I Just Wanted to Propose - Reviews

I Just Wanted to Propose
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just sit with the opening image for a second. A woman bound in soft cloth in a basement, her husband watching her like a hawk, saying 'You will remain a Siegfried until the day you die, my lady.' The stakes here are SO high but they're layered in a way that makes it even more painful. On the surface, Lionette's problem is obvious — she's being sold off by her own father to a man nearly as old as he is, to some estate in Quinton where nobody will know her name and she'll disappear. But Dante's stakes? Those are the ones that actually wrecked me. He needs a fiancée who won't fall in love with him. That's not a casual request. That's the words of someone who has been hurt, who has watched someone he cared about reject him publicly, who is so guarded that his entire strategy is built around minimizing the chance of being vulnerable again. And yet — he proposes to a woman he just met. A woman from the ONE family that's always been his political opponent. The Wagners and the Siegfrieds are on opposite sides of everything. Conservative vs reformist. This isn't just a marriage of convenience, it's a marriage that would make EVERYONE in the empire talk. But here's what got me: the opening scene makes you realize that somewhere between the proposal and that basement confrontation, things went sideways. He says she's been 'acting since the very beginning like I married you out of charity.' What does that mean?? It means she thought she was doing him a favor. She thought this was some noble gesture. And he RESENTS that. Not because he wanted praise, but because it suggests she never once believed he chose her for any reason other than obligation. Meanwhile she wanted a divorce. After however long this marriage has been going on. After whatever happened in between. The tension between them is absolutely electric. Every interaction crackles. She offers him something — a fake wife who looks convincingly in love with him — and he should say no, it's too risky, but he doesn't. He gives her three days. Three days to change her mind. Three days where she's already half-in and he's already compromised. The external conflict is clear, but the internal one? That's the one that's going to destroy them both.
... Read More
"Did she break up with you?" — and then Duke Siegfried is standing there like the concept of modern relationship dynamics has personally offended him. "Since you have no one to tell anyway, I'll just say it. My fiancée confessed her feelings to me, I turned her down, and I took a slap to the face as the price for it." LIONETTE Nods along like this is a normal conversation and I am deceased. The dialogue in this book is SO sharp. Every exchange between Dante and Lionette has this underlying current where they're both testing each other without quite admitting it. Watch this: "You need someone who won't love you but will look like a happily matched couple in front of others. For my part, a marriage of appearances is far better than an arranged sale, if it means I can escape one." "Bold of you, Miss." "If I count that one too, that's three now." I literally said YES OUT LOUD when she said that. The way she just throws out numbers like she's keeping score of his insults and he LAUGHS — actually laughs — because she's the first person in years who hasn't taken him seriously? The voice writing here is impeccable. Every character sounds different. Lionette's inner monologue is this dry, self-deprecating observant thing — she comments on counting pleats in dresses and noticing people are gossiping and thinks about princesses selling their souls to devils. And then Dante? His dialogue is clipped, authoritative, almost surgical. But the moments when he laughs? When he lets something slip past that carefully controlled exterior? Those hit so much harder because the contrast is so stark. The narrative voice itself is third-person limited, mostly riding close to Lionette's perspective, and it captures her completely. She reads novels, she notices everything, she's acutely aware of how she comes across and privately makes fun of herself for it. The author's tone is this perfect blend of wit and warmth — never mean-spirited, always slightly wry, with just enough romantic tension threaded through every conversation that you can't look away.
... Read More
I need to talk about the emotional arc here because it's so much more than just a steamy scene. The first encounter is portrayed with a heartbreaking level of awkwardness and vulnerability. Lionette's internal panic, her body betraying her with sounds she can't control, Dante's own strained desperation—he's just as lost as she is. The author doesn't shy away from the discomfort. It's not all smooth sailing. There's a line, "It felt, subjectively, like he was packed all the way up to her throat..." which captures that overwhelming, almost terrifying fullness of a first time. But what I love is how the narrative pivots from that intensity to something softer and more enduring. The three-year montage isn't glossed over; it's summarized with purpose. They become comfortable in each other's presence. Sharing a bed makes casual affection natural. The lack of "I love you" is telling—they don't need the words because their actions scream it. He pulls out consistently to avoid pregnancy, showing a protectiveness that isn't just about duty. She ruffles his hair without thinking. The picnic is a direct result of this comfort; she wants to share an experience inspired by a book, and he indulges her whim. The emotional peak isn't the sexual climax but the moment after: "She dropped into sleep like a stone." Exhaustion, safety, trust. And then the picnic scene itself, bathed in sunlight, feels like a reward for all that slow-building intimacy. But that ending... the child's cry. It injects a sharp note of emotional uncertainty into this peaceful tableau. It disrupts the serene bubble they've built. Is it a call to responsibility? A hint of external drama? It leaves me with aching need to know what happens next. The romance works because it's grounded in mutual care, not just passion.
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc is built on such a clever structure — it's basically a delayed confession narrative, and I love that the author doesn't rush it. We start with Dante admitting he saw her but didn't say anything, and then we go back into flashback territory to show us WHY. The third encounter with the cat Jiji is where everything clicks. It's not a dramatic plot twist per se, but it's a structural one: we learn that BOTH of them were doing this thing of secretly caring about each other without the other knowing. That's the whole engine of the romance. The payoff at the end where they're actually BEING honest with each other — about love, about fear of having kids, about everything — that's earned because we spent all that time watching them miss each other. And the chapter ending on the pinky promise? Genius. It's such a small, childish gesture after all this weighty emotional stuff, and it perfectly captures that both of them are still figuring this out. They're clumsy. It's real. The story doesn't pretend they have it all sorted.
... Read More
Let's talk about Dante for a second because this chapter completely reframes everything I thought I knew about him. Up until now he's been this controlled, polite, almost gentle husband. But the basement scene? That version of him is GONE. 'A gaze like a well-honed blade, one he had never once turned on her before.' The narrative specifically calls out that he has NEVER looked at her like this. This isn't the man who held her waist every night — this is someone calculating, dangerous, and completely unreadable. And yet. He still smiles at her. 'Like a portrait.' He still calls her name sweetly. The dissonance between his tenderness and his cruelty is what makes him so terrifying and fascinating. Is he genuinely hurt that she might be leaving? Is he manipulating her? The text refuses to give us a clear answer, and that ambiguity is masterful. Lionette's perspective is equally layered. She's lying to Dante's face about her trip — saying she needs rest when really she's plotting a romantic getaway — and she's simultaneously worried about Elise while refusing to admit how much it matters to her. Her internal monologue about clinging to 'a contract that existed only on paper' while hoping against hope for real affection? That is the most honest character moment in the entire chapter. Ephine too — she notices everything, she holds back sighs, she plays along. A servant who sees through everything but can only support from the sidelines. These three characters form such a charged triangle of unspoken truths.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or