Incurable - Reviews

Incurable
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Mu Wan because honestly, she deserves an award for how she handles this situation. Most characters in romance novels would either be defensive or insecure when their spouse gets jealous, but Mu Wan? She just... goes for it. She notices he's distant, she acknowledges her guilt for neglecting him during Lin Wei's wedding, and then she literally climbs onto his lap and starts pecking his face like he's a stress ball. And the best part? She's not fawning or apologizing excessively. She's playful. She says things like, "If I got jealous every time, we'd have enough to start a vinegar factory." Which is hilarious because it's both true and a brilliant deflection. She's essentially saying: I see you're feeling threatened by high school ghosts, and instead of making it bigger, I'm going to remind you that you're the man I chose. Liu Qianxiu is fascinating in this chapter too. He's this serene, almost monk-like figure—meditating, quiet, controlled. But then Mu Wan traces her finger across the condensation on a car window to draw a heart, and suddenly we see this softer side. The Finland memory is everything. He painted a red heart on glass in a cabin surrounded by snow. That man doesn't say "I love you"—he paints love into existence and hopes she notices. Their dynamic reads like a dance. He pulls away slightly, she closes the distance. He stays silent, she fills the space. But here's what's beautiful: neither is performing. This isn't a power struggle. When he finally interrupts her with that kiss, it's not possessiveness—it's him saying, in the only language he has sometimes, "I needed this more than I said." The pregnancy angle adds another layer. She mentions casually, almost offhand, that she's carrying his child. It's not a weapon, it's a fact—something they both know is binding them closer even as they navigate these quiet moments of vulnerability.
... Read More
I'm going to be controversial and say the lotus root is the most important object in this entire passage. Not the ring—not the phone, not the bed, but the muddy vegetable being scraped clean in a kitchen sink. Think about it: lotus roots grow in mud, their exterior dirty and unappealing, but beneath that lies pale, tender flesh—structured, pure, edible only after proper preparation. How many times has Mu Wan's own mother been warned that unmarried pregnancy leaves you stained? That the outside world won't see your interior purity? That you must be cleaned before you can be consumed? Liu Qianxiu handling this root without hesitation, without disgust, without treating it as beneath him—that's the thesis of the novel. He doesn't care about the mud. He knows what's inside. And when Mu Wan watches him, 'their eyes meeting,' she sees not just a man who can cook but a man who understands that value isn't surface-level. This is her answer to her mother's fear: I am different. I will not be judged by my exterior history. The 'dual cultivation' conversation operates on the same symbolic frequency—ancient Chinese practice where two people combine energies to achieve transcendence. Liu Qianxiu reframes sex as spiritual practice, intimacy as methodology, desire as discipline. He's saying: what we're doing isn't vulgar; it's systematic. It's holy in its own way. And Mu Wan accepts this framing because she needs to believe that their physical relationship has depth beyond pleasure—that it's preparation, not just indulgence. Then there's the ending: sleeplessness, the phone call about banquet styles, the abstraction of marriage becoming concrete through color schemes and venue choices. The theme here is inevitable acceleration—how quickly the personal becomes logistical, how fast intimacy gets scheduled. The novel isn't asking whether love conquers all; it's asking whether love can survive being organized.
... Read More
I keep thinking about that wedding dress moment. Mu Wan tries on several styles—traditional, Western—but settles on a simple red one. Red is such a loaded color. In many cultures it's luck, celebration, passion, but also tradition and destiny. She looks in the mirror and suddenly the significance hits her. The solemnity of it all. That moment isn't just about picking an outfit; it's about stepping into a new identity. The red dress becomes a kind of threshold. And Liu Qianxiu watching her emerge from behind the door—that's symbolic too. He's seeing her in this new light, this chosen symbol of her commitment. Their interaction around it—her twirling, asking for his opinion, him adjusting her collar—feels like a ritual. A quiet, intimate one. There's also the garden setting surrounding the dress fitting. Growth, nature, cycles. It mirrors the relationship evolving. And the earlier scene with Su Qiuzi and He Yu descending the stairs? She stumbles, he catches her, she pulls away but he holds firm. It's a mini-drama about marriage dynamics—comfort versus constraint, care versus control. Is it partnership or possession? The story doesn't give easy answers, but it plants the question. Themes of tradition versus personal choice weave through everything. Mu Wan chooses the red dress; it's her decision. Yet it's also steeped in cultural expectation. The narrative holds both truths without collapsing into contradiction. That's the kind of thematic depth I love—it trusts the reader to sit with ambiguity.
... Read More
I can't get over how good the dialogue is in this section. Liu Qianxiu has this wonderful dry wit that comes out in the most casual moments. The whole 'don't let anyone win you over with a lollipop' line is delivered with such seriousness, and Mu Wan literally bursts out laughing. The author writes their banter so naturally—it feels like a real married couple where they've known each other long enough to tease each other about ridiculous things. And Liu Anzhi's voice as a child is perfectly done too. When she says to the other little actress 'I only did well because my mommy was with me. If your mommy acted with you, you'd do just as well'—that's such a smart, kind thing for a child to say, and it feels authentic, not preachy. Even the side characters have distinct voices. The female actor clutching her heart and declaring she'll buy all the lollipops, the other actor comment about genes—these are real entertainment industry people, not generic extras. The author never lets dialogue become functional exposition. Every line does double duty: it reveals character AND advances the scene. That's honestly hard to do consistently.
... Read More
There's so much symbolism packed into these chapters that I couldn't help but notice. The veil itself - she sees him through it during the ceremony and his hand reaches under it to touch her face. That's such a powerful image of seeing someone truly, of removing barriers between you. Then "I'm here to take you home" - home is such a loaded word. Not just a physical place but a feeling of belonging. And the snow! She wants to see snow but it doesn't come immediately. I think the snow represents these moments of beauty that require patience. They don't get everything perfectly on schedule but they're happy anyway. The red decorations in the bridal chamber symbolize tradition and celebration but also passion. Then moving to the white and red villa surrounded by forest - it's like they've entered a new world together. Even the heating and warmth inside contrasted with the cold outside feels symbolic. They've built this warm private space within the larger world.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this scene for a moment. The one where Madam Mei comes to visit Mu Wan the night before the wedding. I genuinely felt my chest tighten. 'Madam Mei stood there, her face full of kindness... The warm light softly illuminated her silver hair, giving her the appearance of a kind grandmother straight out of a fairy tale.' This isn't just description. This is the author telling you WHO this woman is and WHY she matters without saying a single word of dialogue. She's the fairy tale grandmother. She's the archetype of maternal warmth. And yet—she's also haunted. Because when she mentions Qianxiu's mother, the warmth cracks just slightly. Mu Wan pressing her cheek against Madam Mei's hand and rubbing it gently? That's not a small gesture. That's a child seeking comfort from a mother figure. And Mu Wan just lost her own mother. I keep thinking about that. She's about to start her own life, but her mother is gone. And Madam Mei—who is essentially becoming her new mother—stays with her 'until she falls asleep.' Just like she did with her own daughter. The vow Mu Wan makes is devastating: 'We will love each other, be faithful to each other, and live a happy life together. I promise.' She's promising to Liu Qianxiu and maybe to herself and maybe to her dead mother all at once. Madam Mei's smile—'a smile slowly spreading across her face'—that's a woman who lost someone and found hope again. Don't you dare cry on my reading floor but I'm definitely not crying.
... Read More
I don't care what anyone says — snow in fiction is the ultimate pacing tool, and this author weaponizes it perfectly. The entire section operates like a snowflake: it starts slow, accumulates, and then covers everything in a thick white blanket that silences the world. Chapter 34-37 doesn't need explosions or dramatic reveals. The conflict is internal — Mu Wan's fear of happiness not lasting, Liu Qianxiu's quiet devotion, the tension between wanting permanence and knowing life is unpredictable. The structure mirrors the weather: they go from the villa into the cold darkness (rising action), the fireworks scene is the peak (climax), and then they retreat indoors where the intimacy peaks. After that — snow falls overnight, everything resets to white, and they wake into a new scene that feels both completely different and exactly the same. The snow acts as a temporal marker, a scene transition that costs nothing and achieves everything. My only note: the transition from the night scene into morning happens almost too smoothly. I wanted maybe one more beat of aftermath before the next morning — a moment where they're still in that vulnerable post-intimacy state, not immediately sliding into playful banter. But honestly, the author's instinct to keep moving forward rather than linger is probably correct. The reader is already satisfied. Pushing further would risk sentimentality. "I want to be happy right now." That's not a naive wish. That's a philosophical stance.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in pacing control, and I want to break down exactly how it works because it's not accidental. The chapter opens at maximum intimacy — two friends eating breakfast together, discussing pregnancy and engagements. The prose is relaxed, almost leisurely, matching the unhurried morning atmosphere. Each exchange lands naturally: Lin Wei explains why her taste changed, Mu Wan teases her about her mother's reactions, the parents' anger is addressed but not dwelled upon. The author trusts us to fill in emotional gaps rather than over-explaining. Then, just as we're settling into this domestic rhythm, Mu Wan drops the engagement bomb: 'We're getting engaged next week.' Lin Wei nearly chokes on a wonton. The physical reaction — spitting out food, disbelief — provides comic relief while also signaling that this news is genuinely surprising. But instead of lingering on shock, the author immediately undercuts it with 'We already got our marriage certificate yesterday.' Now we're in full speed mode. Two engagements, both happening within weeks, both already partially realized. The pace quickens naturally without feeling forced. The transition to the rain scene is where the pacing genius really shines. After the energetic breakfast conversation and engagement revelation, the narrative simply... slows down. Time stretches. We move from afternoon to evening, from noise to silence, from multiple characters to just Mu Wan and Liu Qianxiu alone. The sentence structure itself changes — longer, more lyrical, focused on atmosphere rather than action. 'The cool night air mixed with the lingering scent of rain, fresh and sweet.' These aren't plot-driving sentences; they're breath-taking sentences. They tell us: slow down. Feel this moment. The engagement banquet scene then accelerates again, introducing new characters and locations. But even here, the pacing never rushes. Mu Wan greets guests efficiently ('the guest list was small'), then moves to the second floor to discover Xu Xingkong and Su Qiuzi already chatting. The information drip-feeds — we learn Su Qiuzi is He Yu's wife, that she's a broadcaster, that she rarely attends events — without exposition dumps. The chapter ends mid-conversation ('Xu Xingkong shared her expe...'), which is a deliberate structural choice. It creates forward momentum — we need to know what she shared, what the women discussed, what happens next. But it also mirrors real life, where conversations trail off and continue later. The author understands that not every moment needs a neat bow.
... Read More
I know this chapter doesn't have any life-or-death conflict, but don't let that fool you — the stakes are real and the tension is masterfully built through social dynamics rather than dramatic crises. Let's talk about the lowest-stakes highest-tension scene in recent memory: the nurses gossiping outside the examination room. "She's pregnant? But Dr. Liu isn't married yet, right?" "So it's an out-of-wedlock pregnancy." Mu Wan hearing this while sitting right there, unable to defend herself, is actually more stressful than any action sequence. The stakes here are reputation, dignity, and the sanctity of their relationship being reduced to hospital gossip. The internal conflict is subtler but equally compelling. Mu Wan's realization that she's actually married to Liu Qianxiu — that's a psychological stake. She went from "I thought you had foreign nationality" to "I love you so much~" to genuinely processing the permanence of their bond. The stakes are emotional growth and the vulnerability of truly letting someone in. Xiao Yun's presence adds another layer of tension. She's a surgeon with a mentor in OB-GYN, she's organizing files, she's there during a private moment. Is she a romantic rival? A threat? The author deliberately leaves this ambiguous, and that uncertainty creates narrative friction without needing any actual conflict. And then there's the Mei family subplot ending the chapter. A phone call from Mei Yaozhi, discussions about the engagement banquet, and the mention of Mei Lao Tai's health — these are external stakes that will likely create complications. Family expectations, traditional obligations, potential interference. The author is laying groundwork for future conflict while keeping the current moment sweet and earned. The chapter proves that you don't need villains or disasters to maintain tension. Sometimes the most dangerous thing in a romance novel is a group of observant nurses with nothing better to do.
... Read More
Okay, so this part of the book isn't all about huge twists or life-or-death stakes, but the way the plot is built is really satisfying. It's like watching a puzzle click together. The main thread is clearly Mu Wan and Liu Qianxiu's relationship moving toward marriage, but it's wrapped up in these everyday scenes—visiting the Mei family, playing mahjong, talking about the engagement banquet. What I love is how the author uses the family dinner and the mahjong game to advance the plot without it feeling forced. When Mei Laotai asks, 'Is the engagement banquet going to be held at the Liu residence?' it's not just small talk; it's the story showing us that everything is falling into place. The subplot of Mu Wan feeling at home in the Mei family contrasts with her quiet worries about Liu Qianxiu's past (his parents' fractured relationship), and it all ties together to make the future seem both hopeful and earned. There's no big dramatic twist here, but the coherence is what gets me. Every little conversation feels like it's building toward something real. And that moment when Mu Wan laughs silently during mahjong because she imagines Liu Qianxiu giving a cringey engagement speech? That's the plot showing us character through subtle humor, not exposition. It's a slow-burn plot, but it's so well-paced that I found myself nodding along, thinking, 'Yeah, this makes sense.' The author doesn't rush; they let the relationship develop through shared silence, small touches, and family warmth. It's a plot that trusts its readers to feel the progression rather than shout it. Makes me wonder if later chapters will introduce some conflict, but for now, I'm just enjoying the steady, reliable march toward that engagement.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is chef's kiss. It's so natural and reveals their personalities perfectly. Mu Wan's voice comes through as playful and a bit teasing especially in intimate moments. Like when she starts to laugh about the wedding night and says "Well, it's our wedding night…" but then gets shy. And Liu Qianxiu's responses are always measured and warm. His line "I won't tire out my little bride" is such a perfect mix of teasing and devotion. The conversation about where to go relax is great too - she says "Let's go somewhere with snow, or maybe to the beach" and he just agrees and makes it happen. Their dialogue doesn't over-explain it just flows. And the manager's lines add this nice business-world texture without being intrusive. The author has a light touch with dialogue - it's never heavy-handed or expository, just natural conversation that moves the scene forward. That's really skilled writing.
... Read More
I need to address the elephant in the room: the fake death. Because everything in this chapter — every tender moment, every decision, every hope for the future — is colored by it. When Mu Wan reflects that 'except for that one incident with Liu Qianxiu's fake death, nothing had ever come between them,' she's not minimizing the trauma; she's marking it as the threshold before which their relationship was different. The word 'incident' is almost too clinical for something that must have shattered her world. And yet — and this is crucial — she doesn't dwell in grief. The narrative moves forward, into engagement planning and baby room designs, because that's how healing works. You don't revisit the wound continuously; you build a life around it. The stakes here are enormous, and the author makes them feel present even in domestic scenes. When Liu Qianxiu says 'I'll protect you and make sure your life is always happy and secure,' read that as a man who has already experienced losing the person he loves and is now hyper-vigilant about never being separated again. His protectiveness isn't controlling; it's traumatized. There's a difference. Lin Wei's conflict is more external — parental disapproval, societal judgment, the pressure of an unconventional pregnancy. Her parents called her 'reckless,' which is the word society uses for women who don't follow the script. But the stakes are clear: if she and Lu Feng fail, she faces not just personal heartbreak but family rejection and social shame. The fact that her parents are now coming to meet him suggests the external conflict is easing, but the memory of that anger lingers. What's fascinating is that both women face different kinds of risk but share the same fundamental question: can they trust that their happiness will last? Lin Wei asks, 'Do you want a boy or a girl?' — a question about the future, about building something permanent. Mu Wan can't even answer that yet because she and Liu Qianxiu haven't discussed it. Why? Because after surviving the fake death, maybe she needs more time to feel safe enough to imagine beyond survival. The engagement banquet scene raises the stakes socially. Introducing the 'Four Young Masters' and their wives suggests a web of relationships that could become sites of conflict or alliance. Su Qiuzi's detachment hints at marital complications. Xu Xingkong's pregnancy experience might reveal something significant. The author is clearly setting up future conflicts even as these women bask in current happiness.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or