It Was You From The Start - Reviews

It Was You From The Start
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The stakes here are suffocating because they're layered. On the surface: a furniture project. Khaki vs. bright colors, target consumers, differentiation—corporate bullshit that could cost In-ah her promotion or force a department transfer. But dig deeper and it's a war over who gets to define their shared history. Jinwon challenges her color choice not because he disagrees, but because he wants to see her squirm. He knows she's vulnerable. She knows he's manipulating. Every ‘Team Leader' and ‘Seo In-ah' is a slap wrapped in courtesy. The puddle crossing is a perfect microcosm. External conflict: physical obstacle. Internal conflict: her pride vs. his offer. What does she stand to lose? Accepting his hand means admitting she still needs him, that the seven years of hardening haven't worked. Refusing means blisters, mud, proving her point but hurting herself. She chooses the pain. Classic In-ah. But the real ticking bomb is the child. When Jinwon asks about the boy, the air leaves the room. In-ah's internal monologue spikes: ‘If he acts like this knowing everything, he's a scumbag without the slightest sense of guilt.' The stakes just shifted from career to survival. This isn't just about who's right about paint colors; it's about whether a father acknowledges his son, whether a mother forgives a ghost, whether two broken people can coexist without detonating. And that hotel encounter! The other woman isn't a rival; she's a mirror. She represents the smooth, painless life Jinwon might have had if he'd walked away cleanly. In-ah's forced compliment to the truck driver, her immediate pivot to ‘I miss you too, wait for dinner with Auntie'—she's performing normalcy while internally screaming. The suspense isn't ‘will they get back together?' It's ‘will they destroy each other first?' The author masterfully balances mundane details (lunchboxes, name tags, elevator rides) with existential dread. Every glance, every silence, every formal address is a loaded gun. I'm holding my breath through every page.
... Read More
"Here they were in Milan, as she had wished, but they were not together." I need to sit with that sentence for a while. That's it. That's the review. No, seriously, that ONE line contains the entire emotional architecture of this story. Every hope, every disappointment, every bittersweet ache of wanting something that's both fulfilled and unfulfilled at the same time—all compressed into two sentences. But let me keep going because I can't stop now. The way the author builds the romantic tension through tiny, almost accidental moments—like Jinwon holding the elevator door and In-ah pointing at it like 'move, I'm important'—that's not just flirty, that's them performing their entire relationship dynamic in thirty seconds. She's proving she has power. He's letting her have it. Both of them knowing exactly what's happening. Then the dress scene. Jinwon frozen in the elevator. In-ah in a BLACK DRESS with heels she barely wears, walking past him like she owns the building. She's not just going to a party, she's going to SHOW HIM what he's risking losing. And then later, staying up until midnight calling a man whose phone is dead, telling herself she's only checking because she's worried about his safety. WE ALL KNOW WHAT THAT IS. And Matteo—that whole scene where In-ah's face blushes like wine because he's being charming and professional and she's just SO HAPPY to meet her idol? That's the emotional trap, folks. That's how predators work. They don't start with danger, they start with admiration. The author knew exactly what they were doing and I respect it deeply. The hospital scene where Jinwon's knuckles are bleeding and he can barely form words, and In-ah's first instinct is to protect HIM by settling? THAT'S the emotional core of their entire relationship. She'd rather carry the world than let him carry guilt. God, I love them. I also want to shake them both.
... Read More
There's something so specific and intimate about the way this story uses space. Let me start with the hotel corridor scene—In-ah and Jinwon literally pressed against the wall, trying to hide from Shin-hye, her back against cold plaster while his body is right there behind hers. The description of her head lolling onto his shoulder, that moment where she lets herself close her eyes despite everything, it's one of those scenes that feels like a camera slowly pushing in. You can hear the elevator ding. You can feel the awkward tension of two people who've spent years avoiding each other now trapped in the same three feet of hallway. And then cutting to Seoul—the restaurant with the course meals, the white tablecloths, the way In-kyung emerges from nowhere to launch a half-eaten dish at Shin-hye like some kind of beautiful, chaotic avenging angel. The contrast between these two settings matters. Milan is this cold, transactional space where they keep running into each other by accident. Seoul feels messier, lived-in, where family actually shows up and throws food. I also love how the furniture fair itself becomes this liminal space—a bustling, noisy place where In-ah's past trauma (Matteo, the miscarriage she thought happened) ambushes her in broad daylight. The world-building here isn't about elaborate fantasy; it's about making ordinary spaces feel charged with history.
... Read More
Let's talk about the chair. Oh god, the chair. It's not just furniture; it's a tombstone for whatever they had. Jinwon spent days crafting it, hands bleeding probably, heart open. She now drags it out of a dark room like it's contaminated. ‘Why didn't you throw this out?' she asks her sister, but the real question is: why did I keep it for seven years? The chair symbolizes the gap between intention and perception. He made it as a gift; she experienced it as another layer of obligation, another reminder of what she lost when he vanished while she was pregnant. Love and hate sharing the same wooden legs. Then there are the white sneakers. Brand new, expensive, practical. She chooses them over accepting his hand. That's not footwear; that's a manifesto. ‘I will walk through mud alone.' But look what happens—blisters, soaked socks, humiliation. Pride as self-sabotage. The author is so clever here, using clothing as emotional armor that quickly fails. And the child. That little boy on Min-jun's arm, calling him ‘Dad,' looking mature beyond his years. Jinwon's question hangs in the air like smoke: ‘Does that child call anyone ‘Mom'?' It's not jealousy; it's something colder, more resigned. The child represents everything Jinwon abandoned, everything In-ah survived without him. Yet the phrasing—‘I guess not'—suggests he's already made peace with his non-role, while she's still screaming inside. Recurring motifs of crossing thresholds (puddles, hotel doors, factory gates) mirror their emotional barriers. Walking away, moving forward, never quite touching. The rain that created the puddle, the crystal that mimics falling water, the mud that clings—everything is about fluidity, about things that can't be held clean. This isn't just a romance about exes reuniting; it's about how the past permeates every surface, how love and hurt share the same bloodstream. And maybe, just maybe, the chair could be restored if someone's willing to sand down the scratches. Who knows?
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is everything. Jinwon's voice is so distinct—he says things like “You're getting involved with me now. Are you sure you want to ask that?” with this calm, almost challenging tone, but then completely undermines himself by asking about wish tickets like a child. The shift from cool team leader to petty ex-boyfriend is hilarious and heartbreaking. And In-ah's internal monologue versus her external responses—she thinks “Ignore it, please” about his mother but says nothing out loud. When he asks her to not get close to the director, she immediately agrees but then backtracks by calling wish tickets “funny.” Her sarcastic laugh, her tendency to clench her teeth and look away, the way she physically recoils from emotional moments—that's all communicated through dialogue and action, not exposition. Even Hye-yoon's voice is distinct with her enthusiastic gossip and rapid-fire questions. The author knows how to make every line of dialogue reveal character. Jinwon's line “Paying attention to every trivial and vulgar rumor doesn't seem very dignified” when defending In-ah? That's love language.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how Jinwon acts around In-ah versus how he acts around everyone else? This man walks into a store and immediately notices she's focused on work while he's over here having a full sensory crisis because she called him 'oppa.' His pupils were SHAKING. The narrative literally says his pupils shook. A adult man in his twenties losing composure over a syllable. And In-ah knows it. She KNOWS. She's deliberately weaponizing nostalgia and intimacy like it's nothing. But let's also talk about Director Lee Seong-jun because this man is a whole problem. He tells In-ah "You really make me want to massage your shoulders" and then follows up with "but if I actually did, I'd be in big trouble, right?" Sir. You are already in trouble. You're a director touching on employee boundaries like it's a joke. And then he corners Jinwon in that meeting room and acts all casual about it while Jinwon is clearly seething. "When are you going to grow up?" he says. Like HE isn't the one being inappropriate. The power dynamic here is disgusting and the author is letting us sit in it. Meanwhile In-ah's family is absolutely unhinged in the healthiest way. Her sister In-kyung acting as a bodyguard with an invisible sword between In-ah and their mom? I screamed. And In-woo complaining about being excluded from rides? The family scenes ground this whole story so well. After the intense showcase and the creeping Director Lee energy, we get pancakes and memorial service preparation and it's just... soft. Warm. In-ah laughing until it fades and then staring at the bandage on her finger. That's when the real character work happens. Not in the dramatic confrontations but in these quiet moments where she's remembering she used to hate Jinwon and now she doesn't know what she feels anymore.
... Read More
Okay so this whole wish ticket thing has got me spiraling. I keep going back to that scene where Jinwon brings it up like it's some kind of currency between them. “I need to retract the wish ticket.” What does that even mean? It's such a weird, intimate detail that reveals so much about their history. And then In-ah's reaction—she regrets bringing it up because it reminds her of when they were happy together, but then immediately distances herself by calling it “funny” for a team leader and employee to be talking about stuff like that. The plot keeps teasing this unresolved tension. Remember when she thinks about his mother's words at the beginning? ‘Are you the one who dumped my son?' That's still hanging over everything like a cloud. And then there's the rumor thread with Director Lee—what was that even about? Someone saw them at a hotel? The plot layers all these loose ends and I'm just sitting here connecting them in my head. TheMilan business trip rumor, the late-night convenience store encounter, the elevator moment where she keeps thinking ‘come quickly' and then it only comes when Jinwon shows up—this author is playing with coincidence like it's a weapon. And that ending where she sees him buying women's clothes? My heart dropped. Who was that woman? I need answers.
... Read More
The structure of these chapters is so deliberate. You open with the showcase—that's high stakes, professional pressure, public criticism, Jinwon's defense, Seong-jun's intervention. It's fast, it's loud, it's all external conflict. And then—the chapter literally says "After the showcase ended, In-ah headed straight to her family home" and drops you into a completely different pace. Pancakes. Memorial service. Sister fighting with brother. Mom smacking people. It's domestic. It's slow. It breathes. I think that's such smart pacing. You can't keep readers on high alert forever or they burn out. So you give them this warm, noisy family scene where In-ah gets to laugh and be a daughter and sister instead of a designer under fire. The transition from the showcase hall to the family home is jarring in a good way—it reminds us this character has a life outside work. Then—cut to the next morning, In-kyung driving her to work, spotting Jinwon on the street, and boom, we're back in romantic tension territory. The car ride is quiet, loaded with unsaid things. Then the JM store scene picks up the pace again with the teasing, the "oppa" exchanges, the staff noticing Jinwon's red ears. Everything builds until Hyun-seo appears and the rhythm breaks entirely. That entrance is basically a record scratch. The pacing goes from smooth and controlled to chaotic and uncertain in one line of dialogue. What I love is how the author uses setting to control tempo. Showcases are fast and public. Family homes are slow and private. Cars are confined and tense. Stores are semi-public where professional and personal collide. Each location has its own rhythm and the transitions feel natural, not rushed. The only question is whether that Hyun-seo interruption will slow things down again or accelerate the romantic conflict. Either way, I'm locked in.
... Read More
Shin-hye yanking In-ah's hair back by the scalp — that moment genuinely made me gasp. This isn't just romantic rivalry, this is physical aggression from someone who has zero restraint. And the worst part? She's completely fearless because she's already won Jinwon's reluctant presence. In-ah is the one with nothing to prove and everything to lose. But Jinwon's conflict is the more complicated one. He knows Shin-hye's pattern — the false accusations, the ruined student in Finland — and he's deliberately staying away from In-ah to protect her from her radar. Is that noble or cowardly? The text leaves it beautifully ambiguous. He's preventing drama but he's also not fighting for her. He's managing the threat instead of eliminating it. In-ah's internal conflict is quietly devastating. She's angry at Shin-hye but then turns and asks herself 'Why am I so angry? At what point?' That self-interrogation shows a person who's been hurt so many times that she's suspicious of her own emotions. She's protecting herself by minimizing her reactions, which is its own kind of tragedy. The stakes keep escalating too. A new director who might be the owner, rumors of mergers and layoffs, a chaebol heir with a bug problem — the professional world is collapsing around these personal dramas and none of the characters seem ready for it.
... Read More
I've been turning over that one line in my head for like an hour. When In-ah closes her eyes on Jinwon's shoulder and whispers "Don't do things like that," it's this tiny, devastating moment where ALL of her walls crack and then instantly rebuild themselves. She's not even looking at him. She doesn't have to. That's the thing about how this author writes dialogue—it's never just about what's said. The bar scene afterward is pure gold too. In-ah trying to thank Jinwon and him cutting her off with "forget everything that happened that day," like he's erasing their shared history the way she's been trying to do for seven years. And then SHE gets the last word: "I think an explanation is necessary." Even though she immediately regrets it and tries to leave. The back-and-forth between them is this exhausting dance where neither person ever says what they actually mean. Jinwon's mother in the restaurant scene is another voice I loved—cold, refined, absolutely terrifying. "I've always been curious about what kind of person would do such a terrible thing" said while staring directly at In-ah's face. Chilling. And In-kyung? Every line from her is perfect. "Should I just stand by while my sister is being mistreated? That's not how I was raised." She doesn't even break stride after throwing soup. This author writes female rage so differently than other romance novels I've read—it's sharp, it's fast, and it comes with a side of dry humor.
... Read More
The sensory details in this opening are chef's kiss. Let me start with the studio scene—that sanding sound, scratch-scratch, building rhythm like a heartbeat. Three AM. Everyone's asleep but these two are working late, and the intimacy of that shared creative space feels so specific and real. You can almost smell the wood dust and feel the quiet hum of the university at night. Then the bag spills. The zipper opens. And there it is—the Maternity Handbook with 'Mother's Name: Kang Hae-jeong' on the cover. The visual of In-ah snatching it away while Jinwon holds it, his expression shifting from warmth to something unreadable, is so cinematic. The author uses that handbook like a Propriad that destroys everything. The café breakup scene is stark and cold in comparison. No sensory richness, just silence and the 'whirlwind' metaphor—her mind going blank, the sound of fierce wind crashing into her ears. It's deliberately hollow, which matches how she must have felt. But then—seven years later—and the author dumps us into this officetel hallway where domestic violence is happening. The noise travels through the thin walls. 'Dull thud.' 'Shrill voice.' In-ah pressing her ear to the door, nails between her teeth, pacing. Then she emerges with a fire extinguisher and sprays this man while he's holding a kitchen knife. The imagery of white powder covering everything like winter snow is gorgeous. 'The entire hallway looked like a winter wonderland.' And Jinwon standing there shaking his head to clear the powder, looking like he's in a photoshoot, then lifting his head in slow motion and—in that moment—she recognizes him. The workplace collision is perfect too. She's clutching her precious iced coffee like it's oxygen, turns the corner, and it goes everywhere—right on his expensive suit. The coffee stain spreading like guilt. Then the moment she looks up and sees his face. Time stops. The author builds atmosphere through objects and sounds more than long descriptions. The sanding, the book, the extinguisher powder, the coffee stain—each one carries emotional weight. The world feels lived-in and specific, from the university studio to the officetel hallway to the BBQ restaurant where the welcome party happens. I'm invested in this world.
... Read More
There are characters and then there are characters who punch through your screen and rearrange your nervous system. Jinwon did that to me in three sentences. Let me back up because you need context. This man has been walking this razor's edge the entire trip—telling In-ah not to get too attached, saying their wish is 'just in Milan,' acting like he's some untouchable team leader—but the second someone actually threatens what's his? The mask doesn't just slip, it EVAPORATES. He literally bursts through a door like an action hero and proceeds to pummel a man who drugged his subordinate. But then—the scene on the bed. Oh god, the bed scene. He grabs her arm, they fall together, and his first word isn't 'are you okay' or 'did he hurt you.' It's 'Am I that terrible?' A grown man who just committed felony assault in Milan, reduced to that vulnerability. That's when you know he's genuinely, catastrophically in love with her and has been denying it so hard his body just broke. And In-ah? Her response—look him right in the eye and say NOTHING—is the most powerful silence I've read in fiction. She could've comforted him. She could've explained. Instead she gave him the void, which honestly felt like the only honest thing she had left to give. Their dynamic has always been this push-pull dance where neither will admit what they're doing, and this entire chapter just crystallized it perfectly. She settled the case to avoid guilt toward him. He got released because of that settlement. They're trapped in this beautiful, miserable loop where every choice they make is about protecting each other while simultaneously pushing each other away. I'M FINE. EVERYONE IS FINE. THE EMOTIONAL DAMAGE IS ABSOLUTE.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or