I Didn’t Know I Was the Prince’s First Love - Reviews

I Didn’t Know I Was the Prince’s First Love
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
So while everyone's busy being dramatic about princes and heroes and dragon mountains, there's this whole parallel plot happening with Evan just trying to track down a damn orphanage. Like, the man shows up at an empty house in Shutzen, gets redirected to a forest cabin, gets growled at by a dog he never expected to have, and then... waits. Days turn into weeks. He's been stuck there starving probably. I love that the author just drops us into Evan's side quest without any fanfare. No big announcement, no chapter title screaming about him. He finds a note from Lina — "Don't waste your energy looking for me" — and I just died. The dramatic irony is killing me because we know exactly who that's written to, but Evan doesn't seem to realize the full weight of it yet. He's just a pawn in someone else's story, knocking on a door in a forest that may never open for him. Meanwhile the main plot is this enormous expedition — 300 Phoenix Knights, three carriages, magical beasts in the Denivbruk Mountains where a BLACK DRAGON awakened. The scale just keeps expanding and I'm here for it. The tension between Cedric and Karsion is basically the emotional engine of everything. Cedric literally says "I can't arrange a place for you" over FOOD and LODGING — that is such a petty, human thing to weaponize, and I loved every second of it.
... Read More
Let me be honest — this chapter made my heart rate spike. The central conflict here operates on three levels simultaneously and the stacking is brutal. First, there's Lina's internal conflict: she's a person with amnesia trying to build a new life, and someone from her past just showed up claiming she resembles someone dead. That's existentially terrifying. Second, there's Karsion's conflict: he's caught between hope and devastation. If Lina IS Renée, his childhood friend is alive after five years of grief. If she's NOT, then he just dragged a random commoner into his world for nothing. The stakes for him are emotional annihilation either way. But the third level is where it gets truly dangerous — the political stakes. Karsion is the Third Prince, hero of the empire, commander of capital security. He doesn't just TAKE people; he commands armies. When he says "And I'll be borrowing one researcher" and then sends his loyal servant to investigate orphanages and squeeze information out of a guy named Lionel... this is a man who operates at the highest level of power, and he's about to collide with an ordinary woman who can't even remember her own name. The Lionel thread adds another layer of conflict. Karsion already imagines this Lionel as a romantic rival despite Lina insisting he's just a friend. Evan even notes with dark humor that Karsion's "killing intent" for something other than dragon-hunting is unprecedented. What happens when Karsion discovers the truth about Lionel? What happens if Lina REMEMBERS and chooses to leave? And the deepest stake of all: Lina herself. She's standing in a potion management room on her first day, surrounded by people who think she's either special or suspicious, while a prince is mentally constructing entire narratives about her identity. She hasn't even figured out her own life and already other people are fighting over what she represents.
... Read More
"Here we are. Various potions are classified by type, so take your time to understand them." That line right there opens the door to what might be the most interesting setting in the whole book. The Magic Tower's potion management room is introduced with this sharp businesslike delivery from Christina, but then BOOM — a pungent smell hits our protagonist and we're instantly pulled into a world where magic ingredients have physical consequences. This isn't just set dressing; the world is telling us something through sensory detail. The potion management room becomes this living space that feels different from the cold, imposing main hall. Christina was ice-cold up there but down here, surrounded by broken beakers and suspicious smells, she's still professional but the environment gives her somewhere to be herself. And Isola! She's introduced dropping glassware like a cartoon character but the text makes her feel genuinely passionate: "There are so many fascinating things here that I couldn't help but explore. My body just gets itchy to research." What I love is how the tower itself seems to breathe. The wide central staircase, the high ceilings, the garden with statues — each space has its own personality. The potion room is chaotic warmth compared to the marble coldness of the administrative areas. And when Christina explains the acquisition system: "Unless it's something completely useless, they'll get it for you" — that's worldbuilding through dialogue, not exposition dumps. It tells us the Magic Tower has resources beyond imagination. The Isola introduction at the end is also great worldbuilding — she's clearly a mentor figure who knows all the informal systems. "If you need materials for research, you can submit a request form." This is the kind of practical detail that makes a fantasy world feel lived-in rather than stage-designed.
... Read More
The line that wrecked me: 'It was almost scary how much you felt like a friend.' Karsion says this and I lose it. He's not hiding because he's cold—he's hiding because Lina's face makes everything complicated and he was afraid of crossing a line he couldn't uncross. And Lina's reaction? She covers her face. Her face is the culprit. The entire premise of this story rests on a face that isn't hers. The stakes are layered and I love it. On the surface: Cedric warning Karsion about Elizabeth potentially repeating the Renée incident. Karsion's response is immediate and violent—'Even if you are my brother, I won't let it slide.' But below that: Lina's identity, her sense of belonging, whether she'll be treated as Renée's ghost or as herself. And below THAT: the question of what friendship means when one person's face triggers seven years of trauma for everyone involved. The dinner scene builds this tension masterfully. Every line of dialogue is a minefield. 'Why did you disappear after we agreed to be friends!' 'Was my brother right?' 'I was carrying you on my back.' 'Half of it was Cedric.' Each revelation raises the stakes while simultaneously making the moment more intimate. By the end, Karsion has her cornered against a chair and she can't look at him because his clothes are open and his chest is rock-solid and she's been caught drooling over another prince. The comedy and the tension aren't at odds—they're feeding each other. That's skilled writing.
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene because it completely wrecked me. Karsion finds Lina, and instead of whatever dramatic confrontation I expected, he just... breaks. "You said you have amnesia." Five words and suddenly the whole towering prince persona cracks. The guy who faces down Black Dragons two seconds later is trembling over a girl who can't even remember her own past. And Lina! Her internal monologue is pure chaos. She's standing there thinking "Please don't tell me he came to get me" while literally everyone around her is gossiping. The contrast between her frantic inner voice and this composed, mysterious exterior is so painfully relatable. I kept imagining myself in that situation and I would have literally melted into the floor. Then Christina drops the bomb: "You do look alike." And suddenly Karsion's entire world shifts again. The scene where he's sitting alone with a blueberry, watching it rot in his mouth because his mind is racing about whether she IS Renée — that moment of his vulnerability is everything. "The remaining blueberry juice in his mouth tasted bitter." WHAT. THAT LINE THOUGHT OF. The Lionel subplot is haunting me too. "Lionel is like family to me." Lina says it so casually but we know Karsion's already mentally murdering this Lionel character. Evan even says it straight: "Is he Miss Lina's lover?" And Karsion's killing intent is so ridiculous and human at the same time. Here's a guy who conquered empires and faces dragons but gets absolutely destroyed by a stupid childhood friend living alone with a man. I'm waiting for the day Lina finally remembers everything and has to choose between her old life with Lionel and this new tangled mess with Karsion.
... Read More
I need to discuss the Cedric confrontation because it was SO WELL WRITTEN and I'm still shaken. This guy shows up in Karsion's bedroom uninvited, already settled on the sofa like he owns the place, and immediately starts weaponizing pleasant conversation. 'Do we need specific business to see each other? Us?' THE AUDACITY. The stakes here are insane on multiple levels. On the surface, it's political — Cedric wants to pull Lina into the palace which would put her directly under the Empress's influence and potentially make her a target. But underneath THAT, the real conflict is Karsion vs. his own inability to protect anyone. He assumes the worst immediately — mistress, coercion, Princess Kate — because that's what his trauma tells him about power dynamics. He SLAMS his fist and shouts 'Absolutely not!' before even hearing the full request. And the most chilling part? Cedric's earlier comment about Karsion only being able to remain friends with Lina. That line is still echoing in my head like a curse. What does Cedric know? What has he observed that he's not saying? The tension between brotherly rivalry, romantic obsession, and political maneuvering is absolutely suffocating and I CANNOT LOOK AWAY.
... Read More
"If you're hitting on me, I'm not interested. You're not my type." This thought running through Lina's head days before meeting Karsion is PURE COMEDY GOLD and it sets the tone for everything about her voice. She's got this sharp, self-aware, slightly cynical internal narrator who comments on literally everything while pretending to be composed externally. Let me give you the contrast: externally she's giving polite professional responses — "Yes, I'm Lina," "I can't do magic at all," "Nice to meet you." Internally she's a tornado of panic, judgment, and absurd observations. When Karsion calls her out, her external response is basically nothing while internally she's screaming "Please don't tell me the so-called hero pettily sought me out for revenge." Karsion's dialogue is fascinating because it's deliberately sparse. He speaks in short, controlled sentences: "Make more." "And I'll be borrowing one researcher." "Search all the orphanages." Each line carries weight because he rarely wastes words. But then Evan gets the full comedic treatment: "Who is Lionel?" "Is he Miss Lina's lover?" This servant has more narrative freedom than anyone else precisely because he's allowed to be human about things the protagonist can't express. Isola's dialogue is pure energy — she talks fast, asks questions, and uses exclamations like punctuation. Christina is the foil: clipped, precise, almost robotic. But even she cracks with "Hahaha. No matter what you say, I'm not that person" — wait, that's Lina actually. Christina's deadpan "You do look alike. Now I understand why you seemed familiar" is perfectly measured. The author has given each character a distinct vocal fingerprint. I could tell who was speaking without seeing tags.
... Read More
There's this one line from Lina that kept haunting me: 'Presumptuously, I thought that perhaps I could become his spring, such an absurd idea.' Spring. Think about what spring represents — renewal, warmth, new beginnings, the end of winter. Karsion has been in an emotional winter for FIVE YEARS since Renée died and the territory was destroyed. The entire Iblaine mansion is a symbol of his refusal to let winter end — he literally rebuilt a dead person's home as if she might walk through the door tomorrow. 'Did he want to create a home for Renée Iblaine to return to, in case she ever came back alive?' That word 'in case.' As if hope itself is a structural foundation. And then Lina arrives, wearing Renée's face, and Karsion can't tell who he's looking at. He practices saying 'Lina' in the bath but keeps failing, because his heart won't let him. The wind that carries Renée's memory is the SAME wind that brushes Karsion's cheek when he sees Lina's carriage. They are wind and memory and grief all tangled together. Time supposedly heals wounds but Karsion explicitly rejects that. He GRITS HIS TEETH and rides faster, as if speed could outrun his own mind.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Karsion because THIS MAN IS A MENACE and also I love him. The scene where he's in the bath practicing saying 'Lina' instead of 'Renée' just absolutely destroyed me. He's not even doing it successfully — he groans, he bangs his head against the tub, he says 'D*mn it.' This guy is so painfully aware that he's projecting onto Lina and he CAN'T STOP HIMSELF. And then Cedric shows up out of NOWHERE, already dressed on his sofa like a home invader, immediately zeroing in on Lina. Their dynamic is so toxic and I'm HERE for it. Cedric literally says 'You're trapped in Renée Iblaine's shadow much more severely than I thought' and Karsion loses it instantly. The fact that Karsion immediately assumed Cedric wanted to MAKE LINA HIS MISTRESS before Cedric even finished his sentence tells you EVERYTHING about how broken this situation is. But then Cedric reveals he wants to bring Lina to court as a companion for the Empress and Karsion is just… speechless? Like he wanted to protect her from something terrible and it turns out it was just Cedric being weirdly mundane? Classic. Also the part where Karsion was sleeping on rooftops for a week?! That man has commitment issues ON A METAPHYSICAL LEVEL.
... Read More
I've been turning over this blueberry scene in my head for hours and I think it's the symbolic core of the entire chapter if not the book. Karsion eating a blueberry while mentally reconstructing five years of lost history — there's something deeply human about that. A fruit, ordinary and sweet, sits in his mouth but tastes bitter because his mind is consumed by what might have been. The blueberry is this small, personal detail amidst empire-level stakes. It grounds the mythic in the mundane. The Black Dragon imagery keeps resurfacing too. Five years ago, Renée was consumed by a Black Dragon's breath. Five years ago, Lina fell from a tree and lost her memory. These two events are mirrors — both involve violent disruption of normal life, both erase the past in different ways. One erases the body, the other erases the mind. The question the book seems to be asking is: which loss is more terrible? Lionel as a name keeps appearing like a ghost. Lina says "Lionel is like family to me" with complete trust and openness, while Karsion hears the same words and imagines the worst. The same phrase, two completely opposite interpretations. This is the book's theme about memory and perception — reality isn't what happened, it's what we believe happened. And the face itself. Two women who look identical but are fundamentally different. One is dead and memorialized; the other is alive and unaware. The theme here seems to be about identity — are we our memories, or are we something more stubborn and irreducible? Lina might not remember being Renée, but she's clearly becoming someone Karsion can't ignore. The orphanage detail at the end is also loaded symbolism — both Renée and Lina came from nowhere, both were found by extraordinary people, both changed the course of history without knowing it.
... Read More
There's this one sequence where Lina wanders through the Iblaine mansion alone and it's just—god, the atmosphere. The evening air with diminished heat wrapping around her skin. The golden setting sun lighting up the corridor floor. Five floors, numerous rooms, knights busy everywhere except where she is. But the real moment comes when she climbs that curved central staircase and this 'strangely subdued mood' transforms into something else entirely—a sense of ecstasy, like she's become the protagonist of a play. 'Why does simply climbing stairs feel so good?' She's channeling Karsion's feelings about rebuilding this place, and you can feel how much the mansion means to him through her. The contrast between the grand exterior and that tiny detail of blueberry doodles on a door is what makes this scene work. Everything about the worldbuilding serves the character here—the rebuilt territory, the Phoenix Knights, theMagic Tower researchers exploring like it's a picnic. But Lina's journey through the corridors, from the main building to that quiet corridor with the sun on the floor, it's so cinematic. And then the tavern scene with the researchers—beer, pumpkin pie, the cozy village atmosphere—they're having fun without her and feeling guilty, which says so much about their group dynamic. Nine more glasses of beer. This is a found family with questionable judgment and I am here for it.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is actually insane when you think about it. We open with Evan arriving at an empty house, getting directions, finding a cabin in a forest, getting growled at by a dog, reading a note, and then — TIME SKIP. "A few hours would turn into days, and a few days would turn into weeks." One line and we've lost track of him entirely. That's bold. Then we snap to Lina's POV and the pace immediately accelerates. Palace greeting, carriage departure, the Cedric-Karsion confrontation, the journey, the stretchy-legs embarrassment with the knights, the stew scene, Karsion's grand entrance — it's all flowing so smoothly that by the time we hit the "creditor and debtor" line, we're already emotionally invested. What I love is how the author uses the lunch scene as a pressure valve. Everything has been building — Cedric's hostility, Karsion's persistence, Lina's anxiety about her peaceful life — and then suddenly everyone is just... eating stew. Happy. The tension doesn't disappear, it just takes a breather. And that's when Karsion appears. Perfect timing. The scene that should be warm becomes complicated again, and I was NOT ready for the vein-popping moment. "Please stop making it so obvious." Right after he deliberately walked across the entire camp to sit next to her. THE MAN HAS NO SHAME AND I RESPECT IT.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or