The Times I Remembered You - Reviews

The Times I Remembered You
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
So the whole chapter starts with this seemingly domestic scene—jewels, dresses, a garden walk—and then BAM, a note appears out of nowhere. You'd expect something more elaborate from whoever's trying to send a message, but it's just three lines scrawled on a scrap of paper. ‘You must not forget me.' Creepy, right? Not exactly ‘I love you' energy. What I found interesting is how Kareina processes it. She doesn't panic. She actually considers it might be a threat and then immediately dismisses it herself, attributing her caution to paranoia. That's such a character-defining moment—it tells us everything about how she's been conditioned to doubt her own instincts. And honestly, that's the real tension here, not the note itself. The note is just a symptom. Then the noble council scene hits like a wave. The plot pivots so sharply from garden strolls to political theater. All those nobles piling on with their Niyev insults, and Raul's transformation is the centerpiece. He goes from silently enduring to literally slamming his fist on the desk. The pacing here is brilliant because the author lets the insults build gradually—you can feel each one getting worse, each jab sharper—until Kareina is just sitting there, glass in hand, taking it all in silence. And then the explosion. The aftermath is where the plot really gets interesting though. Raul appointing Kareina to investigate the bombing? That's a genuine twist. It's not just protection, it's power—and he's giving her both. The nobles' shock is palpable, and it sets up this whole investigation thread that's clearly going to matter later. Plus Marquis Zook getting exiled for saying a few words during the meeting? That's a strong signal that the rules have changed. I'm curious what the author does with the Niyev investigation next, because that's clearly a loaded topic given how the nobles treated Kareina.
... Read More
There are THREE layers of explosions happening simultaneously in this chapter and I am NOT okay. First: the literal one. A bombing attack happened. The initial report written by Duke Debussy is garbage—no details on the explosives, no credible suspects. And who gets handed the investigation? Kareina. The woman everyone in the palace already thinks is cruel and inhumane. If she fails, she fails publicly. If she succeeds, she gains power she never had. That's not a gift; that's a loaded gun pointed at her feet. Second: the political one. Duke Debussy's entire worldview just cracked. He spent years treating Evelyn as his leverage in the palace, and now the Emperor is actively empowering the Empress over his own daughter's family. The text says it plainly: "Those who aligned themselves with the Debussy ducal family will shed tears of blood." The Duke himself is grinding his teeth in a corridor like some kind of villain origin story. But here's what scares me—he's not wrong to be afraid. If Raul regains his memory and decides he actually DOES care about Kareina, the Debussy faction goes from powerful to destroyed overnight. Third and honestly the one keeping me up at night: Raul's amnesia. Is it real or manufactured? The text gives us ZERO answers, only questions. Every time he looks at Kareina with regret, every time he defends her in council—it could be genuine reconnection or it could be performance. And Raul himself seems uncertain. The chief chamberlain was so terrified of saying the wrong thing he just shut up. That silence speaks volumes. When memory is weaponized, everyone becomes a suspect, including the man sitting on the throne.
... Read More
There's this incredible symbolism running through this entire section that I think a lot of readers might miss on a first pass, and I want to really dig into it because it's what elevates this from a standard romance to something with actual depth. Let's talk about the mariposa flower first. It appears at a crucial moment—when Kareina's emotional walls crack ever so slightly. The name itself means butterfly in Spanish, which is significant because butterflies represent transformation. Kareina is literally in a state of transformation throughout this section: she goes from refusing to engage with Raul to sitting beside him working, from cold and distant to showing flashes of warmth. The flower is the external trigger for an internal change she didn't know she was capable of. Then there's the contrast between the flowers and the documents. Raul sends both—flowers for beauty, documents for purpose. The flowers go unsmiled-at but kept on a shelf. The documents are DEVOURD. This tells us everything about Kareina's inner world. She doesn't need romance; she needs agency. She needs to matter beyond being the Empress consort. "To her, who had nothing but the title of Her Majesty the Empress, there was also no one to kindly deliver news of her homeland." This line hits different every time. The entire imperial court treats her as a symbol—a Niyev-born body to legitimise the political union—but nobody sees HER. The flowers are pretty but empty gestures. The documents about Niyev? Those are the first time anyone treats her as someone with knowledge, with expertise, with VALUE. And the imperial palace itself functions as a kind of golden cage throughout. High walls, lofty positions, beautiful but isolating. Kareina is imprisoned by her status, and the only window out is Niyev. Raul becomes the person who holds the key—not because he's freeing her, but because he's the first one who actually opened a door instead of just admiring the bars.
... Read More
I need to talk about the mariposa scene because I literally cannot get over it. So Kareina is basically a statue for most of the novel—cold, distant, treating Raul like furniture—and then she SMELLS the mariposa and suddenly there's this sweet smile on her face. This tiny, faint thing that seems about to disappear. And Raul notices it. He notices EVERYTHING about her. And it destroys him a little because he realizes he's never seen her smile like that before, and it has nothing to do with him. "Though it was a faint smile that seemed about to disappear, Raul had to suppress the impulse to lift her up and head to the bedroom." Like. The man is fighting a war between desire and respect in ONE SENTENCE and I am deceased. But the moment that actually broke me was later when Kareina says "thank you for the gift" after receiving those Niyev documents. Everyone in the room knows what that thanks is really about. It's not about the flowers or the necklace—it's about being SEEEN. For the first time, someone recognized what she actually needed instead of just using her as a political prop. "Kareina longed for Niyev." Two years in this palace and the only thing that makes her alive is the chance to help her homeland. And Raul, this guy who apparently did terrible things before losing his memory, is the one who gives it to her. That's the most complicated emotional situation and I love it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Evelyn first because WOW. This woman is unhinged in the most fascinating way. She shows up uninvited, sits down, orders tea, then when food arrives—raw salmon, no less—she pushes it away with what she pretends is an apology about health issues. But then Kareina just PICKS IT UP AND EATS IT. Not out of malice, not even really thoughtfully. Almost like a child wanting to prove a point. That moment where she smiled gently after eating the rejected food? Chilling. The text literally says: "As the firm salmon and sweet-tangy sauce spread throughout her mouth, her mood improved slightly." She didn't even process it consciously, did she? It was instinct. She won that round without standing up. And Evelyn's line—"Especially... in bed."—that wasn't awkward. That was a deliberate strike. She knew exactly what she was doing. But here's the thing that caught me: Kareina's reaction wasn't anger. Her actual thought was imagining Evelyn being carried out over her shoulder. That's not revenge; that's comedy. That tells me Kareina isn't threatened in the way people expect. She's not playing the wounded wife. She's playing something else entirely. Then there's Raul, who apparently forgot everything except how to look at Kareina like she's the sun. "He had held her hand for quite a while... watched her retreating figure until the end. Regret dripped so obviously from that unnecessarily handsome face." Duke Debussy can't understand why Kareina is playing along if she doesn't actually love him. But maybe she doesn't need to love him. Maybe she just needs him alive and dependent on her, and right now that's enough.
... Read More
The opening scene is so deliberately slow it almost felt like a meditation at first. Kareina standing outside looking at spring leaves while a rude servant delivers terrible news. Just gentle nature imagery and a mundane announcement that slowly builds dread. The author could have thrown us straight into drama but chose to let us breathe first, to establish that for all the chaos coming, Kareina maintains an extraordinary composure. Then the servant drops the bomb that the emperor has awakened and the pacing shifts completely. Each question the maids ask moves the story forward faster. How is his body? Did they catch the bomber? And then that final beat where the servant stops mid-sentence and the room goes silent. That is masterful tension control. The reader is hanging on every word right along with Kareina. I want to specifically call out the underground dungeon memory sequence. Just a few sentences of sensory detail and suddenly we understand everything about why Kareina is afraid. The rusted bars, the dripping ceiling, the cold floor rising through her skin. No exposition needed. The author trusts us to connect those dots. And the structure around the wedding flashback works on two levels. It explains how we got here while simultaneously showing the depth of Kareina's isolation. By the time we return to the present and Raul enters her chambers, we understand exactly how vulnerable she truly is and how dangerous this encounter might become. The author never lets the reader relax once the real confrontation begins.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is so sharp I cut myself reading it. Like, actual cutting. Every sentence has a second meaning layered underneath and the characters know it. Evelyn's got this particular brand of venom disguised as concern. "If it's too difficult, please persuade him well and send him to me. I'm used to accommodating his moods." She's not offering help. She's drawing a line in the floor and saying 'stay on your side.' The way she trails off at "especially... in bed" is pure calculated cruelty—she doesn't finish the thought because she doesn't need to. Kareina already knows what she means and so does everyone listening. But Kareina's responses? Dead calm. "It's natural for an Empress to assist His Majesty the Emperor. You don't need to worry so kindly." That "so kindly" at the end—she's not saying Evelyn isn't kind. She's saying the kindness is excessive, performative, suspicious. One word does so much work. Then there's the casual brutality of the narrator's voice describing Raul: "whatever they were discussing. Then when the Empress left, he even watched her retreating figure until the end." The narrator doesn't even pretend this is normal behavior. It's stated as fact, plain and simple, and that's what makes it hit harder. Ginny's lines provide relief but they're also dangerous—she almost slips and reveals she used to think Kareina was cruel before realizing her own bias. The author uses her voice to show how easily opinions shift when you have nothing to protect them. "People could change easily." That line from Kareina's internal monologue isn't just about Ginny. It's about everyone in this palace, including herself.
... Read More
Let me just say this is one of those moments where the entire emotional architecture of a story holds its breath and then collapses. The pregnancy reveal isn't just a dramatic beat—it's a masterclass in structural tension. Kareina arrives at this dinner already burdened, already aware that Evelyn had the audacity to show up uninvited. And then Raul—oh Raul—forces the issue by making Evelyn stay. The author builds this suffocating three-way dynamic where every utensil clink and every sip of water becomes an act of violence. What's brilliant about the plot construction here is the flashback insertion. Right after Kareina breaks down in the corridor and yanks off that necklace, we're plunged into the past—four years prior, war-torn Niyev, a brother who's clearly on something, and the moment Kareina became a hostage in the country whose emperor she now serves. This isn't just exposition dump; it's a deliberate structural choice that reframes everything we just witnessed. The Raul standing in front of her in the corridor isn't just any emperor—he's her captor. The power dynamic she's struggling with? It's not merely romantic betrayal. It's captivity. And Evelyn? She's not a casual mistress sneaking into a room. She's a political operator who dressed for a ballroom, planted her announcement like a landmine, and watched the Empress's entire world crack. The salmon salad detail—Kareina's own bitter realization that she should've seen it coming—shows the author trusts readers to connect dots. Brilliant.
... Read More
Okay so this section completely threw me for a loop and I need to talk about it because WOW. Raul has been this cold, distant, practically hostile emperor toward Kareina for literally the entire story so far, and then BAM—chapter 47-54 delivers the most unhinged scene where he appears in some kind of fugue state and basically claims her like he's been dreaming about it. And here's the thing that's got me obsessing: he falls ASLEEP mid-intimacy. Like, he has this violent, passionate encounter and then just collapses into regular breathing like he's exhausted from the effort of being someone else for five minutes. And then he doesn't REMEMBER it the next day. Kareina is sitting there trying to process whether she's crazy or whether the man who hated her has suddenly become... what? Something else? The plot is absolutely ratcheting up the tension here. On the subplot front, the Niyev investigation is crawling along with zero solid leads—explosives that apparently exist but can't be found, witnesses who only confirm what they should have seen. Meanwhile there's this SHADOWY figure in a black cloak watching Kareina from across the lake, and she feels this inexplicable familiarity that makes her skin crawl. Is it connected to Nox Atra? To the dark mage disappearance Raul keeps asking about? To something in her past she doesn't even remember? I'm also dying to know about this former version of Raul—the one who looked at her like he wanted to devour her but then spoke with this cracked, broken voice saying "Even if you hate it, endure it. Because it's a dream." That line hit me like a truck. What dream is he talking about? Whose dream? And why does Kareina instinctively try to manipulate him by telling HIM it's a dream so she can escape? She's clearly been studying him this whole time, learning how to survive him.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront—I have never felt so conflicted about a male lead in my life. Every time Raul does something decent, the text immediately undercuts it with this flashback to how terrible his past self was. Like, bro, you apologized and protected her AND you're still writing a paragraph about how your previous self would've let her be humiliated? Can't you just sit with a good moment? But that's exactly what makes these interactions feel real. Raul isn't a smooth operator. When Kareina thanks him and says maybe they can get along, he literally just blinks and can't form a proper response. His head is ‘tangled,' as the text puts it. And then she leaves so fast. The most emotionally honest scene in the entire chapter is two people who genuinely don't know what to do with each other, fumbling around like teenagers, and somehow that's more romantic than any grand declaration ever could be. Kareina's arc in this chapter is equally compelling. She starts off quietly enduring abuse from the nobles—not fighting back, not even reacting visibly. But then she says the thing that surprised me: ‘Perhaps I think we might be able to get along. Your Majesty is a good person.' This isn't flattery. It's careful, measured, almost clinical observation. She's reassessing him based on evidence, not emotion. And that's significant because it means she's actually engaging with the possibility of trust, which is a huge deal for someone who's been betrayed so many times. The Duke Debussy dynamic is also fascinating. He's completely silent today. Normally he'd be the first to suggest Kareina is infertile or keeping a Niyev man hidden. His silence reads as either fear or calculation, and I'm leaning toward calculation. He's playing the long game, and his relationship with his daughter Evelyn as a bargaining chip is starting to look more like a liability than an asset.
... Read More
So the chapter opens with Raul piecing together his past through documents, right? And at first I thought, okay, exposition dump, let me just power through this. But the author is actually doing something clever here — they're using information as a slow drip instead of a fire hose. Each detail lands like a stone in still water. The structural pivot happens when the flowery gesture arrives. Up until that point, we're in cold political territory: succession, marriage as policy, historical grudges. Then suddenly — flowers. And the entire temperature of the scene shifts. What follows is this incredibly intimate sequence where Raul visits Kareina's chambers, hands her a single flower, makes a joke about thorns, and the camera gets so close you can hear both of them breathing. And then — boom — the narrative time jump. We go from eighteen to twenty-two in a few devastating paragraphs, and suddenly all that warmth from the earlier scene is reframed as tragic irony. The reader is sitting there going "wait, she fell in love with him back then and now she's spent four years hating him?" And that structural choice? Chef's kiss. It recontextualizes every warm moment we just experienced and turns it into something aching. The chapter ends on this almost comically perfect note with Raul clearly overstaying his welcome and Kareina trying to politely dismiss him while her heart is probably doing parkour. The pacing here is impeccable — it knows exactly when to linger and when to cut hard. No scene drags, no transition feels rushed. Just clean, deliberate storytelling that respects the reader's intelligence.
... Read More
There is a moment—just one moment—where Raul sweeps Kareina's hair behind her ear in front of the entire noble council, and the text describes it in such casual detail that it hits you like a physical blow. ‘The Emperor's gaze and attitude toward her had also subtly changed from before.' Subtly. That's the author being modest. The entire room notices. The whispered conversations confirm it. And Raul himself barely registers that he did it. This whole chapter is built on emotional micro-expressions. Kareina lifting her glass with a cold expression and taking a sip of water while people systematically tear apart her entire identity. Raul watching this and feeling ‘fire rising from his core.' The way his hand grips hers in the corridor—not gentle, not rough, just desperate. And then Kareina's response: ‘I'm fine. Your Majesty.' The distance in those three words is devastating. But then the turn. Kareina saying she looks forward to working with him. A gentle smile. The gloom lifting instantly. And Raul, unable to respond properly, just standing there as she walks away. This is the kind of romantic tension that comes from two people who keep almost reaching each other but never quite connect. Every gesture is slightly misaligned, every word slightly delayed, and yet the emotional current between them is unmistakable. The most tender line in the chapter might also be the most heartbreaking: ‘Then and now. The ladies-in-waiting who should have protected the Empress weren't by her side, and the husband who should have protected his wife only made her hear insults to her face.' Raul's internal monologue here is pure self-loathing, and it's clear he's mourning the version of himself that let this happen. That's not a romance novel trope—that's a man actually confronting his failures.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or