The Tale of the Nation That Banished the Saint - Reviews

The Tale of the Nation That Banished the Saint
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about how THIS author handles warfare, because holy shit, the pacing is absolutely relentless. We go from crushing a 600-strong vanguard with 6,200 troops, to burning noble mansions, to besieging a fortress, to the rebellion toppling an entire noble house, to a full-scale battle against 15,000 peasants—all within these eight chapters. There's no filler. No breathing room. Every scene pushes the conflict forward. The coolest twist by far? Zopondort getting taken down by the very peasant army he was trying to suppress. The protagonist is literally sitting there preparing for a showdown and gets a messenger bird with news that the big bad is dead. And her reaction—"Seriously, that guy..."—this brief moment of genuine surprise, almost like she's mildly impressed that someone else finished what she was about to. That's such a human beat in the middle of all this political maneuvering. Then Robdo emerges and it's like history repeating itself. Peasant army overthrows a tyrannical lord and immediately declares themselves king, slapping 50% taxes on everyone. Of course. The cycle continues. But the protagonist doesn't just let it happen—she KILLS HIS MESSENGER to provoke him into attacking. That's not just smart tactics, that's psychological warfare. She's playing 4D chess while everyone else is checkers. And the battle sequence at the fortress—Orvos holding the line while she flanks with cavalry, splitting their forces, then hitting them from behind when they're already exhausted from defending—that's proper military fiction. The author understands terrain, supply lines, morale, timing. The repeated cavalry charges breaking peasant morale is a brilliant touch because it shows that raw numbers mean nothing against coordinated violence.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this chapter sequence is a masterclass in pacing. The author doesn't just throw battles at you; they make you FEEL the clock ticking. Remember when that messenger bird arrives from the east? That tiny detail gave me actual chills. One second we're calmly discussing strategy over a horse rest break, and the next—POW—Zopondort's advance party is already at Count Alderan's doors. No warning shot, no dramatic buildup, just a bird dropping news that flips the entire board. And the military strategy layers! I love how the author plays with the numbers game. Ten thousand enemies, twenty-five thousand royal troops—sounds like an easy win on paper, right? But then you read between the lines and realize the kingdom's finances are crumbling everywhere, and every move comes with a brutal cost. The King wants to confront Zopondort head-on, but thenobles are weighing casualties against political fallout. It's not just "good guys vs bad guys"—it's a messy web where everyone's making calculated decisions and nobody has all the information. The scene where Ares realizes he has to secure Count Alderan before Zopondort does—that's the kind of plot turn that makes you slam the book shut and immediately open it again. Because up until that moment, you thought the priority was the main army confrontation, and suddenly the real battleground shifts to a smaller castle with a thousand troops. Brilliant misdirection. Also, Repolins! What a villain setup. Eight son of a mid-ranking noble, desperate to make a name for himself, smart enough to follow orders but ambitious enough to want more. He's not evil for evil's sake—he's the kind of guy who genuinely believes he deserves more, and that makes him way scarier than any cartoon antagonist.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this—the moment Roselia used Saint's Wish to get herself expelled, I literally slapped my thigh. That was peak "I refuse to accept this narrative" energy. She didn't just sit there and follow the script, she actively weaponized the system against itself. Five thousand points? She spent them like paper money because apparently when your entire existence is a transmigration survival situation, you stop worrying about saving currency and start worrying about meeting your destined love interest. But here's what really got me: the plot tried to bend her and it bent right back. The story wants her expelled, Dalforn wants her controlled, Zopondot wants to cut his losses—and somehow every single one of their schemes collides in the most delicious way. The fake saint reveal wasn't even the main twist; the real twist is that Roselia's will is stronger than the narrative itself. She keeps rerolling fate like a stubborn player who refuses to let the game end the way it's supposed to. And then Episode 7 flips everything. Dalforn isn't just some background politician—he's been running this whole operation for two years. He groomed Zopondot, he placed the fake saint, he basically constructed the entire saint system like a puppet show. But then Roselia appears and derails it. The monsters attacking the carriage? Was that him or something else? Because if she survived that and made it to Pirenzol, the entire power structure he built is now hostage to a girl who explicitly does not want to play by his rules. This isn't just "reincarnated into a novel and change the plot" anymore. This is a war between authorial intent and character autonomy, and honestly? Roselia is winning.
... Read More
Okay, I need to process what happened during that peasant army assault and I'm not sure I'm done with it. The protagonist's army is outnumbered 15,000 to however many thousands they have, and the peasants keep coming. Not because they're winning, not because they have a chance, but because—here's the detail that genuinely chilled me—"Peasants are accustomed to collective action, so they will go where ordered. Collective action easily spreads madness among them. A wave of people infected with madness, forgetting their fear, rushes forward. Defending soldiers must respond desperately." This is not a romanticized peasant uprising. This is something far more disturbing. The author isn't glorifying or condemning—just observing, almost clinically, the way individual human beings dissolve into a collective force that has忘记了自己是谁. These people joined believing they could defeat a kingdom. They watched their friends get cut down by cavalry charges and spears, and still they keep coming. Not from bravery. From something deeper and more dangerous. And the protagonist's emotional response? Nothing. Or rather—calm recognition. She understands exactly what she's facing. There's no panic, no moral wrestling. Just a cold assessment: break their momentum, split their forces, attack from behind. But the execution scene later—the ten heads falling, the crowd's mixed reactions—there's something there I can't quite name. Is it remorse? No. Is it weight? Maybe. The narrator says "I feel overwhelmed by the prospect of what's to come." Not guilt. Overwhelmed. Like they see the machinery of power they're now part of, and the machinery doesn't stop. Then the sky opens up with a bird and dragon fighting. And for the first time, the protagonist feels small. Crushed. Finally, someone or something bigger than them exists. Honestly? I kind of wanted them to feel that way all along.
... Read More
Let me just say—the pacing in this batch is absolutely ruthless and I respect it. Chapter 4 starts almost slapstick. Reincarnation backstory, complaining about a thoughtless goddess, enduring etiquette lessons, counting down the days until the expulsion scene. It's light, it's comedic, it's "isekai protagonist vibes." You settle in, you think you know the genre, you relax. Then Chapter 5 pivots. The expulsion happens—but wrong. The verification test happens. Zopondot betrays her mid-scene like a snake shedding skin. The engagement shifts from Roselia to Sophie. The tone cracks open and suddenly it's not funny anymore. Roselia gets restrained, dragged away like criminal waste, and the reader is left gasping. Chapter 6 compounds the damage. Prison conditions. Monster attack. The carriage reversing direction. Every beat stripping away her agency further. And then—the wish. Five thousand points. Desperation made manifest in a skill activation. The pacing here is suffocating in the best way. Short paragraphs. Staccato thoughts. Each sentence narrowing the gap between her and total hopelessness. Then Chapter 7 drops the camera entirely. We're no longer in Roselia's head—we're watching from Dalforn's perspective, standing at a border fortress, receiving reports like a general surveying a battlefield he engineered. The structural shift is jarring because it's intentional. The author is telling us: this story was never just about a girl trying to get home. It's about the man who built the road she's walking on. Each chapter ends on a note that makes the next one unavoidable. No breathers. No mercy.
... Read More
I need to talk about the sensory texture of this novel because it really nailed something. The opening chapter has Ares sitting in his chamber, playing some chess-like board game with tea, and the maids are immaculate. You can literally feel the palace atmosphere—quiet luxury, controlled environment, this kid has everything except freedom. And then Zenias busts in and suddenly you're in the corridor walking and hearing about court politics. The transitions between scenes are so smooth it's like watching a period drama. The guard training scene in Episode 2 with Ristine—wooden swords CLANGING in the garden, the morning light, the physicality of it—this is a boy who could be living like a spoiled prince but chooses to SWEAT instead. That single image of him training tells you everything about his character without any internal monologue. And the birthday party setup in Episode 3 is cinematic. You've got the guests filing in, the tension building, then Zopondote arriving LATE with that villain aura practically radiating off him, Roselia all dressed up in expensive but gauche jewelry, and then Dalforne bringing out this small, unkempt girl who looks like she walked in from the streets but somehow commands more dignity than everyone else in the room. The contrast between Roselia's luxury and Sophie's neat simplicity is visual storytelling at its finest. The world itself feels massive too—68 countries, monster threats managed by saintesses, border defenses held by powerful nobles, the eastern region ruled by a corrupt but wealthy duke. It's not just a backdrop; it's a machine and Ares is trying to understand every gear before it crushes him. Feels alive. Truly.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing—this setup is basically a reverse isekai trap card and I am HERE FOR IT. The protagonist gets told he's reincarnated into a world modeled after a novel he doesn't actually remember reading, and then BAM, two chapters in we learn he's the hated prince who banishes the saintess and his country goes to ruin? Talk about starting your new life with a death sentence attached to it. But the best moment has to be Episode 3, when Dalforne pulls up Sophie like a plot twist from hell. Roselia is there all primped in expensive clothes with her corrupt Duke daddy, smug as anything—and then this scruffy little girl steps out looking CLEAN and NEAT despite her modest clothes? The narration literally says "upon closer inspection." That detail hit me so hard because it flips every expectation we had. We thought Roselia was the real saintess, right? Wrong. Or wait—the novel said Roselia is the saintess who gets banished... but what if this world version is DIFFERENT? "Is this the result of those repairs?" That line from Ares basically summarizes the entire narrative tension of the series. The goddess Meldo supposedly fixed the world because it became unstable, and now the plot might be DIVERTING from what Ares remembered. What if—what if he can actually AVOID the ruin? What if he doesn't have to exile anyone? His proposal to test the saintesses by having Roselia stop using her powers for a few years is genius because it's the kind of political maneuver that would WORK in a medieval setting where direct magical testing is legally restricted. But also, the fact that Dalforne visibly PALES at this suggestion tells me everything about how complicated this is going to get. The plot is layered like an onion and I'm already obsessed.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for Zenias though because her voice is IMMACULATE. This woman walks in on Ares about to kiss his maid and immediately goes into full head-maid mode: "As I mentioned before, if you show too much favoritism towards Lilim, she may be transferred—especially if it involves a prince's favoritism, it becomes a political matter." She's stern, she's professional, she's absolutely not amused—and the fact that Ares still reaches out and TOUCHES HER BUTTOCKS right after this serious conversation? "Blushing, Zenias stammers, unable to answer immediately. Touching her butt, she's quite cute in her reaction." This dynamic is Chef's Kiss. She's the responsible adult in the room and he's a chaotic prince who treats boundaries like suggestions, but there's clearly deep trust underneath it all. She reports to him but also CORRECTS him. That's a relationship. And Dalforne's voice is perfectly calibrated too. Every sentence comes out measured and precise: "Lord Dalforne is at the forefront of national politics—a capable individual. He has never engaged in any misconduct, a sincere person highly trusted by His Majesty the King." The narration itself describes him this way, and then his dialogue matches—he's formal, thorough, almost bureaucratic in his delivery. When he exposes the saintess situation, he doesn't dramatize it. He just lays out the facts and lets the weight speak for itself. Zopondote's panic in Episode 3 is comedy gold: "I-I never lied, at, at least not… t-that's irrelevant! Shut up! Ah, n-no, I mean… Shut up!" The stuttering, the self-interruptions, the desperate pivoting—it's a man whose entire worldview is crumbling in real time. Ares's internal voice is dry, almost detached, which makes the moments when he's genuinely surprised or concerned hit harder. The narration rarely overacts, and that restraint makes the emotional beats land so much better.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this—most isekai novels give the MC a bunch of girls who exist purely to fawn over him and look pretty. That's not what we've got here. The women around Ares all have actual roles. Leila and Lienne are his personal guards, yeah, but even their scolding about him riding too far forward shows they genuinely care whether he lives or dies. Then you've got Miranda and Miliza as warriors, Sheen as the archer, Christine running the military intel side, Rosalia working on ancient texts and agriculture, and Zenias as head maid—this isn't a decorative cast, it's a functioning cabinet of specialists. What I find most interesting is how Ares relates to them. He's not playing some romantic game here. From the moment he realized at ten years old that he'd reincarnated as the villain prince, he started building this network through trial and error. Five years of deliberate effort. And Rosalia? She fled her stifling noble home—she's not here because he swept her off her feet, she's here because she chose this over that life. The dynamic between Ares and his father is also quietly devastating. The king indirectly told him to stay back from the front lines, and Ares still charges into battle anyway. Not rebellion, exactly, but a kind of stubborn love—he knows the kingdom is falling apart without the Saint's protection, and he won't hide while his people suffer. When Rosalia deadpans 'isn't dealing with a rebellion the king's job?' and he just... agrees for a second before deciding to do it anyway, that's a character moment that says everything about him. And the women all push back. Unanimously. 'But that takes time and money.' 'But for the prince himself to take such risks—' They're not props, they're people with genuine stakes in whether he survives. That tension between his self-sacrifice and their fear for him—that's the real relationship drama here.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second. The entire political situation in this book rests on a knife's edge, and the author never lets you forget it. Count Alderan has at most a THOUSAND troops. Zopondort's advance party has a thousand already surrounding his mansion. Two hundred holding the fortress, eight hundred in reserve. And Alderan is refusing to surrender anyway. Do you know what that tells you about this man? He's not surrendering because he's brave—he's surrendering because he has exactly zero options left. Every choice leads to devastation, and he's choosing to die on his feet rather than live as a traitor. Then Ares shows up with his cavalry and basically says "not today" and charges straight into enemy territory like it's nothing. Because here's the thing about stakes—they're not just about whether the kingdom wins or loses. They're about whether six thousand two hundred people live or die. Whether neighboring lords bet on the wrong horse and get crushed. Whether peasants rebel against their own lord and create chaos that spreads beyond anyone's control. The rebellion within Zopondort's own territory! That's the beautiful irony—the guy trying to overthrow the king can't even keep his own people from rising up against him. And yet Ares explicitly rules out assassination: "No assassination. We need a proper stage for them to take responsibility for this." He's building a case, not just winning a war. He's playing long games while everyone else is fighting short ones. But what gets me is the sheer INTIMACY of the conflict. This isn't some grand epic with armies clashing on horizons. It's a prince riding hard through hostile territory with a handful of guards, encountering enemy patrols on country roads, charging into a column of marching soldiers with lances ready. The stakes are existential for the kingdom, but they play out in moments that feel terrifyingly personal—like the moment Repolins realizes Ares is the one attacking him and smiles because he finally understands the trap.
... Read More
There's a question running through these chapters that I can't shake: what makes someone a saint? Roselia has the power. She can heal, create barriers, drive away monsters. She genuinely possesses the goddess's blessing. But the kingdom decides she's a fraud because she wore pretty clothes. Zopondot brought her but refuses to stand by her when it matters. The prince expels her based on aesthetics. The system doesn't care about her actual abilities—it cares about compliance, about appearance, about whether she fits the narrative they've written for her. Meanwhile, Sophie has... nothing shown yet. No demonstrated power, no interiority, just curly hair and a performance of modesty. She's the saint because someone decided she should be. She's the one Dalforn cultivated, shaped, and placed where she would do the most good for his plans. Her sanctity is manufactured, not earned. The recurring symbol here is the wish skill itself. Roselia can literally rewrite reality to fulfill her desires—but every wish costs sacred points, which are essentially the kingdom's life force. She's been feeding a nation with power she didn't ask for, and now she has to spend that same power to escape. The saint's gift is both her chains and her only weapon. And Gaia—the Earth Mother Goddess—presides over all of this silent and absent. Her blessings are harvested by corrupt officials, her saints are discarded for fashion choices, her name is invoked to justify exile instead of justice. The theme is accumulating: institutions claim divine authority while serving human ambition, and the truly holy—Roselia's compassion, her loyalty, her stubborn hope—gets punished for it. The starving people in a blessed land. That image haunts me. A saint's power flows to the rulers, not the ruled. The system works exactly as designed—it's just that the design benefits everyone except the people it was meant to protect.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the agriculture. Like, on the surface this is a political fantasy about succession, rebellion, and a expelled saint. But the thing that ties every chapter together is the land itself. Without the Saint's protection, crops fail. Monsters appear. People starve. And Ares is out there literally rewriting how farming works—gathering ancient techniques, importing knowledge from neighboring countries, training farmers—because he knows the Saint isn't coming back and the seal on the god of destruction is getting worse. The Land of Death is such a loaded image. A region where nothing grows at all, caused by a sealed god of destruction. And the Saints? They're basically living band-aids on a wound in the world itself. Roselia was the real one, expelled by people who didn't understand what they had, and now three years later the kingdom is paying for that mistake in blood and famine. Zopondot weaponizes this—he demands compensation for the 'loss' of the Saint while forgetting he helped expel her. That's not just character hypocrisy, that's the book holding up a mirror to how societies blame victims for systemic failures. The monster exterminations tie into this too. Every battle Ares fights isn't just about safety—it's about buying time. Time for his agricultural reforms to take root. Time for the kingdom to adapt to a world without a Saint. He's racing against something invisible and existential, not just against Zopondot's army. The cavalry with 'zero defense' he specifically chose? That's not a aesthetic preference—that's a man who has bet everything on speed and offense because defense won't save you when the ground itself is turning against you. The sealed god of destruction looming in the background makes every political maneuver feel like it's happening on a ticking clock. Brilliant layering.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or