The Fake Saintess Does Not Wish For Death - Reviews

The Fake Saintess Does Not Wish For Death
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This is the chapter that made me realize literally everyone in this story is fighting a losing battle. Daniel is the most obvious — torn leave request on the floor, sobbing about being incompetent, forced to sign away his own position so Edwin can escape. The stakes for him are immediate: lose his home, lose his purpose, lose everything after three and a half years of what he claims was miserable service. 'How can such an incompetent man wear the robes of a priest?' That's not self-reflection, that's a man whose entire identity just got hijacked. The actress is fighting a different war. Outside the theater, strangers are mocking her, calling her a fake Saint, laughing about purity tests at the temple. Her stake is survival — her reputation, her livelihood, her sanity. She performs with everything she has because it's the only thing keeping her alive, and still they call her rotten on the inside. The protagonist is trapped between Victor and Edwin. Victor promised her shifonra and gave it to someone else. Edwin tortured a monk to get to her but also makes her tremble with fear because of Martin. She's caught between the man she hopes for and the man who's literally dragging her away from danger right now. And Edwin himself — he ran three years and six months of proper sleep to get here, but his temper is still terrible, his guilt still nagging ('his conscience, which he thought had long been worn away by the cries of novice priests, stirred'), and he's clearly still furious about the Saintess decision. He escaped the monastery only to walk into another trap. The stakes keep multiplying. Every character thinks they're the one making choices, but nobody seems to have any real power over what happens next.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is doing heavy lifting, and I want to highlight a few moments that just landed perfectly. First, Daniel and Edwin's scene. This is comedy relief that doesn't feel tacked on—it's organic. Daniel begging to go home, Edwin being petty about it. "You can ask the priest! Or Father Marco is there too!" "Should I tell someone who can barely move to stand and attend Mass all day?" This is such a specific, lived-in exchange. These two have history. You can feel it in the way they bicker. And then Edwin's threat face—"Edwin bared his teeth as if he would devour him"—completely sold me on this power dynamic. But the dialogue that haunts me is Father Revencio's. Every line he speaks is layered with false warmth. "I understand. How unfair must this be?" said while his muscles are trembling with excitement. "It's just a procedure. If you don't even do that, then the Viscountess Miller is guilty of sacrilege." He weaponizes her compassion against her. That's not just good villain dialogue—that's psychologically precise manipulation. He reads her like a book and uses every page. And Licia's interaction with her father is quietly devastating. She suppresses her emotions and forces a smile. He notices but doesn't push. "Well, come on in." Four words. His voice has that "subtle tremor beneath his emotionally restrained tone" that the narration flags. They both love each other desperately and neither knows how to show it directly. The restraint IS the emotion.
... Read More
Let's talk about the moonlight scene because I cannot stop thinking about it. She steps onto the railing of the confessional booth, lifts her skirts under the full moon, and reveals a horseshoe-shaped mark to Edwin through that tiny window. The imagery is so deliberately charged—fragile barrier between them, the veil torn apart, radiant full moon shimmering beyond the partially open window, her trembling fingers clutching the hem like leaves in wind. This is visual storytelling at its finest and I wish more novels committed to this level of atmosphere. Then there's the baptism scene which hits completely different. Stained glass sunlight, holy water being anointed on her head, tears precariously clinging to her eyelashes. The contrast between her internal monologue—countless words that once defined her dissipated like foam on water—and the solemn ritual happening around her is chef's kiss. She's being reborn as a nun while simultaneously planning someone's elimination. The dissonance is beautiful. The world itself feels lived-in too. The monastery has disbursement methods, central temples, prophecies interpreted by theologians, villages with blonde-haired women being gathered like cattle for a Saint selection. There's a whole empire-level bureaucracy behind this religious nonsense and it all feels coherent. The detail about crops withering from drought and the disbursement method changing to food/necessities instead of cash—that's the kind of small worldbuilding detail that makes you believe this universe exists outside the pages. Edwin's bedroom scene at dawn though—him struggling with physiological responses, stabbing his own thigh with a pen—also adds this weird grounded physicality to a story that could easily float away into pure melodrama. The world has texture.
... Read More
I need to talk about Alicia and Victor because THIS is what got me. This entire book is basically a tragedy wrapped in religious propaganda and political scheming, and at its core it's just a love story where nobody can actually reach each other. Remember the very first chapter? She's standing on that balcony, forcing a smile at thousands of people who think she's a goddess, and all she's thinking about is: 'Victor, I miss you.' That's it. That's the entire emotional summary of her existence. She has no power, no voice, no real name even — they took 'Alicia Sossilion' from her and called her Saint. But Victor... Victor was her only anchor. Her only real thing. And now? Three months. Three months without seeing her father. Three months where she's been reduced to 'the daughter of a duke' with no official status, politely asking permission to exist in the same room as the man she loves. And he says no. Not because he doesn't care — probably because he CAN'T afford to. The newSaint is watching. The temple is watching. Everyone is watching. The most devastating line in the whole excerpt is probably this: 'I wished I could go up and embrace him, but I could not.' Not 'I didn't want to.' Not 'he didn't want me to.' Just... I could not. The world literally would not allow it. That's not a romance. That's a prison sentence with a handsome face.
... Read More
"Helena, can blood truly be deceived?"—this single question from the Viscountess is the thematic core of everything that happens in these chapters, and I can't stop turning it over in my head. Blood. Identity. Deception. The Viscountess had two girls dressed identically with different colored ribbons and couldn't tell them apart. But can blood—that literal biological truth—be fooled? Or is the question asking something deeper: when identity is performed through clothing and behavior, does biology even matter? Is Licia still Licia if everyone sees someone else? Is Abigail still Abigail if the world treats her as a sacrifice? The ribbons are so loaded. One ribbon for each girl. Different colors for different daughters. But they're attached to the same dress. The visual of those two white dresses side by side is haunting—a uniformity that erases individuality while pretending to celebrate it. And then there's the chastity test itself as symbol. What does it mean to purify a body that's already been compromised by the system that demands its purity? Father Revencio's temple demands Abigail's compliance under the threat of branding her mother a heretic. The institution uses love as leverage. The "Saint" he's searching for—is she a person or a concept? Has he been hunting a living girl this whole time, or has he been hunting an idea and found a body to fit it? The strawberry. Of all things. A fruit offered freely, taken without thinking, and used as the instrument of entrapment. Innocence weaponized against the innocent. The plot point is almost secondary to what it represents.
... Read More
Okay so Abigail Miller gets chosen as the Saint instead of the protagonist, and at first I was like "wait, I thought the whole thing was supposed to be about YOU being the Saint" but then it actually made sense, didn't it? The protagonist has this whole roadmap in their head from a previous life where they were the one on the stake, and now Abigail — a literal cousin, same blood — gets that role instead. Which means the entire plot pivots from "how do I survive being Saint" to "how do I protect someone else from the fate I died for." That is actually really clever. The story doesn't have to reset or handwave anything; it just shifts gears mid-drive and keeps going. "If it's confirmed, there's no escaping." This line hit different because it's not dramatic or emotional — it's resigned, almost clinical. The protagonist is already three steps ahead mentally, calculating what needs to happen next, and yet you can feel the weight of everything they've already endured underneath that calmness. They know Abigail will burn if they fail, and they know they might end up burning in her place. The stakes (pun absolutely intended) are clear without being spelled out in some big monologue. The coming-of-age ceremony setup is basically the inciting incident for Act 2. Everything leading up to it — the dress, the escort, the social debut — is the protagonist stepping back into the lion's den on purpose. That's a bold narrative choice. Most stories would have the MC try to avoid this, but here they're walking straight into it because they need to meet Abigail and intervene. The story understands that heroism isn't always about running away sometimes it's about showing up exactly where you're supposed to be, even when you'd rather not.
... Read More
What I love about this section is that every character is fighting a different version of the same war. The protagonist is torn between her duty to the monastery and her horror at what's coming. She knows innocent girls will be sacrificed and she's been silent about it. Edwin is caught between his faith, his duty to the temple hierarchy, and his moral revulsion—he called the previous consecration a 'brutal massacre,' not a sacrifice. Revencio represents the corrupt institution, grinning about turning a Saint into an empress like it's a business deal. Daniel is the cautious observer, exchanging silent glances with Edwin, probably wanting to help but knowing the risk. And the nuns—Sarahh especially—are completely unaware, living in this fragile bubble of spring flowers and shared vows, while the protagonist watches them with guilt eating her alive. The external stakes are clear: someone will be sacrificed, the temple will cover it up, history will repeat itself. But the internal stakes are what make it unbearable. Everyone who knows the truth is isolated. The protagonist can't tell the nuns. Edwin can't trust the temple. They're all standing on the edge of something terrible and no one has a plan. That's real tension—when the danger isn't just out there, it's in the silence between people who care about each other.
... Read More
Sua. Oh my god. Let me just say this once: I have never wanted to personally murder a fictional character this badly. She shows up floating on a beam of sunlight like some kind of dark angel, lands in Victor's arms, and immediately makes Alicia's life hell. But here's the thing that actually makes her complicated instead of just a cartoon villain — she genuinely believes she's the victim. Her line: 'I became the Saint in your place, and you couldn't even stay by my side?' — WAIT. What? Because apparently Alicia wasn't desperately holding onto that position SO THAT SUA COULD HAVE IT?! Alicia stayed behind voluntarily. She took the burden of being the fake Saint so Sua wouldn't have to. And Sua thinks SHE'S the martyr here? Then she SHOVES Alicia to the ground and STEPS ON her father's butterfly brooch. Like — the ONE sentimental object she has left — SMASHED INTO PIECES. And Alicia just picks up the shards 'like a desperate animal.' I cannot breathe. Meanwhile Victor... is this man even aware of what's happening? He's 'too busy' to see Alicia but makes time every evening for Sua. And when he sees Alicia at the pond in the rain, he just... stands there. Doesn't reach out. Doesn't say anything. Just watches her like she's a ghost. Which, honestly, kind of makes him tragic instead of purely hateable.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how perfectly Jaylon sounds in every single line? The man has zero filter and maximum emotional transparency and I am HERE for it. "Are you drooling as you say that?" / "I'm not joking, it's true…" / "Well, I don't know about me, but other young ladies might get a little jealous." / "I don't care about impressing other young ladies." / "Holding hands would have been enough." / "I said I'd escort you. I wanted to look good too." This dialogue is doing SO MUCH work. Every exchange reveals character without a single parenthetical description. Jaylon's nervousness, his genuine admiration, his desire to be seen as capable — it all comes through in what he says and how he says it. And the protagonist's voice? Dry, wry, occasionally sharp but always affectionate underneath. "Someone might mistake you for being serious." That's peak Licia. Even Father Edwin gets a moment: "Jaylon, are you upset?" …… "I'm sorry, it was really urgent." The silence doing the heavy lifting. And then the shifonras exchange — forced feeding, gagging, four pieces left uneaten, and Jaylon eating the one with teeth marks on it like it's nothing. "In the end, Jaylon and Father Edwin secretly shared salivas. It seemed better not to reveal the truth to both of them." THE PROTAGONIST'S INTERNAL COMMENTARY IS EVERYTHING. The dialogue never feels staged. It feels like eavesdropping on real people who have history with each other. Every line has subtext, and the subtext is usually: I care about you but I don't know how to say it directly.
... Read More
What a brilliant structural move the author makes by splitting this chapter into two parallel tracks. On one side we have Edwin in the confessional, quietly unraveling over a nun whose face haunts his memories. On the other, Revencio runs a cold, systematic hunt for a Saint candidate like a man choosing livestock. These two threads feel worlds apart until you realize they occupy the same suffocating institution. The plot doesn't just move forward—it tightens. Revencio's dismissal of the theater actress because she lacks humility, his obsession with platinum blonde hair and blue eyes, his casual mention of crushing ants—all of this builds dread. By the time Alicia steps into the marketplace, battered and disoriented, the reader already knows what kind of world she's wandering through. The parallel editing here is masterful. One character struggles with guilt over a glance; another struggles with nothing at all. That contrast tells us everything we need to know about who holds power and who doesn't.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened to Abigail and I'm still shaking. The stakes escalate so fast it's dizzying. One minute she's a girl accused of stealing a strawberry, and the next she's being force-fed into a Saint's habit and pressed onto a blood-stained altar by a man whose wrinkled hands grip her throat. "Noble sacrifice! Honorable death!" The absurdity of his language versus the reality of what he's doing—that's where the true horror lives. Abigail's internal conflict is the most agonizing part. She doesn't resist the chastity test because she's forced to, but because she's terrified her refusal will get her mother branded a heretic. "In her naive purity, Abigail couldn't bear to see Viscountess Miller being branded as a heretic because of her rash actions." She trades her own body for her mother's reputation. That's not coercion alone—that's systematic exploitation of a child's love. Meanwhile, Licia's conflict is quieter but no less intense. She's returning to a father who lost a daughter before and is now terrified of losing another. She carries secrets she can't share—Jaylon's letter, the violence she witnessed, whatever she became during her time away. Her father says it himself: "Was it because I failed to give as much love to her as Helena?" The guilt is eating him alive, and it makes every conversation between them fragile. Two girls. Same face. Different traps. One trapped by a monster in white robes, the other by expectations and silence and the weight of a name. And the question that keeps me up at night—can either of them escape without destroying something irreparable?
... Read More
The central symbol here is the inscription: 'Under the light of the sun, those bearing blue gems on their body will become the emperor's beacon.' On the surface, it's a prophecy. But the text reveals it's a mistranslation—the original referred to 'one hundred unprocessed pearls collected by the clergy,' not virgin girls. This is the story's thesis statement wrapped in a theological error: institutions rewrite truth to serve power, and the cost is paid by the vulnerable. The blue gems become a metaphor for how language itself is weaponized. Then there's the consecration imagery—light, beacons, sacred rituals masking murder. The church that claims divine authority is literally sacrificing children based on a mistake. And the pearls by the seaside? Nature providing the answer while the temple insists on blood. Spring is another recurring motif—new life, renewal, the world tree turning green—but it's framed as 'too luxurious for a cowardly bystander.' The protagonist feels she doesn't deserve peace because she's complicit through silence. Even the white dove is symbolic: a messenger of peace and divinity, delivering an order that will bring death. These symbols aren't decorative; they're the story's moral compass, constantly reminding us that beauty and horror coexist in the same world.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or