Okay so I need to talk about the handshake scene because it literally wrecked me. Everyone's gonna be like oh they got engaged finally but have you SEEN how Melian reacts when Helena actually lets him leave?
He says he'll refuse her proposal, he says it firmly, he bows, he does everything right. And then:
"The young lady did not stop him to the very end. Quietly despairing over the fact that he felt hurt by that, he fled farther away, and farther still."
FARther away. Not just leaving. He's running from his own feelings. And she didn't stop him. SHE HAD EVERY OPPORTUNITY TO AND SHE DIDN'T.
But let's also talk about Helena because wow. This woman proposes marriage like she's ordering lunch. "How much money do you need?" she asks him first — not emotional, not dramatic, just straight to business. And when he refuses, she doesn't push, doesn't cry, doesn't make a scene. She just... lets him go. But the fact that she asked in the first place tells you something. She saw him there, muddy boots and desperate, and instead of laughing him out of her house, she offered him everything. That's not coldness. That's calculation — or maybe that's the only way she knows how to show care.
Melian though... he values reality over ideals apparently, but can you blame him? He's staring at a woman he's basically never spoken to and she just drops this on him. His refusal makes total sense too — he says there's no trust, no affection, nothing. He's not being noble, he's being honest. But I bet he regrets it already. I bet he's regretting it on the stagecoach ride home.
Also: Viscount Raison calls Melian "the son who was given the wrong family" and Melian immediately counters with "I think being born as your child is the greatest fortune in the world." Sir. Sir, this man is having a coughing fit on his living room floor and Melian is still protecting him. That's devotion. That's the kind of loyalty that makes you want to shake both of them.