The Fake Saintess Does Not Wish For Death - Reviews

The Fake Saintess Does Not Wish For Death
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"So, you're that desperate to leave?" — three words and you already know exactly who Sua is. She doesn't need monologues. Her dialogue cuts. Every line she speaks in the garden scene is designed to wound, and the rhythm of their exchange builds like a fight choreography: "Why are you doing this to me?" "If you're curious, I'll tell you. I hate you like crazy." That directness! She doesn't weave excuses or hide behind politics. She just says it. And then: "You're just a fake Saint, and your father is a fool trying to pass you off as the real deal." The casual cruelty of "fool" applied to someone's parent — that's a line that crosses from competition into personal violation. Alicia's voice, meanwhile, is softer but not weak. When she snaps back "My father is not someone you can speak of so disrespectfully!" — it's the first time she raises her voice, and it changes the entire dynamic. Sua's response, choking on the ground moments later, suggests something supernatural is happening. That beat of silence after Alicia speaks is loaded. And the priest's dialogue is so sparse it's almost suspicious. "I hope you recover soon, and I hope I never have to come back here again." Twenty-three words total for a character who just stayed overnight at her bedside. The bluntness feels intentional — either he's emotionally guarded, or he's hiding something. Whatever the case, I want to hear more from him. The crowd chanting "Cut out the witch's tongue!" in the execution scene is less dialogue and more chorus — Greek tragedy style. They're not individuals; they're the mob, and their collective voice is the real antagonist in that scene.
... Read More
Okay so. Helena. The elder daughter who left before Licia. The one her father compares her to constantly. "She's just like Helena. So full of secrets and an adventurous spirit." And now we have Abigail and Licia standing in identical white dresses with different colored ribbons, the Viscountess比对双胞胎似的盯着她们看。I keep thinking about how many layers of mistaken identity and swapped fates are woven into this thing. But the real plot bombshell? Abigail's arc. It starts as this innocent marketplace misunderstanding—strawberries, of all things—and spirals into something absolutely horrifying. Father Revencio's whole operation is sickening. He doesn't just want to test her virginity; he's hunting for something called the "Saint," and Abigail is the perfect vessel because of her appearance. "Saint, I have searched for you for a long time." That line gave me actual chills. This man has been planning this. This wasn't random. Meanwhile, Licia's return parallel cuts both ways—her emotional homecoming with Isidora and her father feels warm and earned, but we know what's happening to Abigail simultaneously, and the tension between those two storylines is doing something really clever. One is a reunion; the other is a descent. And they're mirrors. Same age, same face, same blue eyes, but one walks through a mansion door into her father's arms and the other gets pushed onto an altar. "Helena, can blood truly be deceived?"—this question hangs over everything. Is Licia really who she says she is? Or is there another swap waiting to happen? The plot is threading these mysteries together like a noose.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one scene. Like, I am not okay. The protagonist goes home after all that business with Father Edwin and the Saint news, and her father is waiting for her at dinner. Cold food. He doesn't say anything the whole meal. And then he says 'It's nice to sit together after so long' in this completely flat tone. Flat! But also — you know what he meant by that. He waited. He didn't eat. He was just... there. And then he brings out the dress. Helena's dress. THE dress. From the portrait. He burned everything else, everything connected to her memory, and yet somehow this one dress survived. And now he's giving it to his daughter. "I don't know if you'll like it." That's the most dad-line ever written, folks. Like he's been carrying this moment for years and finally found the right way to hand it over. "When the dance began, she asked why I wasn't asking her to dance, even though I hesitated like a fool. I was so nervous while dancing that I couldn't make eye contact with her. She was that beautiful." My father has never said my mother's name. And then suddenly he's telling me about the first time they danced. I literally made a noise. And then the quill and ink! Not the emerald necklace he gave her for her seventeenth — something she could actually USE, something personal. Something that wasn't going to end up in a drawer forgotten. She throws herself into his arms and he just... lets her. The taciturn duke, crumbling a little bit, smiling for real. And then the flashback to that day at the stake — [Licia, it's all my fault. It's my fault for passing on Helena's looks to you.] — and she finally says what she couldn't say then: Father, it wasn't your fault. It wasn't anyone's fault. I wish I could have told him that in that moment too.
... Read More
The pacing here is interesting because it feels deceptively calm on the surface. We start with a journey, arrival, meeting a grumpy priest—that's pretty standard setup. But the author is planting seeds everywhere. Every interaction with the nuns, every description of the monastery corridors, every mention of spring arriving—it's all building toward this inevitable collision. The shift from the protagonist's POV to Edwin's POV is where the tempo changes. Suddenly we're in a dark room, a man who hasn't slept, a dove delivering bad news. The pacing accelerates. Then back to the protagonist oversleeping on what should be a hopeful morning, and the atmosphere immediately turns wrong. The library scene is peak tension—Edwin pacing like a caged animal, the nuns gathering, him locking them out. And then the confessional, twilight, moonrise, the long wait that makes you feel every second. The author knows exactly how to make you uncomfortable with silence and anticipation. The structure flips between intimate character moments and institutional dread, and each flip raises the stakes. By the end, when she confesses her six months of knowledge, the reader is breathless. Not because of action, but because the ground has entirely shifted under everything we thought we were reading.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter hit me like a truck. Let me just say - the butterfly brooch scene? I am not okay. You get Alicia receiving this gift from her father, all warm and fuzzy, and then BOOM - the memory of it being SHATTERED comes rushing back. Who does that? Who writes something so devastating in one paragraph? And don't even get me started on the memory loss aspect. The whole setup with Huntington sacrificing himself - we KNOW this is important but Alicia can't remember WHY. It's this lingering fog in her mind, and that image of the priest with silver hair just won't leave her. I kept waiting for the author to explain but no, we're left guessing. Love it or hate it, it works. But here's what really got me - theSaintess selection backstory. Three hundred years ago, they gathered ALL women from the empire and drowned them in a lake to find THE ONE. And nuns are exempt?! Alicia reads this and suddenly pieces together the puzzle. No wonder she's running - she's trying to escape some kind of cycle of death and she's figured out there might be a way out. The ending where she's at the monastery with Sister Dorothea, who's getting sicker... it's tender but heavy. And then WE get the flashback to Victor branding her with that hoof mark. WHAT. Just - what. She's been carrying that shame, that brand, literally and figuratively. And now she's hiding in this remote monastery pretending to be just another nun. I'm obsessed. I need to know what happens next. Is she going to confront Victor? What's the deal with the Saintess test? And why does she keep having these fragmented memories? Give me more please!
... Read More
Let me talk about the dialogue because WOW. The opening line - 'In the end, Huntington sacrifices himself and dies, right?' - is such a perfect hook. It's spoken to no one, it's fragmented, it's the sound of someone whose memories are bleeding through cracks. I love that we never get a proper response. It's just Alicia talking to herself, or to ghosts, or to whatever version of reality she's inhabiting. And the priest's voice - 'I hope you recover soon, and I hope I never have to come back here again.' So blunt! So arrogant! But then we see those golden eyes beneath his thick eyelashes and... okay, I'm blushing just writing this. The contrast between his harsh words and that unforgettable gaze? Chef's kiss. Father's dialogue is deceptively simple. 'You still seem to have a fever' - such a normal thing to say when your daughter just remembered she's apparently died before. But Alicia doesn't question it. Neither do we. That normalization of the supernatural is brilliant. The maid asking 'If a situation arose where I had to escape...' and then immediately following up with 'You've been reading strange novels again?' is EVERYTHING. It's so natural! Like a real person covering their own curiosity with gentle teasing. And her suggestion to hide in a monastery - did she mean to help or is she just being practical? Either way, it changes everything. Sister Dorothea's voice is warm and weathered, like the monastery walls themselves. 'Everyone has secrets they find difficult to share.' Such a simple line but it carries so much weight. She's seen things. She knows things. And she still opens her door to a stranger in a rainstorm. But the most haunting dialogue comes from Victor - 'Isn't it impolite to refuse a birthday gift, dear sister?' Mocking, cruel, and delivered with that sneer that makes my skin crawl. The way he calls her 'dear sister' while branding her like livestock... I can't stop thinking about it.
... Read More
Okay so I have to talk about that scene where the emperor grabs Alicia's hand and whispers about something he did 25 years ago, and then immediately croaks dead right after. CHILL. My skin literally crawled. This is obviously the MacGuffin of the entire story — some unforgivable sin that ties directly into why the Saint system exists in the first place, and who exactly picked Alicia to be the fake Saint in the first place. And then Revencio just SHOVES the will at her face in front of everyone like he hasn't got a care in the world. His exact words: 'It is most transparent and fair for the Saintess, as God's representative, to read the will right here and now.' TRANSPARENT??? BRO. The man is sweating with excitement while saying that. You can literally see the gears turning behind his eyes. Also the whole prophecy thing is such a classic but well-executed setup. '[Under the light of the sun, those bearing blue gems on their body will become the emperor's beacon.]' — translated however the temple wanted it to be. A thousand them gold-haired blue-eyed girls qualified, they picked the most obedient one, and here we are. The prophecy wasn't wrong; the interpretation was weaponized. That's the kind of plot twist that makes you want to throw the book across the room in the best way.
... Read More
This author's dialogue writing is legitimately sharp and I need to highlight a few moments that made me actually laugh out loud. Alicia's line when Edwin asks if she has anything else to prove: "Please forgive me graciously. This is the best and only negotiating strategy to persuade you, Father." Deadpan delivery of the most unhinged request imaginable. She treats sexual exposure like a business proposition and that tonal whiplash is comedy gold. Then there's Edwin's internal response: "Haah... It's just a simple physiological phenomenon, nothing to do with that nun." Sir. Sir. You are standing there with a visible reaction and you think telling yourself it's not about her is going to work? The man is gaslighting himself and the text is fully aware of it. But the dialogue that wrecked me was quieter. After Edwin says he can't intervene in matters of faith, she responds: "Every now and then, I wish you would listen to my confession like you did now." And then the actual confession scene plays out almost beat-for-beat with traditional religious language—"Please, have mercy on me and forgive my sins" / "In the name of the Divine, I grant you peace and absolution." Except neither of them believes the words mean what they say. He's performing absolution. She's performing repentance. And underneath it all, she's already planned someone's death. The dramatic irony here is suffocating. Father Revencio's dialogue is appropriately slimy—"You don't yet understand a woman's life" followed by his entire pitch about women being destined for domesticity. It's written so casually that you know the author absolutely intends for Edwin to be repulsed by this worldview, and the fact that he barely hides his disgust while still playing along shows how skilled he is at political maneuvering.
... Read More
I need to address Father Edwin because his dialogue is chef's kiss. From the moment he appears, he doesn't do small talk. 'There's no need for you to go all the way to the outskirts. Come with me and change your clothes.' Brutal. Direct. But then you get lines like 'I can't stand the people of my monastery wearing such ridiculous clothes' and you realize he's not actually being mean—he's being awkward in the only way he knows how. That's characterization through speech. And his breakdown in the library? 'This is absurd.' 'There's no way such a thing could exist.' 'The scriptures are just metaphors!' This is a man whose entire worldview is cracking, and he's saying it out loud to empty shelves. Then in the confessional, his voice 'strained to convey the weight' and then 'trembled with tears'—the dialogue strips away and what's left is raw. The protagonist's lines contrast perfectly. She's polite, formal, always covering her tracks. 'Father, I have known everything, yet I have remained silent until now.' That sentence carries so much. The author uses dialogue like a weapon and a bandage simultaneously. Even the minor characters have distinct voices—Sister Sarahh's 'Alicia, spring will come soon!' vs. Sister Susanna's calm procedural 'We must convey regretful words to the congregation.' You could tell them apart blindfolded.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or