May My Wish Reach You - Reviews

May My Wish Reach You
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay I need to just sit with this for a second because holy hell. This chapter is basically a domino effect of devastating reveals and I was completely caught off guard every single time. Let me try to untangle this because my brain is still spinning. So Eden basically drops a nuclear bomb on Winter in one conversation, doesn't he? First it's the whole backstory about his mother Harriet Mayer and her affair—this man who promised to run away with her and then just vanished, leaving her to spiral. Then he casually mentions Winter's own father was THE man. Jeffrey Wood. Formerly Arthur Helburn. Changed his name, moved to Ceres, lived a quiet life while Harriet literally wasted away and died. The irony is absolutely brutal—the man who destroyed his mother's life got to grow old and be remembered as a devoted father, while the woman who loved him was reduced to a tragedy buried by the royal family. But then—and this is the thing that made me actually say 'what' out loud—Winter is pregnant with his child. She didn't even know. She's been taking the pill, except for that one night, the night where... well, you can imagine. And now here she is, standing in a hospital corridor, having just been told her entire understanding of her own father might be a lie, and she's carrying the Duke of Mayer's heir. That is some next-level dramatic irony right there. The way the author structures this is genius, actually. We get the Eden/Winter present-day framing first, then a flashback-style shift to Winter's perspective with Ellen, and then the hospital scene pivots us back to her waiting to confront her father. Three layers, three reveals, and they all converge. What really got me though was how Eden delivers his confession. He's so calm. So controlled. "What I've just told you is the very reason we can never be together." That line. That is a sentence designed to cut. Not angry, not shouting—just cold, final, and devastating. You can tell he's fighting something inside him the whole time. 'I loved you. And I treasured every moment we spent together.' Those internal thoughts versus his external cruelty—that contrast is what makes this plot work on an emotional level too. I also love how the author plants that detail about Winter's father showing up at the studio at the end. "So this is where you spend all day painting and working." He has no idea who she really is yet. The reader is screaming at the page. And then Winter asks, "Father… do you know someone named Harriet Mayer?" and that silence—oh that silence. The author doesn't even let him answer. Just stops there. I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how Ellen drops the PREGNANT bomb in the middle of this scene like it's nothing?? Because I literally gasped out loud. The entire chapter is this slow-burn tension building—Eden being cold and interrogating Ellen, the King investigating offscreen—and then BAM. A child. Winter was carrying a child and Eden had no idea. Not even a little clue. Think about what that means for the entire narrative going forward. He ended things with her, chose some arranged marriage, threw his life away for duty—and she was alone, pregnant, leaving the capital because she thought HE didn't want her, and now she's dead and he gets to carry THAT truth forever. Also the parallel between the King and Eden is brilliant plot design. Edward is piecing together the same puzzle from a distance, and the author keeps cutting between them like TWO PEOPLE REALIZING THE SAME THING FROM OPPOSITE SIDES. That's not just good pacing—that's structural storytelling. And Eden going to Ceres? The hometown? That's not closure, that's escalation. The plot is clearly building toward something even bigger than a simple tragedy. One thing that stood out: the obituary comes from Winter's FATHER, not from Eden. The man who abandoned her literally got to announce her death to the world while Eden was stuck in denial. That detail? That's not accidental. The author is planting seeds about who had access to Winter at the end, who was actually there, who made those final decisions.
... Read More
There are SO many reflective surfaces in these chapters and I cannot unsee them. The opening image of Winter hiding behind a door while Eden watches her from across the room—two people separated by glass and distance. Then the polished marble floor that catches her reflection as she leaves the gallery, showing her pale, ill face to the reader right before she disappears down the corridor. And the mirror she sees herself in at the studio: "Before she could take in her pale reflection, still recovering from a severe illness, she heard footsteps approaching." She's literally not even recognizing herself anymore. Who is this woman? She came in here as an artist, as someone with talent and ambition, and now she's pregnant, dismissed, heartbroken, and hollowed out. The pregnancy itself functions as the ultimate symbol of everything unsaid. It's the thing that should connect them but becomes the thing that keeps her silent. "I'm pregnant. The words that she had never found the courage to speak were burning in her throat, crumbling into ashes." She buries it because using the child would feel like manipulation, and yet not saying anything means she loses Eden forever. Either way she loses. The title of her former studio—the elegant estate where they met "to avoid prying eyes"—now belongs to her as a parting gift from the man who destroyed her. Patronage. Ownership. Everything the Duke gave her is now a reminder of everything taken away. "Was it wrong of me to love someone like you?" That unspoken question echoes through every mirror, every reflection, every empty hallway.
... Read More
I need to talk about Count Lindal's philosophy because it chilled me to my core. This man looks at a disaster that killed over a hundred people and his entire framework is just: 'Time and money. Those two things could solve almost anything.' He genuinely believes this. He's done it before — 'countless accidents, both major and minor' — and every single time he buried them with cash and silence. The blizzard was convenient for him because 'most people naturally believed the disaster had been caused by the weather.' He's not even evil in a theatrical way. He's just... efficient. Banally, terrifyingly efficient. And then there's Winter's chart — 'Unknown Identity.' Do you see what the author is doing here? The system that killed over a hundred people doesn't just fail to investigate properly — it fails to EVEN IDENTIFY the people it's supposed to protect. Winter, who ran away from her name and her past, gets processed into the system as a blank piece of paper. The same system that Count Lindal manipulates with money is the same system that can erase a person's identity with a misplaced folder. The portrait is another layer of this. Eden hangs his own image — painted by Winter — in a corridor lined with portraits of Mayer dukes going back generations. She's not family. She's not nobility. But somehow her artwork sits alongside centuries of aristocratic power. And now that she's 'dead,' that portrait becomes this haunting relic of someone the system was never meant to value. The fact that Jeffrey Wood — her father, a commoner — is the one who calls to report her death, and Eden races to Ellen's atelier the moment he hears that name, tells you everything about where her real loyalty and love lived versus where her social position was supposed to be. The train itself is such a loaded symbol too — progress, connection, the modern world tearing through the eastern region. And it becomes a grave because the aristocracy decided cost-cutting was more important than human lives.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the stakes get raised in this chapter because honestly I feel like I've been holding my breath for three paragraphs straight. Winter's stakes: she's alone, pregnant, separated from the only person she ever loved, on a train heading home to a hometown she never wanted to return to—and then she loses everything. Not just the baby, but her body betrayed her. She couldn't even protect the child she was carrying. And she has no one. No Eden, no support system, just Mrs. Roche who she doesn't even know yet. But wait—there's also Clara's disappearance. That's a whole other layer of stakes. Her grandmother is devastated, Lily is orphaned in every way that matters, and we have zero answers about where Clara actually is. Is she dead? Hurt? The ambiguity is torture. Eden's conflict is more internal but no less devastating. He told himself he denied what he and Winter had. He walked away. He built this whole narrative that it was her choice, her betrayal. But hearing people talk about her—really talk about her, admiring her beauty, wondering where she went—something cracks open in him. "The mere mention of her name left him rooted to his seat." He's trapped in his own guilt and he can't even articulate it. "What in the world..." That's not a question, that's someone watching their carefully constructed justification collapse. And the Lindal Railway? That's external stakes with massive implications. A month of known track defects? That's not just negligence—that's possibly murder-level corporate malfeasance, and Eden's family is involved. The gears don't add up, as the text literally says. Something is wrong, and the reader knows it before any character does. Every conflict in this chapter is running at maximum intensity simultaneously. There is no breathing room and I am here for it.
... Read More
There's a scene in here that I cannot get out of my head. Winter, alone in the garden, feeling so overwhelmed she has to physically escape the room, and then later stumbling around the hospital half-blind from exhaustion, and then standing on a street corner letting the cold wind hit her face while her mind replays "that night" in slow motion. "Every moment was overwhelming, consuming and impossibly intimate." That description of the night she slept with Eden—it's not just physical. It's emotional. It's the moment where all her resistance dissolved and she just... gave in. And now that moment has become poisoned by context. The same body that felt safe with him is now carrying evidence of a connection that might destroy everything. The emotional whiplash in this chapter is no joke. One moment Winter is trying to hold it together for her father, playing the dutiful daughter showing him her workspace. The next she's asking the question that could unravel her entire identity. And Eden—God, Eden. He tells her the truth with this terrifying calmness, and then the internal monologue betrays him completely. "I loved you. And I treasured every moment we spent together." He loves her. He loves her and he just told her they can never be together. What kind of person does that to someone they care about? What breaks my heart the most though is Winter's isolation. She has no one to tell. She can't go to Ellen because Ellen just found out about the pregnancy and is already dealing with that. She can't call her father because she's about to find out if he's a monster. She stands alone on a street corner, hearing echoes of a doctor's voice, watching her own body betray her with symptoms she ignored. "The baby…" she whispers. Not "I'm pregnant." Not "what do I do?" Just... the baby. As if the child exists independently of all this chaos, as if it's already separate from the wreckage. And Eden, sitting in his dark room swirling liquor, telling Winter the truth about his mother's death like he's reading from a script he's rehearsed for ten years. "I've often wondered how the man my mother dreamed of running away with lived the rest of his life." He needed to know. He needed closure. But instead of finding peace, he found out the man got to live happily while his mother died in misery. And now that man's daughter is the woman Eden loves. The universe has a sick sense of humor. This chapter made me feel like I was suffocating. In the best and worst possible way. I need to lie down.
... Read More
Okay first of all the description of this ballroom scene is INSANE. Crystal chandeliers, towering marble columns, the soaring melody, long tables with sparkling wine glasses and polished silverware — the author paints this entire world in one sweep and you can JUST SEE it. But what I love most is the contrast. This is the Royal Academy's 200th anniversary celebration, which on the surface sounds like an artists' party, but then the text immediately undercuts that: "the true guests of honor were someone else entirely." The king is coming. The aristocracy runs everything. Artists are just there to be admired and patronized. Winter, pale blue skirt blending into the crowd, chooses the corner. She's physically present but emotionally hiding. And then the cold wind when she leaves — "cooling the heat that had gathered around her eyes" — that single sensory detail does so much work. She walks out of the glitter and into the night sky full of stars that "could not penetrate the turmoil raging within her heart." Stars as metaphor for things that shine but can't reach you. Chilling. Then the exhibition hall scene — completely different atmosphere. Late evening, staff clearing out, the Duke arriving unexpectedly. There's this ordinary bureaucratic energy: the curator bowing and apologizing, staff scrambling to tell each other "the Duke of Mayer has come in person." It feels lived-in, not staged. The grand ballroom was all spectacle and hiding; the exhibition hall is all business and unintended encounters. Both spaces tell you exactly where Winter stands in relation to the people she cares about.
... Read More
There's a scene that lives rent-free in my head now. Eden enters the empty house on Greyburn Street alone for the first time—no lights on, just him and the ghost of everything Winter left behind. The author describes it as cold, silent, lifeless, and then focuses on the dressing room. The clothes still on hangers. The jewelry, the hats, the accessories HE GAVE HER, all abandoned like they meant nothing. This is such a quietly devastating use of setting. The house isn't just a location—it's an artifact of their relationship, and every object in it tells a story about what was given and what was taken away. The fact that she left it ALL behind is more powerful than any dramatic confrontation could be. An empty room says more than a screaming match. And then the contrast with the later scenes—the sterile atmosphere of the atelier where Ellen conducts her almost clinical recounting of events, the grandeur of the King's palace where political figures discuss personal devastation as if reading a report, the confined space of the train carriage where Eden sits in silence staring out at nothing. Each setting reflects a different relationship to grief. The house is私人 and raw. The atelier is guarded and formal. The palace is detached and political. The carriage is liminal—Eden suspended between worlds, not quite anywhere. The author doesn't need grand descriptions of castles or ballrooms to make this world feel alive. It's the EMPTY rooms and the silence between words that make everything feel real.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this entire section is built like two mirrors reflecting each other, and I'm still not over it. We're following Eden on a train to Ceres—snow, silence, Parker shushing himself like the grief might escape—and then BAM, we cut to Winter on a completely different journey, rebuilding her life in Santero with an unhealed arm and a secret baby. The structural parallel is almost cruel. Eden is rushing toward a grave; Winter is slowly building toward a future she'll never live to see. And the worst part? The author knew exactly what they were doing here. They let us watch Winter paint on that hill, let us feel her small victories—the bakery bread, Mrs. Roche's kindness, the way time actually starts moving again—and then they yank the rug out by cutting back to Eden collapsing at her gravestone. That's not just storytelling, that's emotional manipulation at its finest and I respect it so much. The timeline itself becomes a weapon. Winter's hopeful moments and Eden's destruction exist simultaneously, and the reader is the only one who knows both sides. When the King asks Eden about breaking off the Lindal engagement, it lands differently now because we've just seen Winter's grave. Every political thread—the marriage arrangement, the Count family, the royal summons—feels suddenly trivial against the raw fact that Eden loved someone and lost them before he could say it. The plot isn't just moving forward, it's circling back around grief from every angle.
... Read More
Oh my god this chapter hits like a freight train—literally. The plot structure here is brutal in the best way. You have three separate narrative threads that feel completely unrelated at first—the train derailment with Winter, Eden at that stuffy social gathering hearing gossip about her, and then Mrs. Roche rushing to the hospital—and then they ALL slam together in this devastating convergence that left me sitting there absolutely stunned. The train accident itself is described with such visceral intensity. "The massive steel train instantly lost its balance. Then it overturned." Just that simple sentence structure, three short statements building to catastrophe. Winter clinging to Lily, the luggage tumbling, the deafening crash—it's chaotic and horrifying and you can feel every second of it. But what really wrecked me was the Clara reveal. Mrs. Roche thinks her daughter Clara is on that train, and when she gets to the hospital she sees this unconscious woman who looks just like Clara and assumes it's her—only to discover it's Winter instead. And Clara? Nowhere to be found. The official line is that bodies were too damaged by fire to identify. My hands were literally shaking reading this. The Lindal Railway Company subplot is such a smart setup. "Cracks had been reported on that section of track over a month ago." A month! Someone knew and did nothing. This isn't an accident, it's negligence or worse, and I am SO ready for this to become central to the conflict. And then Winter waking up, being told she miscarried, having no one to call but pushing Eden out of her mind anyway—that's the kind of narrative cruelty that makes fiction unforgettable.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about Eden realizing—he's the one who pursued her. The text says it so plainly and it absolutely destroyed me: "After the portrait commission ended, she had been ready to walk away. It was he who invited her to dinner. He was the one who approached her first... He was also the one who relentlessly closed the distance between them, never giving her the chance to turn him away." From the very beginning, it had been Eden who kept reaching out to her. He had no right to dismiss her anger." I'm sitting here emotionally compromised and I need everyone to understand what this realization does to a character who has spent however-many-chapters convincing himself that Winter was the one who left, the one who betrayed him. This flips everything. She wasn't running away from him—he was the one who won her over, and then he threw it all away. And Winter's grief after the miscarriage—it's not just sadness, it's this horrifying realization that the tiny life inside her had become her entire future, and now that future is gone and she has no one to share it with. "Even worse, she had no one to share this heartbreaking news with. Eden Mayer... His name was the first to come to her mind. But she pushed the thought away immediately." That line breaks me. She still reaches for him even in her darkest moment, and then she stops herself. She won't let him be her refuge even though he's the first person she thinks of. That's not anger—that's self-preservation. And Mrs. Roche embracing Winter, "another bereaved mother wept alongside her"—two women who lost children in the worst possible circumstances, finding each other in a hospital room. That bond is going to be so important and I'm already crying for it.
... Read More
Let's talk about the triangular neglect in this chapter, because it's everywhere if you look for it. First: Eden and Winter. The relationship that exists almost entirely in negative space. We never see them together — we only see the aftermath. Eden's confession is to someone who never asked. Winter is painting sunsets alone while he's being told to forget her. Their connection is defined by absence, by the king's refusal to acknowledge it, by Eden's own failure to fight for her. But here's the thing that keeps bothering me — the king's own backstory. Hariette ran away with another man, got betrayed, and died. The king's immediate instinct is to bury the past and move on. Eden isn't just fighting his own regrets; he's fighting his uncle's entire philosophy about love and duty. That's a generational wound, not just a romantic one. Second: Winter and her new community. The Roche family took her in. The shopkeeper gives her free strawberries for Lily. Everyone is kind, and yet she's alone. Mrs. Roche's generosity is genuine, but it doesn't fill the hole. Winter accepts the kindness without letting it reach her — she's being supported but not truly seen. Third: Gabriel and Vincent. Actually, this one works. Vincent is loud and caring in equal measure, and Gabriel lets himself smile for the first time in this entire chapter when he says "I was thinking that coming back was the right choice." This friendship is the only healthy relationship on display. Which makes the contrast with Eden's isolation even sharper. And then there's the unspoken fourth relationship — Winter and Gabriel, who just bumped into each other on a cobblestone street and neither of them knows the other's name. Vincent is already collecting gossip about her like it's a hobby. The story is setting something up and I am NOT calm about it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or