May My Wish Reach You - Reviews

May My Wish Reach You
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I'm still not over the moment Winter finds out she's pregnant. Just—just sitting there on that unfamiliar bed, wind howling outside, and she thinks about the child growing inside her and decides it will be her reason to keep going. That's not optimism. That's survival Mode activated. She's lost Eden, she's lost her studio, she's lost her home, and the one thing she has left is this secret she can't tell anyone. The loneliness of it is suffocating. And then—Clara. This random woman on a train with a fussy three-year-old, and Winter just naturally folds into the role of temporary babysitter. There's no grand dramatic moment, no music swelling, just a child tugging at her skirt and Winter looking down and seeing her own future reflected in those wide eyes. The scene where she pulls out her sketchbook and shows Lily the rose drawing—I got genuinely emotional. She's holding a child that isn't hers while carrying a child that is, and she's still giving. Still sharing what little she has left. But here's what really wrecked me: the blizzard. Of course the storm hits right as they're about to reach Santero. The world outside disappears under white. Winter's calculating delays, stressed about time and money, and somewhere in that chaos she's alone again. But she's not completely alone—Clara's there, Lily's asleep in her arms. The ending leaves you hanging between hope and dread, which is exactly where Winter should be. She's moving forward, but we don't know if Santero will be a beginning or just another place she has to survive.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about Eden because my brain is still spiraling. Everything about his behavior in these chapters is so frustrating and fascinating at the same time. On one hand, he finds out about Winter's father—he has every right to be furious, right? The man deceived his mother. But the way he handles it? Cold. Ice-cold. He drags her into that gallery, lets her think they might have a real conversation, and then drops the patronage line like it was nothing. Like their entire relationship was some transaction. But here's what keeps haunting me: the moment she walks away. "Eden watched her retreating figure with dark, sinking eyes. The repressed feelings groaned beneath the strain. A fierce urge rose within him—the desperate desire to take back every word he had just spoken." He wanted to stop her. He wanted to say something else. But he didn't. He just stood there and let her go. And Winter! Goddess, Winter. She had the pregnancy burning in her throat and she swallowed it. She chose pride over everything. "I'm pregnant" stayed trapped inside her like ash. And then Ellen kicks her out of the atelier because of scandal. She has nowhere left to go. Absolutely nowhere. I just—how can someone love someone that much and still choose to destroy them? "Did you just call it patronage?" And Eden's response was literally just tilting his head like he genuinely couldn't understand why she was upset. That's the part that makes me want to scream.
... Read More
This entire section is about the death of a myth—and the birth of something messier but real. The central symbol is the room itself. Winter's bedroom, once the most personal space in her life, gets repainted, refurnished, reoccupied. The author doesn't just say her things are gone—they linger on the absence. No trace remains. Not a single object suggests she ever existed there. This is about how quickly a person can be erased from their own history when the people who share that history decide it's easier to move on than to remember. But the deeper symbol—the one that recontextualizes everything—is the child Winter carries. Throughout the text, there's this tension between what Winter has lost (Eden, Vartz, her father, her home) and what she's carrying forward. The unborn child becomes this paradox: it's a reminder of the relationship that ended, but also a promise that life continues regardless. When Winter touches her stomach on the train, she's not just feeling a physical change—she's acknowledging that she is no longer entirely alone in the world. There's also the recurring motif of doors and thresholds. Winter closes her studio door behind her. She unlocks her father's front door to find it doesn't lead where she thought. She closes her bedroom door upstairs and wanders alone. Then she leaves that house forever. Each threshold crossing marks a transition—from student to outsider, from daughter to stranger, from dependent to someone who must figure out survival on her own terms. And the blizzard at the end—of course the storm arrives as Winter approaches Santero. Snow wipes the world clean, erasing tracks and paths and familiar landmarks. Winter has to trust that she can navigate by instinct now, because all the external guides have failed her. The city by the sea awaits, and we don't know if it will be salvation or just another chapter of endurance. But Winter is moving. She's not stopping. And that tiny, stubborn forward motion—that's the theme. Not hope, exactly. More like resolve.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the stakes in this section aren't about politics or romance or family drama. They're about a man realizing he loved someone and was too cowardly to say it in time, and now it's permanently too late. Everything else—the Lindal marriage, the King's summons, the royal politics—feels like background noise because the real conflict is internal and it's unbearable to watch. Eden is physically deteriorating. Bloodshot eyes, hollow cheeks, hands that shake, knees that give out on cold stone. The author doesn't romanticize grief; they show it as a physical collapse. And the external conflicts keep piling on because of course they do. His father's betrayal—Jeffrey Wood traveling and living with a seamstress barely months after his daughter's death—adds a whole new layer of disgust and sadness. That man called Winter his "only family," and his response to losing her is to disappear into a new life with a new woman. Winter, meanwhile, had no family left. She went back to her hometown seeking safety and found nowhere to belong. Pregnant. Alone. Working at a salon under a false name. Painting on hills by the sea. And then the train derails and it's over. The stakes have never been higher because they were never about winning anything—they were about surviving long enough to tell someone how you felt, and she didn't survive that long. When the King demands Eden explain his refusal of the Lindal match, the absurdity is almost funny if it weren't so devastating. Power, status, political alliance—all of it crashes against the reality of a grave and a charred travel bag with a sketchbook inside. Eden's conflict isn't resolveable. There's no victory here. The only thing left is him kneeling on cold stone, whispering to a woman who can't hear him, and that's the most honest depiction of grief I've ever read.
... Read More
There are two images from this chapter that are just burned into my brain and I can't stop thinking about them. First: Eden walking out of his estate in the middle of the night in just a thin collared shirt, no coat, and Parker scrambling behind him with the duke's actual coat crumpled in the carriage seat. Think about that detail — he didn't even THINK to grab it. His entire body moved before his mind caught up. That man, who has spent however many chapters being cold and composed and controlled, lost every shred of his dignity in about thirty seconds because he couldn't accept that Winter was dead. The author doesn't say 'he was desperate' or 'he was panicked.' They just... show us the bare arms in the cold and the unbuttoned collar and we understand everything. Second: the portrait. 'A painting shaped by Winter's hands. A painting that bore traces of her in every brushstroke.' Eden standing in front of his own portrait, reading her words back to himself: 'If the prince from the fairy tales I imagined as a child really existed... I think he would look like you.' He's touching the canvas. In that moment, the painting isn't just art — it's evidence that she existed, that she saw him differently than everyone else did, that she actually looked at him with something like awe. And now it's all he has left. The hospital scene is also wildly atmospheric — the exhausted nurses, the chaos of post-disaster triage, paperwork getting lost in the scramble. It's not glamorized at all. You can feel the smell of antiseptic and the weight of people who haven't slept in days. And then the coast scene: Winter looking out at the sea for the FIRST TIME in her life. Silver shimmer, sprawling harbor, distant ships on the horizon. She's going somewhere where nobody knows her name. The contrast between the claustrophobic, corrupt hospital and the vast open sea is basically the entire theme of this story visualized.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Winter and her father because this hit me harder than I expected. You spend all these chapters watching Winter look up to Jeffrey, seeing him as this sturdy anchor she can always run back to—and then BAM. She walks through that door and her room is gone. Not just rearranged, but completely erased. Someone else's decorations, someone else's bed, someone else's life occupying the space that was hers. And what kills me most is Jeffrey's reaction. He's not shocked or worried about his daughter showing up unannounced after two weeks. No, his immediate concern is, "Please don't tell Mrs. Karen about the past." He's already calculating how to manage the people downstairs instead of asking his own child if she's okay. The line where it says "the relief that flashed across his face was impossible to miss" when Winter says she's leaving? I actually gasped. He wanted her gone. Not because he doesn't care—but because caring would require honesty, and Jeffrey has never been able to face anything honestly. There's this brutal parallel the author draws: Jeffrey ran away from his affair with Karen's husband, lived a lie for years, and now he's doing the exact same thing with Winter. Except this time the person being run from is his own daughter. It's not just disappointing—it's a fundamental rewriting of everything Winter believed about who her father was. Meanwhile, this unexpected friendship with Clara on the train… it's such a quiet contrast. Clara is also running from something, also starting over in an unfamiliar place with a child. But she's open, grateful, honest. She apologizes freely, offers genuine thanks, lets Winter help with Lily without pride getting in the way. Winter finding kinship with a stranger feels like the author's way of showing that family isn't blood—it's who shows up and who sees you.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the pacing in these chapters is genuinely masterful and I am not okay with it. The chapter opens with Ellen delivering news like a verdict, Eden reacting like a man watching his world dissolve in real time. Very slow. Very deliberate. Then we CUT to Greyburn Street—this long, quiet sequence where Eden is alone with his thoughts and the physical evidence of Winter's absence. The pacing SLOWS even further here. You can feel every second stretching. And then—just when you think the emotional intensity has peaked—it cuts to the King. A completely different perspective, a different pace, almost comedic in its bureaucratic detachment. Edward is reading reports about his nephew's mental breakdown like it's a diplomatic incident. And then back to the atelier, where Ellen drops the pregnancy bomb and the entire structural foundation of the chapter cracks open. The pacing accelerates violently here—short sentences, fragmented dialogue, Eden's composure shattering in real time. By the time we reach the train, everything has collapsed into silence again. Eden barely speaks. Parker tries. Eden says "Leave." End of exchange. What's brilliant is that the author controls reader engagement the same way Eden controls his emotions—by letting silence do the work. The longest, most devastating moments in these chapters are the ones where NOTHING is said. The King's dry laugh. Parker opening his mouth and then closing it. Eden staring out the window. These silences are louder than any internal monologue ever could be.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that completely flipped my entire understanding of this chapter. We spent all this time mourning Winter as dead, right? The obituary, the duke crying, Ellen sobbing at her empty workbench — total emotional devastation. But then BAM, in the middle of the hospital chaos: a chart labeled 'Unknown Identity' gets shuffled into a pile and disappears. It's mentioned almost in passing, like the author is testing whether we're paying attention. And I'm sitting here like... wait. Wait wait wait. Winter didn't board the train to Santero because she wanted to die. She was running AWAY from Vartz, from everything. Mrs. Roche was taking her to the coast — someplace nobody knew her. And now that chart is gone? Into the void of an overwhelmed, underfunded hospital system that's already burying the dead under paperwork? I'm telling you the author is setting up a massive 'she's actually alive' scenario and I am HERE FOR IT. Then there's the parallel cover-up storyline with Count Lindal. The man literally orders Crispin to DESTROY the investigation report. 'The investigative report never existed.' He's actively burying evidence that the railway was negligent, blaming a blizzard to avoid liability for over a hundred deaths. And the timing! He's racing against external investigators. This isn't just corporate negligence — it's an active conspiracy. And somehow I have a feeling these two plotlines are going to collide in a way that's going to blow the whole thing open. The structure is also masterful. We get Winter's 'death' confirmed through three separate channels — the newspaper obituary, Jeffrey Wood calling the atelier, the Royal Academy's statement — each one more devastating than the last. By the time Eden shows up at Ellen's door, we've already had the full emotional arc of grief. Then the author drops the 'Unknown Identity' bomb right after, and suddenly all that grief has this horrible, delicious uncertainty attached to it. Did we mourn the wrong person? Is Winter still out there somewhere?
... Read More
Let me just say this opening sequence—the packing scene—is one of the most vivid pieces of writing I've read in a while. Winter cleaning her workspace one final time, placing the brush case into that worn leather bag whose corners are softened by years of use, arranging the glass paint bottles and charcoal box like she's performing a ritual. The detail about her favorite sketchbook being tucked in last is devastating because it's such an intimate object. That's not just art supply storage—that's her history, her practice, her identity being folded into a bag. And then she writes the letter. The way the author handles this is masterful. Winter doesn't want her goodbye to carry resentment. She forces back tears while she cleans, writes a note that's polite to the point of being heartbreaking, and leaves Ellen's studio without looking back. Those three clicks of her heels echoing across the floor—each one a final step away from the only home she's known. The silence that follows is louder than any dialogue could be. Contrast that with her father's house. The new curtains, the replaced bed, the rearranged furniture—all details that scream erasure. The mother's photograph gone from the wall is the cherry on top. This isn't just a room being reassigned; it's Winter's entire presence being systematically deleted from the places that mattered. Then the train journey opens up this whole new world. Santero is described as the second-largest city in Kartan, a vibrant port city by the sea. But we haven't reached it yet—we're still in transit, still in the liminal space between what Winter lost and what she's building. The blizzard closing in at the end wraps everything in this beautiful, terrifying white silence. The author uses weather like a character itself, reflecting Winter's internal state without ever saying it directly.
... Read More
"In a world buried beneath endless white, the train racing toward the next station overturned in an instant. When everything was over, only a massive steel wreck remained motionless upon the silent snowfield." That transition—from chaos to stillness—is one of the most cinematic moments I've read in ages. It's like the camera pulls up, up, up, and everything just goes quiet and white. The contrast between the violent, noisy crash and that eerie, almost beautiful silence afterward is devastating. And then we cut to Eden's party scene—half-empty wine glasses, people with names that carry weight, the thick smoke, the meaningless chatter about Winter like she's some fascinating object rather than a human being. "Speaking of that exhibition by the new artists the other day... do you know a painter named Winter Wood?" She's讨论ed like a painting, not a person who just got thrown off a train. The scene really made me feel how isolated she must have been even before the accident. The hospital scenes are so cold and clinical—white bedsheets, anesthesia, the nurse's practiced gentleness masking the horror of what she's about to say. "There was significant bleeding when she was rescued. Unfortunately, we've confirmed that she suffered a miscarriage." That clinical detachment makes it hurt more. But the most vivid image for me is Winter staring at those white hospital sheets while tears fall, and Mrs. Roche—the grandmother of the child Winter saved—wrapping her arms around this stranger who saved her granddaughter and lost her own child. Two bereaved women, one who lost a daughter and one who lost a baby, holding each other in a hospital room neither would have chosen. That scene is going to haunt me for weeks.
... Read More
There are so many symbols layered into these chapters that I almost didn't catch at first, and now I can't stop thinking about them. The gravestone is the most obvious one—"Winter Wood, Rest in Peace" carved into something described as "painfully ordinary." The ordinariness IS the point. This isn't some dramatic monument, it's a gray stone in a field of gray stones, and that banality is what makes it hurt. Winter deserved more than ordinary, and the author makes sure we feel that gap between what she was and what she got. Then there's the bread. Of all things, bread. Winter smells freshly baked bread and immediately thinks of Lily, and the author could have gone with something more symbolic—a flower, a song, a book—but bread is domestic and warm and fundamentally life-giving. It's the opposite of death, and it appears in the middle of a chapter about a woman who's already dead. That juxtaposition is brutal. And the unfinished canvas—Winter setting up her easel on that hill, tugging the corners down against the wind, slowly filling a blank surface with color. She was literally building something new, stroke by stroke, and the reader watches her do it knowing she won't finish it. The canvas becomes a metaphor for her entire trajectory: hopeful, fragile, interrupted by forces beyond her control. Even the snow functions symbolically. It covers everything in Eden's journey—fields, mountains, plains—blanketing the world in white silence, mirroring the numbness inside him. But snow also melts, and Winter's story in Santero takes place in late spring, where the ice is already softening. Two seasons, two states of grief, running in parallel. The author isn't just telling a tragedy—they're wrapping it in imagery that makes it ache on a deeper level.
... Read More
Let me just talk about the silence in this text for a minute because it's doing SO MUCH work. Jeffrey's dialogue is pathetic and self-serving in equal measure. "Shameful as it is, that was nothing more than a mistake from my youth." That's the kind of thing someone says when they want you to accept their version of events without question. And then immediately pivoting to "I was the one who took care of your mother through her long illness" — like that's supposed to cancel out whatever he actually did. Winter doesn't even argue back properly. She just asks one quiet question: "Did Mother know about all of this?" And when he confirms she didn't, her only response is a pained breath and then "Please. I'm begging you. I can't hear any of it right now." She doesn't call him a liar. She doesn't threaten him. She just shuts down. That's more devastating than any outburst could be. The narration itself is so restrained too — Winter at the ball isn't having internal monologues about betrayal, she's just watching. Frozen. The text says she "couldn't even blink" when she saw Eden with Violet. Even her thoughts are quiet. But then you get these moments where the narrative voice does get sharp: "No. To hide one lie, countless others must have been necessary." That's the author stepping in and basically telling you what Winter is figuring out on her own. The Jefferson letter at the end is also fascinating — "I am deeply ashamed" but he's already left. He's not even there to face the consequences of his words. The real dialogue is in what everyone refuses to say.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or