The Fake Saintess Does Not Wish For Death - Reviews

The Fake Saintess Does Not Wish For Death
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we talk about the Alicia letter scene for a second? Because that destroyed me. She's clutching that damp, smudged paper, replaying memories like 'I don't want this' and 'I didn't even get a proper farewell.' She's supposed to be the strong one—the one who brings news, who negotiates, who gets the job done. But she breaks. Just completely. And the way the author writes it, it's not dramatic crying, it's quiet. Standing alone in a monastery corridor while everyone sleeps. That's the kind of grief that lingers. Then there's Sarahh, this sunshine nun who wants a sister and beams about spring flowers, and our protagonist has to force a smile back while drowning in guilt. The emotional whiplash between 'let's stay together forever, Alicia!' and the reader knowing exactly how this ends—that's the knife twist. And then Edwin, who seems like this grumpy obstacle at first, turns out to be someone who's also carrying unbearable weight. He's been knowing the truth for six months and hasn't slept. That line—'How long had it been since his last break?' 'When was the last time he felt the comforting touch of a warm bed?'—shows a man falling apart quietly. Two broken people meeting behind a confessional veil, both terrified, both desperately hoping the other can fix something unfixable. The emotional core of this section isn't romance, it's two people who can't save themselves realizing they might be able to save each other.
... Read More
The golden thread Alicia finds in her palm at the end—it's small, almost nothing, but it becomes her only anchor. This symbol works on so many levels. It's sin, yes, the very word the narrator uses: 'a sinful, golden thread.' But it's also connection, a fragment of something larger torn loose and clinging to survival. The map she loses represents something equally significant. Maps give us direction, purpose, a sense of control over our path. When she drops it in the marketplace panic, she literally loses her way. What's left is Dorothea's voice inside the medallion: 'I will forever protect our youngest nun.' That line should wound us. Who is Dorothea now? Where did she go? The thread, the medallion, the voice—they're all remnants of a person Alicia once was, or someone who loved her. The deeper theme here is about what survives when everything else is stripped away. Not grand symbols, not holy titles, but small frayed things we grip onto with trembling hands.
... Read More
Okay so I need to just sit with this for a second because the way this chapter unfolds is genuinely unhinged in the best possible way. We start with Alicia revealing her entire backstory to Edwin—time travel, being a former Empress, branded a witch—and he doesn't just sit there and believe her. No, the man tests her with FUTURE information. Like, imagine your ex showing up claiming they're your soulmate from a past life, and your first response is "prove it by telling me about policies that haven't been implemented yet." That is such a power move. But then—then she literally lifts her dress under moonlight to show him a mark. I screamed. This woman has absolutely zero chill and I respect it. She's done asking nicely. Two maidens cannot coexist, she basically tells him, and then decides the solution is to eliminate the true maiden. That's her plan? That's the endgame? And the narration just casually drops that line like it's no big deal: "If that were to happen, could everyone finally rest in the quiet embrace of the Divine's will?" The plot here is doing three things at once—her backstory as a former Saint/Empress/witch, the emerging conflict around selecting a new Saint (with a hundred candidates apparently), and now her decision to become a nun as a cover while planning something ruthless. The parallel plotline with Edwin interrogating Father Revencio about the Saint selection process is also building nicely, though I have zero trust in that old man based on his dialogue alone. The pacing is deliberately slow-burn until it suddenly isn't—she gets baptized, then immediately decides to commit what amounts to murder. That whiplash is intentional and it works.
... Read More
I need to talk about the color white in this text because it is NOT accidental. The Central Temple is described as a building "painted entirely in pristine white." The Saint's habit is pristine white. Abigail's dress before she changes is pristine white. Father Revencio himself is dressed in immaculate white garments. And then—right underneath all of that whiteness—is crimson. Blood stains on the altar. The word "pristine" keeps appearing like a lie the narrator is telling itself. The contrast is brutal. You have this whole world built around religious purity, white dresses, white habits, white everything, and what's actually happening in those white walls is so dirty it makes my skin crawl. "The pristine Saint's gown, the light golden hair, the pale skin as white as snow"—Father Revencio is describing a living sacrifice on an altar that has blood on it. The imagery is almost holy until you realize it's perverted holiness. Then you cut to Miller Manor, and it's all different—a chandelier that feels too high, a staircase that makes your heart sink with every step, Isidora's mop falling from her hand. The warmth here is real but tinged with grief. Isidora's white hair, described as resembling "the shoddy white muffler I knitted for her as a birthday gift years ago"—that detail destroyed me. Years of loyalty compressed into one sentence. The monastery where Licia was is described as remote, dilapidated, home to aging nuns without a proper priest. It's the opposite of the Central Temple's opulent corruption. Two religious spaces, two完全不同的 vibes, and both are trapping women in their own way.
... Read More
The scene with Sarahh is so fragile it hurts. Two nuns making a promise, intertwining pinky fingers, talking about outings and snacks like girls their age should be doing instead of preparing to be sacrifice materials. 'I really dislike breaking promises'—Alicia says this like it's a personal code, a thing she clings to because everything else in her life is out of her control. And then immediately after, she's alone in the marketplace, hyperventilating over an apple, people calling her Saint like it's a disease. The emotional whiplash is deliberate and devastating. Meanwhile Edwin in his quarters can barely look at a nun's face without remembering how she blushed, how she lifted his shirt hem, how his own composure cracked. His internal conflict isn't theological—it's human. And Revencio? He strokes a statue of a sacrificed Saint and feels nothing but calculation. The emotional spectrum in these pages ranges from tenderness to terror to emptiness, and none of it feels earned by accident.
... Read More
The author builds this world through contrast, and it's exquisite. We start in the cramped, document-strewn quarters of a priest who can't sleep, move to a temple garden where Revencio caresses a statue with dead hands, then drop Alicia into a marketplace so alive it threatens to swallow her. The sensory details do heavy lifting here. The soup with too many carrots. The tempura crispy outside, soggy within—these mundane descriptions ground us before the nightmare escalates. The marketplace itself is rendered with almost suffocating vividness: fresh fruits, baked bread, endless pedestrians, the shouting voices calling 'Saint! Saint!' from every direction. But it's the negative space that haunts me most. The silence of the guest room Sarahh doesn't want to occupy alone. The cold wind on Alicia's face after escaping the crowd. The statue's hands neatly overlapped over the neck, preventing blood from flowing—a detail that reads like a warning. This world feels lived-in because its horrors are so quietly embedded in ordinary moments.
... Read More
"I won't leave you alone. Wherever you go, I'll go with you, my lady." That line from the prologue haunts me. It was supposed to be devotion, and now it reads like a contract with expiration date. Victor's transformation is the most horrifying character arc in this text — not because he became evil, but because his villainy is personal. He doesn't just betray her politically; he personally brands her, rips out her tongue, oversees her execution. The man who swore eternal allegiance becomes the architect of her torture. There's something deeply unsettling about how casually he switches sides. Was there always a viper in him, or did power unmask him? Either way, the emotional devastation of that shift is the spine of this story. And Sua — "I hate pretending to be a Saint for a year in your place" — she's not some cartoon villain either. She's petty, yes, but her resentment is grounded. She was forced into Alicia's role, forced to live someone else's life, and then subjected to public adoration meant for her. Of course she lashed out. The shoe scene is grotesque, no excuse for it, but understanding WHY she does it makes her more than a plot device. Then there's this silver-haired priest who appears after her rebirth. "I hope I never have to come back here again." The way he touches her forehead, the exhaustion in his golden eyes — he's not just a random healer. Something about him feels like it matters. And the father, the Duke, who apparently begged the temple not to make her Saint but was called a blasphemer anyway — there's family loyalty here that hasn't been tested yet the way Victor's was. I need to know what kind of relationship they had before everything collapsed.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter absolutely destroyed me with how smooth Edwin is being. The man tormented Daniel into signing HIS OWN leave request so he could escape the monastery and find her. I mean come on. Think about the mental gymnastics here — Daniel had already torn up his own leave request in despair, and somehow Edwin flipped it so that Daniel ended up signing a document that would REPLACE Daniel with Edwin leaving. That is some next-level manipulation. I was genuinely impressed. And then we cut to the protagonist getting dragged to a third-rate theater by Jaylon, only to spot that actress who looks just like her, watching a play about a woman burned as a witch who somehow mirrors her own situation. The parallel is screaming at me. 'Oh God, why did you choose me, someone dull, instead of other bright individuals' — that line from the play within the play is basically the protagonist's internal monologue translated into drama. It's not subtle at all but I'm here for it. Then she bumps into Martin (Victor's knight who was part of the whole trauma group last time) and Edwin swoops in to rescue her with the cheesiest lie about them sharing a bed. Meanwhile Jaylon gets lost in the crowd like a background NPC. And THEN they go to a dessert shop where Edwin tries shifonra and makes that face. What even IS this chapter. The plot threads are everywhere and I can't tell which one to panic about first.
... Read More
Let me just say: the way this chapter opens with the protagonist casually laughing while Father Edwin chokes down shifonras is a masterclass in tonal calibration. You've got the dark backstory (Saint, stake, burning alive) sitting right beside this almost sitcom-like moment of force-feeding pastries to a grumpy priest, and it DOESN'T clash. It works because the protagonist's voice carries both simultaneously — she's seen horror, but she's also still capable of finding something funny in a ridiculous situation. Then it cuts to: "I had promised to return to the duke's house before dinner, but an unplanned encounter with Father Edwin delayed my return." AND THE FOOD IS COLD. The protagonist's father waited. Doesn't say anything. Just waits. That single detail — cold food on the table — does more emotional work than three pages of exposition about how much the father cares. The structure is deliberately winding. We go from the Saint reveal → to the carriage with Jaylon → to the tense dinner → to the study scene with the dress → to the morning-of preparation → to the mirror moment → to Jaylon by the carriage. It's a procession, each scene building on the last, and the chapter doesn't end with a cliffhanger but with something quieter: Jaylon helping her into the carriage, flustered and earnest, and her noticing how he's grown into those broad shoulders. "I said I'd escort you. I wanted to look good too." And she thinks: I felt like I might burst into tears if I said another word. Despite his large stature, Jaylon hadn't shed his childish traits. The pacing never rushes. It breathes. And that's why it works.
... Read More
Okay so this entire arc is built on this massive revelation and I need to talk about how the author layers it. On the surface, we have this simple journey—bring the youngest nun to the monastery because their friend died. But underneath? Everything. The 120-year consecration cycle, the misinterpreted prophecy, the temple's cover-up about the pearls versus the virgin girls. That's the kind of worldbuilding that doesn't shout—it whispers and then hits you like a truck. The scene where Edwin pulls scriptures around in the library, muttering "This is absurd" and locking the door? That's the plot grinding its gears. He's realizing something terrible, and the reader realizes it with him. Then the protagonist drops the bomb: "I have known this for six months." Wow. She's been carrying that secret alone while smiling at nuns and pretending spring is coming. The plot twist here isn't just information—it's emotional landmine. Father Julio died knowing something, sending his people into danger, and she never told anyone. The stakes just went from "we need a new nun" to "innocent people are being sacrificed based on a clerical error that's been covered up for a century." And the temple's not even trying to hide it anymore—Revencio is straight-up laughing about making a Saint into an empress. What happens next? I am not okay with whatever comes next.
... Read More
There's a moment where the protagonist stands in front of the full-length mirror and Yuma — the maid, her mother's former servant — is adjusting the dress and just starts crying. Not sobbing, not wailing, just tears quietly sliding down her face onto the protagonist's hand. And the protagonist touches her cheek. Like a mother would. Like Helena would have. "You look just like her." And then — and THEN — the protagonist forces a smile, and in the mirror, Yuma smiles back with this ecstatic, almost reverent expression. The mirror becomes this portal between past and present, mother and daughter, life and death. It's not described as magical or supernatural. It's just... a reflection. But it carries the weight of an entire backstory. "Mother, today I will attend the coming-of-age ceremony wearing the dress you once wore. That day must have been a fateful day when you first met Father, wasn't it? Perhaps it might be a fateful day for me too, as I'll face the future I've shaped with my own hands." This is cinema-level writing. The blue dress flowing like waves at night. The golden hair, tangled from months of neglect in the palace, being painstakingly untangled by three maids. The contrast between the elaborate preparation and the protagonist's internal calm — she knows what's coming, she's already lived through this, and yet she's choosing to walk into it again. The world feels incredibly textured here: the fashion details (lace collars considered stifling, dresses with elegant slits being the current trend), the social hierarchy implicit in who gets to dress whom, the physicality of the costume itself as a bridge across generations. And Jaylon standing stiffly by the carriage, flushed, unable to meet her eyes — the contrast between the cold marble of the mansion and the warmth of that awkward, genuine boyish moment.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters operates like a heartbeat accelerating toward panic attack. We begin slowly—Edwin eating soup, signing papers, the mundane rhythm of religious bureaucracy. Then Revencio appears and the tempo shifts. His dialogue is clipped, cold, each sentence a decision being made about someone else's life. 'How pitiful. How pitiful.' He says this about women, not about himself. Then Alicia enters and the prose itself seems to lose its footing. Sentences fragment. Thoughts repeat. 'Saint... Saint!' The marketplace scene is written in a fever pitch, mirroring her disorientation perfectly. We don't just observe her panic—we experience it. The loss of the map, the loss of money, the frantic search through habit pockets, the sudden memory of Dorothea's voice—each beat arrives like a punch. And the ending? She spots the Viscount's carriage, and suddenly there's hope. But hope in this story is always conditional, always borrowed. The structure never lets us breathe, and that's precisely why we can't stop reading.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or