The Greatest Astrologist - Reviews

The Greatest Astrologist
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Chu Qianli because wow. The way she shifts from anxious ('What do you want to talk about, Sister? I love chatting with beautiful sisters') to deadpan ('It's really fine not to compete') in the same breath is iconic. She's so obviously reading the room, managing everyone's expectations while secretly judging them all. But then there's this moment where she mumbles to herself about 'someone rushing to offer themselves up' and I felt that — the reluctant participant who's actually way more capable than everyone gives them credit for. And Qi Yan? She's the bridge. She notices Chu Qianli's trouble immediately and offers the out ('If you don't want to compete, then forget it'), but Chu Qianli has already made her decision. Their dynamic feels effortless, like real friendship where you can read each other's silence. Grandfather Qi is fascinating too — tolerant, perceptive, and apparently smitten with Chu Qianli enough to indulge her. Meanwhile Qi Chengliang is playing 4D chess with Master Liu's involvement and I can't tell if he's the villain or just aggressively pragmatic.
... Read More
The way this scene unfolds spatially is gorgeous. It starts in a once-empty shop that suddenly fills with men in uniform, which immediately creates a sense of claustrophobia and threat. Then they step outside and find a human barricade—a visual of entrapment. But just when it feels like they're trapped, the arrival of the family cars transforms the entire geography of the scene. Five or six vehicles roaring onto the avenue, surrounding the men in black, turning the street into a three-layer spring roll of power dynamics. I love that the author describes the limousine driver as someone Chu Qianli recognizes, which subtly tells us this world has layers of familiar authority figures. The extended limousine, Uncle Qi, the ‘cousin'—all these details enrich the Tan family's presence without info-dumping. And the contrast between the rigid, polite hostility of the men in black and the casual, almost bored dominance of the Tan family driver—‘Can you drive? If not, I can take over.'—that's worldbuilding through tone. You can feel the unspoken rules of this society: wealth and status operate like another form of cultivation power. The setting itself becomes a character, shifting from a quiet Saturday afternoon to a staged confrontation, then to a comically absurd car convoy. The final image of Chu Qianli marvelling at the fleet trailing behind them, with Tan Muxing's embarrassed sigh, perfectly encapsulates a world where ordinary life and extraordinary stakes coexist.
... Read More
I need to address the elephant in the room: He Shichen's emotional state across these chapters is genuinely heartbreaking AND hilarious at the same time. Think about it — he's a top student, completely composed, probably never had a teacher call him in for a disciplinary talk in his entire life. And then BOOM, he's sitting across from his homeroom teacher being told to go home and "talk to his parents" about Chu Qianli's superstition problem. His internal monologue says it all: "He felt trapped. He had never been called in for a talk with the teacher before." That single line crushed me. And then he walks back to class and sees Chu Qianli and Tan Muxing "chatting and laughing" — her being completely oblivious while he's internally screaming about divination rumors. The contrast is brutal. But the real emotional bomb is the Chu Qianli and Qi Yan interaction. Qi Yan is LITERALLY FLIRTING with Chu Qianli and Chu Qianli has NO IDEA. When Qi Yan says "If someone else said that, it would sound a little frivolous. But coming from you, I can still accept it…" — what a devastatingly cute moment for Qi Yan and completely confusing for Chu Qianli. And that line "But I think, in today's world, gender doesn't seem as important anymore?" after finding out Chu Qianli is a girl? CHU QIANLI. TAN MUXING. AND HE SHICHEN. ALL STUNNED IN DIFFERENT WAYS. He Shichen's reaction of completely losing it while the others are just bewildered says everything about his emotional investment in this situation.
... Read More
Okay so this entire sequence is just... chef's kiss? It starts with what seems like a throwaway party game and escalates into something that completely upends He Shichen's entire understanding of reality. First the water cup explodes. Then there's the rumor about her fortune-telling for classmates. And now THIS—grain markets, oil prices, soybeans at five-year highs—and she nails it with literal DICE. The plot mechanics here are so satisfying because the author doesn't just give us one lucky guess. No, no, no. It's THREE separate validations in a row, each one more impressive than the last. That's the narrative rule of three right there, and it's doing heavy lifting. He Shichen is fundamentally a materialist, a guy who trusts numbers and logic, and watching him slowly lose his mind over something he can't explain is absolute gold. "Superstition wasn't the scary part. What was truly frightening was when someone packaged superstition with the most advanced jargon." Holy. This line hit me like a truck. Because that's exactly what Chu Qianli did—she didn't just throw dice and hope, she justified it with 'big data analysis for fate.' She spoke his language and won anyway. The plot isn't just about her being right; it's about the systematic dismantling of someone's worldview through evidence they can't refute. And the fact that it ends on He Shichen's two impossible choices—either she's a financial genius hiding in plain sight, or metaphysics actually beats science—leaves us perfectly suspended. Which path does he pick? I NEED to know.
... Read More
'Encounters between people are about fate, something largely uncontrollable, but one can at least know when the right time is.' This line stopped me cold. The entire Bitcoin subplot isn't just comic relief — it's the author's way of exploring a theme that runs through the whole novel: how much control do we actually have over our lives? He Shichen spent days researching the best entry point, planning his exit strategy, setting goals. And then he forgot. The universe rewarded him not for his competence but for his negligence. Meanwhile Chu Qianli's vague fortune-telling turned out to be more accurate than his spreadsheets. There's something almost spiritual about this — not in a religious sense, but in the sense that the author is asking: what if your efforts are just the amplifier, and luck is the signal? The metaphor extends to relationships too. 'Some people experience a strong marriage luck year... if they keep rejecting everyone, they might miss out on their true match.' This connects directly to whatever's happening between He Shichen and Qi Yan — the argument mentioned in passing that cost him his selling window. His emotional turmoil literally cost him money, or would have, if not for the cosmic joke of him forgetting. The recurring motif here is the idea that timing matters more than effort. And that's a theme worth sitting with.
... Read More
I need to talk about Wang Zheng because this guy is everything. He's not even the main antagonist or anything—he's just this smaller-time antagonist who exists to make life miserable for anyone who talks to Tan Muxing. The narrator casually drops that 'every environment seems to have its designated antagonist' and I was like yes, yes it does, and you've identified it perfectly. But what makes him work is how efficient he is. No monologuing, no grand scheme. Just constant low-grade hostility aimed at isolating Tan Muxing socially. He's the human equivalent of a pop-up ad. And Tan Muxing's response? Frowning slightly, pretending not to hear, and then walking out with Chu Qianli without even looking back. That lack of looking back is THE most important action in this entire passage. It's not defiance. It's indifference. Which is somehow more devastating. The friendship between these three is also worth sitting with—they formed organically through shared interests (astrology, the group chat) rather than proximity, and Qiu Qingkong hasn't abandoned her old friends despite having new ones. That's maturity wrapped in a teenage comedy. Ruan Ya as the model student, He Shichen as the genius, Chu Qianli as the mysterious transfer student—the whole class has become this anime cast, and Tan Muxing is the only one without a label. That detail stung.
... Read More
On the surface, this is a school romance with astrology as flavor. But I don't think that's all it is. The astrology here is doing heavier lifting than most readers might notice on a first pass. Chu Qianli doesn't just READ astrology — she USES it as a framework for understanding human complexity. The entire conversation with Tan Muxing about having "all twelve zodiac signs within you" is a metaphor for something much broader: that people are not reducible to one trait, one label, one expectation. When boys call Tan Muxing a girl for sewing, they're FLATTENING him. Chu Qianli REFLATTENS them by expanding the definition. The birth chart concept itself is symbolic. Two people — He Shichen and Tan Muxing — are described as having equally impressive charts, yet one is celebrated and the other is invisible. Same celestial configuration, wildly different social treatment. The universe doesn't discriminate; society does. That's a pretty sharp commentary buried under what could have been mere character detail. Chu Qianli's relationship with astrology is also philosophically interesting. She says the stars "point the way" but people have to "work on it themselves." She's not a fatalist. She's a guide. She sees potential and patterns but refuses to absolve anyone of agency. That's a nuanced position that the author seems to be building toward — determinism versus free will, played out through cosmic imagery rather than heavy philosophy. There's also the motif of SLEEPING vs. AWAKENING. Chu Qianli literally sleeps through class while mentally tracking planetary positions. She's physically unconscious and spiritually awake. Meanwhile, He Shichen is fully alert but blind to anything outside his ambition. Who's really seeing clearly? Who's dreaming? The inversion is deliberate. And the tarot cards at the end — pulling them out mid-conversation, ready to read for strangers — is Chu Qianli asserting her ontology. In a world that told Tan Muxing he's incomplete and told her she's lazy and aimless, she produces a deck of cards and says: I have a system. I have knowledge. I am valid. The story is bigger than a romance. It's about how we see each other — or fail to.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how beautifully this author writes the fallout after a simple disagreement? Like, they literally didn't even have a real fight—it was about a CARD CATCHER SAKURA reference, which is so petty and yet SO relatable. And then the aftermath... they're still going to school together, eating together, leaving together, but there's this 'inexplicable awkwardness' between them. That's the most accurate depiction of post-argument tension I've ever read. But what got me was Tan Muxing's internal monologue. He's sitting at his desk, looking at his messy sketches, and suddenly he has zero interest in design. Then he picks up the Fool card and just stares at it. This guy is so self-aware—he knows he's not as great as she says he is, he accepted the Fool card as a form of comfort, and I think he's terrified that Chu Qianli figured that out. The text says "Did she get angry because she sensed that?" and I just—chef's kiss. He's not wrong either. He genuinely tries to bridge the gap later by taking her to the exhibition, using the excuse of "getting inspiration for designing clothes." We both know that's not why. He's testing the waters, hoping she's moved on. And she probably has, because honestly, she forgets things easily when there's good food involved. Their dynamic is just so tender in a way that doesn't need grand gestures.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this thing — this UNMENTIONED-but-very-much-FEEL-thing — between He Shichen and Chu Qianli, because it's haunting me. The text gives us these incredibly loaded fragments: "If Chu Qianli hadn't experienced the identity-switching incident, she wouldn't dare to provoke He Shichen so easily. Instead, she would act like she did with Qi Yan — being slightly more cautious, keeping a low profile, and avoiding conflicts with someone as lucky as him." WAIT. So Chu Qianli has a DIFFERENT relationship with Qi Yan? She's cautious around Qi Yan but bold with He Shichen? That's… that's either deep friendship or deep ENMITY or something in between that I cannot figure out. And the fact that she "dared to provoke" him specifically — that takes a certain kind of confidence that only comes from knowing someone intimately, right? Then there's He Shichen's side. The narrative tells us directly that mysticism challenges his worldview and that Chu Qianli is the face of that challenge. But listen to how he describes her: "That brat was unbelievably rude. You wouldn't believe how he insulted Zi Wei astrology!" His master calls him resentful. His master CALLS HIM OUT ON IT. Even Wan Ketian, who barely knows her, can see that He Shichen's hatred is personal. The line that killed me: "He could sometimes come to terms with the former [identity switch], but he still couldn't accept the latter [mysticism]." He's wrestling with something profound, and Chu Qianli is both the catalyst and the target. This isn't simple hatred. This is someone whose entire understanding of reality has been disrupted by one person, and he doesn't know how to process it except through anger. Also — the text cuts off mid-sentence: "Chu Qianli's constant mutterings and fortune-telling at home made He Shichen feel that all fortune-tellers behaved th…" TH. This is clearly "therefore" or "then" or something. He's describing their DAY-TO-DAY interactions. She's at HIS HOME. They live together? Or she visits regularly? And he hears her muttering about fate and luck constantly. That's intimate proximity. That's daily friction. I need to know what their history is. I NEED TO KNOW.
... Read More
There's something deeply ironic playing out here that I can't stop thinking about. You've got Ya Hun, a fraudulent fortune teller pretending to see the unseen, running around claiming supernatural insight while actually selling nothing but confidence tricks. And simultaneously, you've got Tan Muxing — someone who literally comes from a family that owns a mountain — hiding in plain sight at school, letting kids mock him while he says nothing, appearing poor when he's sitting on generational wealth. Both of them are performing versions of themselves that don't match reality. But the difference? Ya Hun's performance harms other people. Tan Muxing's performance just harms him. He could've exposed everyone who made his life miserable with a single phone call and chose not to. That's not cowardice, the text keeps insisting — it's a moral stance he hasn't even fully articulated to himself yet. The livestream itself is basically the ultimate metaphor here. They're trying to use technology to reveal truth — live, unedited, undeniable proof that fortune telling is fake. But Chu Qianli, of all people, is the one who's wildest about not caring about appearances. She'll wear whatever she wants, say whatever she thinks, and she's absolutely weaponizing that authenticity against Ya Hun's carefully constructed facade. The question the text keeps asking, implicitly, is: who actually sees clearly? The woman pretending to read futures, or the girl who's reading people perfectly and just doesn't care to hide it?
... Read More
These chapters are a masterclass in how to pace a scene that has nowhere near the stakes of a battle or a betrayal, and yet manages to feel just as tense. Let me walk through the rhythm: It opens slow — Chu Qianli doing a reading on Teacher Liu, analytical, methodical. This is the breathing room, the setup that lets you settle in. Then the pacing accelerates when Teacher Liu asks about her marriage timeline and Chu Qianli immediately pivots to the "true match" concept. This is where the stakes shift from "interesting fortune telling" to "oh wait, this could actually change something." Then there's the hilarious middle section where Chu Qianli goads Teacher Liu into asking for the birth chart. This is pure comedic timing — every line is shorter, every exchange is faster. The author is practically tapping their foot here. And then — BAM — the WeChat notification. The single most important sentence in the entire passage: "Suddenly, the phone on the desk lit up." One sentence. That's all it takes to pivot from comedy to genuine emotional weight. The pacing holds for one beat — Teacher Liu processing, Chu Qianli celebrating — and then immediately loosens again when Teacher Liu turns off her phone and says "let's talk some more." The structure is wave-like: build tension, release it with humor, build it again with the dinner invite, release it with Teacher Liu wanting to keep talking. It never drags because every beat earns its place, and it never rushes because the author knows exactly when to slow down and let a moment land.
... Read More
Okay so this scene is wild. He Shichen basically lays out his darkest plan — literally considers faking friendship to seize her family's assets and cut off her lineage — and instead of crumpling, Chu Qianli looks at him like he's a mildly interesting specimen. The whole escalation is chef's kiss. He starts off angry, threatening, trying to provoke a reaction out of her. She doesn't flinch. Then she drops the Rupert's Drop metaphor and it's like the whole power dynamic flips in one breath. "I've already found your tail." Oof. And then the absolute best part — she casually reveals she's known about her true identity since birth and chose NOT to come back. He Shichen, who had already decided to walk out that door, immediately stops and turns around. One sentence, that's all it takes. The way the plot pivots from "he's leaving" to "he's now sitting on that stone bench listening to her" is so clean. It's not a dramatic confession or a tearful moment. It's just... information delivered while she's still half-watching her cartoon. That contrast IS the plot point. Also the baby swap subplot keeps simmering underneath without ever taking center stage, which I appreciate. It's the ghost haunting every line of their conversation.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or