The Greatest Astrologist - Reviews

The Greatest Astrologist
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Chen Lili because this subplot about her divorce is somehow doing SO much heavy lifting in these chapters and I'm not even sure the author realizes how good it is. On the surface it's just village gossip — Wang Ping dropping it casually at dinner like, 'oh yeah she's getting divorced, her brother fought someone, the village head was upset about it disrupting the whole civilized village vibe.' But then you layer in the fact that Chu Qianli was the one Chen Lili came to for her wedding date selection, and that she rejected Chu Qianli's advice, and suddenly this whole side story becomes this devastating commentary on the main themes of the book. What struck me is that Chu Qianli didn't fail here — she actually gave good advice, predicted the right outcome, and Chen Lili still chose differently. And Wang Ping's takeaway is basically 'she's not stupid but if she were smarter she wouldn't have married that guy in the first place.' Which is such a brutal, real-world take on fate vs free will. Chu Qianli sees the probabilities — 90% chance of divorce, 10% chance of staying together with damaged feelings — and yet Chen Lili still walked into it anyway. I keep going back to the structural choice of revealing this through Wang Ping's casual gossip rather than a dramatic confrontation. It feels more true to life — most major plot revelations aren't announced with fanfare, they're overheard while peeling vegetables. The Chen Lili thread also raises the question: does Chu Qianli's ability to predict outcomes actually help anyone, or does it just make suffering more bearable by making it inevitable? The plot doesn't answer this directly but it hovers over everything like a cloud.
... Read More
So I've been sitting with this name. Shi Bude. Can't Do. Literally. And I think the author is doing something really clever here that goes way beyond a joke. The whole chapter is built around this tension between fate and choice, between the identity handed to you and the identity you carve out for yourself. Shi Bude is told his destiny is to be popular for only a year — a temporary burst of fame that will collapse if he doesn't pivot. That's not just a plot device, that's basically the premise of every young person's career anxiety in modern China, isn't it? "I need to pivot during that time. However, a boy band debut involved a two-year contract, severely limiting his ability to adapt." The company chose him as a salesperson — not an idol, not a performer, but a pitchman. And you know what? That's kind of beautiful. He accepted the identity they gave him (the "wrong" one) and made it work anyway. He turned "Can't Do" into "Here are some affordable hairspray options for you." And the master — this mysterious figure who supposedly calculated his fate — keeps getting pushed away: "I'm afraid the master would find it too unlucky." Who is she really? A real fortune teller? A metaphor for the forces that shape our lives? Or is she just someone Shi Bude invented to explain why he got the short end of the stick? The final image of him vowing to "buy the company" and then track down the master feels like a quiet rebellion against determinism. He's not accepting his fate — he's collecting the resources to rewrite it. That's the whole book in a nutshell, I think.
... Read More
Okay, so the structure here is interesting because it's basically two separate stories braided together, and I need to think about whether that works. We open with Liu Kaijia's absolutely chaotic morning—cab ride gone wrong, missing the cyclists, getting yelled at by his master, standing lost on a capital street. This thread is all movement and frustration. The pacing is rapid, almost breathless, like we're running alongside him trying to figure out where he's going (literally and figuratively). Then—bam—we cut to the Tan estate. Twilight. Quiet. A grandfather and grandson talking about nothing and everything. The pace drops to a crawl, and honestly? I appreciated it. After the chaos of Liu Kaijia's section, the stillness gave me room to breathe. But I also wonder if the transition was too abrupt. We go from "I'm going to call my master right now" to "a stretch limousine came to a steady stop" with zero connective tissue. It felt like the chapter hit the brakes. The real pacing powerhouse though is the flashback sequence. The author teases it slowly—we see Tan Muxing walking through the courtyard, recalling memories, avoiding the study—before finally dropping us into the full scene of young Tan Muxing hiding behind the door. And then the dialogue with his mother. And then the kindergarten incident. It unfolds like peeling an onion, each layer more painful than the last. What I found brilliant about the structure is that both threads deal with people trying to find their way: Liu Kaijia literally on a river road he can't detour, and Tan Muxing metaphorically navigating a life shaped by accusations from a past he doesn't remember. The parallel gives the chapters a cohesion that the plot itself doesn't provide. The ending is interesting too—it cuts off mid-kindergarten scene with "The injured child was taken to the infir." This feels like an intentional cliffhanger, or maybe the chapter just got truncated. Either way, it leaves us hanging on the most vulnerable moment of Tan Muxing's childhood, which is a ruthless but effective way to end. If I had one critique, it's that Liu Kaijia's thread feels slightly disconnected from the Tan Muxing thread. Right now they're orbiting the same story but not intersecting. I'm curious about when—and if—they'll collide.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this scene is *perfect*. You've got this whole setup of an entertainment company that's supposed to be glamorous and exciting, but what we're seeing is something far more mundane and kind of sad. These kids are sitting in rooms being grilled about their personal lives, their relationships, their so-called 'dreams'—and half of them are failing to even give coherent answers because they rehearsed some scripted response for a talent show audition that nobody asked them to give. The visual of Qiu Qingkong sitting there, utterly defeated, sorting through trainee profiles like she's cataloging the wreckage of a collapsing civilization? That's such a specific, vivid image. She's the daughter of one of the largest media companies in the country, and she looks like she's watching her family's legacy crumble. 'She's sorting through the debris of her collapsing empire'—Chu Qianli basically summarizes the entire emotional weight of the scene in one line. And the hallway! The way the author builds tension through those waiting rooms is masterful. You've got line after line of young trainees, some already looking defeated, others nervously asking each other what happened. The rumor mill starts spinning instantly: 'I heard the company even asks if you have a girlfriend—sensitive stuff like that.' The anxiety is palpable. These kids entered what they thought was an exciting opportunity, and now they're being treated like products being quality-checked before sale. There's this interesting contrast between the dream and the machinery. The first trainee comes in giving this rehearsed speech about making his company and fans proud, and Chu Qianli immediately shuts it down. 'Stop, stop, stop.' The contrast between that performative aspiration and the blunt reality of 'your greatest dream is to make easy money' is brutal but funny. The setting does a lot of heavy lifting here—it's not just a backdrop, it's actively shaping the conflict between illusion and reality. Even the physical description of the room adds to the mood. Chu Qianli in casual clothes instead of her school uniform jacket, Tan Muxing offering sarcastic condolences, Qiu Qingkong looking drained—all of this creates this weird liminal space that's neither fully professional nor fully personal. It's a consultation room that's become a confessional, and everyone involved is uncomfortably aware of it.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the Fool card appears TWICE in this chapter and it is NOT a coincidence. First instance: Tan Muxing finds the Fool card sealed in a wooden frame at his desk. He picks it up, stares at it motionlessly, and the text says he believed in her words—that there are exceptions to everything. But he also thinks the card was just a form of consolation. That's the first layer: he doesn't believe in his own significance. Second instance: the painting turns out to contain a hidden tarot sequence, starting with The Fool. It's disguised as a starry sky, woven so skillfully that normal people would just see a beautiful painting. Only Chu Qianli can see through it because she actually reads the language underneath. The Fool card represents potential, the beginning of a journey, someone who doesn't yet know their own power. Tan Muxing holding it while feeling inadequate? And then the same card hiding inside a painting that triggers a physical reaction in Chu Qianli? This author is threading something deeper here. There's also the question of what Chu Qianli really sees when she looks at that painting. It's not just visual information overload—it's something personal, something that makes her cry. Is it a memory? A message? The text leaves it hauntingly open-ended, and I'm already theorizing that this painting is connected to something much bigger than a gallery exhibit.
... Read More
The conflict in this chapter works on two levels, and I think that's what makes it so effective. On the surface level, Chu Qianli believes she's in mortal danger. She's been divining, she's seen bad omens, she's convinced a 'blood-related disaster' is coming. The stakes feel genuinely high because the narrative treats her fear as real. Every time she checks her phone, every time she avoids the window seat, every time she refuses to step onto the sports field—the story is saying: this person genuinely believes they might get hurt or killed. But the internal conflict is even more interesting. Chu Qianli's problem isn't just the disaster—it's her inability to trust her own instincts. She divines that skipping the test will cause trouble, but she also divines that facing it head-on will cause trouble. So she's trapped between two bad options, and the only way out is... neither? Tan Muxing intervenes, and suddenly the framework she's been using to understand her world breaks open. The disaster wasn't what she thought it was. Her divination was right about the outcome (something bad was coming) but wrong about the nature of the threat. And then there's the unspoken stakes between them. Tan Muxing, who doesn't believe in her astrology, who had a bad experience with fortune tellers, who should have zero reason to care about her supernatural anxieties—he still walks her back from the sports field. He still stands between her and danger. The question hanging over this whole chapter isn't 'will Chu Qianli get hurt?' It's 'why is Tan Muxing the one protecting her?'
... Read More
the sibling rivalry here is SO good and I need to unpack it because both of them are reading each other completely wrong and it's delicious. He Shichen is watching Chu Qianli like a hawk the entire dinner and his internal monologue is peak protagonist energy: she entered the house calling him brother, gained favor instantly, carries herself like she's always been privileged, no generational gap — conclusion: she's the perfect model for a vengeful person, biding her time, plotting to take back what's hers. Bro. You have no idea. She's not plotting revenge. She's plotting how to collect dividends from YOUR company and never work a day in her life again. But the genius of this dynamic is that He Shichen's reading of her is actually kind of correct in the wrong direction. She IS scheming. She IS calculating. She just has completely different goals than he assumes. And Chu Qianli? She has zero emotional investment in him whatsoever. He's just... a character from a book. A convenient income source. The fact that he's the male protagonist means nothing to her romantically or emotionally. She literally thinks being a CEO is just a fancy title for a worker. The dinner table moment where she asks for birth star charts and accidentally exposes that He Shichen's birthday belongs to HER is the ultimate power move and neither of them fully realizes what just happened. Yu Shen trails off mentioning his birthday, Chu Qianli casually says she already knows it, and He Shichen immediately interprets this as humiliation. He's not wrong but the implications run deeper than either of them know right now.
... Read More
Oh my god this chapter had me cackling. Let me break down the plot mechanics because honestly this was so cleverly layered. So here's the setup: Chu Qianli is trying to avoid studying, He Shichen is monitoring her (the 'cash machine' surveillance, what a term), and she immediately creates ANOTHER group chat to bypass him. That's the inciting incident right there. But then Qi Yan joins—not to study but to 'discuss mysticism,' which is such a perfectly passive-aggressive way of inserting herself into He Shichen's plan. The plot twist here is that Qi Yan's reason for joining is actually to learn from He Shichen's 'aura'—this is both a joke and a genuine power move. Then the real plot engine kicks in: the debate. What starts as a minor squabble over group chat rules escalates into a full-blown argument about education, investment, class privilege, and teaching methodologies. The author uses this debate as a plot device to do two things simultaneously—advance the interpersonal dynamics AND give the readers something to theorize about. It's a brilliant double function. The climax hits when they reach an agreement: each lays out a teaching plan and herds Chu Qianli into the library. The irony? Chu Qianli 'felt dizzy from all the studying' but ultimately 'got through the final exams without incident.' The plot resolves in the most satisfying way—she studied anyway, even though she tried to cheat. And then the birthday surprise ending with Aunt Li cooking and He Yuanyuan arriving late? Perfect comedic button. I especially loved how the subplot of Shi Bude's identity was mentioned but never resolved—it's a reminder that this story has layers beneath the slice-of-life surface.
... Read More
Okay so I just finished these chapters and honestly the plot is doing this thing where it's casually layering conflicts on top of each other like an onion and I am HERE for it. You've got Hu Yongjin getting manhandled by Tan Muxing — which was genuinely hilarious because Tan Muxing's whole vibe is 'I don't want to hurt anyone but also I'm holding you too tight to let go' — and then halfway up the mountain the tone shifts and BAM, the neighboring village is excavating. The pivot from comedy to genuine stakes is handled so smoothly I barely noticed it happening. Chu Qianli's line about the Four Sacred Sands was the moment my eyebrows went up. She explains feng shui principles like she's gossiping about her neighbor's house renovation, which is such a Chu Qianli way to deliver exposition. But underneath the casual delivery, the implications are heavy. If the sacred sands are being destroyed, this isn't just about property lines — it's about the spiritual foundation of the entire village. And the fact that Grandpa made an agreement years ago that apparently nobody told the neighboring village about? That's a ticking bomb. The plot's building tension masterfully here — it starts with a physical altercation, moves to a scenic mountain trip, then drops this revelation like a brick. No melodrama, no over-explaining, just the quiet horror of realizing someone's been digging up something ancient without permission.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this chapter did NOT come to play. What starts as another Wang Zheng being a little b*tch somehow spirals into the most emotionally devastating conversation I've read all week, and I am SHOOK. On the surface, the plot is straightforward: Wang Zheng provokes Tan Muxing, Tan Muxing snaps and physically defends himself, Chu Qianli gets dragged into the mess, and then ALL THREE get sent to the teacher's office. Classic school drama setup, right? Wrong. Because what happens AFTER the fight is what actually destroys me. The way the narrative pivots from the school conflict to Tan Muxing's entire existential crisis is genius. One minute we're dealing with 'oh no he got called to the office,' and the next we're listening to a young man articulate the crushing weight of feeling utterly worthless despite being born into wealth. The author doesn't even try to hide it—this fight was never really about Wang Zheng. It was about Tan Muxing finally having enough. And don't even get me started on the He Shichen thread. The fact that this is now Chu Qianli's THIRD incident in three weeks? The author is absolutely laying the groundwork for something bigger, and I'm here for it. He Shichen's internal monologue about keeping her away from Qi Yan because 'if she's useful, Qi Yan will support her; if not, everything changes' is such a cold, calculating observation that it genuinely chills me. He doesn't trust anyone's loyalty—it's all transactional to him. Meanwhile, Qi Yan dropping those shade-throwing remarks like 'if she were in our class, I guarantee the person you're all talking about wouldn't even dare to act out' is the kind of dialogue that makes me want to screenshot and send to my group chat immediately. The plot is doing SO MUCH work here. Every interaction feels like it's building toward something inevitable, and I have zero doubt that Tan Muxing's arc is going to hit absolutely devastating at some point.
... Read More
"He Shichen: '???' Wait a minute, that logic for parenting doesn't sound right either!" That line. That entire exchange. He Shichen goes from impatient sibling to confused observer in three beats, and the dialogue does all the work. No narration, no internal monologue—just the raw absurdity of his father's advice landing on him like, 'I did not raise you to say this.' Chu Qianli's voice is instant. "Is there a major where you don't have to study?" Deadpan. Testing the waters. Knowing exactly how to frustrate everyone in the room. And when He Zhenghe suggests astrology schools? Her response—"They should be paying me to be a teacher there. Why should I pay them to learn? It's such a loss. No way."—is so perfectly arrogant, so perfectly Chu Qianli, that I laughed out loud. She's not refusing to study; she's refusing to be dumb about it. Tan Muxing's dialogue is his guilt made audible. "…That use of 'only' is quite something." He doesn't need to say more. The ellipsis does the work. His entire arc in this chapter is communicated through hesitation, awkward scratching, and the occasional blurted observation. But the real masterclass is in what doesn't get said. Yu Shen's line about the GPS tracker and the bodyguard—that's love expressed through surveillance. He Zhenghe's childhood story about losing money and learning lessons—that's wisdom disguised as embarrassment. He Shichen's dismissal of Chu Qianli as "not understanding anything"—that's protectiveness masked as condescension. The dialogue never explains. It performs. And it's gorgeous.
... Read More
Wait wait wait — I need to talk about the plot threads converging in this chapter because honestly? The author is playing 4D chess and I am not ready. On one hand you've got the school party prep subplot — class meetings, role assignments, the whole bureaucratic student council chaos. Ruan Ya handing out parts, Chu Qianli trying to escape with zero lines, Tan Muxing reluctantly accepting the general role. Classic comedy of errors stuff. But then BAM — the birthday revelation drops like a bomb. He Shichen's contact list doesn't even have his exact birth date? Only the month? And when Tan Muxing casually asks, everyone flips it around to ask about HIS birthday instead. The avoidance is SO obvious. And then the stranger following them? Oh my god. Tan Muxing says "I keep feeling like someone is following us" and his expression is uncomfortable, furrowing his brows. Then we cut to Liu Kaijia in a taxi, watching them disappear, and he HURRIEDLY asks the driver to turn around. Who IS this person?! Why are they following them? And Tan Muxing was sent to a training camp by his family to lose weight but his weight didn't change — so he developed this inexplicable sense of crisis. What does that even mean?? The plot is literally stacking on top of itself. School party + birthday mystery + stalking stranger + unexplained training camp backstory. I'm living for the tension here. Every question opens three more doors and I just need to know what's happening next.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or