Mixed - Reviews

Mixed
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say - the way this author handles the Chi Nuan and Song Shixue dynamic is honestly painful to read in the best way. I kept thinking about how Chi Nuan literally dreams about this person every night for three years and yet the moment she sees her in person, all she wants to do is run home. That contradiction? Chef's kiss. But here's what really got me - the bracelet. When Song Shixue grabs Chi Nuan's wrist and she sees it, you realize this isn't just some casual breakup story. Chi Nuan made that bracelet by hand. It had imperfections. She poured love into something imperfect, and Song Shixue kept wearing it for three years after abandoning her. That detail alone tells you more than any dialogue could. I also had to laugh at Xiao Li's internal monologue. While everyone else is sensing 'tension' and 'a feud,' Xiao Li is over here thinking triangles are stable and wondering if they were a couple. The assistant character is even worse - that whole flamboyant entrance with the pink frames and the "Angry Dragon" comment just screams he's trying way too hard to be protective but ends up being insufferable. What's fascinating is how both women seem frozen in time. Chi Nuan hasn't moved on at all - she's stuck in this cycle of rage and longing. But Song Shixue? She came back voluntarily. She specifically requested Chi Nuan without telling her why. She's still wearing the bracelet. Something happened three years ago that we don't fully understand yet, and the fact that she can't even explain it beyond "I'm sorry" is driving Chi Nuan absolutely insane. The power dynamic is also interesting - Chi Nuan is clearly successful (she drives a BMW M5, she's a Photography Director at 25), but emotionally she's completely at Song Shixue's mercy. Every time Song Shixue speaks softly or uses that old coaxing tone, Chi Nuan's defenses crack a little. That scene where her voice "instinctively softened by a fraction" when Song Shixue asks her to stay? That's not anger talking - that's three years of love breaking through.
... Read More
Let me just say this straight up: Jiang Luohe is the most dangerously persistent person I have ever encountered in fiction and I am not okay. She gets explicitly told "I don't like you" at breakfast and her reaction is basically to sit back down and ask if she can keep pursuing Song Shixue. Her internal monologue — that since Song Shixue has no partner, she still has a 50% chance regardless of sexual orientation — is simultaneously terrifying and hilarious. The author wrote Song Shixue thinking she looks at Jiang Luohe and feels nothing but irritation, yet here this woman is treating a direct rejection like a suggestion box. But the REAL conflict isn't even between Song Shixue and Jiang Luohe. It's the triangle forming between all three of them, and the stakes keep rising. Chi Nuan watching from the pickup gate, seeing Song Shixue walk past her without acknowledgment, and immediately assuming the worst. The airport scene where Jiang Luohe deliberately positions herself side-by-side with Song Shixue knowing full well Chi Nuan is watching. Song Shixue calling Chi Nuan to the underground parking because she can't handle the sobbing on the phone. Every conflict layer is compounding on top of the other and I cannot look away.
... Read More
The spatial choreography in this chapter is actually really sophisticated and I want to talk about it. There are four distinct environments, each one reflecting a different emotional state for Song Shixue, and they move from claustrophobic intimacy to cold public performance. First: Song Shixue's apartment. The imagery here is so specific — the empty cigarette case with just crumpled foil and traces of tobacco, the camisole strap slipped down to a mole, the half-raised knee creating a curve that the narration specifically notes would make someone look like a "beautiful crazy person." This is a woman alone with her thoughts and they are NOT kind. The hot milk ritual, the black coffee, the stove with half a pot of clear water — every object is a beat in a loneliness symphony. The scallion oil noodles cooking becomes the centerpiece of this domestic theater, steam and aroma filling a space that was previously just... empty. Second: the bathroom connected to that apartment, where Chi Nuan suffers. Suddenly the intimate space fractures into vulnerability and care. The toilet bowl, the medicine cabinet search, the crouching positions — it's all lower camera angles, closer framing. Domestic crisis as romantic confrontation. Third: the airport and the hotel room in Beicheng. Cold, transient, functional. The text notes Song Shixue never likes airplane meals or late-night snacks — this is a woman who exists in motion, not in place. The curry pork chop rice scene with the unwanted mojito and the greasy man adds a layer of public discomfort that contrasts sharply with the private tenderness she just shared with Chi Nuan. Fourth: the seminar venue, formal and bright, where Song Shixue becomes "the leader of the current young generation." The golden lighting, the applause, the elderly artists fawning over her — it's all performance. And then Jiang Luohe enters like a red stain across this pristine white canvas, and the worldbuilding just got a lot more dangerous.
... Read More
I need to talk about the hug. Just the hug. Because it is THE moment of this entire chapter and possibly the whole novel so far. Let me set the scene: Chi Nuan just found out Song Shixue was in a relationship. A real one. Lasted half a month but apparently left scars. She's trying to be brave, trying not to fall apart in the car, and she says she wants to go back to school. She's running away from the pain of knowing Song Shixue belonged to someone else before her. And Song Shixue — cold, distant, unreadable Song Shixue — says: "Chi Nuan, come here for a moment, please?" Please? Song Shixue doesn't use that word casually. She pulls Chi Nuan in. One hand on the shoulder, one around the waist. And then — here's the thing that killed me — she slowly releases the hand around Chi Nuan's waist and says, "It's a bit warm." That is such a Song Shixue move. She can't just say what she means. She can't say "don't go" or "I don't care about the past" or "you matter to me." She buries it under a practical excuse about temperature. But her ear tips are pink. The narration tells us Chi Nuan notices and smiles so slightly that Song Shixue doesn't even see it. And then the internal monologue — "Song Shixue, you only need to take the initiative once toward me, and I will take the initiative thousands and thousands of times toward you." That line absolutely destroyed me. Chi Nuan has made this decision. She has chosen, fully and completely, to love this person who struggles to show it. But what also struck me is how Song Shixue's perspective shifts throughout the chapter. She's aware of Chi Nuan's emotions — she notices when Chi Nuan is unhappy, she knows it's jealousy, she wants her to stay longer. She's not blind. She just doesn't know how to bridge the gap.
... Read More
There's so much symbolism packed into these chapters and I'm still processing it all. The butterfly motif is obviously huge - Song Shixue comes out wearing transparent butterfly wings, and the theme is Spring, rebirth, freedom. But butterflies are also fragile creatures that leave cocoons behind. Is Song Shixue the butterfly that escaped three years ago? Or is Chi Nuan the one trapped, staring at the butterfly through a lens, unable to reach it? The concept of muteness is fascinating too. The text literally says they communicated through eyes, like Song Shixue was "mute" back then. And now? Song Shixue can't seem to find words beyond "I'm sorry." There's this whole theme about things left unsaid, about communication breaking down, about people who can express everything through art or photography or glances but nothing in plain speech. Chi Nuan as a photographer is basically a modern-day oracle - she captures truth through her lens. She sees everything, understands everyone's emotions, but she can't see into Song Shixue's heart. The camera is both her power and her limitation. She can freeze moments in time, but she can't change them. She can capture beauty, but she can't make someone stay. The Star Bracelet is probably the most important symbol. It's handmade, imperfect, worn for three years despite the abandonment. It represents love that persists despite hurt, a connection that survives distance and silence. But it's also a chain in a way - Song Shixue wears it while refusing to explain herself. Is it devotion or guilt? Or both? I'm also struck by the dream imagery from the opening. The idea that dreaming of someone uses up your chances of meeting them in reality - well, Chi Nuan clearly used up all her dreams because now they're actually together and it's devastating. The dreams were safer. In dreams, Song Shixue couldn't leave again. The title "Mixed" itself feels symbolic - mixed emotions, mixed signals, mixed signals, mixed history. Nothing is clean or simple here.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in controlled pacing, and I want to break down exactly how it works because the author is doing something really sophisticated here. The chapter opens with low-stakes energy — a supermarket trip, cooking, casual conversation. It's warm, almost sleepy. You could read this part and think, okay, this is a cozy character study. And that's intentional. The author is lulling us into comfort before pulling the rug out. The cooking scene peaks at Chi Nuan's enthusiastic reaction: "It's so delicious! Teacher Song, it's even better than what they make in restaurants outside!" Her cheeks puffed out, looking satisfied. Song Shixue's response — that slow curve of her lips, that tenderness in her eyes — is the last purely warm moment before everything shifts. Then: Song Shixue stands up, goes to the kitchen, goes to the balcony. The pace slows further, almost to a standstill. Smoke rises. Questions are asked. The past is revealed. This is the chapter's gravitational center, and the author gives it room to breathe. After the emotional climax, the pace picks up again but now with a completely different energy. The car ride back is tense and quiet. Chi Nuan's request to leave creates urgency. The supermarket encounter with Chen Zhiyu feels almost comedic in its normalcy — and that's what makes it unsettling, because we just spent ten pages in heavy emotional territory and now we're talking about bubble tea and movies. The chapter ends on what could be called a cliffhanger — Chi Nuan checking her phone obsessively, no reply from Song Shixue, and then... she walks toward a fried chicken place. Where is she going? What happens next? The author has positioned us perfectly for the next chapter's conflict. What's remarkable is that despite all these shifts in tone and pace, nothing feels jarring. The emotional arc — warmth to tension to heartbreak to tentative connection — flows naturally because every beat is earned.
... Read More
Let me just say — the domestic scenes in this chapter are absolutely gorgeous and I need to dissect why. The supermarket sequence is one of those perfect slice-of-life moments that makes you feel like you're actually there. Song Shixue picking up chili peppers, asking if Chi Nuan can eat spicy food. Chi Nuan internally screaming with joy because Teacher Song is showing interest in her preferences. The shopping cart exchange where Chi Nuan begs to help push it — "since you're treating me to dinner, can't you at least let me help with the heavy lifting?" And then the petulant pout and double blink that makes Song Shixue freeze internally because WHY IS CHI NUAN SO CUTE. Then the kitchen. Chi Nuan immediately going to work, cutting green pepper stems, the two of them cooking together. The narration notes that this is perfectly normal for an average family but for Song Shixue, solitude has always been the norm. That single sentence does so much worldbuilding about this character's life of isolation. And the dining table scene — "She ate very little; she felt full after consuming barely a third of her bowl of rice." But she's not full from food. She's full from the overwhelming normalcy of sharing a meal with someone she cares about. The balcony scene shifts the atmosphere entirely. Night, city lights, cigarette smoke, blueberry and mint. The narration says "just looking at her silhouette, she felt that the night and Song Shixue were a perfect match." That's such a visual — this woman who carries darkness inside her, standing against the backdrop of a dark sky, and Chi Nuan watching from inside, unable to look away. The final scene at the movie theater with Chen Zhiyu provides this bright, noisy counterpoint to all the intimacy — the casual friendship, the bubble tea shop, the group photo posted online. It's almost too normal, which makes the underlying tension even sharper.
... Read More
The imagery in this section is actually insane and I need to appreciate it. First there's the awards ceremony—Chi Nuan walking toward the podium and ALL the lights converging on her, bathed in golden glow, described as a star shining with its most dazzling brilliance. It's such a visual moment, like the whole scene just opens up around her. And then CUT TO Song Shixue standing in the DARKNESS below the stage, watching from the shadows. The contrast is intentional and it hurts my feelings. Song Shixue has spent so long in her gray world and Chi Nuan is this golden thing on a stage and Song Shixue is down here in the dark taking photos instead of going up there to claim her spot. Then we get Song Shixue's studio—the easel, the oil painting, the way she uses cool tones for everything except Chi Nuan's eyes which are warm orange-yellow. This detail gave me actual chills. The fact that Chi Nuan is the ONLY warm thing in Song Shixue's entire artistic vision? That's not subtle worldbuilding, that's the author laying it on thick and I am HERE FOR IT. And the balcony scene at night—Song Shixue in gray-white silk pajamas, cigarette in hand, looking at stars, phone glowing with Chi Nuan's photo as her chat background. This is cinematic. This is a movie. The author keeps giving us these perfectly framed visual moments that just *breathe* atmosphere. I keep forgetting to take notes because I'm too busy trying to mentally storyboard everything.
... Read More
There's a theme running through these chapters that I can't stop thinking about: the act of looking. Of seeing. Of being seen. Chi Nuan's entire relationship with Song Shixue begins with a photograph—something captured without permission, something that froze a moment in time and made it permanent. She took the photo because Song was "too beautiful, too dazzling" and she "really couldn't resist." But what she couldn't resist wasn't just Song's appearance. It was the possibility of truly seeing someone, of preserving that vision. Photography is her language of love and it's only now that she's learning to use her voice instead of her lens. Song, on the other hand, sees Chi Nuan in multiple ways that carry symbolic weight. She sees her in class—noticing the furrowed brows, creating the nickname "Little Black Shiba." She sees her in photographs, studying the composition and lighting with genuine admiration. And then she sees her in a drawing, involuntarily sketching her face at midnight. Each medium—photography, art, memory—becomes a way of processing what Song feels but cannot say. The nightmare sequence introduces another layer of symbolism: the cycle of violence and trauma. Song Maoye beating Cheng Xue, the belt described as "biting" skin like a mad dog, the pool of blood—these images aren't just backstory. They're the ghost that drives Song's fear of intimacy. When she kisses Chi Nuan in the bar, she's reaching toward connection while simultaneously drowning in the memory of what connection has cost her before. "Next, it's your turn..."—the nightmare ends there, but it echoes throughout the present. Song isn't just afraid of being hurt. She's afraid of becoming the thing that hurts. And that's why she pulls away after the most vulnerable moment, why she becomes cold the morning after. The trauma isn't in the past for her. It's in the furniture of her every decision.
... Read More
The balcony scene. I've read it three times now and each time it hits differently. Song Shixue is on the balcony, smoking, looking at the city lights. The narration describes the air as thick with scent of blueberry and mint — which is probably Chi Nuan's perfume or soap, now mixed with cigarette smoke. That sensory detail alone tells you something: these two worlds are colliding. Chi Nuan asks about the smoking. Song Shixue gives a vague answer about it being a habit. Then the question that changes everything: "Teacher Song, have you ever been in a relationship?" What follows is the most emotionally dense passage in this entire batch. We learn about Song Shixue's freshman year, her confusion about her feelings for another girl, the brief relationship that lasted only half a month, and the cruelty of those final words: "If you weren't so good-looking, I wouldn't have lasted half a month!" Notice how the betrayal isn't just about the breakup — it's about the conditions of it. She was loved only for her looks, and even that love was fragile enough to shatter over difficulty. No wonder Song Shixue built walls. But the emotional peak comes when Song Shixue says just two words: "I have." She could have lied. She could have deflected. But she doesn't. She tells the truth to Chi Nuan, even though it clearly costs her something. And Chi Nuan's response — to leave, to force a smile, to run — that's not weakness. That's honesty. She's scared, she's hurt, and she knows it. The tragedy is that both of them want the same thing but neither knows how to ask for it directly. The hug at the end is Song Shixue's first real initiative. One time. And Chi Nuan's inner vow to reciprocate a thousand times over is the kind of devotion that makes your chest ache.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the awards ceremony scene because this is where the author really pulled something clever. Chi Nuan gives this speech that sounds completely generic on the surface—"thank you judges, thank you family and friends, I hope you have a pleasant day today"—but then she drops the mic with "I hope you have a pleasant day today" which EVERYONE online interprets as some grand romantic gesture while we, the readers, know EXACTLY who she was talking about. The dramatic irony here is *chef's kiss*. Meanwhile Song Shixue is sitting in the darkness below the stage, heart doing Olympic gymnastics, wondering if Chi Nuan spotted her. And she did! Chi Nuan smiled at her! But neither of them will ever actually confirm this out loud. The subplot with the online comments is also doing heavy lifting here. People calling Chi Nuan attention-seeking, disgusting, copying others—that's the author planting seeds for future conflict. Someone is going to find out about Song Shixue and Chi Nuan's relationship and it's NOT going to be pretty. The fact that Song Shixue immediately starts reporting those comments tells us everything we need to know about where her loyalties lie. Also the hotpot dinner invitation is basically Chapter 14's version of a plot twist—Chi Nuan asking to come over and Song Shixue saying yes so casually when we've been watching her resist for literal chapters. Something is shifting.
... Read More
"It feels like there are so many bugs crawling inside." — I NEED A MOMENT. This line from Chi Nuan during her allergic reaction is somehow both the most visceral description of physical suffering and the most heartbreaking moment of devotion in the entire chapter. Let's break down why this destroys me. Song Shixue is crouched beside Chi Nuan, holding her throat, whispering "be good, bear with it" like she's soothing a wounded animal. Chi Nuan is gasping, face red, scratching at her neck, and still — STILL — her gasps and hot breath fall onto Song Shixue's collarbone. And Song Shixue is trying so hard to not react to it. The text literally says she's suppressing her desire. Desire. Not worry. Not concern. Desire. But then the moment shifts and becomes almost sweet in its tenderness. Song Shixue applying erythromycin ointment with cotton swabs, their eyes meeting, both of them swallowing at the same time. The parallelism here is so deliberate it hurts. They're both feeling the exact same thing and neither will say it. And Chi Nuan's reaction afterward — "Teacher Song, please don't be angry, okay" — the way she drops into that subservient position, half-kneeling, acting coquettish to diffuse Song Shixue's frustration? That's love language, baby. That's someone who has memorized exactly how to make another person soft. I am not okay. The moment is shattered by the phone ringing. Of course it is. Just when everything could have been different. A man named Qin Shanshu needs Song Shixue to go to Beicheng for a seminar and suddenly we're back to reality. But not before Song Shixue reads those thirty-something WeChat messages from Chi Nuan and smiles. God, I hope she doesn't forget that smile on the airplane.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or