Mixed - Reviews

Mixed
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how HIGH the stakes are here? This isn't some light rom-com where they'll make up by chapter five. The emotional damage runs so deep that every interaction feels like it could be the breaking point. Chi Nuan's internal conflict is brutal. She literally hates that Song Shixue is back, she's angry about being called in on her day off, she wanted to walk out immediately - but she CAN'T. Because underneath all that rage is three years of longing, of dreams, of sending messages to a red exclamation mark. She's torn between self-preservation and this pull she can't explain. Song Shixue is dealing with her own conflicts too. She came back voluntarily - she主动 contacted the company, she requested Chi Nuan specifically, she wore the bracelet. But she also can't explain WHY she left. "I'm sorry" doesn't cut it when someone deleted all your contacts and disappeared without a word. She wants reconciliation but won't give the explanation that would make it possible. The external conflict with the assistant is almost comedic compared to the main drama, but it serves a purpose - it raises the temperature, forces Song Shixue to choose sides, and gives Chi Nuan someone to direct her frustration toward when Song Shixue won't give her what she needs. What makes this work so well is that the author never lets the stakes drop. Even during the photoshoot - which should be professional and detached - there's constant tension. They're touching, guiding, looking into each other's eyes through a lens. It's intimate but charged with unresolved history. Every pose, every glance, every technical instruction is loaded with meaning neither of them will name. And that bracelet moment? That's when the stakes become existential. It's not just about whether they'll get back together - it's about whether Chi Nuan can trust anything Song Shixue says or does. If she kept the bracelet but still left, what does that mean? What does that make Chi Nuan's three years of pain? The suspense is maintained beautifully because we're constantly waiting for the explanation that never comes. Every chapter raises more questions than it answers. When will Song Shixue actually tell her why? Can Chi Nuan forgive her? What happened three years ago? The author keeps pulling the thread and we're all just hanging on desperately.
... Read More
Let's talk about scallions. Scallions. In a novel where food seems to carry meaning heavier than dialogue, this过敏反应 is the central symbol of the entire relationship, and I am not taking this back. Scallion oil noodles — 葱油面 — are a dish of simplicity and warmth. Song Shixue making them is an act of care, the kind of thing you make for someone you want to nourish and keep close. But Chi Nuan is allergic. She cannot eat them. And yet she does. Not because she wants to, not because she's foolish, but because the alternative — telling Song Shixue "you made this and I can't have it" — would wound the giver more than the allergen wounds the receiver. This is the core metaphor operating beneath the entire text: the things we swallow to preserve someone else's feelings. The allergies we hide. The love we endure instead of communicate. But there's another layer. Song Shixue, who seemingly knows everything about Chi Nuan, doesn't know THIS. What else doesn't she know? What other allergies — emotional, psychological, spiritual — exists in this relationship that neither party has named? The text keeps returning to the idea that Song Shixue is gathering information about Chi Nuan (checking Moments, zooming in on photos) but gathering data is not the same as understanding. Then there's the hot milk. Song Shixue drinks it hoping it will "erase everything she had seen and heard today." She wants to sleep through her own feelings. The milk doesn't work perfectly — she sleeps until noon instead of falling into oblivion — but the desire for erasure is telling. What is Song Shixue trying to unsee? The photo with Chen Zhiyu? The way Chi Nuan looked at her? The fact that this woman exists outside of Song Shixue's control? And Chi Nuan's scratched neck — those marks from her own desperate scratching, left behind like a trail of evidence. Song Shixue applies ointment to them, healing what her own ignorance helped create. The caretaker becomes the causer becomes the healer, in one continuous loop.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the pacing in these chapters is absolutely calculated? It starts slow and domestic—the dorm room banter with Chen Zhiyu, the casual shower-and-text routine—and then BOOM, awards ceremony, public speech, online wildfire, Song Shixue painting secrets, the whole thing accelerates like a car hitting turbo. But the real pacing masterstroke is the good night exchange. Chi Nuan sends "good night" and adds "see you tomorrow" and that tiny addition is the ENTIRE emotional turning point of this section. Think about it—she's been writing "wan an" (good night) for days because of some cute pinyin coincidence she heard, and suddenly she upgrades it. She's not just saying good night anymore, she's saying SEE YOU TOMORROW. And Song Shixue agrees to let her come over. This single punctuation mark change is worth more than entire chapters of confession scenes. The transition between Chi Nuan's side and Song Shixue's side is also perfectly executed. We get Chi Nuan bouncing around excited, then CUT to Song Shixue alone in her studio, painting, smoking, lying awake staring at the ceiling wondering "is what I'm doing right?" That last line hit me like a truck. Both of them can't sleep. Both of them are overthinking. The parallel structure of their insomnia is gorgeous. The only thing I'd complain about is the chapter ending mid-scene in the supermarket with the kid almost running into Song Shixue. I know it's a cliffhanger but it's also just... cruel? I need the NEXT chapter immediately.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how sensory this writing is? I'm not even being dramatic. Every scene has a distinct olfactory and visual identity that makes it feel like I was there. The office scene—"the evening breeze carried a pleasant, woody scent"—that description of Song Shixue's personal fragrance is something I will never get over. It's mentioned again when Chi Nuan finds her at the bar and the "classic cologne scent rushed toward her." The author uses smell as an emotional anchor. Every time Chi Nuan smells that woody-citrus thing, she's drawn to Song. It's almost primal in how it's written. The bar itself is rendered with enough detail to film: "dim lighting," "red light," "loud, noisy music and cheers." But the most powerful visual moment is Song sitting alone by the window, strands of hair on her forehead, cheeks flushed—not drunk in a comedic way, but drunk in a quiet, aching way that makes the predatory glances of strangers around her feel genuinely threatening. And then Jiangnan Bay: "soothing orange scent," minimalist wooden style, two framed paintings on the wall. This is a home that belongs to someone who values order and beauty precisely because her inner life has none of those things. The contrast between the clean, sharp apartment and the chaos inside Song's head is one of the most effective uses of setting I've read in a long time.
... Read More
Let me just say — the stakes in this book are NOT subtle and I am HERE for it. On the surface, Song Shixue lost her mother. That's the external conflict — a woman beaten into a vegetative state by Song Maoye, held alive for four years, and now gone. But the real stakes are internal, and they're devastating. Song Shixue spent her entire adult life becoming strong enough to protect someone, and the moment she achieved that strength, she lost her. That is cruel in a way that goes beyond plot convenience. And then there's Chi Nuan. Her conflict is quieter but no less real. She's terrified — of rejection, of being used, of crossing a line with her teacher. But when Song Shixue goes missing, fear gets replaced by something else entirely. The stakes shift from emotional vulnerability to literal survival. "Please don't let anything happen." That's not about pride anymore. That's about love, whether either of them has named it yet. The question hanging over everything is: can Song Shixue let someone in before it's too late? Because right now, she's surviving, but she's not living. And Chi Nuan is the threat to that survival — not because she's dangerous, but because she makes Song Shixue want something she's convinced she doesn't deserve.
... Read More
I need to talk about the supermarket scene because it is THE scene. Four centimeters. That's how close Chi Nuan's hand was to Song Shixue's wrist before she chickened out. FOUR CENTIMETERS and the author made me SCREAM. Let me just sit with that for a moment. But here's what's actually brilliant about this moment—Song Shixue NOTICES. She slows her steps. She's expectant. The tension between these two isn't just one-sided pining, it's a TANGO and both of them are just desperately trying not to step on each other's toes. Then BAM, a kid runs into Song Shixue and Chi Nuan's body reacts before her brain does, pulling Song Shixue into her arm, chests close, breathing the same air. And Song Shixue's internal thought? "I really want to bite her." NOT "I really want to hold her hand." NOT anything wholesome. She wants to BITE her. That is such a Song Shixue thought. So possessive and feral and completely unlike anything she'd ever say out loud. Meanwhile Chen Zhiyu is over here acting as our comic relief wingwoman, completely oblivious but also somehow the most emotionally perceptive person in the room. She's the one who notices Song Shixue at the ceremony, she's the one who calls out Chi Nuan's obsession, she's the friend who exists solely to make us root harder for these two. I swear if Chen Zhiyu doesn't get her own spinoff I'm going to be so upset.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the stakes in this story are NOT about whether they end up together. Anyone reading this knows they're going to end up together. The tension comes from HOW painful the path is going to be for both of them, and that's what makes it so gripping. Song Shixue's internal conflict is laid bare in this passage: "She was afraid of forming intimate relationships. She believed that once an intimate relationship formed, she would inevitably mess it up in the end." That single paragraph contains her entire emotional backstory and her core wound. Every time Chi Nuan gets close, Song Shixue pulls back—not because she doesn't want her, but because she's convinced she'll destroy whatever this is. The external conflict is smaller but equally tense—the award ceremony invitation, the awkward rejection, the whole "in what capacity" moment. Chi Nuan is standing there with an IV drip counting down, literally struggling to articulate what she is to this woman, and Song Shixue can't even look at her when she says no. But the real stakes are in those tiny moments. Like when Song Shixue wants to walk over and hug Chi Nuan at the base of the Teaching Building but "never found the resolve to take that step." She's physically incapable of crossing that distance. That's the conflict—the body wants to move but the mind won't allow it. And Chi Nuan's side of the conflict is just as sharp. She's constantly negotiating between wanting closeness and being terrified of being too much. The chapter ends on this note where Song Shixue walks up the stairs and doesn't even say goodnight. Not because she doesn't care, but because if she says it, she might say too much. The stakes are emotional survival, and that's infinitely higher than any plot drama could ever be.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the way this chapter structures its drama is genuinely clever, and I need to talk about it because most people will probably breeze past it. The chapter opens with this seemingly throwaway scene in a supermarket where a little boy scratches Song Shixue's dress. But look at what happens next: Chi Nuan notices terror in Song Shixue's smile, not kindness. That's a tiny detail, right? But it immediately establishes that Song Shixue has edges, that she's not just the gentle teacher everyone sees. And then Chi Nuan protects her from creepy men without even making a big deal out of it — she just moves faster, glares, and makes it clear. Then the cooking scene. Sweet, domestic, warm. The kind of scene that makes you soft. And then — BAM — the balcony. Song Shixue smoking. Chi Nuan asking about her past relationship. The whole emotional floor drops out from under us. What's brilliant about the plot structure here is that the author doesn't just dump exposition. Song Shixue barely says anything about her ex — just "I have" when asked — but we get this entire flashback through narrative summary, and it's devastating. "Anyone who falls for you in the future must have the worst luck imaginable!" I literally gasped reading that. The author trusts us to understand the damage without spelling it out. And then Chi Nuan's reaction — asking to go back to school, forcing a smile, knowing she'll fall apart if she stays one minute longer — that's not just plot, that's character-driven plot. Every beat follows from who these people are. The chapter ends with Chi Nuan checking her phone constantly after posting about the movie, which is both funny and heartbreaking because we know Song Shixue didn't even reply. The setup for the next conflict is already there.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how these two communicate for a second, because the dialogue in this chapter is absolutely phenomenal. The conversation in the supermarket is so naturally casual — Chi Nuan asking about dishes, Song Shixue responding like a normal adult asking a normal teenager her preferences. But there's this undercurrent of meaning in everything. When Song Shixue says "Yes, as long as it's not too rare," and Chi Nuan lights up about sweet and sour pork — that's not just about food. That's two people learning each other, building a shared language. Then there's the dialogue on the balcony, which is where the author really shows their skill: "Teacher Song, why do you smoke?" "It's a habit, I suppose." Simple. Flat. But underneath it is a lifetime of habit and coping mechanism. And then: "Teacher Song, have you ever been in a relationship?" This question hangs in the air like smoke. Song Shixue's answer is two words: "I have." That's it. Two words carrying the weight of a broken first love, self-discovery, betrayal, and the ongoing fear of being abandoned. And Chi Nuan hears all of that in those two words. Later, when Song Shixue says "It's a bit warm" after the hug — that's such a perfectly Song Shixue thing to say. She cannot express affection directly, so she wraps it in practicality. But the narration tells us her ears are pink, and Chi Nuan sees it. The dialogue says one thing, the body language says another, and the reader gets the truth. Chen Zhiyu's dialogue provides this wonderful contrast — fast, loud, analytical: "First, she immediately stared at our linked arms! Second..." She's the audience surrogate, naming what we've all been suspecting. And Chi Nuan's response to Song Shixue's text — not replying, just tossing the phone aside — says more about Song Shixue's emotional state than any dialogue could. The silence between words is where this story lives.
... Read More
I need to talk about the stakes in this story because honestly they're stacked so high and the author doesn't even seem to realize how brutal this setup is. On the surface, Chi Nuan has a crush on her professor. That's already problematic — power dynamics, professional boundaries, the whole thing. But then add in the fact that Song Shixue is a 27-year-old successful artist who has built a reputation, and Chi Nuan is a college student who depends on her grades and academic standing. The conflict isn't just "will they or won't they" — it's "what happens if this goes wrong and Chi Nuan loses everything she's worked for?" And then there's the queer angle, which the text addresses directly through Chen Zhiyu's panicked note: "What if she doesn't like girls, or she's married, or has kids!" The author isn't ignoring this. In today's society, heterosexuality is still mainstream. The chance of Song Shixue being gay is even smaller. This isn't just romantic obstacle — it's structural. The world itself is stacked against them. But here's what makes me keep reading: the stakes aren't only external. Chi Nuan's internal conflict is what really gets me. She's aware of everything that could go wrong. She knows Song Shixue is unreachable. And yet she writes on that piece of paper: "I have to reach out to have a chance." That's the kind of courage that comes from someone who has nothing left to lose because she's already given everything to this feeling. The tension isn't just about whether they'll end up together — it's about whether Chi Nuan will find the strength to be honest with herself even when the odds are absurdly against her.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about the video call scene because WOW. Chi Nuan watching Song Shixue do her post-seminar wind-down routine and then dropping that line about being proud of her... I literally stopped breathing. The way Chi Nuan tries to hide her tears by blaming it on the wind? The author wrote: "the wind is too strong this night, and it makes my eyes uncomfortable" and I was wheezing because of course that's what she says instead of just admitting she's overwhelmed with emotion. And then Song Shixue seeing right through it but NOT calling her out — she just plays along and teases her instead. That's not just subtlety, that's affection. The way they dance around everything without ever saying the actual words... I've been screaming into a pillow for twenty minutes. But then — and this is what destroyed me — Song Shixue seeing Chi Nuan at the airport and literally walking past her like she's invisible because Jiang Luohe is right beside her. Chi Nuan crouching down crying in a corner while Song Shixue has to call her and practically beg her to come to the underground parking lot. The phone call where Chi Nuan's voice is trembling and Song Shixue hears it and just... crumbles. "Don't cry, please come down, okay?" That's not a plain request, friends. That is someone who has lost their composure entirely.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is absolutely exquisite and I keep going back to specific lines because the author writes speech the way some people write symphonies. Take the exchange where Chi Nuan finally tells Song about the photo: "I-I didn't mean to! It's mainly because you were too beautiful, too dazzling. I really couldn't resist, so, I'm very sorry." This is such a perfectly written line because it does three things at once—it's an apology, it's a confession of attraction, and it's Chi Nuan being completely unfiltered for the first time. She doesn't perform politeness here; she performs honesty. And the stammering gives it away: she's nervous but she's choosing to be vulnerable anyway. Then Song's response: "Is that so? Student Chi, how about this: let me see the photo first, and then I'll decide whether or not to forgive you." The languid quality of that line—every word landing directly on Chi Nuan's heart—shows a woman who is learning to use her power in small, controlled ways. She's teasing but she's also testing. The bar scene dialogue is where it all converges. "Are you worried about me, Student Chi?"—said with her finger tracing Chi Nuan's cheek, confirming reality. And the simplest line in the entire passage: "May I kiss you?" Three words. No flourish. Just a woman asking for something she's terrified of needing. That's dialogue writing at its absolute finest.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or