The symbolism in these first seven chapters is layered and deliberate. Let me start with the roses—they're everywhere, blooming in summer, filling the air with fragrance, giving the mansion its nickname. But roses are thorny, and the beauty here masks something darker. The White Rose Residence is a gilded cage, just like Estelle's family home, just like the identity she's forced to wear.
Names are the second major symbol, and honestly the most devastating one. Estelle works as "Lumiere." The Duke calls out "Lumiere" in passion, thinking it's Estelle's name. Her twin sister stole her identity in life AND in love. The question of who gets to be seen, who gets to be known—it runs through every relationship in this story.
Then there's silence versus sound. The four rules demand suppression—no noise, no breathing, no movement. But Estelle breaks every rule. She makes herself heard, she takes up space, she whispers and cries and laughs. Her voice is her rebellion. And yet, in the most ironic twist, the Duke doesn't even know her real name. She's screaming silently into his ears.
The closed curtains in Rule One are also significant—what is being kept hidden? What truths are being blocked from view? The Duke himself is something of a closed book: we know he's powerful, wealthy, devoted to a memory, but his full history remains shadowed, literally described as "shrouded in deep shadows" in the moonlight.
And Estelle's silver hair—woven from moonlight, turning pale gold in sunset, making her look like a "moon fairy." She's otherworldly, almost too luminous for this world, which both elevates and isolates her. Beauty as both gift and curse, a recurring motif.
The deeper theme, I think, is about recognition. Who sees Estelle? Who truly knows her? The Duke sees her body and hears her voice but doesn't know her name. Her family sees her utility but not her worth. Only Katie sees her clearly. And Estelle herself is still learning to see herself.