So That Bad Ending Was Not The End? - Reviews

So That Bad Ending Was Not The End?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk structure. These eight chapters move like a held breath. Chapter 27 starts in media res—May is already exhausted, the compass already wreaking havoc. No exposition, no backstory dumps. Just immediate immersion in her misery. The prose is sluggish, matching her drowsiness. Then, around Chapter 30, something shifts. Johan notices her pattern of symptoms. The pacing quickens as he pieces together the correlation. Suddenly, the narrative is active, investigative. The outing scene is a breathing space—lighter, almost comedic in its awkwardness. May's excitement, her babbling about trivial things, Johan's internal monologue about her being “like white bread.” It's a palate cleanser. But then—Chapter 33. The sea isn't enough. The crisis returns, sharper. The pacing fractures again. Sentences shorten. Thoughts become fragmented. “I, I suddenly don't feel well… Ugh…” And then the rescue. The carrying. The proposition. The kiss. It's all so fast, so urgent, that you skip over the logical objections and just *feel* it. I found myself breathless. The author makes a bold choice here: they don't linger on the aftermath. They don't slow down to let us process the emotional implications. They cut straight to the next moment—May's confusion, Johan's quiet satisfaction, the lingering question of what this means. It's risky. Some readers might find it rushed. Others, like me, might find it perfectly calibrated. The cliffhanger at the end is subtle but devastating: the compass's energy is still active, still hidden, still waiting. The structure doesn't promise resolution; it promises escalation. And that's what keeps me turning pages.
... Read More
Okay so I NEED to talk about this scene where Aiden shows up unannounced and the emotional violence happening beneath the surface. May is literally chewing the inside of her cheek until it tastes like blood, right? She's terrified of him—I mean genuinely SCARED—and yet she still instinctively puts herself between Aiden and Johan when he approaches. That hand she extends... it's not brave, it's panic. She can't stand the thought of him hurting Johan even though Johan is basically weaponizing their closeness for his own amusement. And here's the thing that got me: when Aiden pulls May away from Johan, his jaw clenches at the sight of her gripping Johan's arm. He noticed. Of course he noticed. Every single movement she makes when she's around Johan is catalogued and stored somewhere in that brooding head of his. "Who are you embracing in front of whom." — I'm still processing this line. It's not even asked as a question really. It's pure territorial rage delivered in the calmest voice possible. And Aiden dropping the news that Johan is some kind of cult member with a warrant out for his arrest? That's not just information-sharing, that's psychological warfare. He wants May to look at Johan differently. He wants to see fear in her eyes directed at someone else. The CP energy between them is absolutely toxic in the best way. May's fear is real but so is her attachment. And Aiden... he's clearly agonizing over this while also being completely insufferable about it. Remember the flashback? He was lying in the garden minding his own business, furious about rumors, and then May accidentally drips mulberry juice in his mouth and instead of murdering her she just... fusses over him like he's some hungover commoner. She scolds him for drinking too young. The man is a noble heir and he's being maternal-ed by a maid. I almost laughed out loud.
... Read More
OK so I need to talk about this Johan character because WOW. The man is SUCH a vibe. He walks into a sun god temple—a place he clearly doesn't even believe in—to steal something, and then THIS girl bumps into him and his whole energy shifts. Like, his own goddess has literally told him there's no such thing as coincidence, and you can SEE him lean into that. He follows her with his eyes, notices everything—the anxiety, the compass, the fact that she's been crying—and instead of just moving on, he attaches his magic to her shadow. That is NOT the behavior of a random passerby. That is the behavior of someone who decided this mission is now PERSONAL. And the coolest part? He doesn't just swoop in and grab the compass from her. He watches. He plans. He waits. That shows this level of calculated patience that's honestly kind of hot in a deeply concerning way. Meanwhile May is over here trying to survive a haunted house situation, screaming at strangers, and Johan's just... observing her like she's this fascinating puzzle he wants to solve. Also can we talk about how he introduces himself at the mansion? DON'T STEP ON THE THRESHOLD. Who starts a conversation like that?? But he's also wearing a wig to hide his gold hair, which means he already knows something about her family situation and is deliberately concealing who he really is. The tension between them is going to be ELECTRIC. I'm already obsessed.
... Read More
“Surely I won't have to live like this forever…” That line hit me hard. It's not just whining—it's the sound of a character realizing her suffering has no end date unless something shifts. And shift it does. The plot here is doing that delicate dance between supernatural dread and very human need. We've been fed clues about May's condition since page one: the fevers, the nausea, the way the compass acts up whenever Johan's near. But the author refuses to hand us a neat diagnosis. Instead, we get these jagged episodes where May's body betrays her, and Johan—ever observant, ever calm—starts mapping the symptoms like a physician crossed with a detective. The great turn is when he suggests they go out. Not to cure her, but to distract her. And it works, briefly. The seaside scene is pure narrative misdirection: we think we're in a romance-adjacent stroll, then *bam*—her arm clamps onto his, her face drains, and the purple energy inside her goes feral. That's when Johan drops the bomb: “Ask for help.” Which, of course, she can't. So he offers the only solution left—an “improper advance.” Now, on paper, that's a scandalous move. In practice, it's portrayed with such clinical tenderness that you forget the impropriety and just feel the relief. The plot's smartest trick, though, is the compass itself. It doesn't fight back during the fever. It *hides*. The golden light repels it, which tells us two things: first, Johan's magic is real and potent; second, the compass has limits. It's not an omnipotent curse—it's a trapped thing, and it's afraid. That's a twist I didn't see coming. It changes how I view the whole earlier misery: maybe the compass isn't the cause, but a symptom of something deeper. And that something is starting to stir.
... Read More
There are a few scenes in this stretch that just painted themselves so vividly in my head I couldn't stop seeing them. First, the Ghost Mansion itself. It's on a hill with a vast sea spread out behind it. Just that image — isolation, grandeur, proximity to something endless and dark — and suddenly the whole place feels alive. You don't need the ridiculous superstitions explained to you; the setting does half the work. Why would anyone refuse a carriage ride there unless it genuinely felt cursed? Even Glen, who was just doing his job, could sense the tension before the passenger even spoke. Then there's the carriage scene. Aiden sitting in the back, hooded, simmering with irritation, and as the speed increases the scenery blurs past the window — I could practically feel the wind. The text says his "cold face" is reflected in the glass. This man is so wound up that even his reflection seems unhappy to see him. And then his thoughts spiral: servants working for May. A young man among them. His jaw tightening. The way he replays memories of May's stupid, bright-eyed face from that morning in the garden. "I thought I smelled alcohol from the start. You look younger than me, you shouldn't be doing this already..." May's voice in his head, scolding him over juice dripping onto his lips. The garden memory itself is such a contrast — dappled light, mulberry bushes, a nobleman passed out on a bench, a clumsy servant treating him like a common drunk instead of the Third Young Master. It's almost comedic until you remember he was seriously considering having this girl's tongue cut out five minutes prior. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works beautifully.
... Read More
"I don't know how you felt, but I enjoyed it... To the point where I was a bit hurt when you avoided me." This line from Johan is absolutely critical and I need to dissect it because the subtext is doing heavy lifting. On the surface it's a confession of romantic interest, but read it in context of everything we've established about Johan—his father's teachings, his methodical approach to soul elimination, his strategic mind—and this sentence becomes something far more dangerous. He's admitting vulnerability. He's saying her avoidance physically affected him. And then immediately after, he's the one who orchestrates the entire ghost confrontation, who watches the compass act autonomously, who forms a magic sphere and then withdraws it at her touch. The dialogue throughout this section maintains this razor-thin balance between warmth and calculation. Even his gentle moment—stroking her hair while thinking about killing the grandfather—is rendered in prose that refuses to resolve the tension. The author's voice is particularly sharp in the internal narration, where Johan's cold pragmatism constantly undercuts his warm actions. And May's dialogue? Her stammering, her interruptions, her desperate "Don't do it!"—it all feels authentically flustered in a way that contrasts beautifully with Johan's controlled delivery. The gap between how they speak is the gap between who they are.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or