I Am This Type of Woman - Reviews

I Am This Type of Woman
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
So many symbols in one scene. The peacock pattern on Ban Hua's skirt—peacocks are proud, ornate, watched. They don't blend in. Yan Zhen sees her as a goddess (Luo River reference), but Ban Hua knows she's being observed, evaluated, placed on display. Then there's Rong Xia in the golden sunlight, ‘pure as gold or tin refined.' The poem compares him to a crafted weapon or scepter—strong, polished, useful. But also cold, manufactured. Yan Zhen is white marble, pale, untouched. Ban Hua is wearing luxurious clothes, jeweled shoes, ‘used to being the focus of service.' She's stepping onto a different kind of stage. The pavilion itself—a place of viewing, not living. Everyone is watching everyone else. The mother‑in‑law story she recalls is the ultimate symbol: promises as fragile as husk‑stuffed mouths. Men's words, buried quickly. The real theme here is performance—how love, marriage, and duty are staged, observed, and often scripted by others. Ban Hua isn't rejecting Yan Zhen; she's refusing to play the role he's written for her. And Rong Xia? He's already outside the script, watching from the corridor, never quite stepping onto the stage.
... Read More
I need to pause and just process the emotional complexity of Kangning trying on that dress. So she's in this hidden courtyard - the Grand Princess's SECRET fancy dress room - and she sees this purple palace dress with the flying peacock embroidery and she is TEMPTED. Like genuinely tempted. The text says she was "tempted" and I felt that in my chest because we all know that feeling of wanting to just... wear something beautiful even when you know you shouldn't. But then she remembers who she is. Who her father is. Hui-wang, the frugal Buddhist prince whose family never wears luxurious things. She's supposed to be humble. She's supposed to be the good loser. So she picks the plain one. The sombre ruqun. And of COURSE it's made of tributed snow satin - the kind only the Empress uses. The universe has a sense of humor. And then she looks in the mirror and sees "the dashing image of her elegant self" and can't bring herself to change. That moment - where she rationalizes it as "the attendant told me to wear it, I didn't disobey my father" - is one of the most human things I've read in a long time. She's not just wearing a pretty dress. She's allowed herself exactly one act of defiance and she needs to convince herself it doesn't count as defiance at all. "Count Cheng'an would notice her?" - she's literally thinking about being SEEN at this exact moment. Not by just anyone. By HIM. The emotional math here is so precise. She's been downplaying herself her whole life, and the one time she lets herself shine, the one time she's actually breathtaking, her first thought is whether someone specific is watching. I'm not crying. You're crying.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is absolutely razor-sharp, and I want to highlight how Madam Zhou speaks versus how Yan-furen speaks, because these two women are doing almost the same thing and their words couldn't sound more different. Madam Zhou arrives at the Yan household and immediately deflects: "Ban family loves their delicate girl, I believe you all know. They didn't expressly refuse, they wanted to see what the two juniors think." She's delivering a rejection wrapped in cotton. Yan-furen, on the other hand, throws rules like weapons: "According to the rule of the ancestors, marriage is by the parents' orders and the matchmaker's words." She's so caught up in defending propriety that she doesn't even notice her own position is absurd — her family is the one begging, not the other way around. And Madam Zhou's internal monologue? Brutal. "In her heart she thought if you were concerned with observing parents' order and matchmaker words, then just give up and look for another girl instead of anxiously begging Ban family." That is the kind of savage clarity that only exists in the narrator's voice, never in the characters' speech. The exchange about Ban Hua meeting Fule Junzhu at the Shi family banquet is pure political theater — Madam Zhou announces it casually as she stands to leave, dropping a piece of intelligence like it's nothing while Yan-furen desperately tries to keep her seated for a meal she clearly doesn't want. Every line of dialogue here is doing double duty. Characters are saying what they mean, meaning what they don't want you to hear, and hearing what they hope someone will say.
... Read More
'A crafty rabbit has three caves'—and this entire passage is basically an extended meditation on what that proverb actually means in practice. Ban Hua isn't just hiding treasure; she's building an entire philosophy of survival into the earth itself. Every layer of soil, every scattered stone, every piece of grassy turf placed back on top represents a deliberate act of trust in the future. She's burying her family's wealth not because she expects to need it tomorrow, but because she refuses to be vulnerable if tomorrow comes. The haunted mountain setting is doing so much thematic heavy lifting here. It's supposedly haunted—meaning it's a place where the normal rules don't apply, where the supernatural might intervene. And yet Ban Hua chooses THIS location precisely because no one else would come here. The very danger that keeps ordinary people away is what makes it the perfect hiding place. There's something deeply philosophical about trusting the terrifying unknown over the watchful eyes of civilization. Then you've got the treasure itself—gold bars, gems, wealth that could buy entire counties. What does it mean that this family is so wealthy they bury riches for 'fun' while simultaneously living in constant fear of threats that require shadow operatives and midnight ambushes? The gold is both their power and their vulnerability. It's what makes them targets and what they're trying desperately to protect. The night imagery throughout is also carrying weight. 'The sun was sinking in the west and night was approaching' opens the passage, and darkness literally envelopes everything by the end. Night is when the real conversations happen—between Rong Xia and Du Jiu, between Ban Hua and her unexpected visitors. The supernatural hauntings, the political schemes, the family loyalty—all of it lives in the dark.
... Read More
Okay so this whole rejection scene is basically the narrative equivalent of a masterclass in dramatic irony. Yan Zhen comes in hot — I mean, literally stammering, red-faced, all-in — and Ban Hua gently deflates him like a balloon. But the real plot move here is what happens NEXT. You'd think the chapter would just end on that bittersweet note and call it a day, right? Nope. Enter the Shi siblings and Rong Xia like a three-act play compressed into one hallway encounter. It's like the author said, "we have time for one more complication" and honestly? I respect it. The way Ban Hua almost literally runs into Shi Feixian and Shi Jin while trying to exit stage left — that's not accidental writing, that's deliberate threading. Every character who walks through that door changes the power dynamic. Yan Zhen was the emotional center one second, then suddenly he's the sidelined guy chasing after two people who are already gone. And Rong Xia? The timing of their appearance is suspiciously convenient. Are they protecting Ban Hua or cornering her? Either way, the chapter doesn't rest. It keeps moving the pieces around the board.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this whole chapter is basically a masterclass in reading male behavior through Ban Hua's eyes and honestly I'm here for it. Every single man in this scene notices Shi Feixian except one, and that one man is the most interesting one there. Rong Xia? He literally looks right through her like she's fog. Ban Hua notices this immediately and you can see her brain working—her exact thought is "so in Rong Xia's eyes, the Shi Feixian that had made Second Prince head over heels was no different from white fog. This was very interesting, too interesting." And I'm sitting here like oh she's just observing but NO, she's already doing the math on who pays attention to whom and who doesn't. Meanwhile Shi Feixian is watching Rong Xia walk away and she has to literally squeeze her handkerchief to keep her face from falling apart. That detail though. That one line about squeezing the handkerchief says more than a thousand words about how much she cares about his opinion versus how little he cares about hers. Classic unrequited tension right there. And then Ban Heng shows up asking for money like he's not literally receiving expensive furs as a gift. Their sibling dynamic is so casually funny—"when are you going to buy me something?" "If I wasn't your brother, would you give me money?" I'm wheezing.
... Read More
There's something almost CINEMATIC about how this passage is structured. You've got the Grand Princess's birthday banquet — elaborate, bright, full of people smiling their way through political landmines — and then you CUT to the dimmer, quieter interior of Hui-wang's residence where a father is screaming at his daughter. The visual contrast is brutal. At the banquet, you have Kangning in snow silk ruqun attracting attention, Ban Hua with her peony hairpin glowing under the lights, Rong Xia moving through the crowd like a man who owns every room he enters. Everything is surface-level beautiful and deeply ugly underneath. Then you go home and it's: a father red-eyed with rage, a mother crying, a daughter sitting in the dark processing the fact that her own blood struck her. The Wangfei tries to play the peacemaker — "she changed to this dress because of an accident" — which is such a delicate way of saying her daughter didn't even MEAN to dress up but still got punished for it. And the bath scene with Ban Hua? Warm water, drowsy,Bruise healing on her arm. This woman is literally glowing in comfort while everyone else is falling apart. The scene transitions between these two worlds — one of sunlight and performance, one of shadows and survival — and the reader is left breathing between them.
... Read More
'Whenever Rong Xia lifted his head, he couldn't stop from peeking with the corner of his eyes.' I NEED to talk about this sentence because it is EVERYTHING. Three words of actual dialogue across an entire chapter and one glancing description of eye movement and I am UNWELL. This is the kind of slow-burn romance writing that makes you want to shake the author. Let me count the emotional beats here: First, there's Yun-niang's devastation — the raw, almost clinical way she recounts being abandoned. 'She knew he wouldn't come back but she still waited for two years.' That is not a character who moved on. That is a character who is still standing in that exact moment from years ago, frozen. And then you have Ban Hua, beautiful and adorned and surrounded by people who are all smiling at her but she probably doesn't trust a single one of them. She's performing happiness while internally calculating which compliments are genuine. And then Rong Xia. Just... watching her. Across a crowded room. The fact that he has to 'peek with the corner of his eyes' tells us he's trying NOT to stare openly, which means he's trying really hard not to stare openly, which means he's been staring. The Grand Princess notices everything and says nothing. 'It was said that good looking women were the source of calamity, were good looking men the cause of sin?' She's watching her granddaughter and this Count and she sees the future disaster before anyone else does. That line alone gave me chills — it's the author dropping foreshadowing so subtly you miss it on first read. And Ban Hua's little wave? Inconspicuous. Invisible to everyone except him. That is the most romantic gesture in the entire passage and neither of them says a word about it.
... Read More
The visual composition of this chapter is absolutely chef's kiss. Let me walk through the palette because the author is clearly playing with color symbolism and I am HERE FOR IT. We open with morning fog—the kind of thick, diffused light that makes everything soft and dreamlike. And into this haze rides Shi Feixian, described as wearing "light green dress and a plain silver cloak," looking like "a kind of unsurpassed beauty" that Ban Hua compares to "the fluttering gracefulness of a celestial being." Beautiful, ethereal, fragile. Then Ban Hua enters the frame and the whole color scheme SHIFTS. Goose yellow riding clothes, apricot yellow cloak, a dazzling gold hairband, and a bright red five-petal flower drawn on her forehead. She is LIVING COLOR while everyone else is muted. The visual contrast between these two women couldn't be starker if the author tried harder. And then—ENTER SHI JIN. Dressed in black. The text even makes a point of noting it: "Was wearing black the current trend in the Capital? After Xie Chong'an in black, now Shi Jin was also in black." This is such a small detail but it builds this entire visual identity for a character. Black mourning clothes, black horses, black mood. Meanwhile the furs gifted later—fire fox fur and white fox fur, flawless, no mixed colors—are these incredibly opulent items that Ban Heng notes she couldn't buy even with money. The world feels tangible here. You can see the textures, the layers of fabric, the horses' manes in the morning light, the weight of fur against cold air. Every scene has a director's eye for composition.
... Read More
There are so many symbols layered in this passage it's almost overwhelming. Let me just start with the PEONY — 人间富贵花. The flower of nobility and wealth. Rong Xia calls Ban Hua a peony and it's not just a compliment, it's an acknowledgment that SHE BELONGS somewhere better, somewhere brighter, while others in this story are literally being crushed beneath the weight of political survival. Then there's the imagery of the FISH ON THE CHOPPING BLOCK — Hui-wang describing himself and his family. A fish doesn't fight back. A fish doesn't speak. A fish just lies there and accepts whatever comes. This is the central metaphor for their entire existence, and the fact that he says it with bitterness and helplessness rather than acceptance makes it even more devastating. The snow silk ruqun Kangning wears becomes a SYMBOL of everything she's forbidden from having — beauty, freedom, the simple joy of looking pretty. Her father sees it as a threat because in a world where survival depends on appearing worthless, looking good is almost an act of rebellion. And Ban Hua's greenish bruise disappearing in warm water? That's the body telling you something the mind won't — that healing is possible, that pain fades, but only if you have the luxury of soaking in a bath while someone massanges your shoulders. Not everyone in this story gets that luxury. Some people are still on the chopping block.
... Read More
I need to talk about the emotional undercurrents in this chapter because there are SO many layers and I'm barely keeping it together. On the surface it looks like a casual encounter on the road, right? Two carriages meeting, polite greetings, everyone smiling their fake smiles. But underneath all of that is this entire web of unspoken feelings that just makes my heart ache. Shi Feixian's POV at the beginning hits so hard—she's genuinely uncomfortable seeing Ban Hua and Rong Xia together, and the text says it outright: "Shi Feixian had never realised how much she hated Ban Hua." But then you realize she doesn't hate Ban Hua, she hates that Ban Hua gets to exist in the same space as Rong Xia without any mourning period holding her back. Rong Xia lost his entire family—three years for his mother, three years for his father, then his brother—and yet here he is, smiling gently at Ban Hua while Shi Feixian stands there in light green and silver, trying desperately to be seen. The cruelty of it all! And Ban Hua, bless her golden hairband and red forehead flower, she's just vibing over here thinking about how beautiful people are. She has zero awareness of the emotional landmine she's walking through. But that contrast between her carefree energy and everyone else's heavy, complicated feelings is what makes this chapter so rich emotionally. You can feel the weight of grief beneath Rong Xia's smiles—the narrator even speculates that his smiles "must be just a cover." How do you move on from losing your entire family? You don't. You just learn to wear the smile better.
... Read More
'When we have no money, we all live a hard life together, when we have money, we will spend it together.' — Ban Heng, probably the most financially responsible statement this brother has ever made (read: absolutely none). I have to talk about how every single character in this passage has a completely distinct voice and I am HERE for it. Ban Hua's dialogue is sharp, commanding, occasionally sarcastic. She doesn't waste words on anyone—'Go away, let me do it' and 'If you can't, then shut up. A grown man talks so much, how will you get a wife?' These are lines that don't just reveal character, they BUILD character. You can hear her father's quiet pride, her brother's nervous deflection, and her uncle Ban Huai's affectionate teasing all through what they say and how they say it. Du Jiu's formal, obsequious speech pattern is perfectly calibrated for a guard trying to de-escalate a potentially hostile encounter. 'Please Junzhu don't be alarmed, we are just passing by' followed by the genuinely impressive move of removing his own sword to show good faith? That's a character who knows how to read a room even when that room is a haunted mountain at night. And Rong Xia—bro only speaks three lines in this entire passage but each one is iconic. 'Master, This Subordinate is incompetent' and then later 'Dig this up and check.' He doesn't need to speak more. His presence is felt through his silence and his authority. The narrative voice itself is doing some really clever work too. There's this dry, almost wry observation woven throughout—like the narrator noting that 'in the books, curious people who heard a noise and went to check it usually died young' right before the family does exactly that. The author is clearly winking at us.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or