It Was You From The Start - Reviews

It Was You From The Start
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how this whole Matteo situation went from 'oh look it's my idol designer' to 'why am I watching a thriller' in approximately four seconds flat. Like, the setup is deliciously simple—In-ah gets invited to a party by someone she admires, goes to a fancy mansion, and the party was 'canceled' which should have been the biggest red flag in history but we were all just too excited for her to notice. But here's what actually made me gasp out loud in public: the pacing of that scene. The author starts with all this dreamy atmosphere—the grand house, the wine, the unreleased furniture designs—and you're sitting there thinking, this is a romance novel, everything is fine—and then suddenly Matteo's shirtless above her and she can't move. THE DRUG. THE DRUG THEY GAVE HER. I SCREAMED. Or I would have if I wasn't in a library. And then Jinwon bursting in like a wrecking ball of rage and bad decisions—that punch he threw wasn't just violence, it was every suppressed feeling he had about her almost losing herself to someone else. The fact that he kept hitting even after Matteo was down? Chilling and perfect. The aftermath is where the real plot genius happens though. In-ah settling because she doesn't want to feel guilty toward Jinwon? That's not just plot convenience, that's character motivation layered ON TOP of plot convenience. And then the midnight phone call sequence where she tries to reach him and his phone's dead? That's not a cliffhanger, that's emotional torture disguised as a simple detail. I loved every second of it.
... Read More
This author does NOT mess around with pacing. Chapter 1 Part 1 alone covers: meeting in a studio at 3 AM, an intimate moment, a misunderstanding over a maternity handbook, a breakup in a café, AND a seven-year time jump with a domestic violence rescue and reunion. That's... that's insane. And it works because every scene is doing heavy emotional lifting. The opening studio scene lingers just enough—we feel the sanding sounds, the quiet, the tenderness of him watching her sleep and tucking hair behind her ear. It's slow and intimate, making the whiplash of the breakup hit harder. Then the break himself is nearly dialogue-free: 'Let's end it here.' Six words that destroy a relationship. The silence after is deafening. The seven-year jump is handled with a single line: 'Seven years later.' No transition chapter, no flash forward framing. Just—there. We're suddenly in In-ah's officetel, ordering food, hearing violence. The pacing here accelerates. Short sentences. Panic. Action. She's grabbing a frying pan, then a fire extinguisher, then spraying a knife-wielding man. The urgency mirrors her fear and bravery. Then—immediately—recognition. Jinwon. Her ex. Her new boss. The collision with coffee. The welcome party she tries to skip and fails. The BBQ where everyone's drinking except apparently him (until he proves he can). The way the scene moves from party to party-to-party with Sang-wook appearing like a plot device to make Jinwon jealous. All in one sitting. The chapter ends on a cliffhanger that's practically screaming at us: she's sitting next to Sang-wook grilling meat, Jinwon is across the table watching, and nobody has addressed the elephant in the room. Perfect pacing. I need Chapter 2 yesterday.
... Read More
I am actually furious for In-ah and I need to sit with this for a minute. The way Jinwon breaks up with her—just straight up, no explanation, no 'let's talk about this'—that broke my heart. He sees a maternity handbook, makes aassumption, and ends their relationship like it's nothing. Like their year together is disposable. And then when she confronts him, all he can manage is 'I'm sorry' while bowing his head? That's not accountability, that's cowardice. But here's what got me: the scene where she runs out of the café and laughs hollowly while tears pour down her face. That laugh—it's not anger anymore, it's grief. She's mourning something that never actually happened. The child he refused to acknowledge. The relationship he threw away over a misunderstanding. The version of Jinwon who used to look at her like she was the only person in the room. And then seven years later, he's the new Team Leader and pretends she doesn't exist. Pretends. Like their history is erasable. But watch how he looks at her when Sang-wook sits close. Watch how he notices she didn't take soju but then bravely drinks it anyway. He's performing indifference while absorbing every detail. The domestic violence scene though—THAT was everything. She hears someone getting hit, grabs a frying pan (terrified but brave), runs into the hallway with a fire extinguisher, and saves a stranger. And Jinwon? He's already there confronting the abuser. They both step up when it matters. They're not so different, these two broken people. I need them to talk. I need him to find out the truth about that handbook and realize what he lost. And I need her to stop letting his silence define her worth. But honestly, watching them circle each other at that BBQ place with Sang-wook playing wingman and Hye-yoon being chaotic energy in the background? I'm here for the slow burn. Just please let them communicate at some point.
... Read More
The author really knows how to juggle tones. You go from Shin-hye grabbing In-ah's hair at the hotel — full-on thriller energy — to some middle-aged man paying In-ah to flick a bug off his shoulder, and then suddenly you're in this achingly quiet scene where Jinwon is watching someone sleep and his whole world softens. The whiplash is real and I love it. What works brilliantly is how the Shin-hye confrontation gets resolved so efficiently. She doesn't win. She doesn't even get a real argument. Jinwon literally just walks away, supports her fake ankle injury, and whispers that possessive line in In-ah's ear. The author could've drawn this out for three chapters of drama but instead — done. Next scene. It keeps the momentum moving. The Seongjun introduction through the moth scene is also smart structurally. It gives us comic relief but also plants a new character who seems like he's going to matter later. 'From the beginning...!' — cliffhanger energy in the middle of a comedy beat. I was genuinely curious who this guy was before I even realized the scene had shifted gears. And that late-night sequence — no dialogue for a good chunk, just Jinwon's internal world bleeding through small actions. The tension there isn't dramatic, it's atmospheric. Different kind of grip on the reader.
... Read More
'In front of the hospital operating room, In-ah was anxiously waiting for the results with her mom, sister, and younger brother... Jinwon watched In-ah from a distance. His gaze eventually fell on In-ah's bare feet. She had rushed over without even having the presence of mind to put on shoes.' I am not okay. I repeat, I am NOT okay. This single detail — the bare feet — carries more emotional weight than any dramatic confession scene could. Think about it: In-ah gets a phone call, her father is collapsing, she runs out of the company building without stopping to put on shoes. And Jinwon? He drives her. He watches from a distance while she's falling apart in front of an operating room. And then — and THEN — he goes BACK TO THE COMPANY to retrieve her shoes and brings them to her. That is the kind of love language that doesn't need words. He doesn't hover. He doesn't make a scene. He just... takes care of the practical things while she's in crisis mode. The fact that she doesn't even notice until her brother points it out tells you everything about her headspace. She's so consumed with fear for her father that the one person quietly ensuring she's not uncomfortable goes completely unrecognized by her in the moment. And this comes right after the prop room confrontation where she basically told him to leave. The narrative arc here is brutal and beautiful: she pushes him away with words, he responds by bringing her shoes. That contrast hit me like a truck. The whole hospital sequence is rendered almost clinically — short sentences, no internal monologue from In-ah during the waiting. Just: surgery goes well, they breathe, she sinks into a chair, her brother notices her feet. The emotional restraint makes it hurt more. When she finally sees her shoes neatly placed at the end of the bench and stares at them in silence... that's the moment the author lets you feel the full weight of Jinwon's presence in her life despite all her attempts to make him disappear. And then immediately after, the NEXT CHAPTER has her arguing with him again in a prop room. The author does not let me rest. It's like emotional whiplash — comfort, then pain, then comfort, then more pain. I'm exhausted and I love it.
... Read More
I can't stop thinking about the porridge. Think about it—Jinwon cooking rice porridge with one hand in a cast, asking a Korean bar staff member to help him deliver it anonymously, and In-ah immediately imagining him struggling at a stove. That single image contains the entire emotional architecture of this story. He's been taking care of her the whole time, even when she thought he'd abandoned her. Even when she built a life on the foundation of believing the worst thing he could have done. The ramen flashback hits the same note—him mixing instant rice with ramen broth, pressing and mixing with such care, and her laughing not because it's funny but because it's this perfect metaphor for their whole relationship: makeshift, improvised, somehow nourishing anyway. And then there's the pregnancy revelation, which I keep circling back to. Whether or not she was actually pregnant, the BELIEF that she was changed everything. Seven years of her life shaped by a story she told herself. Jinwon saying "I never abandoned her" is both a confession and a deflection—he's telling the truth but also refusing to explain WHY she believed otherwise. That gap, that silence, is where the real theme lives. The story isn't really about whether they get together again. It's about how much damage we do to ourselves with the narratives we construct when we're too hurt to ask questions. In-ah didn't ask. She ran. And now she's running again, even as she stands in that hallway demanding answers.
... Read More
The puddle scene is everything. Seven years ago, Jinwon would carry her across smaller puddles like it was nothing—humming, playful, treating her like princess. Now? She stares at his outstretched hand and marches her white sneakers into black mud instead. No hesitation. No gratitude. Just a stubborn, silent ‘I don't need you.' That's the whole damn relationship distilled into one image. And Jinwon? He doesn't push. He just picks her up when she's limping, and she immediately fights him, calling it harassment before quietly swallowing her pride. Classic In-ah. Classic them. But what kills me is the factory worker's little confession: Jinwon built that chair for her, days of meticulous work, just a gift for his girlfriend. Look at In-ah now, dragging that same chair out of a dim storage room, calling it an ‘object of hatred.' How does love rot that fast? Yet the moment Jinwon smiles at her across the sample table—just a brief, tired smile—her chest does that traitorous thing. She looks away fast, pretending to be all about professional differentiation, but her heart's racing because his chest is right there against her head and she can feel his breath. And then the hotel. Oh, the hotel. She goes for a stupid errand, sees him with some stunning woman clinging to his arm, and instead of walking away, she stands frozen. ‘Ignore it. Why should it matter?' But her pupils don't obey. When Jinwon spots her and walks straight over, cold as ice, asking ‘Why are you here?'—and she fires back ‘There's no need for you to know about my personal life, is there, Team Leader?'—that's the dam cracking. She's using the title like a shield. He calls her by her full name, Seo In-ah, and suddenly the other woman's all over her, scanning her like prey. The tension isn't just romantic; it's territorial. It's two people who once knew each other's breathing patterns now playing chess with live wires. I'm obsessed.
... Read More
The stakes in this section operate on three levels and they're all threatening to collide. First, the professional stakes: In-ah's furniture project is being torn apart at the showcase. A low evaluation means cancellation. Her reputation, her team's work, everything hangs on those critics' opinions. Jinwon risking his own standing to defend her design is a professional gambit. Then Seong-jun stepping in saves the project but creates a different kind of debt—one she doesn't want. Second, the romantic stakes. In-ah vowed to make Jinwon suffer. She hated him. And yet here she is, letting him drive her, accepting his bandage, hearing him say he never expected forgiveness. The emotional risk is huge—if she lets her guard down, she's vulnerable to being hurt again. But if she keeps him at arm's length, she's stuck in the past. Every interaction is a calculation. Third—and this is the new variable—Hyun-seo. Who is she? Why does she call him "oppa" with that familiarity? Why is she crying? The narrative says In-ah's eyes widened because she knows Jinwon has a weakness for being called that. This woman isn't just a random interruption. She's a living piece of Jinwon's past crashing into their present. And In-ah has to watch from the passenger seat while this pretty, tearful stranger throws herself at the man she's still fighting to figure out. The suspense is maintained perfectly because we don't get answers. Hyun-seo's purpose is unclear. Seong-jun's intentions are murky. Jinwon's full history is hidden. In-ah's true feelings are unresolved. Every scene raises more questions than it answers. And that's what keeps you turning pages—not because you know what's coming, but because you're desperate to find out.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the rain is basically its own character in this story? The way In-ah can't handle being in the rain—it's not just weather, it's trauma manifested. She pays for psychiatric counseling because a single raindrop feels like needles piercing her body. That's heavy. And then the author drops this entire flashback sequence where they first meet during a rainstorm, and it's so vivid I could almost feel the wet pavement. The practice room with the sleeping bag, Jinwon half-awake looking out the window—that's straight out of a Korean drama opening credit. But here's what really got me: the blue umbrella. It's themed with a restaurant opening celebration, has a theme park logo, and is large enough for two people. It becomes this symbol of protection, of shelter from the storm, and now at the end she's holding it while watching him stand in the rain with his arms spread wide. The visual of him like that—eyes closed, embracing the downpour—it's so cinematic. And the office scenes, the chilly atmosphere when she comes back from Milan, people whispering in groups, the loud slam from Jinwon's office that makes everyone freeze. The author builds these spaces so well that you can feel the tension in every room.
... Read More
Let's talk about In-ah's voice because this woman is hilarious and the author lets her shine. When Jinwon asks why her 'newlywed' is acting so natural, she just shrugs and says "Because I've done it before." And when he looks shocked, she adds "When doing pre-research on competitors, acting as newlyweds is essential. I've probably had about ten husbands by now. No, maybe more than ten?" I fell out of my chair. This is the kind of line that makes you read it aloud to your friends. She's deflecting, teasing, and asserting control all in one breath, and it's delivered with such casual smugness. Jinwon's dialogue is quieter but equally telling. He barely speaks in the showcase scene but when he does, it's precise. "Since it's for newlyweds and a bridal gift, ignoring the in-laws' perspective was the reason for the failure." That's not just a rebuttal—that's him showing he understands her work on a deeper level than the critics do. And later in the car: "I never expected to be forgiven." Three words. No flourish. Just honesty dropped like a stone. Director Lee Seong-jun's voice is another whole category. "You really make me want to massage your shoulders. But if I actually did, I'd be in big trouble, right?" The casual menace. The fake innocence when Jinwon confronts him—"Why are you doing this?" "Doing what?" widening his eyes. This man speaks in layers and every line is performative. He's always testing boundaries wrapped in jokes. Even the minor characters have distinct voices. Hye-yoon's coquettish complaints. In-kyung's theatrical sword-drawing. In-woo's loud complaints about being left out. The memorial service mom yelling "Shhh- Quiet!" The store staff being polite while sensing tension. Everyone sounds different. The dialogue isn't just functional—it's character building in real time.
... Read More
The prop room confrontation is structured like a bomb detonating in slow motion, and I need to unpack every second of it because the craft here is insane. In-ah finds Jinwon waiting for her — he called her, she ignored him, she kept working. The first tell is when she stands up too fast and hits her head on the shelf. Physical comedy. A distraction. The author is lulling you into thinking this is just a funny workplace moment. Then Jinwon asks 'Do you know what time it is?' and she looks out at the rain. The tone shifts immediately. Night. Rain. Just the two of them. The atmosphere does all the heavy lifting here — no narration needed. Then the explosion: 'Why are you doing this to me?!' comes out of nowhere. In-ah has been holding this in for so long that the question isn't really about today — it's about seven years of silence, seven years of wondering, seven years of him not reaching out. Jinwon's response — 'Everything you said is right. I'm sorry, I'm sorry' — is pathetic in the most human way possible. He doesn't have a better answer. He never did. The physical action that follows is what makes this scene unforgettable. She TRIPS. Blood seeps from her knee. She doesn't stop to tend the wound. She keeps picking up props like her hands have a mind of their own. The author juxtaposes the internal emotional chaos with mundane physical action — bending, reaching, gathering — and the contrast is devastating. And the final line before the scene ends: 'The icy chill left by In-ah lingered around Jinwon.' Not a kiss. Not a reconciliation. Just cold air where she used to be standing. The author refuses to give us the catharsis we've been starving for across seven years of narrative. What's brilliant about the structure is that this scene is BOOKENDED by two lighter moments — the store ladder scene earlier, and the Hae-jeong beer scene later. Both are comedic, both involve women talking to other women about men. The author uses comedy as a pressure valve, releasing tension so it can build again. It's like the book breathes in comedy and exhales drama. And that's why this batch works so well — the emotional range is enormous, and the author never stays in one register for too long.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about the Seong-jun scene because THIS is where the external stakes of the story suddenly escalate beyond a simple workplace romance. Director Lee Seong-jun pulls up in his car, offers a ride, and within three paragraphs has already established he's both interested AND dangerous. The moment he says 'I know you used to date Team Leader Jinwon' and then pivots to 'Are you starting over?' — my stomach dropped. This isn't just office gossip anymore. This is a director who has his own agenda, who knows about the Milan incident, and who is explicitly warning In-ah to 'be more careful.' The stakes here aren't romantic — they're professional. Career-ending, reputation-destroying dangerous. But the absolute perfection of this scene is In-ah's response. Most protagonists would either crumble or make a fool of themselves. In-ah? She SPILLS HOT COFFEE on the director's pants, gets out of the car, and then turns around and warns HIM: 'You know there are rumors about you and me at the company, right? I'd appreciate it if you'd be more careful.' She weaponizes HIS own threat back at him. 'Please avoid situations like today.' The author writes: 'The color drained from the Director's face in an instant.' I laughed out loud. This woman does NOT play. What makes this conflict so tense is the asymmetry. Seong-jun holds institutional power — he's a director, he controls narratives, he's already mentioned he hears everything about the Milan incident. In-ah is a team leader with barely any authority by comparison. Yet she stands there barefoot-adjacent, coffee-stained situation, and flips the entire power dynamic with a single well-placed reminder that SHE knows how to play this game too. The stakes just went from 'does Jinwon still love her?' to 'will a senior director use company rumors to control her career?' And I am absolutely terrified for her because unlike the Jinwon conflicts, which have romantic resolution potential, this conflict has NONE. There's no heartfelt apology coming. There's just a man in expensive pants who now knows she's not going to be easy to manipulate.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or