I Am A TS Reincarnation, But I Have A Kid - Reviews

I Am A TS Reincarnation, But I Have A Kid
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There are so many layers to unpack in these chapters, and I keep coming back to one idea: the novel is deeply concerned with how love communicates—or fails to communicate—between people. The cloud table itself is symbolic. It's a space between worlds, a liminal zone where truths can be spoken that would be impossible in the real world. Mika can only confess her deepest regrets in heaven. Saki's parents can only express gratitude from beyond death. The setting isn't accidental—it represents the novel's thesis that some understanding requires stepping outside ordinary life. Then there are the cookies. The protagonist eats them and thinks 'That's good.' Simple, domestic, grounded. Even in this heavenly space, food connects us to humanity. It's a tiny detail but it matters. And the puzzle Saki is working on when the protagonist returns—'it seemed to look like that you just had to fit the pieces together, which was very different from the picture on the package.' This image of mismatched expectations vs. reality echoes everything: Mika's strictness didn't match her love, Saki's fear didn't match her reality, and the protagonist's confusion didn't match their growing bond with the girl. The recurring motif of mismatch is everywhere. The Nonogami parents thank someone who isn't who they expected. Mika receives forgiveness she never imagined. The protagonist discovers that the dead can sit across from the living and share tea. Nothing is what it appears to be, and yet—everything still fits together, like puzzle pieces you can't quite see but somehow connect.
... Read More
Let's talk about the stakes here because on the surface this reads like a cozy slice-of-life transmigration story and I am here for the slow burn of absolute catastrophe building in the background. The protagonist has no money of their own—the bank book contains Saki's inheritance, which they feel morally obligated to preserve. They have no job (Mika was unemployed, apparently after yelling at a director and grabbing him by the head—okay so Mika was a chaotic mess and now that chaos is inherited). They have no identity of their own, no memories that fully align with this body, and they're raising a three-year-old girl who has every reason to be traumatized and suspicious. Meanwhile there's Yuki texting about workplace drama, there's the unresolved tension with Mika's family who clearly rejected Saki, and there's the looming question of what happens when people find out this isn't really Mika anymore. The author is stacking problems like Jenga blocks and I am waiting for the tower to fall. But what I love is how the protagonist handles it—all the urgency channeled into folding futons and cooking dinner and making sure a child eats her vegetables. The external stakes are catastrophic and the internal stakes are equally huge, but the story treats them with the same weight. That balance is incredibly hard to pull off and this author nails it. The question isn't whether they'll survive—it's whether they'll survive without losing themselves, and whether Saki will ever truly trust someone who looks like her aunt but isn't her aunt...
... Read More
There is a moment in chapter 8 where the protagonist reads through Mika's unsent emails and discovers that Saki's parents both died in a car accident—her mother literally shielding her with her body—and then the grandparents are dead too, and the only family left (Mika's family) didn't want her. Just... that. One after another after another. And the protagonist reads this and starts crying. Not dramatic sobbing, just quietly losing it while looking at the kid sleeping peacefully across the room. I cannot deal with this. I am not okay. The line that wrecked me though? "She didn't get along with her family?" The protagonist interrupts their own reading because their heart breaks mid-sentence. They can't even finish processing how cruel this all is. And then they look at Saki and make this promise—"I was going to protect this child! I promised myself firmly." Right there. No fanfare. Just a person who just woke up in someone else's body making a vow to protect a three-year-old girl who has already lost everyone. What hits me the most is the contrast between the darkness of what the protagonist discovers and the almost mundane domesticity of everything else. They find out about mass death and family rejection, and then their immediate reaction is to shout "Let's take a bath for a change!" to cheer themselves up. The voice is high-pitched and unfamiliar and they apologize for waking Saki. These tiny human moments layered on top of genuine trauma—that's where the emotional power lives. Not in the big declarations but in the daily practice of showing up.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is honestly so clever and I want to unpack it. We open on what feels like a completely separate scene — tickling Saki, playing around, pure joy. Then we cut to midnight. Just... midnight. No warning. One moment they're laughing and the next our protagonist is alone in the dark practicing his new name. That transition is brutal in the best way. It goes from light to heavy in a single beat and you just... feel it. Then morning comes at 6am with Yuki absolutely demolishing the peace. The pace spikes — loud dialogue, physical comedy (the back-kicking detail?), chaotic energy. But then Saki wakes up and immediately goes back to sleep with this cute 'Umu~' and the whole scene deflates gently. The author knows exactly when to compress and when to expand. What really works is how the internal monologue is woven into the pacing. Our protagonist's thoughts about the dead Mika, about Satoshi, about whether to send Saki to nursery — they come at natural breathing points in the scene, never interrupting the flow. The breakfast conversation at the end feels like the calm after a storm, and it ends on this almost mundane note about yogurt. Which is perfect. Life goes on. The chaos subsides. And we're left wanting more.
... Read More
Let me be honest—the structure of this chapter could have been a mess. You have a breakfast scene, a taxi ride, a statue visit, a hair salon, and a clothing store. That is five locations in what amounts to a single day trip and it is easy to see how this could drag or feel rushed. But the pacing here is surprisingly controlled. The author uses Saki as a metronome. Whenever the scene risks losing momentum, Saki spots something—a tall building, a dog, a cat—and the energy resets. Her childish curiosity pulls the narrative forward. The taxi scene is where I think the pacing is most impressive. We start with dialogue about strawberries and aloe, move into Saki's fear of the taxi, and then the author drops this devastating realization: 'I should have realized this sooner.' That single paragraph shifts the entire tone from light to heavy without slowing the scene down at all. Then we recover with the Hachiko encounter, which is physical comedy at its best—the three of them struggling to let Saki touch the statue while strangers watch. The hair salon and shopping sequences serve as denouement and resolution. By the time Mika buys herself that pink diamond necklace, the chapter has completed its emotional arc. It is not a cliffhanger chapter but it does not need to be. The pacing trusts the reader to care about small moments.
... Read More
I need to talk about the room-searching scene because the way the protagonist describes snooping through Mika's things is honestly one of the most awkwardly human moments I've read. They literally say they feel like a thief. Like they're invading privacy. And yet they do it anyway because they need to understand who they are now. The details are so specific and telling: the expired driver's license, the insurance card, the family register hidden under clothes (like someone was trying to hide it or protect it), famous brand clothes and bags that the protagonist "was unlikely to use." This is a woman who had money but was unemployed. Who had connections but was isolated. Who kept her family register hidden like it was evidence of a crime. And then the phone. The unsent emails. That's such a brilliant storytelling choice by the author—having the protagonist discover the truth through digital artifacts rather than exposition. The emails read like fragments of a life, not a neatly packaged backstory. We get pieces: the car accident in early March, the mother's sacrifice, the dead grandparents, the hostile relationship with the parents. Each detail drops like a stone into water and we see the ripples. The bedroom itself feels lived-in and real. Clothes in drawers, a phone with saved contacts ("Yuki"—just a first name, which tells us something about how Mika managed her relationships), a bank book with the PIN conveniently written on paper. This isn't a curated space; it's a real person's messy, complicated life frozen in static.
... Read More
I came in thinking this was going to be some generic isekai fluff and now I'm sitting here writing essays about a fictional toddler like she's my actual child. Saki-chan, you menace. You absolute menace. The moment that absolutely destroyed me was when Saki asks "Are you an angel? You're giving me this?" and the protagonist just says yes. That exchange is so simple but it carries so much weight. This child—who has clearly been through something, who hides money because she doesn't trust adults—looks at this person who took her in and sees someone miraculous. And the protagonist, who is probably just as lost and confused as she is, doesn't correct her. They let her believe they're an angel. That's not lying—that's choosing to be the soft thing in her world. And then there's the wallet scene. The protagonist takes out Mika's wallet—which they should probably not be touching, honestly—and gives Saki money. Not because they're rich or anything, but because they want to give this kid something. Even the fact that they're using someone else's money to do it adds this layer of guilt and tenderness. They're surviving in borrowed circumstances and still trying to give. What gets me every time is how the protagonist's affection for Saki is portrayed—not as some grand heroic sacrifice but as small moments. Writhing on the floor because she's too cute. Saving her drawings. Taking pictures. Making pasta sauce two days in advance so lunch is ready. These are the details that make you cry, not some dramatic confession scene. The author also doesn't shy away from the harder emotions. The call center scene—"There really are no good men here"—that's not just comic relief, that's loneliness. The protagonist is isolated in a body that's not theirs, doing a job they probably hated before and still hates now, and the only bright spot is a three-year-old who thinks they're an angel. That contrast is devastating in the best way. I'm not okay. This book has me emotionally compromised and I'm only on chapter fourteen.
... Read More
"It's good!" She said this about the kids' meal and her eyes were sparkling and I literally had to put the phone down for a second because THAT IS SO CUTE I CAN'T. This is the kind of moment that makes transmigration novels worth reading. Not the truck, not the god, not the new body—it's the omelette rice with a flag sticking out of it and a three-year-old experiencing what seems like genuine warmth for the first time. The protagonist started eating their own sandwich, and the girl literally copied them, spoon in hand, trying to mirror this strange new person who did something kind. What wrecked me was the narrative aside: 'Maybe she couldn't believe this woman was being nice to her, but it hurt me a little bit because I was the one instead of her.' That line hits different. The protagonist is so empathetic that even experiencing kindness toward the child vicariously stings—because they understand exactly what the child has been missing. They're projecting their own understanding of neglect onto every silent nod, every frozen expression. There's also something bittersweet about the protagonist's internal panic over their own body—'I'm so beautiful'—while the real emotional weight is on the child's simple joy. The contrast between surface-level transmigration shock and deep maternal attachment happening simultaneously is beautifully handled. One moment they're freaking out about having breasts, the next they're emotionally destroyed by a kid saying 'it's good' about a childhood meal. I'm already shipping this mother-daughter bond harder than any romantic CP in any novel. No competition.
... Read More
I need to talk about the girl because my heart actually hurt during that family restaurant scene. The way the narrative describes her—frozen, eyes on the protagonist, mouth open, silently pointing at the menu like she doesn't even know what to do with kindness—that is such a precise, devastating detail. This child has clearly never had someone buy her a meal, let alone ask what she wants. And then later at the supermarket, those stares from strangers, people checking out the beautiful woman and then seeing the child and losing interest? That tells you everything about how this mother-daughter pair has been perceived in this world. Invisible when the mother was alive, probably ignored, probably suffering quietly. The protagonist's reaction is equally telling. They feel anger at the dead woman—not just negligence but cruelty, leaving a child starving while the fridge is full of beer. But there's no time for genuine hatred because the child is right there, scared and hungry, and the protagonist has to be whatever this kid needs. That internal conflict between 'I'm still figuring out who I am' and 'this little girl needs me' is the emotional core right now. I'm already invested in how their relationship evolves. Will the girl learn to trust? Will the protagonist resist and then soften, or is it instant maternal instinct overriding everything? The fact that the girl was initially scared of them says so much about the damage done. And the protagonist sensing that fear but choosing to walk slowly anyway—small gesture, huge character moment.
... Read More
The symbolism in these early chapters is surprisingly rich if you pay attention. The most obvious one is the fridge—completely empty of food but stocked with beer. That's not just a plot detail about poverty; it's a visual metaphor for the previous owner's priorities and self-destruction. Alcohol fills the space where nourishment should be. The fancy clothes in the closet, brand new and unworn, suggest someone who was performing a lifestyle rather than living one—appearance over substance, which is exactly what neglecting a child looks like. Then there's the currency of knowledge. The protagonist knows where the station is and how to navigate the city but doesn't remember their own name. This inversion—gaining the world but losing the self—is a quiet commentary on identity. What makes us who we are? Is it memory? Body? Relationships? The story seems to be suggesting it's the last one, because right after the existential crisis about their forgotten name, the narrative immediately pivots to the child's hunger. The silver-ash hair and beautiful face of the body is also interesting. The protagonist is given a mask of beauty and youth that the world will respond to positively, but that mask hides the trauma underneath. People stare at her, but they stop staring when they see the child. Beauty draws attention; motherhood erases it in this world's eyes. That's a commentary I didn't expect from chapter 4 but here we are. And the light motif—from the blinding white space of transmigration to the sparkling eyes of the girl at the restaurant—connects the cosmic-scale event to the intimate-scale joy. The same light that brings you into a new world also illuminates a child's happiness over a kids' meal. Big themes, small moments, same glow.
... Read More
I cannot stop thinking about how perfectly this sequence mirrors the narrator's life—always starting with careful intention and immediately getting derailed by external chaos. Let me unpack why this works so well on a structural level. The chapter opens with what seems like a quiet, intimate moment: the narrator teaching himself to do Saki's makeup. This is a low-stakes setup that makes you feel safe, right? But watch how the author immediately undermines it. First by having Chinatsu arrive and critique his work, then by having him agree to learn cooking as a way to repay her. Every time you think the scene is settled, someone knocks at the door. The real plot twist here isn't any big revelation—it's the timing of Yuki's arrival. Think about it: the narrator has just made peace with the fact that Chinatsu is taking over the kitchen, has sent her a meaningful apology glance, has accepted that tonight is about teaching her to cook. And then Yuki shows up with a hot plate and announces yakiniku. The structural irony is delicious. Chinatsu, who came all the way here in her uniform apron on her day off, becomes the background character in her own arc. What makes this plot move so smoothly is that every beat feels inevitable in retrospect. You could argue it's chaotic, but that chaos is the point. The narrator keeps making plans—makeup for Saki, cooking for Chinatsu—and every single one gets interrupted by someone entering through that door. It's a running gag that also reflects something true about how these three people's lives intersect: none of them get the scene they wanted, but somehow it all works out anyway. The ending is perfect because it doesn't resolve anything cleanly. Chinatsu sighs and leaves the kitchen. Saki is jumping around yelling made-up words that combine soft serve and grilled meat. The narrator is left holding the knife he was never going to use, watching Yuki set up a hot plate that wasn't on the menu. It's open-ended in a way that feels satisfying rather than frustrating, because the story has never been about control—it's about adaptation.
... Read More
So this batch opens with what sounds like a pretty intense scene — someone grabbing another person by the head, lots of resentment against a middle-aged male employee, Mika doing something heroic. But then — BAM — we're cooking dinner and watching TV with a kid. The whiplash is REAL and I love it. The transition is basically: action moment → dinner prep → Saki mutters 'hide and seek' because she saw it on a recorded anime → and suddenly we're in the Coziest Scene Ever. The author doesn't waste any time dwelling on the dramatic stuff though. It's almost like, yeah, there was some conflict, whatever, let's get to the GOOD STUFF — playing with the kid, measuring heights, figuring out dinner. Then it pivots AGAIN to Mika getting a job. Part-time call center, 1500 yen per hour after training, working from home so she can still take care of Saki. The author just... slides right into this practical life update like it's no big deal. But honestly, it works. The pacing feels VERY deliberate here — big dramatic moments are kept short and punchy, and then we get these long, quiet stretches of DAILY LIFE that somehow carry just as much weight. The chapter ends with Saki asking 'How old are you, Saki-chan?' and it cuts off mid-sentence. Classic cliffhanger energy but also kind of funny because it's just a kid being a kid mid-conversation. The author knows exactly how to control the rhythm — when to slow down and let us BREATHE in these domestic moments, and when to cut things off abruptly to keep us hooked. No dragging, no rushing, just... perfect.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or