Incurable - Reviews

Incurable
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about how this chapter starts—Mu Wan casually dropping the bombshell about 'little Hema kissing Anzhi' and Liu Qianxiu's reaction? Chef's kiss. The author doesn't need some massive plot twist to make your stomach drop; a toddler with a wandering mouth is somehow more tense than any life-or-death scenario. And the way Mu Wan tests him—watching his face, waiting for that flicker of jealousy—it's such a clever use of domestic space to create drama. Then you have the zhuazhou scene where Anzhi grabs a camera first, then a novel, and suddenly the whole room is applauding like it's some grand destiny reveal. Which, honestly, it kind of is. The subplot threads are all woven through these tiny moments—the rival baby, the futureCP anxiety, the family traditions—all happening in a single afternoon. Makes you wonder though: is the author setting up some huge reunion or conflict down the line, or is this just gonna be a cozy slice-of-life all the way? Because right now it feels like the calm before something.
... Read More
I know this isn't some dramatic romance chapter with tension and conflicts but THAT'S literally why it destroyed me. Mu Wan and Liu Qianxiu after their intimate moment — she's exhausted, snuggling into his chest, voice hoarse from the birthday chaos — and he's just there, present, making sure she's okay. The way he pulls her into his arms 'with just the right amount of strength' — this man knows exactly how to hold her. And then they're whispering about zhuazhou superstitions half-asleep, and he admits his family background was complicated and Tao was 'just a way to seek peace of mind.' That's him opening up to her in a moment of vulnerability, right before falling asleep together. Not dramatic. Not forced. Just trust. And then Mu Wan's confidence about her daughter being beautiful 'just like me' — Gao Mei covering her mouth to stop the jinx, both of them laughing — it's domestic bliss and I am HERE FOR IT. This is what makes the upcoming drama hit harder though, isn't it? Right now they're happy. We know something's coming.
... Read More
I need to talk about the garden scene. The one where they're walking at night, the sky full of stars, and Mu Wan is all bundled up in her thick down coat with her scarf hiding most of her face. They're on a small bridge over the lake and the lights are reflecting off the water— it's so cinematic I could literally see it as a film scene. She's sharing everything Xu Xingkong told her, and he's listening, and she asks if he already knew it all, and he says "I knew some of it." But the narration tells us he actually knew way more than that. He was just being modest. She smiles and feels happy, and then the whole thing pivots to her worrying she's being careless and him gently touching her hair and her shrinking back a little at his touch. That little detail—her shrinking back—it hits different when you think about her past with her uncle. This man is the safest person in her world and her body still remembers to flinch. I won't ever get over that. Then she leans right back into his embrace anyway and asks about what he can't do. And his answer—"There are things I can't do either"—is so simple but it carries the weight of everything. He can't carry her child. He can't feel the pain she's about to endure. He can't protect her from the suffering that's coming. And she reads all of that in his silence. The fact that she then pats his shoulder and tells him not to worry, that she can handle pain, coming from someone who survived abuse and stunt injuries—it's both sweet and devastating because we KNOW she's about to severely overestimate herself. The next chapter basically destroys that confidence.
... Read More
This is the fifth time I've read the scene where Liu Qianxiu holds Anzhi and she calls him by name. FIVE times. And I still get that tightness in my chest. It's not just that he's a good father—it's the way the narrative keeps circling back to this man who probably built an empire with ice in his veins, now reduced to squatting on the floor asking his one-year-old daughter what she likes, his fingers gently guiding her hand toward objects like it matters, like her choices matter. And Mu Wan, watching him. Always watching him. There's this whole quiet love story happening in the margins, in glances and sighs and the way Lin Wei teases about genetics while secretly being relieved her own kid isn't the one being scooped up like a prize. The Lu Yi He and Anzhi thing? Yeah, it's adorable now but also kind of terrifying in the best way. That moment when he throws his arms around her and she just melts into it? I'm not okay. Neither is Liu Qianxiu, apparently, because he literally freezes when Mu Wan brings up the kissing thing. What did you expect him to feel, surrounded by competition before she can even walk properly? The emotional current here is so steady and warm it's almost unbearable.
... Read More
I need to be honest — I had to go back and reread the entire arc after finishing this chapter because my brain needed to understand HOW they got here. This moment feels like the emotional culmination of everything. Not the plot climax, obviously — there might still be external conflicts looming — but the relationship climax. This is where they both finally say what they mean without needing dramatic circumstances to force it. What I love about the structure here is how the author weaves in subplot threads organically. Mu Wan brings up Anzhi's acting opportunity, which ties back to everything we've seen about Liu Qianxiu's protectiveness over her. The Lu Yihe mention adds a tiny spark of... something, maybe future conflict, maybe just flirtatious tension. But the author doesn't dwell on it. They acknowledge it and move forward, keeping the focus exactly where it belongs. The pivot from "let's talk about our daughter figure's career" to "actually, what about ME?" is seamless. Mu Wan uses the Lu Yihe situation as a springboard to ask about herself, and Liu Qianxiu's reaction confirms everything she needed to hear. This is excellent plotting — using side conversations to advance the main emotional storyline. The author clearly knows how to keep multiple threads going without losing sight of the heart of the scene.
... Read More
I need to address the dialogue in these chapters because the author has found a genuinely fresh way to write romantic communication. Who else is out here genuinely moved by a couple texting each other about their baby? [Daoist Liu: Two little flowers.] vs [Wooden Bowl: One big and one small, both belong to you.] These aren't just messages - they're character. Liu Qianxiu's use of a playful username, his poetic brevity ('two little flowers' for mother and daughter), the way Mu Wan responds with something warmer and more expansive. Their voices are distinct even in text form. And the spoken dialogue is equally sharp. 'Which one do you want?' / 'I want both.' during labor - that's not exposition, that's character revelation. She's joking while in pain. He's asking because he genuinely cares about her wishes. The subtext carries more weight than the text. Dr. Chen's professional, clipped dialogue contrasts perfectly with Liu Qianxiu's emotional responses. 'Not fully dilated yet. Take her for a walk.' versus the trembling voice Mu Wan notices. The author uses register to show us who these people are under pressure. The only slight quirk is that some of the narrative voice occasionally drifts into overly descriptive territory, but it's a small complaint for dialogue that feels this authentic. The text message exchange alone makes these chapters worth reading multiple times.
... Read More
This batch moves like water. We start with the temple afternoon — fishing nets, releasing small fish, keeping the big ones. Domestic. Peaceful. Then: "In the days that followed, Mu Wan truly experienced what it meant to live a life of peace and freedom." Four sentences to establish an entire philosophy. No drama, no conflict, just... time passing beautifully. Then the descent from the mountain. "As their car merged onto the highway, the density of people increased, and the bustling energy of the world once again surrounded them." The transition from temple to world is handled in one paragraph. We don't linger. The reader feels the shift — like stepping out of a dream. Mei residence scene: lively chatter, warm atmosphere, Qingchan behaving with "unusual decorum." This is world-building through contrast. The temple was quiet; here, noise and people and tradition collide. But neither is better — "Life at Qingyuan Temple was not dull, and the world outside was not so mundane; the perception of both depended on one's inner state." That's the thesis statement right there. The author is telling us: don't romanticize either life. Both have value. It's about perspective. Then the dressing room scene at night. The pacing slows dramatically. One moment, they're at a family gathering; the next, it's moonlight, a slightly open door, soft rustling sounds. The narrative zooms in from wide shots (highway, temple, family home) to an intimate close-up. And then — wedding practice. "In the days leading up to the wedding, Mu Wan had little to do other than practise the ceremony routine." Boredom? No. "Despite the lack of tasks, she wasn't bored; being with Liu Qianxiu every day made her happy." The pacing never drags because the emotional content is dense even when nothing happens. We're not waiting for conflict. We're watching two people simply exist together, and that's the point. Final note: the Lin Wei scene cuts off mid-conversation about antiques. Almost like the author is saying — we'll get to that later. Don't worry. The story isn't rushing. It's breathing."
... Read More
I need to address the dialogue in this section because it is SO GOOD and I don't say that lightly. Mu Wan's voice is immediate and distinct. 'Liu Qianxiu, I'm hungry.' That's it. That's the whole opening line and it tells you everything: she's comfortable, she's direct, she expects him to take care of her and he will, and she's not apologizing for any of it. Later: 'You speak Finnish too?' and 'I have such great taste.' Playful. Teasing. Confident in a way that only comes from knowing you're safe. Liu Qianxiu's responses are shorter but never empty. 'A little.' When asked about Finnish. Classic understatement that says more than any boast could. 'Maybe we should think about it at home. Otherwise—' He's the voice of reason, but not the boring kind. The kind that means I'm already thinking ahead, I'm already planning, I'm already including you in every version of the future. Then: 'Li Zhi.' Two words. That's all it takes. He doesn't explain himself. He doesn't hedge. He just offers the name like it was always there, waiting for the right moment. The supporting characters also have distinct voices, even briefly. The Finnish waitress—professional, efficient. The boy's parents—apologetic, warm. Even the unnamed driver exists through action (chains on tires, knowledge of the area) rather than dialogue, which is a smart choice. These people feel like they have lives outside this scene. And the narrative voice! It never judges. It doesn't tell you how to feel about Mu Wan's happiness or Liu Qianxiu's competence. It just... shows you. 'Her eyes blinked at him with curiosity.' 'His gaze softening.' The narration trusts the reader to understand emotion without being handed a label. This is what competent romantic writing looks like. Not flowery prose, not endless internal monologues. Just people talking to each other like they matter.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how perfectly Liu Qianxiu is written as a partner? He's not flashy or overtly romantic in a grand way, but every little action screams 'I care.' Remember when he's at the sink washing celery, and Mu Wan hugs him from behind? He freezes, turns off the faucet, and then says 'What's up?' That's not indifference; that's him being fully present, ready to listen. And when she calls him 'husband~' with that rising lilt, his response—'Everything you call me sounds good'—is delivered with a smile that's described as 'the thawing of ice in a spring field.' It's such a vivid metaphor for how he's been reserved in the past but is now warming up to her. The author shows his character through these tiny gestures: pinching her ear to signal her to explain her laughter, removing fish bones for her at dinner, holding her firmly when she tries to run away. His motivation isn't dramatic; it's simply to protect and cherish Mu Wan. Their dynamic is built on mutual respect and quiet affection. She teases him, he catches her; she calls him husband, he validates her. It's a relationship where actions outweigh words, and that's what makes it feel so real and deep. I'm curious how his past (those fractured parental relationships) has shaped his cautiousness, but it hasn't broken him—it's made him appreciate this peace more. The way Mei Laotai observes them, thinking 'he had found his soulmate,' confirms it. This isn't just a romance; it's a portrait of two people choosing each other daily. The author nails the subtlety of long-term partnership, where love is in the silences and the small adjustments. Makes me want to reread all their interactions to catch every little detail.
... Read More
'I'm a doctor. I'll take care of it.' That line hit me like a physical thing. Not because it's dramatic, but because it's so ordinary. Liu Qianxiu isn't saying he'll protect her from the world—he's saying he'll manage the practicalities of their bodies, their health, their future pregnancy, with the same calm competence he brings to cleaning lotus roots. That's the romance here. Not grand gestures, but delegated care. The whole sequence from the kitchen to the bedroom to the phone call reads like a single breath. Watch Aunt Wu's perspective for a second—she goes from worried single-mother-analog to relieved matriarch in real time. She sees the ring, sees him in her kitchen, sees them together, and her heart 'gradually fill[s] with relief and joy.' That's the emotional arc of an entire generation condensed into one scene. The older woman who lived the 'mistake' gets to watch the younger woman live something different, and that shared history between mother and daughter-in-law-to-be is more powerful than any love confession. And then there's the intimate scene—which could have been gratuitous but isn't, because it's anchored in character. Mu Wan calling herself a 'bad student' isn't coquettish; it's genuinely playful, and Liu Qianxiu's response—'Dual cultivation is also a form of practice'—is such a specific, intellectualized way of being affectionate that you believe this is how he loves. He doesn't lose control; he reframes control. He makes tenderness sound like methodology. That's a voice. That's a person. The moment that actually broke me was quieter: 'He washed her gently before cleaning up himself.' No fanfare, no dialogue, just action. After sex, after passion, after the vulnerable exposure of bodies—he still takes care of her. That's the emotional core the author is building toward: love as maintenance, not just fire.
... Read More
Okay so this whole section is basically one continuous mini-milestone arc and honestly? Chef's kiss. The author takes what could be an incredibly mundane scene—two babies learning to roll over—and turns it into something with actual dramatic weight. Let me explain. We start with Mu Wan receiving that call from Lin Wei, which functions as the inciting incident of this whole sequence. Suddenly we have two families converging in one nursery. The setup is almost comedic in its symmetry: two babies, two mothers, both four months old-ish, both at that magical developmental stage where rolling over is the holy grail. And then the author drops the timeline reference—"Three months to roll over, six to sit, nine to crawl"—which does double duty as both practical parenting info AND narrative scaffolding. We know exactly where this is heading. What I loved was the pacing of the actual roll-over attempts. First Liu Anzhi tries and fails with a soft "plop." Then Lu Yi He, ever the competitive one, flips over again like "watch this." And then the climax—Liu Anzhi finally does it, and the moment she lands on her stomach, face-to-face with Lu Yi He, the narrative practically holds its breath. This is the scene everyone waited for, and the author delivers with this line: "She looked like a mochi dusted with powdered sugar, rolling right over Mu Wan's heart, sweet enough to make Mu Wan momentarily speechless." But here's where the plot gets interesting—right after the roll-over triumph, Lu Yi He leans in to nibble on her. Lin Wei scoops him up like "NOPE, not happening" and delivers the line about asking permission before kissing a girl. This is essentially the first instance of romantic comedy groundwork being laid for these two kids. The author is subtly building toward some future pairing, and the fact that both mothers are already joking about making Liu Anzhi Lin Wei's "daughter-in-law" adds this delicious layer of dramatic irony. We know something is coming; the characters are just playing along. The ending circles back beautifully to Liu Qianxiu returning home and witnessing the same roll-over in person after already seeing the video. The author makes a point about how "witnessing her roll over in person made his eyes flicker with emotion"—which tells us everything we need to know about this father's character without stating it outright. This is showing, not telling, and it works. Overall, the plot structure here is deceptively simple. On the surface it's slice-of-life domestic content, but underneath there's genuine narrative architecture: setup, escalation, climax (the successful roll-over), and a denouement that plants seeds for future plot developments. The author treats baby milestones with the same narrative seriousness as any epic plot point, and honestly? That's what makes it work.
... Read More
Okay so this whole baby-holding scene is genuinely one of my favorite character moments. Like, Mu Wan is all nervous and clumsy trying to cradle the kid, getting instructions from Xu Xingkong, and then Liu Qianxiu just... steps in and handles it perfectly without any hesitation. No "where do I put my hands?" nonsense. He just knows. And when Huai Jing calls him out on it—"You're pretty good at holding a baby. Why were you so modest about needing advice?"—and Liu Qianxiu says "He looks like you" with this tiny little smile? I literally gasped. That is such a Liu Qianxiu move. He doesn't do anything loud or showy, but he's clearly been paying attention to every single person in this room. The fact that he noticed the baby resembles Huai Jing without being prompted tells me everything I need to know about this guy's level of observation. Meanwhile Mu Wan is over here tugging his arm like "I just held him, he's so soft!" and she's still trying to figure out if she's being careless for not knowing all these pregnancy things. Liu Qianxiu handles all the details while she feels inadequate—that dynamic right there is everything. He's meticulous, she's absent-minded, and they balance each other out without either of them resenting it. Also the moment on the bridge where she asks what he can't do and says "Can't give birth in my place?" and he just... doesn't answer? That silence says so much. He's sitting there thinking about how helpless he feels in the face of what she's about to go through, and he can't even put it into words. Men really do have it easier in these situations, as she pointed out, and watching him struggle with that powerlessness is kind of heartbreaking.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or