, reduced, vulnerable. That word choice, 'the third fish,' makes me want to scream. He's a player at a table named after his seat, not his face. And third, it creates this perfect parallel with Xia Xi in the SAME moment throwing punches at an audition. He's in a bed being poked with needles, she's in a room full of people who said her arms could 'probably snap with a little force.' The story is saying: you chose power and control and it cost you your body; she chose a world that looks at her and sees fragility, and she just... punched through it. The intercutting is clean. I get why the author splits them into two locations for the same afternoon. It's not lazy parallel editing, it's thematic juxtaposition. And the 'Pick 101' casting subplot isn't filler either - it's the mechanism that FORCES their paths to cross under professional conditions, not just whatever private dynamic they had before. Did your family's cook go to pick up her grandson from kindergarten? That line is the comic beat that makes you groan, but it's also the last straw that tips his 'mildly irritated' into 'genuinely angry.' The escalation works. I'm just still trying to figure out when we get to see Xia Xi actually arrive at his hospital room. Is it coming in the next batch or am I being starved on purpose? Because my brain is doing the same thing his blood sugar is doing. Running on fumes.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or