I Really Am Just A Substitute[E-Sports] - Reviews

I Really Am Just A Substitute[E-Sports]
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so this batch starts with what reads like a post-match scene. ENG wins 2:1, there's some casual team gossip about IB struggling to find a mid-laner, and then we're on the bus. It feels cozy, almost slice-of-life. But then—bam—the narrative pivots hard into spy-thriller territory when Lin Lan decides to visit Dr. Wu Ming. I have to admit I was slightly caught off guard by this tonal shift. One minute we're talking about gaming rosters and the next Lin Lan is wearing a disguise, carrying a voice recorder, and shadowing a suspicious doctor to a suspect's apartment. That said, the author handles the transition fairly well by using the bus ride as a buffer. Xiao Shengjing's warning about not investigating acts as a bridge—it plants the seed of the conspiracy while the mood is still relaxed. The pacing within the hospital scene itself is tight though. Dr. Wu Ming handing over the unlisted medicine bottle, Lin Lan's moment of dizziness, the deliberate disguise change, the covert photography—all of it moves with purpose. No filler. The chapter ends on a cliffhanger with Wu Ming calling to schedule a follow-up exam, which screams suspicion. I immediately flipped to the next chapter. Sorry, my attention span is not to blame here.
... Read More
This chapter moves in waves, and I'm not sure if that's accidental brilliance or calculated restraint. We start in medias res with Thresh and a smurf account—immediate tension, no warm-up. Then we drop into the Jiang Jin backstory, and it unfolds like a case file being read aloud: indecisive person, three-page analysis, voice message rejection, solo queue brutalization, joining the enemy team. Each beat is deliberately spaced, like the author knows we need air between revelations. But then—back to present, Draven pick, Jiang Jin going conservative, Lin Lan teasing him with 'can't even catch the axes,' and then the pivot: combo secured, enemy AD carry down. The pacing here shifts from reflective to kinetic in two paragraphs. And that cliffhanger ending with the enemy jungler showing up? Perfect. Not because it's suspenseful for its own sake, but because it mirrors Jiang Jin's entire arc: always about to be caught, always one step behind, always reaching. What I love most is how the chapter structure itself enacts the theme. The past intrudes on the present like Jiang Jin keeps intruding on Lin Lan's lanes. We're never allowed to settle into one timeline, just like Lin Lan can't settle into being just a mid laner anymore. Every transition feels earned, every pause feels heavy. And that final image—Lin Lan executing another combo, nearly killing the enemy carry, forcing Jiang Jin to follow his rhythm—that's not just a gameplay moment. That's the chapter's thesis in motion.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is sharp enough to cut glass. Let me pick apart why it works so well. First, Xiao Xia's voice is immediately distinct. She's manipulative, calculating, always three steps ahead. Watch how she handles the LPL player's response: > "Is this kind of anticipation normal?" She doesn't just accept the answer—she probes, she guides, she engineers the narrative. And when she posts: > "Xiao Xia consulted a very authoritative player (someone with super skills). He also thinks that this kind of 'anticipation' is not normal. Xiao Xia can't reveal more but hopes to continue broadcasting well in the future. Heart~" The parentheses, the vague references, the heart emoji—it's all performatively innocent while being maximally damaging. This is how real toxic fans operate. The author clearly understands internet culture at a granular level. Brother Mu's voice is the comic relief but it's earned. He's loud, he's broke, he's righteous, he's reading cultivation novels. His speech patterns are messy and authentic: > "Nonsense! I'm so broke I can't even afford equipment. Why would I buy cheats? Cheats are free, huh? Oh, not that I'm buying cheats, but you're saying Lin Lan is buying cheats? That's even more absurd." He's arguing with himself, contradicting his own logic, and somehow it's the most coherent defense of innocence I've ever heard. The comedic timing in paragraph form is impressive. Lin Lan's dialogue is sparse but weighted. When he says "The pure remains pure, the impure remains impure"—that's a philosophical stance, not just a refusal. It echoes his backstory about swallowing humiliation once and vowing never to again. Two words that carry his entire character arc. Xiao Shengjing says almost nothing. "No need." "No problem." But each phrase lands because the text surrounds it with internal reaction. His silence IS his voice. The bullet comments are legitimately good writing too. They sound like actual stream chat—fragmented, reactive, occasionally insightful:
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how alone Lin Lan is in this entire passage? Like, the management throws him under the bus, the fans are torn between defending him and hating him, and even his own team's last pick situation is this weird silent expectation that he should just magically fix everything. But the most interesting relationship dynamic here is actually Jiang Jin. This guy is watching from the sidelines absolutely terrified for Lin Lan because HE KNOWS what online violence does. The text says Jiang Jin experienced it himself, that his introverted nature made it hard to get through. So he's not just some random worried friend—he's someone who has been carved up by the same internet mob, and now he's watching the person he cares about walk right into it again. That's the part that got me. It's not dramatic confrontation or emotional confession—it's just this quiet, aching worry from across the room. And then Lin Lan, who has every reason to run away, literally steps forward anyway. The passage says "No one knew the determination he had made." Whoa. That line hit me hard. Because it implies Lin Lan's decision wasn't some heroic speech moment—it was private, internal, maybe even painful. He carries all of this history of being destroyed by public opinion, and still chooses to stand in the crosshairs. That's not just courage, that's something more complicated than bravery. It's almost like he's trying to prove something to the version of himself that used to hide in his room.
... Read More
Let's be real—Xu Shengwei's dialogue is basically one word repeated across three paragraphs. "Yeah." "17." "No, I'm afraid I'll drag you down." "Yes." That's it. And somehow, it works. His voice is defined by everything he doesn't say. When Lin Lan asks him to come to the main team, Xu Shengwei doesn't celebrate or even smile—he just obeys. When Feifei teases him about being nervous, he can't even respond. The author is doing something clever here: by giving this character such a stripped-down voice, every single word carries weight. Compare that to Lin Lan, who speaks casually and confidently—"Quite diligent," "Not willing to support me?"—and you immediately understand their dynamic without a single narrator description. Lin Lan's dialogue has rhythm and warmth, even when he's being direct. And then there's Lu Shi, the extroverted one who bounces off everyone else, trying to keep conversation flowing and getting awkwardly blocked every time. The real masterstroke is the dialogue during the match itself. It's almost nonexistent—just Lin Lan giving terse instructions like "Pay attention to my positioning" and Xu Shengwei responding with "yes." But those sparse exchanges are doing so much work. They show us Xu Shengwei's growth in real time without needing internal monologue. He doesn't need to say he's learning; the fact that he follows instructions and eventually flashes to save Lin Lan tells the whole story. The author understands that in high-pressure situations, people don't monologue—they act.
... Read More
The forum scene is one of the most vividly imagined school-world details I've read recently. Not just 'there's a chatroom'—the author built an actual ecosystem. The eagle emblem. The five-second quiz questions that test your knowledge before you even get in. The VIP-only club sections with lock symbols. The way the non-encrypted posts look normal on the surface but rot the further you scroll. 'These are the secret codes within their circle. Only they can understand them.' That single line does so much worldbuilding. It tells you that Shengyuan has an underground social hierarchy that operates in a coded language outsiders can't penetrate. It's not just a fancy school with rich kids—it's a parallel society with its own customs, its own surveillance, its own enforcement. The Gotham club description alone is chilling: 'Welcome to the land of desire,' clown mask profile picture, 171 members, ranked #1 above the Student Council. The author doesn't need to show us what they actually do—we already know from the murder mentions and the alley bullying. The horror is in what's implied, not shown. And the technical detail about IP restrictions! The fact that Xiao Shengjing has to fabricate a virtual school IP just to log in tells you everything about how isolated and controlled this environment is. This isn't a normal school website with weak security—it's fortress-level. Which makes the fact that the bullies still operate through it even scarier. They're not just untouchable in the physical world; they're untouchable in the digital one too. The river scene afterward is beautifully understated though. Sunlight, breeze, the simple act of walking. It grounds the whole tech-heavy mystery in something sensory and human.
... Read More
I have to appreciate how the author renders the online fan culture because it genuinely feels alive. The opening paragraph about the barrage/danmu is such a vivid snapshot of esports fandom. You have people who previously criticized DT for buying promotional articles now SILENTLY wishing DT would buy MORE — that is such a specific and accurate portrayal of fan psychology. Then you have the latejoiners who 'deliberately waited for the DT match to finish' thinking they could join in the criticism, only to be 'immediately overwhelmed by the massive flood of genuine fans.' The image of those confused new fans searching up the match and realizing 'oh my, what did they miss?' made me laugh out loud because this happens ALL the time in every fandom. The author captures that moment perfectly when the tide has already turned. And then contrasting that with the ENG vs IB match where 'the barrage is significantly more intense, with the fans' output being quite astonishing' — you can literally feel the toxicity and energy shifting between the two matches. The first match brought unity and praise; the second brings chaos and hostility. The world feels real because the internet culture around it is so specifically rendered. Even little details like fans 'poking at each other's sore spots, digging into each other's dark histories' — this isn't generic sports fandom, this is specifically Chinese esports culture and the author knows it.
... Read More
Let me paint you a picture of what's about to go WRONG. Really wrong. Beautifully wrong. On one side, you've got Lin Lan—already drowning in his own secrets (the whole 'I'm not actually Lin Lan' thing, which we know but Jiang Jin doesn't). He just accidentally sent a voice message confirming his real identity to the one person who's been wanting to team up with him. And his reaction? 'How did he recognize me?' Like it's a minor inconvenience, like he dropped a rank. He has NO IDEA the mountain of drama he just kicked into gear. On the OTHER side, you've got Jiang Jin, who has spent chapters admiring this mysterious noob player, seeing potential, building this fantasy of a partnership. And now? Now he has proof. Not circumstantial evidence—VOICE DATA that matches exactly. This man is trembling as he sends 'Are you Lin Lan?' and Lin Lan is over there thinking about breakfast and rank drops. The stakes here are SO much higher than a simple identity reveal. If Jiang Jin finds out Lin Lan was deceiving him this whole time—playing as someone else, using a different name, hiding behind a screen—what happens to their friendship? To the professional team opportunity Jiang Jin has been dangling? To whatever bond they built through late-night matches and trash talk? And it's compounded by the fact that Lin Lan's FIRST response is 'I didn't mean to deceive you.' Which, honey, that's an ADMISSION, not a denial. You've already confessed to the crime before the trial even started. Meanwhile, completely oblivious to all of this, Xiao Shengjing is at home trying to get a passed-out Lin Lan to sleep after helping him change clothes. Three different conflict threads running in parallel, and they're all about to collide. I can feel the impending doom and I am HERE FOR IT.
... Read More
This passage wrecked me in the best possible way, and I need to process it. Wu Tianqi's arc is the emotional centerpiece here. Remember how the text described him? "His usual arrogance and domineering attitude were replaced by a sense of humiliation, bowing down as if being made small." There's something almost painful about watching a character who built his identity on superiority get systematically stripped of it. But here's what surprised me — I didn't feel zero sympathy for him. The author carefully shows us that this same person trained until 3 AM trying to earn his place back. "He must strive to get on the stage and regain control." That desperate hunger underneath the shame? That's human. Then there's Lin Lan, who was "treated with contempt" and is now suddenly the center of attention. The passage doesn't dwell on his emotions explicitly — instead it shows us through Lu Shi's disbelief, through the team's laughter, through Wu Tianqi's clenched fists watching from the sidelines. The victory is quiet but enormous. The Jiang Jin thread adds a completely different emotional flavor. In the original timeline, Lin Lan teased him, lied to him, and Jiang Jin followed him like a lost puppy before spiraling into rivalry. Now, in this new world, Jiang Jin is still pursuing — but the power dynamic has shifted. When Lin Lan asks "Are you really a support player?" after that pentakill, there's this bittersweet recognition happening beneath the text. Jiang Jin sees someone extraordinary and can't quite reconcile it with who he thought that person was. The pentakill itself is pure catharsis. Six kills in ten minutes, cutting through the lane, dominating a player who clearly has serious skill. For a support-turned-AD player to pull this off isn't just gameplay flexing — it's the emotional payoff of a character who was always capable but never given the spotlight.
... Read More
I want to give credit where it's due: the commentary voices in this chapter are genuinely good. Not the typical esports fic problem where every analyst sounds like they're reading from the same Wikipedia article, but actual distinct reactions that feel like real people watching a match live. 'Lulu built a Crucible? It's the third item, and she already built a Crucible?'—that line has genuine shock in it. You can hear the commentator leaning forward in their seat. And later, 'What if the damage overflows?' shows someone who actually understands the mechanics and is worried for the right reasons, not just generating filler dialogue. The live chat reactions are a nice touch too: [Isn't this too risky for the item build?] [If Jiang Jin makes a mistake, won't they lose everything?] These feel like actual Twitch chat, not author-insert opinions disguised as viewers. The narrator's voice is also doing a lot of work here—phrases like 'A double kill in one wave, making him incredibly wealthy' and 'In front of the predator, even the strongest enemies could only become prey' have this almost poetic quality that elevates it above standard game commentary. The Fiora lines, especially 'He jumped at the opportunity, engaging Lin Lan aggressively. An AD carry without Flash in front of him was as easy to cut through as a cabbage'—that's funny without being try-hard. The author's voice in this chapter is confident, observant, and knows exactly when to be brutal and when to let the action speak for itself.
... Read More
This match segment is a masterclass in escalating stakes, and the real genius is that the conflict isn't just about who wins the teamfight—it's about perception. The enemy top laner (Fiora, 5-0, godlike items) thinks he has an easy target. He sees an immobile AD carry with no Flash and engages. Meanwhile, Lin Lan and Jiang Jin know something he doesn't: the Crucible is ready. The entire sequence plays out like a predator becoming prey, and the text makes you feel that reversal in real time. Every time Fiora thinks he's about to land the killing blow, something stops him—the shield, the cleanse, the ultimates piling on. By the time three consecutive CC chains lock him down, the stakes have shifted from 'can DT survive this fight' to 'how many bodies is Lin Lan going to add to his scoreboard.' What makes the tension work so well is that Lin Lan's fragility is always present. He's squishy. He has no mobility. He's buying pure damage items while commentators and viewers are losing their minds over whether this is too risky. The danger is real—the text explicitly raises the question of what happens if Jiang Jin makes a mistake. But that danger is also what makes the payoff work. When the 7-second wipe happens, it's not just a win; it's the elimination of every doubt everyone had about Lin Lan's build. The psychological shadow this leaves on WS is the real stake—Kiner won't even dare to pick Big Mouth in the next round. That's how effective this conflict arc is.
... Read More
There's so much layered meaning in these chapters that I can't stop thinking about, especially regarding symbolism and recurring motifs. Let's start with the rings. Xie Zilu is described as "twirling the rings on his fingers" during their confrontation. Later, when Lin Lan is recalling the attack in the alley, he remembers the leader of the group wore a clown mask and "liked to wear rings." The rings become a physical marker connecting Xie Zilu to the clown-masked figure, but they're also symbolic of something else - ownership, control, the kind of jewelry that says "I have time to play with objects while someone else suffers." It's a status symbol disguised as a habit. Then there's the mineral water versus soft drink dynamic. This seems small but it's actually profoundly telling. Xie Zilu offers Lin Lan a soft drink - something sweet, artificial, pre-packaged and offered with fake hospitality. Lin Lan refuses it and produces his own unopened bottle of mineral water instead. The text explicitly notes: "No, drinking beverages is not healthy. I like drinking mineral water." This is Lin Lan asserting control over the only thing he can control in a situation where everything else is being controlled for him. The mineral water is pure, unprocessed, something he brought himself. It's a tiny act of defiance that speaks volumes about his relationship with a world that keeps trying to poison him - literally and figuratively. The clown mask itself is the biggest symbol here. Masks in general, really. The text describes these students who "wear masks and use voice changers, leaving no traces behind." The mask is both literal protection and metaphorical commentary - these aren't just hiding their identities, they're performing identities. The clown is a figure of mockery, of entertainment, of someone who makes others laugh while causing pain. Xie Zilu literally laughs "like a lunatic" during the confrontation. The clown and the madman are the same archetype. And then there's the game metaphor that threads through everything. Xie Zilu says "I hope this game can last a lifetime." Lin Lan responds with cold efficiency. But the deeper truth is that this isn't a game for Lin Lan - it's survival. For Xie Zilu it's entertainment. That fundamental mismatch in how they experience the same situation is the core tension of the entire story.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or