From Your Sincere Fan - Reviews

From Your Sincere Fan
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I'm still haunted by this one scene. You know those moments in novels where the sensory details hit you so hard you feel like you're actually standing there? That's Scene 4. The old theater, the vintage interior, the way the author describes it: "not so much that one couldn't recognize its original form." This is a place with history, with layers of performances and footsteps. And then there's the woman—"hair flowing down below her shoulders gleamed like gold coins in the late summer sunlight," the blue tint around her eyelids from her stage makeup, the white cane caught on this intricately crafted metal installation. I could SEE her. Not just visually though—the author makes you feel her presence even though she's blind. The cane, the delicate way she navigates, the confidence with which she guides the man toward the banquet hall despite not being able to see a step ahead of her. And the ball itself! "The garden filled with the scent of damp soil, and all the lights and flames of the school to themselves." Late August. Long summer days. Piano and violin melodies flowing along old cream-colored walls. There's a texture to this world that feels incredibly specific—this academy with its founder's philosophy about popularizing theater, the tradition of the masquerade ball, the hierarchy between student events and public performances. What strikes me most is how the physical space mirrors the emotional space. The corridor where Perry nearly escapes but gets caught—five steps to a spiral staircase she couldn't possibly know about unless she'd been there before. The man who memorized this building's layout and yet couldn't memorize his way out of confronting her. Everything in this scene is about visibility and blindness, about seeing without eyes and being seen without wanting to be.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Bria Sol because this woman is honestly terrifying and I am OBSESSED with how the author wrote her. On the surface, she's everything you'd want: daughter of a legendary actress, stunning, kind words for the workshop kids, gracious in defeat. But then there's this scene after Perry's performance where Bria Sol sits down and just... dismantles her friend's relationship with Yuan petal by petal. Like literally. She takes a rose, plucks the petals one by one, and lets them fall. And then she walks right over them with her shoes. "An actor needs to stand on their own feet. You have to seize opportunities yourself. Getting entangled with such a rich man can plunge you into a quagmire in an instant." She says it with this sweet, concerned tone but it reads like a threat. A professionally delivered, elegantly wrapped threat. And the worst part? Perry basically accepts it. She thanks her for the concern. She doesn't push back. She's too polite, too eager to be the good little rookie. Meanwhile, Perry's letters to Yuan are the realest relationship in this whole book. The way she checks in on him, remembers his preferences without him asking, the genuine warmth beneath all her self-deprecating humor. When Yuan sends those catered meals for the rehearsal, her reaction is not entitlement—it's guilt. She worries she'll become someone who takes kindness for granted. That's the opposite of what Bria Sol wants her to be. I keep thinking about how Bria Sol describes her own gestures as "thoroughly staged." Even fiddling with her lips is apparently performance. Everything about her is calculated, including what passes for kindness. Perry notices this—she says it would have been more certain if she could touch Bria Sol's face, like she's trying to verify whether she's real. That line hit me hard because it suggests Perry already senses something artificial about her, even as she admires her. The dynamic between these three characters creates this incredible tension: Perry caught between genuine devotion (Yuan) and industry pressure (Bria Sol), and Bria Sol positioning herself as both mentor and gatekeeper. What happens when Perry has to choose?
... Read More
there's a motif running through this entire batch that I can't stop thinking about: the tension between being seen and being invisible. perry keeps getting rejected for things she can't control—her face, her eyes—but then she's also the person who sees OTHER people most clearly. yuan literally says she's breathed life into HIS existence. she notices details about the man in the rain—the tie pin, the tension in his jaw, the way his glove hesitates before touching her hair. the rain itself is such a loaded symbol here. ravina night is a witches' festival that rains EVERY year—seven days of it. and perry, who navigates the world differently, is out in it anyway. the rain blurs boundaries, makes everything indistinct, yet it's also what brings her and the man together. without the storm she'd never have stopped to ask for directions. without the rain he wouldn't have followed her to the theater. chaos as catalyst. and that yellow umbrella—bright, stark, almost absurd against his all-black outfit—is probably the most important symbol in this passage. it's warmth in a cold scene. it's care disguised as practicality. he could have just left it at the desk but no, he had to personally deliver it, had to make sure she was okay. "you didn't have an umbrella"—so simple, but it carries the weight of someone who remembered a detail others wouldn't have noticed. the most haunting symbol though is the WICKEDNESS of surface-level judgment. every casting director in this text reduces perry to her appearance, her eyesight, her ability to be memorable at a GLANCE. but the story keeps proving them wrong. perry doesn't need to be pretty to move people. she doesn't need perfect vision to navigate her world. the text is essentially screaming that the industry's definition of beauty is both shallow and WRONG, and perry's entire arc is living proof of it.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how this whole opening section is basically structured as a cascade of letters and I cannot stop thinking about that choice. We start with Perry getting a physical letter in the lobby after the final performance, then the story just... spirals into correspondence. Each letter pushes the plot forward by a notch and honestly it works because you're literally reading someone trying to get closer to someone who's pulling away. The fan writes to praise her, she writes back with a touch of the magical realism element (the witch route), the fan writes again with desperation when she says she won't perform, then there's the landlord note and rejection letters from theaters thrown in like salt in a wound, and then the fan reveals himself as Yuan Bellium and offers money. The tension here is that every time Perry opens a door—whether it's accepting the fan's devotion or shutting it down—the floor moves. The scene where the landlord's note about unpaid bills appears right after the fan's emotional plea? Brutal. It grounds everything in reality like a bucket of cold water. And then the theater rejections pile up on top. The plot doesn't have big explosive twists but it has this slow-building pressure cooker feel where Perry is being squeezed from every angle and the reader is left wondering what will actually break first.
... Read More
I need to process the Yuan letter. Just process it. On the surface, Yuan is writing a supportive reply to Perry's theater festival success. He praises her acting—"one should see it at least three, five, or at minimum ten times"—he tells her she gained fans, he says he had an excellent seat. Sweet friend energy, right? Then he pivots. Hard. "Did that 'gentleman' behave with proper manners and not display any arrogant attitude?" Not "I hope you had fun." Not "Tell me about this guy." The quotation marks around gentleman. The specificity of worrying about ARROGANCE. The whole paragraph that follows is Yuan performing emotional acrobatics—he's worried about her safety, yes, but also about WHO she's letting close to her, and why he feels entitled to ask, and how he's trying to dress it up as casual advice delivered "over tea" when clearly this is keeping him up at night. And Perry's response? She laughs. Not a dismissive laugh—a genuine one. "I laughed for the first time when I read your letter." She addresses his concern directly: she's not naive, she just hasn't found anyone worth being cautious about. Until now. She doesn't say that last part, but it's THERE. Meanwhile, in Scene 4, the man—Yuan?—is being pressed by his father's ghost (literally, the father mentioning the mother and Bellium) and can only think about escaping, until this blind woman blocks his path and asks him to dance. His answer comes out before he can stop it: "Of course, I don't mind. If it helps, gladly." The stakes here are enormous and they're entirely emotional. Perry risks everything on her dream and keeps hitting walls. Yuan watches from afar, giving advice he can barely admit he's giving, wearing a tie pin like a signal flare. And whatever happened—or is happening—between them at that ball? That's the tension that's going to explode. I just know it.
... Read More
i need to talk about this ONE scene because it's easily the most visually striking passage in this entire batch. you know that feeling when you read something and it just PLAYs out in your head like a movie? that's exactly what happens when perry is trudging through the rain on ravina night. "heavy raindrops struck perry's clear cheeks fiercely" — start strong. immediately you're feeling the cold. the way the author describes the rain blurring boundaries between buildings and trees and crosswalks... it's like the world itself is losing its edges, which is such a perfect mirror for how disoriented perry must feel as a blind person navigating a downpour. and the white cane detail! "as her white cane touched the right side, her left foot stretched forward" — this is written with such precision that you can SEE her moving through the world, measuring each step, trusting her instruments in a landscape that's actively working against her. then she meets THE MAN. the black umbrella, the neat suit, the black leather gloves. the whole visual palette shifts from grey rain to stark black-and-white, and that contrast is NOT accidental. the way his glove touches her hair—"as carefully as if touching flesh would mean death. as if fire might spread at the slightest touch" — this is the most electric moment of physical contact in the entire text and it's described with the tension of a bomb defusal. and the umbrella exchange at the end! he waited for her. he came back into the rain. he brought her a bright yellow umbrella into his monochrome world. the visual symbolism is so thick you could cut it with a knife and i loved every second of it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Perry and Yuan because this correspondence section absolutely wrecked me. The way Perry writes to Yuan — she's vulnerable in a way she never lets anyone else see. She confesses things like 'I tend to be reckless. Though I'm timid, when I focus on one thing, I charge toward it, unable to see my surroundings.' That's not just a personality quirk, that's her entire life philosophy laid bare. And Yuan's reply? 'For all the time Perry was, is, and will be an actress, I am your fan.' I literally sat there staring at that sentence. The depth of commitment in that line is insane — he's not just saying he supports her career, he's saying her identity as an actress is something he commits to across all of time. Meanwhile Perry is over here panicking about whether he'll keep the tie pin or store it in a vacuum-sealed case forever. The asymmetry is everything. She's terrified of being too much, and he's already decided she's not enough of a threat to ever leave. Also wild: Perry says she tried to maintain appropriate distance as his 'actress' but then immediately lists all the ways she crossed that boundary — bringing tea leaves into her home, accepting restaurant introductions. She's been crumbling her own walls the whole time and pretending she hasn't.
... Read More
can we appreciate that yuan writes like he THINKS like he speaks— flamboyant, dramatic, utterly sincere—and somehow it NEVER feels performative? the text explicitly acknowledges this: "i'm aware that my vocabulary has been excessively flamboyant and dramatic. and that's why my sincerity is being doubted." but here's the thing: the narrator TRUSTS him anyway, and that's because yuan's voice has CONSISTENCY. every word he writes feels like it came from the same brain, the same heart. compare that to perry's voice, which is... different. she starts formal and structured in her first letter, almost clinical in how she lists her failures. but by the third letter, the structure FALLS APART. "i have so much to say, but can't write even a single line properly. can you see the ink stain pressed heavily here?" she's physically leaving marks of her emotion on the page. her voice becomes messier, more raw, more HER. and the dialogue in the rain scene—oh my god. the restraint! the man barely says anything and yet every word weighs a ton. "ten minutes should be enough... i'll guide you." so casual but loaded. then the hair-touching moment where neither of them speaks at all and the silence does MORE work than any dialogue could. and then at the end, perry just BLUNTLY asks "why did you pretend not to know me?" after all that buildup of polite small talk—it's such a perfect character moment because it shows who perry REALLY is underneath all the politeness. the author also nails how people DON'T say what they mean. every line in that scene is about something OTHER than what it's actually about. the umbrella, the hair, the tie pin—all of it is coded communication between two people who clearly have history.
... Read More
There are so many symbols layering on top of each other in this section I barely know where to start. Let me just pick the one that's been living in my head rent-free. The tie pin. The tie pin is EVERYTHING. Perry gives Yuan a tie pin. Months pass. Then at this masquerade ball—where everyone is supposed to be hiding behind masks—she spots that exact same tie pin on a stranger's lapel. The department store clerk had called it trendy. Now it's appearing everywhere: on colleagues, passengers, strangers. But specifically on THIS person, in THIS moment, when Perry is experiencing what might be the most vulnerable interaction of her life. A masquerade ball is supposed to be about anonymity. About hiding who you really are behind masks and costumes. And yet the most revealing moment happens precisely because of something that IDENTIFIES—not conceals. The tie pin betrays the game. Perry, who cannot see, notices what everyone else wearing masks might have missed. Yuan, who is presumably somewhere visible, either chooses to wear the token Perry gave him as a form of disguise (it's just a trendy accessory now, after all) or accidentally reveals himself through it. Then there's the dance itself—"Without a single mask, unable to hide anything." Perry asks for a waltz not because she wants romance but because she needs practice for auditions. She frames vulnerability as practicality. But the way the scene unfolds, every guard drops. She touches his elbow, asks him to guide her, requests another favor. And Yuan—the man who seems to carry so much weight (the family name Bellium, the father's disappointment, whatever illness makes him press his temple)—agrees immediately. "Of course, I don't mind. If it helps, gladly." The fable references in Perry's September letter are also doing heavy symbolic work. The old man who reached for the sun and burned. The woman who competed with a god and became a scorpion. These are stories about humans who dared to aim too high and were destroyed for it. Perry is asking: is my ambition just another version of this hubris? And the deeper question underneath: what does it mean to pursue something beautiful in a world that seems designed to punish beauty?
... Read More
Let me just say: Jin is a entire personality built on the foundation of 'I will not be the one to ruin this.' He wears suits to casual outings, says 'it's fine' as a lifestyle choice, refuses to share what he asked the fortune-teller, buys mistletoe and then doesn't give it to her. The man is a fortress. But here's what's fascinating — Perry sees right through it and still doesn't push. 'He's always been a secretive person. I can't be too greedy.' She knows exactly what he's doing and she lets him have his privacy. That's not naive, that's trust. She trusts that when he's ready, he'll tell her. Their dynamic reminds me of two cats who want to sleep together but both pretend they don't care. The rainy walk where they merge under one umbrella — that's the closest they get to physical contact the entire chapter. And Jin's reaction when she says she doesn't hate rainy days? 'I felt the vibration of him sharply inhaling.' SHE FEELS HIM INHALE. From across an umbrella. That is HOW MUCH ATTENTION HE PAYSTOHER. Meanwhile Perry, who can read fortunes on the back of her own hands, apparently cannot read Jin's. Or chooses not to. Which is its own kind of blindness, isn't it?
... Read More
What strikes me most is how DISTINGUISHED the two voices are despite being about the same topics. Perry sounds like someone who talks to herself while walking. 'Ugh, considering everything, I still want to do it so badly.' 'I was withering like a leaf that had gotten too much sunlight, but now the whole world feels beautiful!' Full of dashes, fragments, sudden shifts from panic to euphoria. She even makes donuts when anxious and then has twenty donuts with no idea what to do with them. THAT IS A PERSON. Yuan is quieter but no less distinctive. 'Though I normally perceive ten colors, in that instant it felt like twenty.' That's someone who observes the world through a more measured, almost clinical lens — until emotion cracks it open. And her advice to Perry? 'Believe in yourself. If that's difficult, believe in me who believes in you. If even that's difficult, let's believe in the Perry of the past.' That's not just dialogue — that's a philosophy of encouragement distilled into three escalating options. The author could've made them sound similar. Instead, each letter feels like hearing two different people talk on the phone to you.
... Read More
This chapter structure is so clever and I need to dissect it. We open with Perry's letters—dry, self-contained, almost clinical observations about her life that slowly reveal warmth underneath. She writes about bagels and vegetables and gossip with this flat, almost detached tone, but every letter ends with these tiny cracks where her real feelings seep through. "I wasn't hurt by this. So don't comfort me." "Reading and answering your letters feels like my only rest." These are people who care deeply but don't know how to say it directly. Then Yuan's letters arrive and the energy shifts completely. His prose is denser, more rambling, full of asides and postscripts that spiral further and further from the main point. He writes about stationery for three paragraphs before circling back to Perry's showcase. This structural difference between their voices tells you everything about their personalities without a single line of narration. The Bria Sol scene at the end breaks this epistolary pattern entirely. We drop into third-person narrative, present-tense immediacy, physical sensation. Perry's cold sweat, trembling eyelids, the blanket falling to the floor. It's a jarring shift and it works perfectly because Perry's world is literally being interrupted—by an authority figure who represents everything the letters haven't addressed yet. What's brilliant is how the author uses the letters to build anticipation. Perry mentions the showcase dates in one letter, then we get the emotional aftermath of that performance two chapters later. We've been waiting with her for weeks of real time before we finally experience the moment. That's pacing done right. The chapter ends on what I can only describe as a velvet-wrapped cliffhanger—Bria Sol has issued her warning, Perry has tentatively accepted it, and the reader is left wondering how long this friendship can survive external pressure. Not a bang, but a slow, creeping dread. Much more effective.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or