From Your Sincere Fan - Reviews

From Your Sincere Fan
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I've been sitting with these two characters for a while now and the dynamic between Perry and Yuan is everything. Perry is this woman who seems to carry herself with this quiet dignity—no makeup, unremarkable face, but when she's on stage she becomes something else entirely. The letter from Yuan literally says she becomes the character itself, down to her breathing. And yet offstage she's struggling with bills, rejected by theaters, and clearly isolated enough that a single fan letter shakes her. What strikes me is how defensive she is without being harsh. When she returns Yuan's checks, she's not cruel—she's embarrassed. There's this line where she says 'an actor never leaves the stage before the audience does' and it hits different because it's clearly a vow she's making to herself more than to him. Yuan on the other hand is fascinating in this awkward, intense way. He describes himself as someone who finds paintings and orchestras meaningless but Perry's acting changed everything for him. That's not normal fan behavior, that's obsession dressed up as devotion. The P.S. about icy roads at the end of his letter? That's the kind of detail that makes me uncomfortable in the best way—he's paying attention to her life in a way that goes beyond admiration.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes because they're layered in a way that makes this way more tense than a straightforward career-success story. On the surface, Perry wants to get into the Roju City Theater Company workshop — it's a six-week commitment that requires quitting her part-time restaurant job, and the training fee is substantial. She just paid off her debts and bought herself a dress and some lace socks, so money is tighter than it's ever been. But the real stakes aren't financial. They're existential. Perry has spent her whole life waiting to be seen on stage, and now someone — Yuan — actually sees her. Truly sees her. And that terrifies her more than any failure could. When she writes 'I tried to maintain an appropriate distance as your actress' and then immediately admits she failed at every boundary, she's describing the core conflict: she wants closeness and she's afraid of it simultaneously. The workshop represents a chance to prove herself professionally, but also a chance to lose the safety of her current precarious balance. If she gets in, her life changes completely. If she doesn't, she's back to the same gray audition dress and the same restaurant shifts. Either way, she's charging forward — 'unable to see my surroundings' as she literally put it. And that's what makes every letter feel like a gamble.
... Read More
The snow symbolism is everywhere and I can't unsee it now. It's not just weather — it's isolation, it's the things that pile up when you're already struggling, it's literally what makes Perry fall. But also… the heating wires at the end? That's hope, right? The city installing something to prevent the snow from being so dangerous next time. The mayor ‘personally ordered it” which is weird because earlier the text says he's ‘complacent”… so why would he care about tactile paving for blind people? And the theater motif. Early on, Perry describes those old theaters near the airport and says “You came to mind.” She imagines Yuan would like that place. Later, she gets called back to perform in the exact play they'd presumably discussed. The stage becomes this space where she's visible, where she's performing for an audience… but also where Yuan is supposedly watching. Meanwhile, Yuan is up in the sky, literally above everything, but also emotionally distant in their letters. ‘A person flies up into the sky because they're too happy” — that's such a bizarre question for a pilot to ask. Like, what law covers THAT? Is the author suggesting that happiness itself is somehow unregulated, uncontainable?
... Read More
Okay so this whole section is basically the pivot point where Perry's professional life and personal life start colliding, and it hits differently. On one thread you've got the play wrapping up — the curtain closing on A Midsummer Commotion, the packed theater, the whole triumphant thing. On the other thread you've got this mysterious flower delivery that turns out to come from a kid, not from whoever Perry assumes it does. And THEN the cane collision happens on the street — that moment where she drops her cane and this tall stranger hands it back, and the rose scent hits her. That's a plot device that screams 'this person matters' without actually telling us who it is. My brain immediately went: this is Yuan, right? Because who else would send flowers AND show up? But I can't confirm it yet, and that's delicious writing. Then you stack the letters on top — the fan letter from some anonymous admirer practically weeping about her performance, then Perry's cascade of replies to Yuan where she spills everything: the workshop application, the dress she bought, the fact that she paid off her debts. The plot doesn't explode here, but it swells. Every event pushes her toward something bigger, and the reader feels it building.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this letter-writing structure because it's doing something really clever here. The novel is basically running on parallel tracks—Perry's theatrical world and Yuan's aerial world—and they only intersect through these beautifully layered missives. But then BAM, Scene 4 hits and everything collides in the most devastating way possible. The theater festival subplot isn't just filler or backstory—it's the entire engine. Perry doesn't get any professional audition offers, but her school's annual festival gives her the stage she craves. And here's the thing that made me put the book down and stare at the ceiling: she meets this quiet gentleman at the masquerade ball, they waltz, and she notices the tie pin. The SAME one she gave Yuan. Is Yuan that gentleman? I've reread that encounter three times now and I genuinely can't tell. The scene is written with such deliberate ambiguity—you see his physical reactions (pressing his temple, swallowing a sigh, the humorless smile when his family name comes up), but Perry's blindness means we only get fragments. And then Yuan's letter response is practically vibrating with suppressed emotion: "Did that 'gentleman' behave with proper manners?" Not "Did you meet someone nice"—the specificity of it, the almost jealous concern, the way he circles around the question like he's afraid to ask directly? Then Perry's September letter cuts so deeply: "Am I someone who shouldn't dream of being an actor?" After all that buildup about her passion, her successful performance, her tireless practice—she's still doubting. The plot isn't just moving forward, it's pulling apart the characters from the inside.
... Read More
OK so the whole middle section with Perry falling in the snow was honestly unexpected but it worked. I didn't see it coming at all when she was just casually describing the weather and then suddenly — boom — she's in a cast. The author really used that accident as this turning point where their whole dynamic shifts. Before that, it was just friendly letters back and forth, but after? Suddenly Yuan is showing up at her place with medicine, the landlord is gossiping about her situation… the stakes went way up without anyone actually saying ‘I'm worried about you.' And then the play callback! When Perry mentioned she got called back for ‘A Midsummer Commotion', I immediately thought about how early in the letters she described those theaters near the airport and how she imagined Perry would like the place. That's such a tight loop. The author planted that detail about the old theaters early on and then paid it off months later in the narrative. Also, the ending where Perry notices Yuan's letters getting stiffer… is that a plot twist or just foreshadowing? Because the text ends mid-sentence and I NEED to know what happens next.
... Read More
The worldbuilding in this book is sneaky. It doesn't info-dump — it just drops details like breadcrumbs and you realize halfway through that the world is FULLY ALIVE. Ravina Night — no sunset, silver lines shimmering around dark clouds, flights grounded by regulation, superstition about not being alone. It has this beautiful contradiction where modern life (aviation regulations, theater auditions, costume warehouses) coexists with magic (fortune-telling candies that write on your palms, witches' shadows rippling between clouds, paths that deliberately lead you astray). The author treats all of it with the same matter-of-fact tone, which makes it feel infinitely more real. My absolute favorite image: 'A blue-white light shone down like a very thin curtain. If someone had been beside me, I couldn't have seen their profile more clearly than at that moment.' That sentence contains an entire unspoken longing. The light is so vivid Perry wishes someone were there to share it with. The worldbuilding isn't just sets and rules — it's emotional architecture. And the secondhand costume shop with gleaming golden letters that somehow appears when you're lost? Classic fairy tale logic dressed in urban clothing. I love it.
... Read More
I have to stop and just appreciate one specific passage because the author absolutely killed it here. Yuan visits this old bookstore near his company housing. You know, he'd never actually gone in before despite knowing where it was. And then this description hits you like a wave: "Through the transparent glass window, colorful covers are displayed in two rows, and the inside of the bookstore is filled with the rich aroma of coffee. They sell not only books but also miscellaneous items. Things like stationery, ink, pen nibs, and such." That's it. That's the whole thing. Just a few sentences and suddenly I can SMELL that bookstore. I can see the light coming through the glass, the organized chaos of items, the whole cozy atmosphere. And the most important detail—the ink color he chose is "a light brown similar to your hair color." He picked stationery that matches Perry. Without saying it outright. That is the kind of writing that makes you immediately want to text your crush or, you know, send anonymous luxury catering to theater workshop students. But the scene that really lives in my head is the post-performance dressing room. Perry collapsed on a sofa after what must have been an emotionally devastating show, wrapped in a thin blanket, cheek makeup glistening with sweat. The lighting shifts from "blue-white lights" to "dim daylight-colored light"—and that transition alone tells you everything about how exhausted and vulnerable she is. Then Bria Sol enters. Her entrance is described through sensory details: a voice "higher and more cheerful than Perry's, a soft tone reminiscent of silk and roses," the sweet scent she exudes, the elegantly curled ends of her hair. Every sense is engaged. She glides into the scene like a character who belongs on a stage—because she does, constantly. The contrast between these two women in that small dressing room, one sweaty and shaking, the other perfectly composed, is visually and emotionally perfect. The author doesn't need to state the power dynamic explicitly. The atmosphere does all the work.
... Read More
okay first of all can we just talk about how this entire section is basically two people pouring their souls onto paper and somehow that's even MORE intimate than face-to-face conversation? perry writing to yuan about failing audition after audition—she literally says she wanted to show only her impressive side because yuan is her fan. that line hit me so hard. like. she's already thinking about someone else's feelings before she even processes her own failure. that's the kind of selflessness that makes you love a character immediately. and then yuan's response?? bro really went FULL VULNERABLE BACKROUND DROP. the parents thing, the party house, the whole 'i had nothing I wanted until i saw you on stage' confession—this man is laying his entire existence bare and i am NOT okay. "for you to shine eternally on stage, for me to be your first and last audience member"—I literally gasped out loud reading this. the devotion is palpable through the PAGE. but here's what REALLY got me: perry's letter right after passing the audition, where she talks about meeting that guy from the festival and getting all flustered about whether he considers her a friend. she's so insecure about it, asking yuan for advice like "was I too presumptuous?" meanwhile yuan's writing back all protective like "if that fellow behaves rudely, be sure to tell me." the emotional layers here are INSANE. it's not romantic tension between perry and yuan—that's something else entirely—but it's THIS deep, aching intimacy where two people hold each other's worst days and best days and somehow it only makes them hold tighter.
... Read More
Let me start with the fortune-telling candies because THEY ARE NOT JUST CANDIES. Two pieces, one for each of them. Mine says 'move forward,' his says 'it's too late.' But here's the thing — ordinary people can't read the writing on their palms anyway. So what was the point? Was it really about the prophecy or was it about SHARED SECRET? They both ate candy, both looked at their hands, both received messages only the witch could interpret. A ritual that bound them together without either having to say anything out loud. The mistletoe is another one. 'A mistletoe decoration that drives away outsiders.' He bought something meant to keep other people away and almost gave it to HER. What does that say about who he wants near him versus who he wants gone? Absolutely enormous implications from a store-bought decoration. And the dress — found magically in the exact size, soft fabric, described as 'exactly the kind of dress my character would wear.' It's not just costume, it's ARMOR. She walks into the audition wearing something that makes her feel invincible, and the red-haired employee says 'the dress has finally found its owner' like it's destiny. In a story about witches and fortune and paths that deliberately mislead you, nothing is accidental. Every object is a choice, every choice is a confession.
... Read More
This text is dripping with symbols and I can't unsee them now. The most obvious one is the stage itself—Perry transforms completely when she performs, becoming someone else entirely, but the question hanging over everything is whether she knows who she is off that stage. Her 'unremarkable' face in the lobby contrasted with the praise from Yuan about how she becomes the character... that's not just about acting, that's about identity itself. Then there's the witch element, which I think is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. The path that only appears when Witch Isobel's feast day approaches, the path that those with 'closed hearts' can't see—that feels like a metaphor for opportunity or connection or something spiritual that only opens up under certain conditions. Perry claims she's 'always been good at finding the way,' which is interesting because she's clearly lost in her career but confident in this mystical sense. And the letters themselves—physical objects traveling through impossible means—feel like a symbol for the invisible threads that connect people. The oil and electricity bills, the rent due on the 15th, the theater rejection letters—these are all symbols of the mundane world pressing in on someone who lives in imagination and performance.
... Read More
The structure here is honestly brilliant and I need to unpack why. You open with a personal letter from Perry mid-rehearsal — intimate, immediate, in medias res. Then you snap to the play's final performance with full dramatic weight. Then back to letters. The fan letter arrives like a gift, Perry's reply to Yuan is warm and expansive, then BAM — 'Please burn the letter. PLEASE!' The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works because the previous letter was so tender that this panic reads as genuine terror, not drama. Then another letter calms everything down with the tie pin gift and the workshop news, and Yuan's reply lands like a warm hand on the shoulder. The pacing never drags because every section does different emotional work. The play scene is climax-adjacent. The fan encounter is intrigue. The burning-letter panic is conflict. The gift letter is relief. And Yuan's final response is... something quieter, deeper. It doesn't resolve anything but it deepens everything. That's how you pace a correspondence-driven narrative without it feeling like paperwork.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or