The Night My First Love Ended - Reviews

The Night My First Love Ended
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
OK I need to process what happened here because my chest actually hurts. Lisette and Leon's relationship is built on this foundation of promise and abandonment that I'm still not over. Think about it—three years ago, he swore he'd come back. He swore he'd protect her with his life. And she? She believed him so completely that she spent every single day after he left waiting, writing letters she'd never send, counting down to a reunion that would never happen the way she imagined. But Leon—Leon came back and became someone else. Not a villain, not a jerk, just... a stranger wearing the face of the boy who once held her hand. The way he looks at her now, those cold eyes hiding behind wind-blown hair, it's like he's a completely different person. Or maybe the real Leon was always there and she just never saw him. What breaks me is the moment by moment evolution of their dynamic. First there's the raw awkwardness—he's half-naked, she's mortified, and there's this tiny vulnerability where he covers himself with a towel and his ears go red. For a split second, you can almost see the old Leon peeking through. Then the wolf comes. And suddenly he's her protector again, pulling her close, whispering in her ear, holding the door against the beast. It's intimate in the most desperate way possible. And then—then—he lets her go. The physical distance he creates afterwards is so telling. He steps back, changes his tone, becomes formally polite. Every action refuses her. He's building a wall, brick by brick, and she's standing on the other side watching it rise. When she asks herself why she can't even find the courage to ask him why he's like this now, that's the real tragedy. She knows the answer already. He doesn't need her anymore. And the nanny scene at the end? I'm still replaying that in my head. Lisette slamming the door in her caretaker's face—not out of anger, but because if she looks at anyone right now she'll crumble. She can't pretend. Not even for a second.
... Read More
"[A bird in a cage, I suppose you thought it could never happen to you.]" — that opening line from the figurine. Right there. That IS the theme of this entire novel compressed into one sentence. The idea that some things are inevitable. That you can't outrun your own choices. Lisette literally thought the curse could never happen to HER after what happened three years ago. And now? Here we are. But the real symbol that destroyed me is the figurine itself. An angel figurine that's actually a demon. She treasured it for years — a gift from Leon as a child, something she kept close to her heart, called a wish-granting angel. The person she loved gave it to her, and inside it lives something that will force her to confront exactly what she's been running from. How perfect. How absolutely cruel and beautiful. And the curse itself — the marks spreading across her body, turning her dream into something that might consume her if she doesn't act — it's not just a plot device. It's physical manifestation of her guilt. Three years of carrying this weight, pushing Leon away, thinking she's protecting him, and meanwhile the curse has been BUILT into her body this whole time. Every mark is a choice she made. Every wound is a moment she ran instead of staying. The fog-covered forest keeps coming back to me too. She saw the marks on another person — someone who suffered because of the same curse. She thought she was the only one, but she wasn't. The idea that her selfishness hurt someone else, that she dragged an innocent person into her ruin alongside her... that's the guilt that's actually destroying her, not the curse itself. The curse is just punishment. The guilt is the real story. And then the ending — the blurred line between dream and reality. She's touching herself, waking up slick and desperate, and her mind keeps going to Leon's voice, his touch. The curse is making her body want exactly what her mind is terrified of. She says [He was a demon] but her body doesn't believe that. The whole novel is built on this tension between what she THINKS she wants (to stay away from Leon, to protect him) and what her body/knows/deep down actually wants. And the figurine knows it. The figurine just said it outright: [Realize your desire. And you will be free from the curse.]
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are INSANE and I need everyone to understand what just happened. On the surface level, Lisette is cursed. There's a physical consequence — marks on her body, dreams that are making her body react in ways she can't control, waking up every night in a state she can't explain. She's been trying to ignore it for four days, coping by touching herself, but it's not working. The curse is escalating. She told herself [It's only a dream] and now she's admitting to herself it might not be harmless. But the REAL stakes are the relationship with Leon. She's spent THREE YEARS running from him. Three years of building walls, of telling herself she's protecting him by staying away, of convincing herself that their past doesn't matter. And now the ONLY WAY to break the curse — THE ONLY OPTION — is to go to HIM. To spend a night with him. The one person she's been avoiding. The one person she thinks will only get hurt if she gets close. And the demon knows this. The demon is literally saying [He's a man too, so he's probably hoping for it deep down...] and Lisette is FURIOUS about it because it's true. She can feel it in her body. Every night she's waking up desperate for exactly what she's been running from. But here's what makes the conflict so much worse — there's NO ONE TO TELL. The nanny notices something's wrong but Lisette can't say anything. The rumors at the manor are getting wilder by the day. Baron Tarmen is arriving in one week. She has a BETROTHED person coming and she needs to keep her distance from Leon but her BODY won't let her. The external pressure is mounting while the internal conflict is eating her alive. And the most terrifying part? If she does go to Leon, if she spends that night with him, [once it's done, there was no going back to what they had been before]. Whatever happens, the three years of separation, the careful distance she's maintained, the way she's been protecting him by staying away — it all ends. Either the curse breaks and they're forced to confront everything, or something worse happens. There is no safe option. Every path forward destroys something. I cannot handle this.
... Read More
Okay so the Leon reveal in Chapter 7 needs to be discussed because wow. Three years. Three entire years she's been waiting for him, clutching his clothes to fall asleep, dreaming about his return—and what does she get? He literally PHYSICALLY PULLS AWAY from her hug in front of everyone. Like, he takes her wrist and UNWINDS her arms from around him. And his eyes? "Nothing of who he had been three years ago remained." That description gave me chills. The author paints his gaze as this completely alien thing—"razor-edged. Like those of a predator." A predator. Her Leon was the gentlest person she knew. Now he looks at her like she's prey, like she's a threat. And the reason?? "There are many eyes watching." That's it. He doesn't even try to explain himself properly. He doesn't say "I'm sorry, I can't do this here" or anything that would give her a sliver of hope that tomorrow might be different. He just... shuts the door in her face. What really wrecked me was the contrast. Three years ago she sent her brother to war as a sacrifice for the family, and he came back changed. But Leon? Leon went to war and came back as someone else entirely. He didn't just lose his warmth—he lost whatever bond they had. And Lisette? She stood there frozen, unable to process it, and had to be physically led away by Alexander like she couldn't even stand on her own. The family dynamic is so complicated too. Celine yelling at her to come here this instant, Theodore glaring, everyone treating her like she's made of glass, and Leon—the one person she actually wanted to see—acts like she's nobody. But then the night forest scene... he KNEW she'd come. He was waiting at the cottage. Why wouldn't he meet her openly but he lets her walk into a wolf-infested forest alone??
... Read More
"You, really." "Ha." "Fool." Three words. Three completely different tones. The de Vermoa family dialogue is so distinct I could identify it blind. Alexander's speech is clipped and impatient—he interrupts, he uses commands disguised as questions, he teases with a physicality that makes you feel like you're in the room with them. When he says "Get up," it's not a request. When he says "Sorry. I forgot about your condition," it's almost embarrassingly genuine, like he didn't plan to apologize and just blurted it out. Lisette's voice is such a contrast—she deflects with humor and sarcasm when she's uncomfortable. "So I'm a fake lady?" comes right after she's been physically manhandled down a corridor. That's not confidence; that's survival instinct through wit. And then her dialogue starts fragmenting when she's emotionally overwhelmed—"S, still, he's quite kind"—she can't even form complete sentences when talking about Leon anymore. The most striking dialogue moment has to be the angel figurine's voice. It doesn't speak like a person. It speaks like cold, absolute certainty. "Child, did no one teach you? Enter a fog-covered forest at dawn and you fall under the curse of an Incubus." No warmth, no drama—just factual devastation. The author uses formatting brilliantly here too, bracketing the figurine's dialogue to visually separate it from human speech. It's a subtle touch but it signals that something fundamentally OTHER is speaking. And Leon's silence? His dialogue consists of one muffled "Young master, Miss..." before being cut off. That restraint is powerful. What he doesn't say is doing so much heavy lifting.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this scene handles silence because honestly the dialogue here is barely there and it works so much better than any monologue could. Like, when they're both struggling with this overwhelming physical and emotional moment, what comes out of their mouths is these broken fragments—'Mi... ngh.' 'Ha.' 'Le... on.' And somehow those incomplete sounds are doing more work than any polished romantic speech ever could. The few complete lines that do exist are so perfectly calibrated too. When Leon says 'Relax' three times in different contexts—once when he touches her below, once after he pulls away covered in evidence of her arousal, once when he's about to enter her—it's not repetition, it's evolution. Each 'Relax' means something different. The first is physical guidance. The second is almost a whisper of intimacy. The third is surrender, or invitation, I can't tell which. And Lisette's voice! I love how her dialogue shifts from commanding ('Put it in, Leon.') to vulnerable ('I want to be filled with you.') in the span of two sentences. There's no transition, no hand-holding, just the raw honesty of someone who's decided to stop performing composure. The author doesn't waste words on her—she speaks sparingly but each word lands. Then there's the narrator's voice weaving through all of this, which I have to mention because it's doing something really interesting. It moves fluidly between Lisette's POV and Leon's interiority without any jarring shifts. 'So this was what it meant to feel like losing one's mind'—that line transitions from describing her state to describing his, and it works because both of them are experiencing the same thing, just from different angles. The most striking moment though is when the author just... stops. No dialogue, no internal monologue, just the image of Lisette looking up at him and saying 'Put it in.' And then the chapter ends mid-sentence with 'I want to be filled with you.' That cut-off ending! It's either going to be continued in the next chapter or it's deliberate. Either way, it left me staring at my phone for a solid ten seconds.
... Read More
There's something deeply unsettling and brilliant about how the curse in this story works as a metaphor. It's not just a magical plot device—it's a literalization of everything a woman in her position is expected to suppress. The curse makes her body react with desperate, undeniable hunger, but the real prison is the social one: she can't tell anyone, can't confide in her maid Phoebe even when she desperately wants to, because 'they may be like furniture, but the difference is they can open their mouths.' The heat that rises through her kills her appetite, makes her foggy-headed, keeps her awake at night—her own body becomes the site of her rebellion against the life plotted for her. And Leon? He's both the cure and the temptation, the embodiment of the freedom she can't have. Notice how he appears wounded, beaten, 'covered in wounds as though someone had beaten him'—he's just as trapped by this world's expectations as she is. His question to her, 'Is that something you can do? Take another man into your arms. Embrace him. Kiss him. Spend the night with him,' isn't just jealousy speaking. It's a challenge to the entire structure that demands she swallow her desire and play the part. The parasol she drops when their eyes meet? A small detail, but it symbolizes her dropped defenses, her lost protection. This story is so much deeper than a romance with a curse, and I'm obsessed with how layered it is.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter? This is the moment everything finally snaps into place, right? Because up until now we've been tracking Lisette through these dream sequences where she's reliving intimate moments with Leon, but never actually living them—always that gap between desire and action. And here, she finally decides to close it herself. She literally climbs onto his lap and takes charge. That's such a massive plot shift because for most of the story she's been reactive, waiting, haunted by visions she can't control. Now she's making things happen. What hit me hardest is the way she unties his trousers herself. 'With just a small pull downward, the trousers slid open, and his length revealed itself in full.' It's such an ordinary, domestic action—untying laces—but it carries the weight of a thousand dream-phantoms finally dissolving. She's crossing a threshold that isn't just physical but narrative. Every time before, the dream would reset or shift away. This time, nothing resets. And then there's the little detail I couldn't stop thinking about—the dried remnants from the night before still visible on him. The author doesn't shy away from the messiness of it all. This isn't some pristine, fantasy-clean version of intimacy. It's real, it's sticky, it's human. Which makes the emotional beats land even harder. But here's what I keep coming back to: when Leon says 'I gave you plenty of time to run,' and she replies 'You gave me plenty of time to run'—that callback to his own words turned back on him? That's not just a nice plot beat. That's the entire power dynamic of this relationship flipping on its head, and I need to know what happens when he realizes she's not afraid anymore.
... Read More
I need to talk about Leon's last words to her three years ago. "I will come back alive, without fail." She says "Don't get hurt" and he says "You must also stay safe, Miss." This exchange is repeated almost reverently in her memories, and it broke me a little. Because what kind of bond produces words like that? A master-servant dynamic that has clearly evolved into something far deeper, far more dangerous. And the power flip in the dream—where Leon, who always looks at her with "guileless expression," becomes this decadent, commanding figure who reduces her to trembling and tears—is honestly the most honest thing about her feelings. In the dream, she doesn't have to pretend. In the dream, she screams for him, begs for him, and when he pulls away and makes her SAY what she wants, that's when the real heartbreak lives. 'Tell me what you want, Miss.' She can't. Even in fantasy. Even when her body is betraying her so viscerally that she's dripping onto the chair and desperate for him to finish what he started—in her head, she still can't voice it. Then she wakes up and his voice calls her "Miss!" and everything collapses. The cruelty of that parallel is incredible. And don't even get me started on the mother saying "you'll do that again with that lowborn" like Leon is some shameful secret instead of the person who's been her anchor for however many years. This isn't romance. This is a cage.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how good Alexander's dialogue is in this chapter? Because the shift from the heavy, aching tension between Lisette and Leon to the scene with her brother is such a perfect tonal pivot. Alexander comes in and immediately cuts through everything with this deceptively casual energy: 'This face does all the work.' And then—he knows. He just KNOWS. Before she can even finish brushing him off, he drops 'Something happened between you and Leon' like he's commenting on the weather. The way he mirrors her own deflections back at her ('Nothing' → 'Nothing?') is chef's kiss. But what really sold me was how each character's voice is distinct. Lisette's internal monologue is frantic, breathless, full of these sharp self-interruptions—'No. The dream's voice and gaze rushed up and swallowed her whole.' Meanwhile, Leon's dialogue is sparse, almost fractured, especially after their encounter. 'You. That you are happy.' Those fragmented sentences say more than any monologue could. And Phoebe! Oh my god, Phoebe's lines are perfectly crafted—'The Baron is very, um, gentle. Gentle!' The exaggerated stuttering, the way she recites like a practiced parrot, it's hilarious but also kind of heartbreaking when you realize every servant in this house is performing. The narrative voice itself is restless and intimate, always sliding between external observation and raw internal panic, which makes every scene feel like you're trapped inside Lisette's head. That's masterful prose.
... Read More
'They were the wishes of a seven-year-old child, squeezing out the best way she could think of for everyone to be happy.' I have never felt more attacked by a single line in my entire life. Lisette's emotional journey in this passage is absolutely devastating, and I need to talk about why it lands so hard. From the very first paragraph, we're introduced to a girl who has built her entire understanding of love around sacrifice. Two wishes—the angel figurine promised two wishes—and Leon gives BOTH to her. "Your wishes are my wishes, Miss." That line alone should come with a warning label because it establishes the entire emotional foundation of their relationship: he exists to serve her happiness, and she exists to receive it. It's codependent in the most beautifully tragic way possible. Then three years pass. Three years of absence. Three years of her holding onto that figurine like a talisman against oblivion. And when she finally throws it into the fire, the physical reaction is almost biblical—her body seizes, her heart wrenches, she crumples. This isn't metaphor. The author makes it literal. Her soul is tethered to that object, and severing the tether tears something inside her. And then—the dream. Oh god, the dream. This is where the author really goes for the throat. Lisette wakes from her fever to find Leon beside her, and the sensual detail is so vivid I actually had to pause and breathe. The water on her lips, his fingers at her chin, the way he kisses her like he's drowning too—it's not just romantic, it's desperate. Every touch is tinged with the knowledge that this might not last. "Perhaps one day she would regret this choice. But not now." THAT LINE. That is the emotional core of the entire passage. She knows whatever she's doing—whatever she's choosing—might haunt her later. But the present ache is so acute that the future self doesn't matter. And then the dream ends. Leon is gone. She's alone on the floor, and the emotional whiplash is something I genuinely couldn't handle. The author makes us feel every layer: the warmth of his body, the reality of his absence, the humiliation of crying silently while everyone else goes about their morning. The family breakfast scene is where the emotional devastation deepens rather than resolves. Alexander sees through Lisette's performance—"Unlike his mother's expression, which practically beamed with pride, Lisette's lips barely managed to lift at the corners." He witnesses her smiling through agony, and his helplessness mirrors our own. But Lisette? She deflects. She tells him she's fine. She calls the stranger who wants to marry her "kind." She performs gratitude while her soul is actively being packed away to someone two weeks' ride from everything she loves. And then that voice. "I'm here. The only one who can make your desires come true." This isn't just a plot hook—it's an emotional landmine. Whatever this voice offers, it's offering exactly what Leon couldn't: permanence. Safety. The fulfillment of that seven-year-old's wish. And Lisette, broken and alone and performing happiness for a family that doesn't see her, is the most vulnerable version of herself. The romantic tension between what she wants and what she's being sold is suffocating, and I am not prepared for what comes next.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this out loud because I need to process it: Lisette is such a mess and I love her for it. Three years ago she blocked Leon's path, made a wreck of things, couldn't protect him, and now?? Now she's the reason HE'S cursed. The figurine literally says [You weren't the only human in that fog-covered forest.] and I just—my heart stopped. She thinks she's the cursed one but the marks on HER body are IDENTICAL to the ones on someone else's. She made someone else pay for her mistake. And the way she immediately tries to take all the blame again, right? She's lying on her bed, shaking her head like a drowning person, thinking [The mess I made three years ago is more than enough] and she's ready to just SUFFER ALONE instead of dragging Leon into it. That's so Lisette. That's the person who ran TO him three years ago at the last moment and then somehow still failed. Her entire arc is her trying to protect people by pushing them away and somehow making everything worse. But what got me was the ending. The part where she's waking up every night soaked and desperate, touching herself, and her mind keeps going back to LEON. His voice. His touch. And she's thinking [This dream was a nightmare, and he was a demon.] But also her body isn't having any of that. The line between dream and reality is GONE. She's literally wet just thinking about him. And what's terrifying is—she's right. She NEEDS to spend a night with him to break the curse. The very thing she's been avoiding for three years IS the only way out. The cruelty of this author is unmatched. I also need to talk about how the manor is literally gossiping about them. One day it's "Leon confessed and was rejected" and the NEXT DAY it flips to "Lisette confessed and was rejected" and Céline is losing her mind about throwing Leon out. People around them are feeding these rumors like it's entertainment. Four days of her actively avoiding him and the whole estate has built an entire narrative. I cannot—I just—I need to sit down.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or