Secretly Like You for Many Years - Reviews

Secretly Like You for Many Years
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second because the stakes in this story are so quietly devastating. Jiang You's external conflict is obvious: she wants to get into the best jewelry company for her internship. Night, owned by the Bai family. That's the career goal. But her INTERNAL conflict? That's the real story. She's a girl who was born out of wedlock, whose father abandoned her and her mother, who has a half-sister who looks at her with contempt. She doesn't know if she's worthy of being loved without conditions. Every time she tries to connect with someone—making breakfast for the Fu parents, wanting to sleep next to Fu Jin because she's scared alone—she's terrified it will end badly. And it always does. The dream sequence is the key to understanding her stakes. She makes this elaborate breakfast, full of love and effort, and the Fu parents don't even eat it. They leave. And in her dream, her father and half-sister do the exact same thing—they look at the food, say it looks bad, and leave. She chases their car for three blocks crying. Three blocks. That's how deep this wound goes. But here's what makes the conflict so tense: Fu Jin knows. I don't think the text says it explicitly, but he KNOWS. He's seen her mother's busy life, he's seen her grow up alone, he's seen her be 'sensible and well-behaved' because she had to be. And when she says 'Uncle Fu, I'm scared alone,' that's not a child asking to sleep with an uncle. That's a young woman admitting she's terrified of being by herself. And Fu Jin? His conflict is even more dangerous. He's been in love with her since she was three years old—he carried her and her mother through a thunderstorm, he's watched her grow up, he's come back from abroad just to be near her. But he's also 'Uncle Fu.' He has this role, this reputation, this family. The text says his face darkened when she asked to sleep with him and he refused immediately. But then he escapes 'in haste' like he's running from something. What is he running from? Himself? The fact that he's a grown man who wants this girl and can't have her? The fact that if he lets himself want her, everything changes? The stakes are: if she stays at his house for ten days, something will break. Either she'll fall harder and he'll have to keep rejecting her, or he'll break first and cross a line neither of them can uncross. And Xu Chaoyang is standing right there, across the hall, watching, waiting, ready to step in if Fu Jin doesn't move fast enough. I am NOT okay with this.
... Read More
There's something really interesting about the clothing and body imagery in this section. Jiang You is wearing Fu Jin's oversized pajamas with no pants underneath — a visual metaphor for her position in relation to him, isn't it? She's wrapped up in his world, covered by his presence, but fundamentally exposed and unprotected. The damp hair, the flushed face, the bruised toe — all these details of a body in transition, caught between childhood and adulthood. And then the underwear scene. Her finding her own clothes hung to dry, his hands having touched something so intimate and private, it's almost too much. But what really struck me is the contrast between Fu Jin's world and Qi Ye's world. The Fu residence is all modern luxury and assistants who bow and retreat. Qi Ye's home is an old alley house with a cement floor, a fan, no air conditioning. Yet there's something equally warm about it. The story seems to be asking: what does home actually mean? Is it the grand house where someone washes your underwear for you, or is it the old courtyard where a friend washes a watermelon at an outdoor faucet? Both are forms of care, just different kinds.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this about Jiang You — the girl is playing 4D chess while everyone else thinks she's just a cute little sister. The scene where she throws herself into Ruan Guixia's arms and acts all sweet and grateful? Chilling. And then the narration drops this: "Others saw her as a little sister, but she wanted to be their daughter-in-law." That line hit me like a truck. She's literally cooking for the family, making pickled cucumbers, staying up early — all to win them over. Meanwhile Fu Jin is just sitting there eating carrot cake like a man who has no idea his future is being meticulously engineered around him. And Mrs. Fu! Oh my god, Ruan Guixia is such a fascinating character. A woman in her sixties who insists on being called "Xianjie" and puts 18 candles on her birthday cake. She's been spoiled by her husband for decades and it shows — she's dramatic, affectionate, slightly ridiculous, but genuinely warm. The fact that she adores Jiang You so much that she wants to swap granddaughters? That's both hilarious and kind of tragic because Jiang You knows exactly how much power that affection gives her. Then there's the Fu Qihai and Ruan Guixia relationship itself — the villa built over ten years as a wedding gift, the old servants who remember when the master barely ate. This couple is the blueprint Jiang You is studying. She has zero doubt that Fu Jin will be loyal because "like father, like son" — but also zero doubt that Ruan Guixia would break his legs if he ever cheated. Smart girl. She's playing the long game and she knows exactly which buttons to push.
... Read More
There's so much going on beneath the surface in these chapters and I want to talk about the symbolism because it's subtle but deliberate. The carrot cake is interesting — Jiang You bakes it, Fu Jin eats it and says it's delicious, and this small moment of domestic intimacy happens between them while his mother is performing elsewhere in the room. The cake is golden brown with crisp edges, soft and moist inside. It's an act of care that goes almost unnoticed. Fu Jin's barely audible chuckle after breakfast — is that genuine amusement? Does he sense something? The text doesn't say, and that's the point. Then there's the villa itself as a symbol. Ten years of construction, built from the names of the parents, a testament to enduring love. Jiang You studies this relationship like a textbook. She believes in it — "like father, like son" — but the reader might wonder: is she projecting? Fu Jin is clearly different from his father. Aloof, distant, emotionally unavailable. The villa represents the ideal; Fu Jin represents the reality. Wen Nian's outfit choice is another symbol worth noting. She goes for "pure desire" — youthful but alluring, innocent but provocative. It's a costume, just like Jiang You's persona as the sweet little sister. Both girls are performing versions of themselves to get what they want. The mirror becomes a recurring image — Wen Nian checking her reflection, Jiang You observing her friend. Who are they when no one's watching?
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is honestly masterful and I need to unpack why. It starts slow — a breakfast scene that could have been tedious but isn't, because the author fills every moment with character revelation. The fish maw soup, the carrot cake, the cucumbers, the mother-son dynamic, the father watching everything with a smile. An hour-long breakfast that flies by because nothing is wasted. Then — boom — Fu Qihai and Ruan Guixia leave and Jiang You collapses on her bed. That moment of relief is so well-timed. After the performance of being the perfect guest, we get to see her actually exhausted. It's a breath, a pause, and then Wen Nian calls and the whole energy shifts. The transition to Wen Nian's storyline is where I think the author really earns their keep. We go from the Fu family's refined world to a bedroom that looks like a crime scene, and suddenly the pace is faster, more chaotic, more comedic. The dialogue snaps. Jiang You's deadpan humor — "Did you kill someone at home? Planning to destroy the evidence?" — keeps things moving. And then the Su Rui backstory drops. Two years of history compressed into a few paragraphs: the actor, the father's sabotage, Su Rui's intervention, the birthday, the girlfriend. It's dense but it works because each beat raises the emotional stakes. By the time Wen Nian knocks on that restaurant door, I'm already invested in what happens next. The chapter ends on that knock and I was absolutely ready to turn the page.
... Read More
I need to talk about the pacing in these chapters because the author is doing something really clever and I want to dissect it. Chapter 4 starts with a car ride conversation—low stakes, just two people talking about internships and jewelry companies. It's calm. Peaceful even. Then suddenly they arrive at her apartment and Xu Chaoyang opens his door. BOOM. The energy shifts instantly. The text goes from casual conversation to this charged, silent standoff between two men who both want the same thing but will never admit it. And then Jiang You just stands there confused, like she's watching a tennis match and doesn't know who's serving. The transition from her apartment to the Fu mansion is where the pacing really picks up. She falls asleep in the car, wakes up to a moonlit garden, and suddenly she's in this massive estate that feels like another world. The author describes the cloudstone chandeliers, the begonia-patterned windows, the diamond-shaped shadows moving with their footsteps. It's almost dreamlike. And then—she bumps into his back. Physical contact. The first real touch between them in this sequence. And he catches her. Of course he catches her. But the real pacing masterstroke is the bedroom scene. She's sleepy, clingy, and accidentally says the line that changes everything: 'Can I sleep with you tonight?' And Fu Jin's response—'No!'—is so immediate, so sharp, that you can feel him holding back something much bigger. The text says his face darkened and his eyes had 'two fiery sparks hidden in the depths.' That's not rejection. That's restraint. And the pacing here is perfect because it slows down to almost a stop—we feel every second of that tension—before he escapes like a man running from his own fire. Then Chapter 5 starts with a DREAM. Not a normal morning. A nightmare about her father and half-sister leaving her. She wakes up drenched in sweat, then immediately does this weird calisthenics routine while chanting 'Fairy, get away from me quickly!' Which is hilarious and heartbreaking at the same time. She's literally exorcising her demons before breakfast. And then she's fine. She's smiling. She's making breakfast. The pacing from trauma to normalcy in one paragraph is wild. The breakfast scene itself is structured like a mini-tragedy: she wakes up excited, makes everything, serves it, and then gets rejected by the very people she's trying to impress. The dream mirrors the reality—her father leaving in the dream, the Fu parents leaving at the table. Two abandonments in one chapter. And then Fu Jin's smile saves her again. The structure is: hope → disaster → rescue → hope again. It's a cycle and she's trapped in it.
... Read More
The tension in this section works on so many levels simultaneously and it's exhausting in the best way. On one level, there's the external threat — Bai Hao, who harassed girls and is now facing the Tao family's version of justice. Fu Jin's line 'His hands are too unclean' is delivered so casually but it's genuinely chilling. Then there's the interpersonal tension between Jiang You and Fu Jin, which is basically a pressure cooker of unspoken feelings. She's drunk and bold, he's sober and restrained, and the gap between them is where all the drama lives. But the deepest conflict is internal — Jiang You's realization that she can't stay a child forever in his eyes. When he says 'You've grown up,' it's not rejection, it's something worse: it's the recognition that the rules have changed. And she has to decide what to do with that. The stakes here aren't about life and death (though the Bai Hao subplot dangerously close to that), they're about something more universal — the moment you realize the person you love sees you differently than you see yourself. That's the real suspense, and the author knows how to stretch it out.
... Read More
Okay so the opening with Tang Yu and Fu Jin discussing Bai Hao is such a sharp pivot — one second we're in this domestic, almost cozy vibe with Jiang You getting drunk and Fu Jin caring for her, and the next we're hearing about the Tao family being summoned to deal with someone's hands. It's cold. It's efficient. And honestly it tells us everything we need to know about Fu Jin's world. The plot here is doing double duty: the surface story is a girl trying to win over her older uncle figure, but underneath there's this entire underworld machinery humming along. I love that the author doesn't separate these threads — the Bai Hao situation and the Jiang You romance are happening simultaneously, and they feed each other. Fu Jin's ruthlessness toward Bai Hao makes his gentleness toward Jiang You feel even more deliberate and significant. And then there's the Wen Nian subplot with Jian Shuran — apparently the actor from that drama she was obsessed with? That's a nice touch of realism, like the characters live in a world where pop culture exists. The Qi Ye introduction at the end also adds another layer. This story has range.
... Read More
"You can lose in love, but you can never lose face." This line came out of nowhere and it completely reframed everything that followed. Wen Nian is about to walk into a room and confront the man who rejected her once, and her entire strategy is built on maintaining dignity while pursuing what she wants. The stakes here are layered. On the surface, it's a teenage girl's crush — she likes Su Rui, he rejected her, she wants to try again. But the backstory adds real weight: her father tried to sabotage her relationship with this man, Su Rui went against her family for her, and now she's standing on the edge of potentially losing him too. The power dynamic is everything — he's the successful older man with connections, she's the wealthy but young girl with a crush. Jiang You's own stakes are different but equally high. She's not just helping her friend — she's using this as practice. The text explicitly says she originally planned to use this strategy on Fu Jin. So Wen Nian's confrontation is also Jiang You's rehearsal. If Wen Nian fails, Jiang You learns what not to do. If Wen Nian succeeds, Jiang You learns what works. And then there's the Su Rui mystery itself — the man in the silver-gray suit, the frameless glasses, the broad shoulders. He's described almost like a romance novel hero, and the fact that he already has a girlfriend (or had one) adds another layer of complication. The restaurant door opens, he appears, and the chapter cuts. The tension is unbearable and I need to know what happens next
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this out loud because I need to process it: Fu Jin is NOT just an uncle figure here and I think the author knows it. The way he looks at Jiang You? The way his pupils go dark when she bumps into his back? When he literally lifts her into his arms like she weighs nothing and she wraps her arms around his neck and his breath gets hot against her skin and he goes rigid like a mountain? That is not a man who sees a little girl. That is a man fighting a war inside his own chest. And then Xu Chaoyang shows up and suddenly the hallway feels like a battlefield. The text literally says Fu Jin exuded hostility, like a lion protecting its territory. A LION. Not a protective guardian. A predator. And Xu Chaoyang felt it too—he couldn't help but feel a chill in his bones even though it was summer. That scene where he looks at Fu Jin and thinks 'Where did this extra uncle come from?' and then slams his door like he's escaping something? Chef's kiss. But here's what really got me: Fu Jin's smile. The text says ever since he returned from abroad, she hadn't seen that kind of smile again. And then when she's crying over the breakfast disaster, his smile is described as warm like a fire in a winter fireplace. That's the moment she stops crying. That's the moment she grabs his hand and tries to pull him to the table like nothing happened. She's been abandoned before—her father and half-sister left her in a dream sequence that shattered her—and Fu Jin's smile is the anchor that pulls her back to reality. The mother-son dynamic with Mr. and Mrs. Fu is also interesting. They're uncomfortable with the pigweed and century eggs and shrimp allergy but don't say anything until AFTER she's already made everything. That's a cultural thing maybe, but it also shows how Jiang You keeps trying to win people over and keeps messing up because she doesn't know the rules. She's always one step behind, always preparing for a rejection that's already happened. And the fact that she sets alarms for EVERY hour just to make breakfast for his parents? That's not just politeness. That's a girl who is terrified of being unwanted and is trying to earn her place at the table. One way or another.
... Read More
I need to talk about this villa because the description is actually stunning. Three thousand square meters, traditional Chinese garden style, craftsmen who worked on the Forbidden City, Lake Tai stones, million-dollar viewing trees. And it was a TEN-YEAR wedding gift. The name itself — Qixia, pulled from the couple's names — that's such a romantic detail that most romance novels skip over but this one lingers on. What struck me most was how the setting mirrors the emotional landscape. The villa is beautiful but also a fortress — it's where Fu Jin lives separately from his parents, where Jiang You is a guest who doesn't quite belong, where Wen Nian's family isn't quite powerful enough to sit at the same table. The physical space tells you everything about hierarchy and belonging. Then you jump to Wen Nian's house — high-end villa in the city center, but the bedroom is described as a crime scene. Eyeshadow scattered, skirts on the floor, the whole dramatic setup for a girl who's about to confront the man she likes. It's such a vivid contrast: the Fu family's ordered, beautiful, ancient elegance versus Wen Nian's chaotic, expensive, teenage desperation. Both are wealthy, both are beautiful, but they feel like entirely different worlds. And the restaurant scene at the end — Su Rui booking a private room in a trendy spot because he thinks Wen Nian is too young. The author doesn't describe the restaurant at all, which is interesting. It's deliberately empty of detail, which makes me think the setting doesn't matter — it's all about the power dynamic in that room.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this plot works because it's not doing what I expected. On the surface, this is a romance about a girl who moves in with her 'uncle' and there's obvious tension. But the plot is actually about a girl learning whether she's allowed to want things. Every chapter is structured around desire and denial. Chapter 4 starts with her wanting to know which jewelry company she'll intern at—career desire. Then she wants to stay at the Fu mansion—safety desire. Then she wants to sleep next to Fu Jin—intimacy desire. Each desire is met with a soft denial. The internship isn't decided yet. She can stay but not in the main house. She can't sleep with him. And each denial is gentle, which makes it hurt more. But then Chapter 5 introduces a new plot thread: the nightmare. This is where the author reveals that Jiang You's past isn't just backstory—it's an active plot force. The dream about her father and half-sister isn't random. It's the reason she's clinging to Fu Jin. It's the reason she sets ten alarms. It's the reason she's terrified of the Fu parents' discomfort. The plot structure here is circular. She wakes up from a nightmare → makes breakfast → gets rejected → Fu Jin's smile saves her → she's fine again. This is her life in miniature. Trauma, effort, rejection, rescue, repeat. The author is showing us that Jiang You is stuck in a loop and doesn't know how to break it. What's brilliant is how the author uses the Fu parents as a mirror. In the dream, her father rejects her food. In reality, the Fu parents also reject her food (indirectly). Two rejections, two tables, two versions of the same pain. But Fu Jin is different—he doesn't reject her. He stays. He smiles. He says 'I like it' even though she didn't make anything for him specifically in that first breakfast disaster. The plot is also setting up a love triangle, but quietly. Xu Chaoyang is across the hall, watching, suspicious, protective. He's the neighbor who's always been there. Fu Jin is the man who came back from abroad and immediately claimed territory. The plot hasn't declared the triangle yet—it's still whispering. But the hallway standoff was the first real signal. And the ending of Chapter 5? Mrs. Fu pulling Jiang You close, glancing at her son, saying 'What did you make for him? He eats anything, don't tire yourself out.' That glance—what was in it? Approval? Concern? Calculation? The plot is laying bricks and I'm already building a house in my head.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or